EXPLANATION-Matter enclosed in bold-faced brackets [thus] in this bill is not enacted and is intended to be omitted in the law. SECOND REGULAR SESSION SENATE BILL NO. 681 101ST GENERAL ASSEMBLY INTRODUCED BY SENATOR O'LAUGHLIN. 4133S.01I ADRIANE D. CROUSE, Secretary AN ACT To repeal sections 161.097, 167.263, 167.268, and 167.645, RSMo, and to enact in lieu thereof five new sections relating to reading success in schools, with a delayed effective date. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Missouri, as follows: Section A. Sections 161.097, 167.263, 167.268, and 1 167.645, RSMo, are repealed and five new section s enacted in 2 lieu thereof, to be known as sections 161.097, 167.263, 167.268, 3 167.645, and 186.080, to read as follows:4 161.097. 1. The state board of education shall 1 establish standards and procedures by which it will evaluate 2 all teacher training institutions in this state for the 3 approval of teacher education programs. The state board of 4 education shall not require teacher training institutions to 5 meet national or regional accreditation as a part of its 6 standards and procedures in making t hose evaluations, but it 7 may accept such accreditations in lieu of such approval if 8 standards and procedures set thereby are at least as 9 stringent as those set by the board. The state board of 10 education's standards and procedures for evaluating teache r 11 training institutions shall equal or exceed those of 12 national or regional accrediting associations. 13 2. There is hereby established within the department 14 of elementary and secondary education the "Missouri Advisory 15 Board for Educator Preparation ", hereinafter referred to as 16 "MABEP". The MABEP shall advise the state board of 17 SB 681 2 education and the coordinating board for higher education 18 regarding matters of mutual interest in the area of quality 19 educator preparation programs in Missouri. 20 3. Upon approval by the state board of education of 21 the teacher education program at a particular teacher 22 training institution, any person who graduates from that 23 program, and who meets other requirements which the state 24 board of education shall prescribe by rule, regulation and 25 statute shall be granted a certificate or license to teach 26 in the public schools of this state. However, no such rule 27 or regulation shall require that the program from which the 28 person graduates be accredited by any national o r regional 29 accreditation association. 30 4. The state board of education shall require literacy 31 and reading instruction coursework for teacher education 32 programs aligned to certification in early childhood 33 education, elementary education, middle sch ool education 34 with subject area certification in language arts, secondary 35 education with subject area certification in English, 36 special reading, and special education to include training 37 in: 38 (1) The core components of reading, such as phonemic 39 awareness, phonics, fluency, comprehension, morphology, 40 syntax, and vocabulary; 41 (2) Oral and written language development; 42 (3) Identification of reading deficiencies, dyslexia, 43 and other language difficulties; and 44 (4) The administration and interpretation of 45 assessments and how to translate assessment results into 46 effective practice in the classroom specific to the needs of 47 students. 48 SB 681 3 5. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that term is 49 defined in section 536.010, that is created un der the 50 authority delegated in this section shall become effective 51 only if it complies with and is subject to all of the 52 provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 53 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and 54 if any of the powers vested with the general assembly 55 pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective 56 date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently 57 held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking 58 authority and any rule proposed or adopted afte r August 28, 59 2014, shall be invalid and void. 60 167.263. 1. A program to provide teacher assistants 1 in regular classrooms in grades kindergarten through three 2 is established. For the purposes of this section a "teacher 3 assistant" is defined as a qualified person employed by a 4 school district to assist a certificated teacher in 5 classroom instruction and management. No teacher assistant 6 shall be counted as a teacher for the purposes of 7 establishing ratios of teachers to pupils in a classroom, 8 school or school district. Any public elementary school 9 containing such grades which meets the criteria pursuant to 10 this section shall be eligible for a state financial 11 supplement to employ teacher assistants. Eligibility 12 criteria are that the school shall have a breakfast program, 13 the school shall serve at least forty percent of its lunches 14 to pupils who are eligible for free or reduced price meals 15 according to federal guidelines, and the school shall have a 16 reading [intervention] success plan for any student who 17 requires such a plan pursuant to section 167.268. 18 2. A school district which contains such eligible 19 schools may apply to the department of elementary and 20 SB 681 4 secondary education for a state financial supplement to 21 employ teacher assistants in those schools named in the 22 application and in no other schools of the district. The 23 state full-time equivalent financial supplement shall be 24 three thousand dollars per teacher assistant. No more than 25 one assistant per classro om shall be supplemented by the 26 state pursuant to this section. Teacher assistants thus 27 employed pursuant to this section shall assist teachers in 28 grades kindergarten through three and in no other grades. 29 School districts shall not apply for or assig n teacher 30 assistants employed pursuant to this section in classrooms 31 designated as special education or compensatory education 32 classrooms. 