Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa Senate Bill SF212

Introduced
2/6/23  
Introduced
2/6/23  

Caption

A bill for an act prohibiting discrimination against adoption and foster care providers, or adoptive and foster parents, based on religious belief.

Impact

If enacted, SF212 will significantly affect state laws by establishing a legal framework that protects individuals in the adoption and foster care sectors from discrimination. The bill allows those affected to bring claims against the state for violations, ensuring that the state cannot limit access to benefits or impose penalties based on religious beliefs. This move is seen as enhancing protections for religious freedom while potentially increasing the number of providers in the adoption and foster care system.

Summary

Senate File 212 is designed to prohibit discrimination against adoption and foster care providers, as well as adoptive and foster parents, based on their sincerely held religious beliefs. The bill specifies that the state government cannot take any discriminatory action against individuals engaged in adoption or foster care services if their actions align with their religious convictions. This implies that support and access to such services must be inclusive of the varying beliefs upheld by these individuals and entities, ensuring they are treated fairly by the state government.

Remedies

The bill provides mechanisms for redress, including declaratory and injunctive relief, compensatory damages, and coverage of attorney’s fees for those who successfully assert claims under this chapter. It also lays out a two-year statute of limitations for individuals seeking to assert claims of discrimination, ensuring that issues can be addressed within a reasonable timeframe. The clear legal pathways established aim to support individuals seeking accountability from the state regarding discriminatory practices.

Contention

Notably, there are elements of contention surrounding SF212. Critics argue that this could enable discrimination under the guise of religious belief, potentially impacting the placement of children in care due to the belief systems of adoptive and foster parents. Proponents, on the other hand, advocate that the bill upholds the rights of those with religious beliefs in a sector that is already under strain. This debate highlights a tension between ensuring religious freedoms and maintaining a child welfare system that prioritizes the best interests of children.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

IA SB1399

Adoption; foster care; religious discrimination

IA HB1669

To Create The Keep Kids First Act; And To Provide For Protections From Discrimination For Adoption And Foster Care Providers Acting In Accordance With Sincerely Held Religious Beliefs.

IA HB655

Prohibit discriminatory action against persons providing adoption or foster care services

IA HB0149

Adoption discrimination-keep kids first act.

IA SF473

A bill for an act relating to certain sincerely held religious or moral beliefs of child foster care providers and prospective adoptive parents. (Formerly SF 236.)

IA SF236

A bill for an act relating to certain sincerely held religious or moral beliefs of child foster care providers and prospective adoptive parents.(See SF 473.)

IA HB2153

Relating to foster or adoption parents sincerely held religious or moral beliefs regarding sexual orientation or gender idenity

IA HB4898

Relating to foster or adoption parents sincerely held religious or moral beliefs regarding sexual orientation or gender idenity

IA HB2033

Relating to foster or adoption parents sincerely held religious or moral beliefs regarding sexual orientation or gender identity

IA A1050

Requires child's religion not be changed due to foster care or adoption.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.