West Virginia 2023 Regular Session

West Virginia Senate Bill SB288

Introduced
1/18/23  

Caption

Relating to Sexual Assault Examination Network

Impact

If passed, SB288 will impact the existing statutes governing the handling of sexual assault forensic examination kits. It mandates that health care providers submit these kits to the West Virginia State Police Forensic Laboratory within a specified timeframe after collection. Additionally, it introduces stringent protocols for maintaining the chain of custody of DNA samples and requires that certain biological evidence not be destroyed until the legal proceedings associated with the case are resolved. These revisions are intended to better protect victims' interests and enhance law enforcement's ability to prosecute sexual offenses effectively.

Summary

Senate Bill 288 aims to amend the provisions related to the Sexual Assault Examination Network in West Virginia. The bill specifically addresses the protocols for handling DNA evidence collected from victims of sexual assault, particularly in cases involving surgical or chemical abortions due to rape or incest. This includes defining terms related to abortion and establishing requirements for notifying victims when evidence is collected. The key goal is to ensure that evidence is preserved in a manner that supports potential criminal prosecutions, thereby reinforcing the link between forensic examination and the judicial process upholding victims' rights.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB288 is largely focused on the need for improved practices in the treatment of sexual assault cases. Supporters of the bill, which include various advocacy groups, argue that the proposed measures will strengthen the process for collecting and preserving vital evidence. Nevertheless, concerns have been raised about the implications of notifying victims about evidence collection related to abortion procedures, which some view as intrusive. Legislative discussions reveal a passion among lawmakers and stakeholders about balancing the need for justice while respecting the choices and privacy of victims.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding SB288 center around the protocols for informing victims of the collection of DNA evidence during abortion procedures. Critics worry that the requirement to inform victims of the collection may deter some individuals from seeking necessary medical care, thus inadvertently affecting their reproductive rights. This conflict highlights the broader debate within the state legislature around the intersection of sexual health, victim advocacy, and legal processes, underscoring differing views on how best to support victims within the legal framework.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WV SB379

Relating to Sexual Assault Examination Network

WV HB2944

Relating to DNA collection requirements in abortion cases relating to rape or incest

WV HB4677

Relating to the reimbursement of sexual assault forensic medical examinations

WV SB89

Requiring hospitals to staff qualified personnel to perform sexual assault forensic exams

WV HB3420

Relating to the reimbursement of sexual assault forensic medical examinations

WV SB1094

Sexual assault: medical evidentiary examinations.

WV AB358

Sexual assault forensic examination kits: databases.

WV SB675

Increasing reimbursement of sexual assault forensic medical examination kits

WV AB538

Sexual assault: medical evidentiary examinations and reporting.

WV AB334

Sexual assault.

Similar Bills

CA AB2763

English language education: English learners: observation protocol.

HI SB1557

Relating To Gifts.

GA HB527

Domestic relations; creation and revisions of certain child abuse protocol procedures for cases of alleged child abuse; provide

HI SB1557

Relating To Gifts.

CA AB293

Greenhouse gases: offset protocols.

HI HB2069

Relating To Gifts.

HI SB3037

Relating To Gifts.

CA AB727

Dams and reservoirs: exclusions.