Minnesota Senate Bill SF3033

Minnesota 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/22/23
• Refer: 3/22/23

Caption

Altering of a flag clarification

Impact

If enacted, this bill could significantly impact existing statutes in Minnesota relating to flag usage. By setting clear criteria for what constitutes an 'altered' flag, it could affect how individuals and organizations display flags in public spaces. The clarification might also influence legal proceedings related to the misuse or modification of flags, particularly concerning issues of free speech and artistic expression. Local governments and constitutional advocates may need to adjust their policies in alignment with the new definitions to ensure compliance and protect citizens' rights.

Summary

SF3033 is a bill that aims to clarify Minnesota Statutes regarding the alteration of flags, particularly the Stars and Stripes. The bill seeks to amend current laws to specify what constitutes an 'altered' flag and who can legally alter it. Specifically, it states that an altered flag cannot be changed without the approval of the flag's private or public owner unless the alteration falls under expressive conduct protected by state or federal constitutions. This change in definition is intended to provide clearer guidelines for what is considered acceptable use and display of flag designs in public and private domains.

Contention

The bill's provisions may create points of contention between advocates for free expression and those who advocate for respecting national symbols. Proponents of the bill argue that it helps safeguard the integrity of flags, particularly the national flag. However, critics may argue that such regulations could infringe upon the rights to free speech and artistic expression, especially in contexts where flags are used creatively or in protests. Debates on this bill may also reveal broader societal values regarding nationalism, patriotism, and individual rights within the Minnesota legislative context.