Tennessee Senate Bill SJR1184

Tennessee 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/21/24
• Engrossed: 3/21/24
• Enrolled: 3/21/24
• Passed: 3/22/24

Caption

A RESOLUTION to call a joint convention of the Senate and House of Representatives to consider and act upon the recommendation to remove Andrewnetta Melissa Boyd of Shelby County from the office of Criminal Court Judge in the Thirtieth Judicial District as provided in Article VI, Section 6 of the Tennessee Constitution.

Impact

The resolution was brought forward following a recommendation from the Board of Judicial Conduct, which suggested Judge Boyd's removal based on various allegations presented in a letter dated January 25, 2024. In response to this recommendation, Ad Hoc Committees were formed and subsequently unanimously recommended her removal after reviewing the circumstances. The legislative session to act upon this recommendation is set for April 4, 2024, at which Judge Boyd will have the opportunity to present a defense.

Summary

Senate Joint Resolution 1184 (SJR1184) is a resolution introduced to call a joint convention of the Tennessee Senate and House of Representatives. The purpose of this convention is to consider and act upon the recommendation for the removal of Andrewnetta Melissa Boyd from her position as Criminal Court Judge in the Thirtieth Judicial District. This resolution references Article VI, Section 6 of the Tennessee Constitution, which outlines the procedure for the removal of judges by a concurrent vote of both legislative houses.

Contention

This bill highlights important procedural and ethical considerations within the judicial system in Tennessee. Supporters of the resolution argue that it reinforces accountability among judges, ensuring that they uphold the necessary standards of conduct required for their roles. Conversely, there may be concerns regarding the implications of such actions, especially about due process and the potential for political motivations influencing judicial removals. The debates surrounding this resolution reflect broader conversations about judicial integrity and legislative oversight.

Next_steps

The resolution's passage indicates a significant step in addressing the issues surrounding Judge Boyd's conduct as a Criminal Court Judge. Observers will likely scrutinize the joint convention proceedings closely, as the outcome will set a precedent for future legislative interventions in judicial appointments and removals in Tennessee. The resolution passed with a vote of 70 in favor and 19 against, demonstrating a substantial legislative backing for this course of action.