33 3. The state board of education shall promulgate rules 34 and regulations for the implementation of this secti on. 35 Such rules shall include identifying minimum qualifications 36 for teacher assistants which may include teacher education 37 students, determining the minimum number of pupils per 38 classroom to be eligible for a teacher assistant, 39 establishing applicati on procedures for school districts, 40 and determining a method of awarding state financial 41 supplements in the event that the number of applications 42 exceeds the amounts appropriated therefor. No rule or 43 portion of a rule promulgated under the authority o f this 44 chapter shall become effective unless it has been 45 promulgated pursuant to the provisions of section 536.024. 46 167.268. 1. The state board of education, in 1 collaboration with the coordinating board for higher 2 education and the literacy advisory council established 3 pursuant to section 186.080, shall develop a plan to 4 establish a comprehensive system of services for reading 5 instruction. 6 SB 681 5 2. Each local school district and charter school shall 7 have on file a policy for rea ding [intervention] success 8 plans for any pupils of the district or charter school in 9 grades kindergarten through [three] four pursuant to the 10 provisions of this section. Such plans shall identify 11 strategies to be followed by the district or charter school 12 teachers to raise a pupil identified as reading below grade 13 level by recognized methods to reading at grade level by the 14 end of the [third] fourth grade. Recognized methods of 15 identification may include but need not be limited to the 16 scores of the pupil obtained through any established 17 standardized testing program currently administered by the 18 district or charter school, observations of classroom 19 teachers, and documented classroom performance. The local 20 policy shall be aligned with the guid elines developed by the 21 department of elementary and secondary education for reading 22 success plans. 23 [2.] 3. The [state board of] department of elementary 24 and secondary education shall develop guidelines to assist 25 school districts and charter schools in formulating policies 26 for reading [intervention] success plans. Such guidelines 27 may include, but are not limited to, measures of reading 28 proficiency, strategies for addressing reading deficiencies 29 and disorders, timelines for measuring pupil imp rovement in 30 reading[,] and information on screening for and treatment of 31 [auditory] dyslexia[, and information on the Lindamood 32 Auditory Conceptualization Test and the Auditory 33 Discrimination in Depth Program ] and other reading 34 deficiencies. In addition, any guidelines for instruction 35 shall meet the needs of the students by ensuring that 36 instruction is explicit, systematic, and diagnostic and 37 based on phonological awareness, phonics, fluency, 38 SB 681 6 vocabulary, comprehension, morphology, syntax, and 39 semantics. Such guidelines may also identify performance 40 levels for pupils identified as handicapped or severely 41 handicapped and conditions under which such pupils [are] may 42 be exempt from the provisions of this section. 43 [3.] 4. Each local school di strict [enrolling a pupil 44 identified as reading below grade level shall develop an 45 individual plan of reading intervention for such pupil. The 46 individual pupil's plan may include individual or group 47 reading development activities. The plan may be developed 48 after consultation with the pupil's parent or legal 49 guardian] and charter school shall provide supplemental 50 reading instruction under a reading success plan created 51 pursuant to section 167.645 to any enrolled student who 52 exhibits a reading defi ciency. 53 167.645. 1. For purposes of this section, the 1 following terms mean: 2 (1) "Dyslexia", the same meaning given to the term in 3 section 633.420; 4 (2) "Evidence-based reading instruction", scientific 5 research-based interventions that have been peer reviewed 6 with substantial evidence of their effectiveness through 7 multiple outcome evaluation; 8 (3) "Reading assessment", a recognized method of 9 judging a student's reading ability, with results expressed 10 as reading at a particular grade level. The term reading 11 assessment shall include, but is not limited to, standard 12 checklists designed for use as a student reads out loud, 13 paper-and-pencil tests promulgated by nationally recognized 14 organizations and other recogniz ed methods of determining a 15 student's reading accuracy, expression, fluency and 16 comprehension in order to make a determination of the 17 SB 681 7 student's grade-level reading ability. Assessments [which] 18 that do not give a grade-level result may be used in 19 combination with other assessments to reach a grade -level 20 determination. Districts and charter schools are encouraged 21 but not required to select assessment methods identified 22 pursuant to section 167.346. Districts and charter schools 23 are [also] encouraged to use multiple methods of assessment; 24 [(2)] (4) "Structured literacy", an evidence -based 25 reading instruction that addresses phonology, sound -symbol 26 association, syllable instruction, morphology, syntax, and 27 semantics when such instruction is ta ught through 28 systematic, cumulative, explicit, and diagnostic methods; 29 (5) "Summer school", for reading instruction purposes, 30 a minimum of forty hours of reading instruction and 31 practice. A school district or charter school may arrange 32 the hours and days of instruction to coordinate with its 33 regular program of summer school. 34 2. For purposes of this section, methods of reading 35 assessment shall be determined by each school district and 36 charter school. Each school district and charter scho ol 37 shall provide training on the administration of reading 38 assessments to all kindergarten through fifth grade teachers 39 and any other personnel who provide literacy instruction . 