Prohibits seeking or referencing a specific dollar amount or stating a range for a jury to consider with respect to awards for noneconomic damages
Impact
The implications of HB2017 are substantial, affecting how juries assess noneconomic damages in civil cases, such as pain and suffering or emotional distress. By prohibiting any reference to specific amounts, the bill aims to create a more equitable environment where jurors can focus on the merits of the case without being biased by financial suggestions. This change could lead to more uniform jury decisions across similar cases, potentially decreasing the variability in awards for noneconomic damages.
Summary
House Bill 2017 seeks to amend Chapter 537 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri by introducing a new section, 537.092. This legislation stipulates that in civil actions where a jury is involved, neither party nor their attorneys can mention a specific dollar amount or state a range that jurors should consider when determining awards for noneconomic damages. The primary intention behind this bill is to prevent juries from being influenced by monetary figures that could sway their impartiality during deliberations.
Conclusion
Overall, HB2017 is positioned as a significant reform in Missouri's civil procedures regarding noneconomic damages. If enacted, it will require adjustments in how legal counsel approach case presentations in front of a jury, ensuring compliance with the new stipulations while aiming for fairness in litigation outcomes.
Contention
The discussion surrounding HB2017 may involve contrasting perspectives on the role of monetary reference in jury decisions. Proponents argue that it helps ensure impartiality and fairness in the judicial process, preventing undue influence that could arise from knowing the potential financial consequences of their verdicts. However, critics might contend that it could restrict jurors' understanding of the case's context, potentially leading to inadequate awards for legitimate claims.
Provides that parties or attorneys in a civil action with a jury shall not make reference to specific dollar amounts or ranges of awards for noneconomic damages
Nuisance; prohibiting nuisance action for oil and gas activities after specified time period; placing limitation on noneconomic damages. Effective date.