Rhode Island 2022 Regular Session

Rhode Island House Bill H7685

Introduced
3/2/22  

Caption

Courts -- Judicial Selection

Impact

By amending sections of the General Laws concerning judicial nomination, H7685 directly impacts the procedure by which judges are appointed in Rhode Island. It reinforces the significance of diversity not just as a moral or ethical imperative, but also as a necessary component for the credibility of the judicial system. The act is expected to lead to a judiciary that not only interprets the law impartially but also brings varied perspectives shaped by different life experiences, thereby enhancing public faith in judicial outcomes. The act also reinforces the governor's role in judicial appointments, with the stipulation that nominations must now consider diversity actively.

Summary

House Bill H7685 concerns the judicial selection process in Rhode Island, specifically aiming to enhance the diversity of candidates considered for judicial appointments. The bill mandates that the judicial nominating commission, responsible for submitting qualified nominees to the governor, must include at least two candidates of color in every list it submits. This is part of a broader initiative to ensure that Rhode Island’s judiciary reflects the state's diverse population and experiences. The amendment is targeted at ensuring that individuals from historically marginalized backgrounds are more likely to receive consideration for judicial roles, thereby promoting a more inclusive justice system.

Contention

While the bill aims at positive reform, there may be contention surrounding the implementation of these diversity measures. Critics may argue about the efficacy and feasibility of mandating diversity within judicial nominations, potentially questioning if it could lead to undermining the merit-based selection of judges. Supporters argue that this measure is crucial for addressing systemic biases and ensuring that candidates from diverse backgrounds are afforded equal opportunities. The discussions surrounding this bill may reflect broader societal debates over representation and equity in government institutions, particularly in the context of the judiciary, which plays a vital role in upholding laws and rights.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

RI H7686

Judicial Selection

RI SB0129

Judiciary Amendments

RI SCR1044

Judicial retention elections

RI HB07041

An Act Concerning The Composition Of The Judicial Selection Commission And Decisions Rendered By Said Commission.

RI HB05380

An Act Concerning The Composition Of The Judicial Selection Commission And Decisions Rendered By Said Commission.

RI H4516

Judicial Merit Selection Commission

RI H3033

Judicial Elections, lawyer-legislators

RI HB1205

Office Of Judicial Ombudsman

RI SB619

Judiciary Department - Commission on Judicial Disabilities - Temporary Appointment

RI SCR1019

Judicial elections

Similar Bills

LA SB553

Provides relative to special attorneys for flood protection authorities. (gov sig)

AZ SCR1026

Appointment commissions; membership

KS SCR1617

Proposing a constitutional amendment to require that vacancies in the offices of the secretary of state and the attorney general be filled by election at a state party delegate convention.

HI SB349

Relating To Boards And Commissions.

HI SB349

Relating To Boards And Commissions.

TX SB1984

Relating to the canvass of election returns for the offices of governor and lieutenant governor.

TX HB5007

Relating to the establishment of the Texas Committee on Foreign Investment to review certain transactions involving certain foreign entities; creating a civil penalty.

TX SB2117

Relating to the establishment of the Texas Committee on Foreign Investment to review certain transactions involving certain foreign entities in coordination with the attorney general; creating a civil penalty.