Michigan House Bill HJRM

Michigan 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/20/24
• Refer: 2/20/24

Caption

Crimes: other; exception to prohibition on slavery; eliminate. Amends sec. 9, art. I of the state constitution.

Impact

If enacted, HJRM would fundamentally alter the legal landscape surrounding punishment for crimes in Michigan. Traditionally, the state constitution has allowed for exceptions where involuntary servitude could be applied as a form of punishment. By amending this provision, the bill aims to eliminate any ambiguity regarding the use of such practices, thereby aligning Michigan's laws with contemporary human rights standards and eliminating practices perceived as outdated or inhumane.

Summary

House Joint Resolution M (HJRM) proposes an amendment to the Michigan state constitution, specifically targeting Article I, Section 9. This amendment seeks to prohibit slavery and involuntary servitude for the punishment of crime, which traditionally has been an exception permitted under certain circumstances in the constitution. The resolution is framed as a necessary update to ensure that these practices are unequivocally outlawed within the state, reflecting a growing acknowledgement of human rights and dignity in the penal system.

Contention

Discussions surrounding HJRM may highlight various contentions. Opponents of the existing constitutional provision may argue that it allows for punitive labor as part of rehabilitation; however, proponents of the amendment assert that any form of servitude undermines fundamental human rights. This potential conflict suggests that while advocates for the amendment see it as an essential step towards justice reform, there are still debates about the implications for crime and punishment, as well as the broader impact on state prison systems.