West Virginia 2022 Regular Session

West Virginia Senate Bill SB97

Introduced
1/12/22  

Caption

Prohibiting gender-based price discrimination

Impact

If enacted, SB97 would amend the existing Code of West Virginia, thereby establishing a clear legal framework against gender-based pricing discrepancies. The bill enables the Attorney General to seek injunctions against businesses that violate this pricing rule and imposes civil penalties for non-compliance. These penalties are designed to deter businesses from discriminatory pricing practices and promote equitable pricing across genders. The bill puts a spotlight on consumer rights and fairness in commercial practices, aligning with broader efforts to eliminate discrimination.

Summary

Senate Bill 97 aims to combat gender-based price discrimination within the state of West Virginia by prohibiting businesses from charging different prices for goods and services that are substantially similar, based solely on the gender of the consumer. The bill introduces a new provision in the state's unfair trade practices code, specifically targeting the pricing of goods and services marketed toward individuals of different genders. Such practices are seen as unfair and potentially harmful, reinforcing gender stereotypes and economic inequality.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB97 appears to be largely positive among advocates for gender equality and consumer rights, who view it as a necessary step toward ensuring fair pricing practices. Supporters argue that the bill is essential for promoting equal treatment of all consumers and preventing businesses from exploiting gender-based stereotypes for profit. However, some opponents voice concerns about the practicality of enforcement and the potential for unintended consequences, including the burden of compliance on small businesses.

Contention

Discussion surrounding SB97 reflects a notable tension between consumer protection efforts and business interests. While the bill's proponents emphasize its protective measures for consumers against unfair pricing strategies, detractors argue that it may lead to increases in administrative costs for businesses as they adapt their pricing structures and compliance thresholds. A significant point of contention centers on defining 'substantially similar' goods and services, which could lead to challenges in identifying violations and enforcing the law effectively.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WV AB1287

Price discrimination: gender.

WV S1412

Prohibits gender-based price discrimination.

WV A4752

Prohibits gender-based price discrimination.

WV S1005

Prohibits gender-based price discrimination.

WV SB873

Gender: discrimination: pricing.

WV HB1406

Relative to gender-based pricing of goods and services.

WV SB320

Gender: discrimination: pricing.

WV SB164

Trade Practices; surveillance based price discrimination and surveillance based wage discrimination; prohibit

WV AB1615

Gender discrimination: civil actions.

WV SB189

Prohibiting insurance discrimination against firearms manufacturers

Similar Bills

WV HB2551

Relating to consumer protection of new manufactured home warranties

WV HB3228

Relating to consumer protection of new manufactured home warranties

WV HB2237

Relating to consumer protection of new manufactured home warranties

VA SB1140

Single family homes; prohibited acquisition, civil penalty.

WV HB4529

Relating to consumer protection of new manufactured home warranties

WV HB2287

Providing for solar energy production on formerly mined land

WV HB2067

West Virginia Firearms Liability Clarification Act

WV HB2830

Providing for solar energy production on formerly mined land