Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB247

Introduced
6/2/23  

Caption

Providing for hospital patient protection provisions; and imposing penalties.

Impact

The proposed legislation would significantly alter several aspects of the Health Care Facilities Act by mandating transparency in staffing and accountability for violations. Hospitals would be required to maintain compliance with prescribed nurse staffing levels, with civil penalties imposed for infractions. Moreover, the new regulations would allow for modifications in staffing plans during emergency situations, requiring hospitals to report changes to their staffing strategies and demonstrating efforts to maintain required staffing levels. This bill thereby aims to ensure that patient care is not compromised, especially during critical times.

Summary

Senate Bill 247, also known as the Hospital Patient Protection Provisions, seeks to enhance healthcare delivery by implementing strict staffing requirements in hospitals across Pennsylvania. One of the main features of the bill is the establishment of a hospital nurse staffing committee which is tasked with developing and reviewing staffing plans that ensure adequate nurse-to-patient ratios. These ratios are meant to reflect patient acuity and ensure that hospitals are equipped to provide appropriate care based on their specific patient populations and unit types. The intent is to improve overall patient safety and care quality while addressing existing staffing shortages in the healthcare system.

Sentiment

The sentiment regarding SB 247 appears to be mixed with advocates arguing that it is a necessary step towards safeguarding patient rights and enhancing quality of care within hospital settings. Proponents, including healthcare worker unions and patient advocacy groups, support the notion that increased staffing will lead to better health outcomes and a more supportive environment for nurses. Conversely, critics raises concerns about the potential burden on hospital operations, suggesting that strict regulations might exacerbate staffing shortages if hospitals struggle to comply with the mandated ratios. This dichotomy highlights ongoing tensions between patient safety initiatives and the realities of healthcare workforce management.

Contention

One key point of contention surrounding SB 247 includes the potential impact on hospital budgets and operations, as enforcing mandatory nurse staffing ratios may require additional funding and resources that some institutions may not readily afford. There are worries that small or rural hospitals might be disproportionately affected, risking their operational stability and, ultimately, access to care for the communities they serve. Additionally, opponents fear that the heavy regulatory burden could lead to unintended consequences such as reduced hiring flexibility, which could in turn contribute to increased staff turnover rates.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA HB106

Providing for hospital patient protection provisions; and imposing penalties.

PA HB2427

Relating to the rights and duties of hospital patients and certain health care providers; providing civil penalties.

PA HB2880

Relating to the rights and duties of hospital patients and certain health care providers; providing civil penalties.

PA HB235

Hospitals; protocols for patients receiving rehabilitation services.

PA H0695

Delivery of Patient Protection

PA SB816

Providing for End of Life Options Act; and imposing penalties.

PA H0349

Delivery of Patient Protection

PA HB543

Providing for compassionate aid in dying; and imposing penalties.

PA HB72

Nursing Staff-to-patient Ratios In Hospitals

PA HB1109

Providing for compassionate aid in dying; and imposing penalties.

Similar Bills

CA AB601

Correctional industry safety committee.

CA AB912

People with disabilities: pilot civil service apprenticeship program: environmental service technicians: correctional facilities.

CA AB31

Office of the Child Protection Ombudsperson.

AZ SB1369

Dental board; investigation committees; delegation

CA AB31

Whistleblowers: California State Auditor.

DE HB261

An Act To Amend Title 29 Of The Delaware Code Relating To State Government.

NJ A244

Requires hospitals to establish nurse staffing committees.

NJ A966

Requires hospitals to establish nurse staffing committees.