Michigan House Bill HB5705

Michigan 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 5/7/24
• Refer: 5/7/24

Caption

Criminal procedure: sentencing; mandatory sentencing for certain crimes regarding contraband in prisons; require. Amends secs. 1, 3, 3a & 5 of 1909 PA 17 (MCL 800.281 et seq.).

Impact

If enacted, HB 5705 would impose stricter sentencing guidelines for those found guilty of delivering contraband to prisoners. Under the new amendments, individuals could face felony charges and substantial prison time, with sentences ranging significantly for different types of infractions, indicative of the severity with which the state views the issue of contraband. The bill will also extend these prohibitive measures to the introduction of weapons and wireless communication devices, reflecting an evolving understanding of the risks posed by unauthorized access to these items within a correctional setting.

Summary

House Bill 5705 aims to amend existing legislation regarding the prohibition of contraband in correctional facilities, specifically addressing the illegal transfer of alcoholic liquor, prescription drugs, and controlled substances to prisoners. The bill is designed to enhance penalties for individuals who violate these prohibitions, reinforcing the state's commitment to maintaining order and safety in correctional environments. A significant aspect of the bill is its focus on strengthening restrictions on not just prisoners but also employees and outsiders who might attempt to unlawfully furnish contraband within or outside of correctional facilities.

Contention

Debate around HB 5705 may center on its social implications, particularly concerning the effects of severe penalties on already vulnerable populations, such as those involved in the prison system. Critics may argue that harsher sentencing could exacerbate existing issues within the criminal justice system, such as mass incarceration. Furthermore, there could be concerns regarding the balance between maintaining order in prisons and ensuring fair and just treatment of individuals within the correctional system. As the bill progresses, these discussions will be essential in shaping the final form of the legislation.