Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB332

Introduced
2/14/23  

Caption

In employees, providing for use of force and deadly force policy for law enforcement agencies; and making an editorial change.

Impact

The proposed legislation could potentially reform how use of force incidents are handled across Pennsylvania law enforcement agencies, aiming for increased accountability and transparency. By requiring clear written policies, training, and recording protocols, SB332 seeks to mitigate the risks associated with excessive use of force and improve community relations with law enforcement. Furthermore, the biennial certification process for law enforcement agencies to ensure compliance with the policy could enhance oversight and adherence to established guidelines, contributing to public safety and trust in law enforcement.

Summary

Senate Bill 332 aims to amend Title 53 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes by establishing clear guidelines and training regarding the use of force and deadly force for law enforcement agencies. The bill mandates that each law enforcement agency develop and implement a written use of force policy, which will include decision-making principles for the initiation, continuation, and termination of the use of force. Additionally, the legislation prohibits the use of choke holds, except in instances where deadly force is authorized. By instituting these measures, the bill looks to clarify and standardize policies surrounding use of force across law enforcement agencies in Pennsylvania.

Sentiment

There appears to be a cautious optimism regarding the bill among advocates for police reform, who believe that the structured guidelines may lead to better practices and outcomes in law enforcement conduct. However, there may also be resistance from some law enforcement agencies concerned about how the implementation of these policies could affect their operations and the ability to make split-second decisions during confrontational or dangerous situations. The sentiment thus reflects a mix of support for reform and apprehension about the potential practical implications of such regulations.

Contention

Some points of contention surrounding SB332 include the details about training provisions and the prohibition of choke holds. Critics could argue that while the intent is to prevent excessive force, this could inadvertently hinder officers' ability to protect themselves and others in high-pressure scenarios. The balance between ensuring accountability and providing law enforcement with adequate flexibility during critical incidents remains a hotly debated issue. Thus, the discussions may revolve around the efficacy of the proposed reforms in preventing misuse of force while ensuring law enforcement can effectively carry out their duties.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA SB279

In employees, providing for use of force and deadly force policy for law enforcement agencies; imposing duties on the Municipal Police Officers' Education and Training Commission; and making an editorial change.

PA HB462

Providing for actions by law enforcement; and, in employees, providing for use of force recordkeeping and reporting for law enforcement agencies.

PA SB230

Law enforcement: use of deadly force: training: policies.

PA AB1652

Law enforcement agency policies: use of force: protests.

PA SB1388

Justification; deadly force; law enforcement

PA SB66

Providing for the adoption of a Statewide model policy related to the prevention of excessive force by law enforcement officers and school security personnel.

PA SB1091

Law enforcement: other; use of force policies; require law enforcement agencies to create. Creates new act.

PA SB0333

Law enforcement: other; use of force policies; require law enforcement agencies to create. Creates new act.

PA HB6117

Law enforcement: other; use of force policies; require law enforcement agencies to create. Creates new act.

PA SB46

Providing for adoption by the Attorney General of a Statewide model policy related to the prevention of excessive force by law enforcement officers and school security personnel.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.