West Virginia 2023 Regular Session

West Virginia House Bill HB3139

Introduced
1/30/23  

Caption

To allow for modification of a family court order involving drugs in certain circumstances

Impact

The introduction of HB3139 signifies an effort to address the complexities surrounding custody arrangements in situations impacted by substance abuse. This legislation allows for increased flexibility in the judiciary's handling of cases where parental substance abuse affects child welfare. By balancing the need for responsible parenting with the goal of rehabilitation, the bill promotes a supportive approach that prioritizes the child's best interests. This could lead to better outcomes for families dealing with substance abuse issues, ensuring that children are placed in safe and stable environments.

Summary

House Bill 3139, introduced in January 2023, aims to amend the existing statutes concerning the modification of parenting plans in cases where substance abuse is a factor. The legislation stipulates that courts may modify parenting plans if they find substantial changes in circumstances, particularly in situations involving a parent with substance use disorder. Notably, if a parent completes a rehabilitation program successfully, the court is required to restore the previous parenting plan, which emphasizes rehabilitation over punishment.

Sentiment

Discussion around HB3139 suggests a generally positive sentiment towards the bill, particularly among those who advocate for compassionate treatment of parents struggling with substance abuse. Supporters argue that the bill reflects an understanding of the challenges that addiction poses, and it offers a pathway for parents to regain their parenting rights upon successful rehabilitation. However, some concerns may arise about how courts will interpret what constitutes a substantial change in circumstances, indicating that there may be contentious discussions ahead regarding the bill’s application in practice.

Contention

A point of contention in the discourse surrounding HB3139 could center on the circumstances that qualify as significant changes warranting a modification of the parenting plan. Opponents may raise questions regarding the potential for misinterpretation or misuse of the bill, particularly in how courts handle cases where a change in a parent's economic status or personal relationships occurs. Critics may worry that the focus on rehabilitation could sometimes overshadow the immediate safety and well-being of children, especially if the definitions of harm or substantial change are not clearly articulated.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

WV HB4590

To allow for modification of a family court order involving drugs in certain circumstances

WV SB829

Divorce; modifying permissible grounds for divorce; requiring court to consider degree of fault when entering certain orders; requiring court to order establishment of trust fund under certain circumstances. Effective date.

WV SB421

Child support; modifying guidelines for computation of income under certain circumstances; requiring modification of certain orders. Effective date.

WV HB2986

Creating a statutory right to petition circuit and family courts for sibling visitation

WV HB5053

Creating a statutory right to petition circuit and family courts for sibling visitation

WV HB3478

Creating a statutory right to petition circuit and family courts for sibling visitation

WV SB598

Permitting judges to refer parents to prosecuting attorney for making certain false allegations in child custody proceedings

WV A1704

Requires domestic violence orders to be issued in other languages in addition to English under certain circumstances.

WV S1000

Requires domestic violence orders to be issued in other languages in addition to English under certain circumstances.

WV A1940

Requires domestic violence orders to be issued in other languages in addition to English under certain circumstances.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.