Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania House Bill HB2419

Introduced
6/13/24  

Caption

In trade and commerce, providing for the offense of fraudulent misrepresentation of a service animal.

Impact

The implications of HB2419 are significant, as it modifies existing laws related to animal rights and public accommodations. The bill, if enacted, would establish stricter penalties for those found guilty of misrepresentation, which could deter false claims and protect legitimate service animal users. This change can lead to smoother interactions in public spaces, as businesses and facilities would have clearer guidelines on how to handle inquiries about service animals. Overall, it aims to improve the safety and quality of life for individuals who rely on service animals for everyday functioning.

Summary

House Bill 2419 focuses on addressing issues related to the fraudulent misrepresentation of service animals. This bill seeks to create legal frameworks and penalties aimed at preventing individuals from falsely claiming that their pets are service animals, a practice that undermines the rights and protections afforded to actual service animals and their handlers. It underscores the importance of service animals in providing assistance to individuals with disabilities and ensures that the integrity of service animal programs is maintained. By criminalizing fraudulent claims, the bill aims to enhance trust and compliance in the use of service animals in public spaces.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB2419 appears to be generally positive, particularly among advocacy groups for individuals with disabilities and service animal organizations. Supporters argue that the bill is a necessary measure to prevent abuse of the system that protects those who truly need the assistance of service animals. However, some concerns have been raised regarding the potential for the bill to create additional barriers for legitimate service animal users, particularly in how laws are enforced and what constitutes a valid service animal.

Contention

One of the main points of contention regarding HB2419 revolves around the definitions and criteria used to distinguish between legitimate service animals and those that may be misrepresented. Critics of the bill argue that overly stringent regulations could inadvertently penalize individuals with legitimate needs while failing to adequately address the broader issues of public awareness and education regarding service animals. Discussions also highlight the challenge of distinguishing service animals from emotional support animals, which do not have the same legal standing in public accommodations.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA HB2079

In penalties, providing for the offense of fraudulent misrepresentation of a candidate; and imposing a penalty.

PA HB2353

Providing for civil liability for fraudulent misrepresentation of candidates; and imposing penalties.

PA HB811

Providing for civil liability for fraudulent misrepresentation of candidates; and imposing penalties.

PA SB1217

Providing for civil liability for fraudulent misrepresentation of candidates; and imposing penalties.

PA HB2392

Further providing for definitions; establishing the trained service animal card; providing for the documentation of service dogs and for admittance of registered service animal to public accommodations; establishing a trained service animal card database; providing for immunity from liability; and making editorial changes.

PA H1481

Relative to the misrepresentation of a service animal

PA SB286

Creates the offense of misrepresentation of entitlement to assistance animals. (8/1/20) (OR INCREASE LF RV See Note)

PA HB467

In forgery and fraudulent practices, providing for the offense of academic fraud.

PA SB219

An Act To Amend Title 6 And Title 25 Of The Delaware Code Relating To The Misrepresentation Of Service Animals And Assistance Animals.

PA SB327

Emotional support animals in housing; falsely claiming that an animal is a service animal; and providing a penalty. (FE)

Similar Bills

CA SB277

Criminal procedure: search of persons.

CA AB937

Plastic products: commercial agricultural mulch film: labeling: soil biodegradable.

CA AB2632

Segregated confinement.

CA AB1464

Housing preferences.

MI SB0975

Employment security: benefits; disqualification from benefits; modify. Amends sec. 29 of 1936 (Ex Sess) PA 1 (MCL 421.29).

CA AB2564

Individual Shared Responsibility Penalty: waiver: health care service plans.

CA SB479

Termination of tenancy: no-fault just cause: natural person.

CA SB1428

Reproductive health: mifepristone and other medication.