Provides that statements by a health care provider regarding the unanticipated outcome of a patient's medical care and treatment shall be inadmissible as evidence of an admission of liability or as evidence of an admission.
Impact
The enactment of HB 7169 could lead to significant changes in the way civil liability is approached within health care contexts. By making apologies and expressions of sympathy inadmissible as evidence, the bill aims to foster a more transparent and compassionate environment in medical settings. This could potentially improve patient-provider relationships, as healthcare professionals may feel more at ease in expressing empathy without concern that it might be construed as an admission of fault. However, it could also raise concerns among patients regarding their rights and the accountability of health care providers in the event of medical errors.
Summary
House Bill 7169 addresses the legal implications surrounding statements made by health care providers regarding unanticipated outcomes that occur during patient care and treatment. The bill stipulates that any expressions of apology, sympathy, or concern conveyed by health care providers to patients or their representatives concerning such unanticipated outcomes shall be inadmissible as evidence of liability in any civil action or claim against the provider. The intention behind this legislation is to encourage more open and honest communication between health care providers and patients without the fear that such communication could be used against them in legal proceedings.
Contention
While supporters of HB 7169 argue that it promotes better communication, critics may contend that it undermines accountability within the healthcare system. Opponents could express concerns that patients need protections and the ability to seek recourse when affected by medical negligence. The discussions surrounding the bill may highlight the delicate balance between encouraging compassionate dialogue and ensuring that patients' rights to justice and reparations are not adversely affected.
Determination Of Need For New Healthcare Equipment And New Institutional Health Services -- Licensing Of Healthcare Facilities -- The Hospital Conversions Act