Texas House Bill HB4691

Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

• Filed: 3/10/23

Caption

Relating to public school accountability, including performance standards and sanctions and public high school graduation requirements.

Impact

The implications of HB 4691 are significant as they shift the focus of assessment from punitive measures to more supportive student evaluations. By removing the direct connection between end-of-course assessment results and graduation criteria, the bill seeks to foster a system that encourages learning and growth over test performance. This change is expected to impact the way school districts approach both assessments and instructional practices, aligning them more closely with student needs and learning outcomes rather than compliance with rigid standards.

Summary

House Bill 4691 addresses public school accountability in Texas by revising performance standards, sanctions, and high school graduation requirements. Specifically, it amends the Education Code to eliminate the criterion that end-of-course assessments can affect graduation eligibility. Instead, these assessments will primarily serve diagnostic purposes to identify student strengths and deficiencies. The bill aims to promote a more supportive educational environment by ensuring that assessments guide instructional strategies rather than serve as hurdles for graduation.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 4691 appears to be generally positive, particularly among educators and advocates who emphasize the importance of a supportive learning environment. Proponents argue that the bill represents a crucial step towards improving the educational landscape in Texas by reducing unnecessary pressure on students. However, some critics express concerns about potential implications regarding accountability and the effectiveness of measurement tools without graduation-related stakes, suggesting that it may lead to complacency in educational standards.

Contention

Despite the overall positive reception, there are notable points of contention surrounding HB 4691. Some stakeholders worry that the removal of assessment impact on graduation may lower educational standards and accountability for schools. Critics suggest that assessments play a vital role in ensuring that students meet minimum competency levels before graduating, and fear that eliminating this pressure could undermine efforts to increase academic achievement across the state. These discussions highlight the ongoing debate between fostering a supportive educational atmosphere and maintaining rigorous accountability measures.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Education Code

• Chapter 39. Public School System Accountability
  • Section: 025
  • Section: New Section