Wisconsin 2023-2024 Regular Session

Wisconsin Senate Bill SB491

Introduced
10/16/23  
Refer
10/16/23  

Caption

Prohibiting certain indemnification provisions in contracts relating to design professional services.

Impact

The bill is significant as it aims to shift liability and responsibility in civil contracts involving state projects. It specifically limits indemnification obligations, thereby potentially reducing the financial risk for design professionals. By prohibiting broad indemnification clauses, the bill aims to protect smaller firms and professionals who may otherwise be burdened by unfair contractual obligations that extend beyond their control. However, this may also lead to increased caution from the state and municipalities when contracting for design services, as they might bear more risk themselves.

Summary

Senate Bill 491 seeks to create a new statute that prohibits certain indemnification and defense provisions in contracts between the state or political subdivisions and private entities engaged in design professional services. Under this bill, any clause that requires a private entity to indemnify or defend the state or any political subdivision will be rendered void and unenforceable, with specific exceptions noted. Design professional services are defined broadly to include a wide range of services performed by architects, engineers, surveyors, and other related professionals, ensuring that numerous fields are covered by this legislation.

Contention

Discussions around SB491 may reveal notable points of contention regarding the balance of risk between the state and private entities. Advocates for the bill argue that it will foster a healthier business environment for design professionals, particularly helping smaller firms compete fairly in the public contract arena. Conversely, critics may voice concerns that this could limit the state’s ability to hold private entities accountable for negligence or performance issues. This tension is indicative of a broader debate on regulatory reform and the role of liability in public-private partnerships.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WI AB514

Prohibiting certain indemnification provisions in contracts relating to design professional services.

WI SB361

Relating to indemnification provisions in construction contracts.

WI HB818

Relating to indemnification provisions in construction contracts.

WI SB555

Relating to indemnification provisions in construction contracts.

WI HB2010

Relating to indemnification provisions in construction contracts.

WI HB1926

Indemnification; contracts; design professional services; effective date.

WI HB1073

Design Professionals; declare certain provisions in contracts for services void and establish standard of care.

WI HB993

Design Professionals; declare certain provisions in contracts for services void and establish standard of care.

WI SB24

Relating to construction contracts; to provide regulations for indemnification agreements in certain construction contracts.

WI HB2049

Relating to indemnification and duties of engineers and architects under certain governmental contracts.

Similar Bills

CA AB586

Professional fiduciaries.

NJ A2285

Establishes process for formation of professional limited liability companies.

NJ S1425

Revises "The Professional Service Corporation Act."

MS SB2133

Mississippi Design Professionals Act; enact.

MS SB2217

Mississippi Design Professionals Act; enact.

MI HB4172

Probate: guardians and conservators; requirements to be appointed as guardian or conservator; modify. Amends title & secs. 5106, 5108a, 5313 & 5409 of 1998 PA 386 (MCL 700.5106 et seq.) & adds secs. 5106a & 5106b. TIE BAR WITH: HB 4171'23

CA SB1024

Replacement of an incapacitated or deceased professional fiduciary.

MI HB4728

Occupations: individual licensing and registration; licensure of professional guardians and conservators; require. Amends sec. 303a of 1980 PA 299 (MCL 339.303a) & adds art. 14A.