Texas 2015 - 84th Regular

Texas House Bill HB2617

Voted on by House
 
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to reorganizing the grand jury as the probable cause jury.

Impact

The impact of HB2617 on Texas laws includes amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure, dramatically altering how probable cause is determined in criminal cases. The proposed changes seek to enhance accountability and transparency in the judicial process by requiring that all jurors must be licensed attorneys with substantial legal experience. Additionally, the bill stipulates specific compensation for jurors, which is designed to attract qualified individuals to serve in this capacity, thus ensuring that the jury system operates at a high standard.

Summary

House Bill 2617 proposes a significant overhaul of the grand jury system in Texas by reorganizing it as a probable cause jury. This reform aims to streamline the process of determining whether there is sufficient evidence to bring charges against individuals. Instead of the traditional grand jury, which typically consists of a larger panel, the probable cause jury will consist of a smaller three-person panel appointed by various local officials, including a municipal presiding officer and a county judge. This bill represents a shift toward a more accessible and efficient legal framework for pre-trial procedures.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding this bill include concerns about the potential implications for justice and access to legal representation. Critics may argue that reducing the number of jurors could undermine the checks and balances inherent in the traditional grand jury system. Furthermore, questions have been raised regarding the independence of a smaller jury composed solely of attorneys, particularly in high-profile cases where biases and conflicts of interest could arise. As these discussions unfold, the balance between efficiency and thoroughness in the legal processes remains a critical concern.

Companion Bills

TX HJR112

Enabling for Proposing a constitutional amendment to change the composition of the grand jury.

Previously Filed As

TX HB1258

Relating to grand jury proceedings; providing a punishment for contempt of court.

TX HB519

Relating to the expunction of arrest records and files when a grand jury fails to find that probable cause exists to believe the alleged offense was committed.

TX HB4671

Relating to the qualifications and summoning of grand jurors.

TX SB677

Relating to grand jury proceedings.

TX HB469

Relating to the sequestration of a jury in a criminal case.

TX HB918

Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

TX HB142

Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

TX SB516

Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

TX HB4674

Relating to the qualifications, summoning, and reimbursement of jurors.

TX HB5159

Relating to an argument before the jury after a subsequent jury charge in a criminal case.

Similar Bills

CA AB2783

San Diego Unified Port District.

NJ S3054

Revises law requiring school districts, charter schools, nonpublic schools, and contracted service providers to review employment history of prospective employee for allegations of child abuse or sexual misconduct.

NJ A4126

Revises law requiring school districts, charter schools, nonpublic schools, and contracted service providers to review employment history of prospective employee for allegations of child abuse or sexual misconduct.

NJ A4074

Requires Commissioner of Education to review school safety and security plans.

NJ S1681

Requires Commissioner of Education to review school safety and security plans.

NJ A304

Requires Commissioner of Education to review school safety and security plans.

TX HB1842

Relating to public school accountability, including the intervention in and sanction of a public school that has received an academically unsuccessful performance rating for at least two consecutive school years and the designation of a school district as a district of innovation.

NJ S2780

Requires Commissioner of Education to review school safety and security plans.