Maine 2023-2024 Regular Session

Maine House Bill LD930

Introduced
3/2/23  
Refer
3/2/23  
Refer
3/2/23  

Caption

An Act to Allow Only Students of Female Gender to Participate in Women's and Girls' Scholastic Sports

Impact

Should LD930 be enacted, it will impact the existing state laws concerning gender participation in athletics, reinforcing the current trend seen in several states to define participation based on biological sex rather than gender identity. Proponents argue that the bill is necessary to ensure fairness in competitive sports, while opponents advocate that it undermines the rights of transgender and non-binary students, limiting their opportunities and participation in sports based on their gender identity. This legislative effort aligns with similar bills across the country aimed at restricting participation based on gender identity.

Summary

Bill LD930, titled 'An Act to Allow Only Students of Female Gender to Participate in Women's and Girls' Scholastic Sports', aims to establish clear guidelines regarding participation in scholastic sports for students designated as female. The bill specifically prohibits any student who is not identified as female from joining or participating in teams and sports activities designated for females, women, or girls at elementary, secondary, or postsecondary institutions. This measure is intended to preserve the integrity of women's and girls' sports by ensuring that only individuals of the female gender can compete in these events.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding LD930 has been deeply polarized. Supporters of the bill, including some parents and advocacy groups, assert the importance of protecting women's sports from perceived inequities that could arise from allowing transgender women to compete. Conversely, critics, including various LGBTQ+ rights organizations, express that the bill exacerbates discrimination against transgender individuals and violates principles of equality and inclusion. This division reflects broader societal debates surrounding gender identity and rights in various aspects of life, including sports.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding LD930 include the implications it may have on transgender athletes and the potential exclusion from sports based on gender identity. Opponents argue that laws like LD930 perpetuate discrimination and could lead to psychological harm for affected individuals. The discussions also revolve around whether the bill truly protects women's sports or primarily targets another demographic, raising fundamental questions about equality, inclusion, and the evolving understanding of gender in society.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

ME HB2238

Creating the fairness in women's sports act to require that female student athletic teams only include members who are biologically female.

ME SB44

Provides for the Fairness in Womens Sports Act relative to a school's ability to offer equal opportunities to each student to participate in team sporting events on an equal basis. (8/1/22) (EN SEE FISC NOTE GF EX See Note)

ME HB542

Provides for the Fairness in Women's Sports Act relative to a school's ability to offer opportunities to each student to participate in team sporting events on an equal basis

ME SB156

Provides for the Fairness in Women's Sports Act relative to a school's ability to offer opportunities to each student to participate in team sporting events on an equal basis. (8/1/21) (EN NO IMPACT LF EX See Note)

ME HB1120

K-12 schools and higher educational institutions; student participation in women's sports, etc.

ME SB723

K-12 schools and higher educational institutions; student participation in women's sports, etc.

ME SB749

K-12 schools and institutions of higher education; student participation in women's sports; civil cause of action.

ME HB1809

K-12 schools and higher educational institutions; student participation in women's sports, etc.

ME HB1399

Elementary schools, etc.; designation of interscholastic, etc., sports, student participation.

ME SB766

Schools; male students shall not participate in female sports, etc., civil cause of action.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.