Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

Texas House Bill HB4897

Filed
3/10/23  
Out of House Committee
5/8/23  
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to civil liability for online impersonation.

Impact

If enacted, HB4897 will amend the Civil Practice and Remedies Code by adding Chapter 98C, which specifically addresses online impersonation. The bill outlines that individuals found liable for online impersonation may owe damages to victims including actual damages, costs related to counseling, and other associated claims. The legislation further stipulates that damages should not be less than $500 for exemplary damages and confirms that courts may issue restraining orders against continued impersonation, thus enhancing the legal framework surrounding online identity rights.

Summary

House Bill 4897 aims to address the growing issue of online impersonation, commonly referred to as catfishing. This bill introduces civil liability for individuals who use another person's name, likeness, or identity online without consent, particularly targeting malicious intents such as fraud, intimidation, and harassment. The legislation responds to alarming statistics, such as Texas being the third most affected state by catfishing incidents, which have led to significant financial and emotional harm to victims. By incorporating concrete legal remedies, HB4897 seeks to provide victims with a means to seek justice and compensation.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB4897 appears to be generally supportive, especially among advocates for consumer protection and privacy who view it as a necessary step to safeguard individuals from deceptive online practices. Testimonies from various witnesses underscored the need for stringent penalties to deter fraudulent activities, particularly for vulnerable populations like the elderly. However, there are voices of caution regarding potential oversights that could inadvertently impact innocent users of online identities, suggesting a need for careful consideration in implementation.

Contention

Notable points of contention involve concerns raised during committee discussions around the potential impacts on free speech and the definitions of what constitutes online impersonation. Critics fear that the bill could unintentionally penalize legitimate online activities, such as satire or parody, given the complex nature of online interactions. As the discussion evolves, navigating the balance between protecting victims from harm while ensuring that the law doesn't infringe on individual rights remains a crucial aspect of the ongoing legislative debate.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Civil Practice And Remedies Code

  • Chapter 98. Liability For Trafficking Of Persons
    • Section: New Section

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

CA AB469

Crimes: impersonation of first responders.

AZ HB2030

Impersonation; veteran; armed forces

WI SB132

Classification of the crime of impersonating law enforcement officers, fire fighters, and certain other emergency personnel and providing a penalty.

WI AB136

Classification of the crime of impersonating law enforcement officers, fire fighters, and certain other emergency personnel and providing a penalty.

TX HB783

Relating to civil liability for online impersonation.

TX SB2682

Relating to civil liability for online impersonation.

MS SB2197

Criminal law; increase penalties for crimes of impersonating patrolman or law enforcement officer.

AZ SB1424

Impersonation; veteran; armed forces