40 Unless a student has been determined in the [current] 41 previous school year to be reading at grade level or above, 42 each school district and charter school shall administer a 43 reading assessment or set of assessments to each student 44 within [forty-five days of the end of the third -grade year] 45 the first thirty calendar days of school for grades one 46 through four, and by January thirty -first for kindergarten , 47 except that the provisions of this subsection shall not 48 apply to students receiving special education services under 49 SB 681 8 an individualized education plan pursuant to sections 50 162.670 to 162.999, to students receiving services pursuant 51 to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 whose 52 services plan includes an element addressing reading or to 53 students determined to have limited English proficiency or 54 to students who have been determined, prior to the beginning 55 of any school year, to have a cognitive ability insufficient 56 to meet the reading requirement set out in this section, 57 provided that districts and charter schools shall provide 58 reading [improvement] success plans for students with an 59 individualized education plan that have a reading 60 deficiency, for students receiving services under Section 61 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 whose service plan 62 includes an element addressing reading, and to students 63 determined to have such insufficient cognitive ability. The 64 assessment required by this subsection shall also be 65 required for students who enter a school district or charter 66 school in grades four, five , or six unless such student has 67 been determined in the current school year to be reading at 68 grade level or above. 69 3. [Beginning with school year 2002 -03, for each 70 student whose third-grade reading assessment determines that 71 such student is reading below second -grade level, the school 72 district shall design a reading improvement plan for the 73 student's fourth-grade year. Such reading improvement plan 74 shall include, at a minimum, thirty hours of additional 75 reading instruction or practice outside the regular school 76 day during the fourth -grade year.] (1) School districts 77 and charter schools shall offer a reading success plan to 78 each student in grades kindergarten through four who 79 exhibits a reading deficiency, has been identified as being 80 at risk for dyslexia in the statewide dyslexia screening 81 SB 681 9 requirement, or has a formal diagnosis of dyslexia to ensure 82 students can read at or above grade level by the end of the 83 fourth grade. School districts and charter schools shall 84 consider the input of teachers and other building -level 85 staff when identifying students for reading success plans. 86 The reading success plan shall be provided in addition to 87 core reading instruction that is provided to all students in 88 the general education classroom. The reading success plan 89 shall: 90 (a) Include, at a minimum, thirty hours of additional 91 reading instruction or practice outside the regular school 92 day during the fourth -grade year; 93 (b) Be provided to all students in grades kindergarten 94 through four identified with a reading deficiency as 95 determined by the school district or charter school using 96 local or statewide screening assessments administered within 97 the first thirty days of school for grades one through four, 98 and by January thirty -first for kindergarten; 99 (c) Provide explicit and syste matic multisensory 100 instruction in phonological awareness, phonics, fluency, 101 vocabulary, and comprehension as applicable to each student; 102 (d) Monitor the reading progress of each student's 103 reading skills throughout the school year and adjust 104 instruction according to the student's needs; and 105 (e) Be implemented during regular school hours. 106 (2) A structured literacy reading program shall be 107 provided to any student with a formal diagnosis of dyslexia 108 or for a student who was found to be a t risk for dyslexia in 109 the statewide dyslexia screening. 110 (3) If a student who is provided a reading success 111 plan is determined to not be reading at or above grade level 112 by the end of second grade, the student shall receive 113 SB 681 10 structured literacy ins truction as well as additional 114 support and services including but not limited to: 115 (a) Frequent, targeted reading intervention based on 116 the student's needs and provided in a small -group or one-on- 117 one setting; 118 (b) Frequent monitoring of the st udent's reading 119 skills throughout the school year; and 120 (c) Adjustment of the structured literacy instruction 121 and reading interventions according to the student's needs. 122 (4) For students in grades six through twelve, school 123 districts and charter schools shall continue to address the 124 reading deficiencies of any student for whom the deficiency 125 creates a barrier to success in school. 126 4. A reading success plan shall be created for a 127 student within forty -five days following the identificat ion 128 of a reading deficiency by such student's teacher and other 129 pertinent school personnel, after consultation with the 130 student's parent or legal guardian, and shall describe the 131 evidence-based reading intervention services the student 132 shall receive to remedy the deficiency. The reading success 133 plan shall specify whether the student was found to be at 134 risk for dyslexia in the local or statewide dyslexia 135 screening requirement or whether the student has a formal 136 diagnosis of dyslexia. Each student shall receive 137 appropriate reading intervention until the student no longer 138 has a deficiency in reading. 139 5. The school district or charter school shall 140 determine the [method of reading instruction ] specific 141 structured literacy curriculum necessary to enforce this 142 subsection. The school district or charter school may also 143 require the student to attend summer school for reading 144 instruction as a condition of promotion to fourth grade. 145 SB 681 11 The department of elementary and secondary education may, 146 from funds appropriated for the purpose, reimburse school 147 districts and charter schools for additional instructional 148 personnel costs incurred in the implementation and execution 149 of the thirty hours of additional reading instruction minus 150 the revenue generated by the school district or charter 151 school through the foundation formula for the additional 152 reading instruction average daily attendance. 153 [4.] 6. Each student for whom a reading [improvement] 154 success plan has been designed pursuant to subsect ion 3 of 155 this section shall be given another reading assessment, to 156 be administered within forty -five days of the end of such 157 student's fourth-grade year. If such student is determined 158 to be reading below third -grade level at the end of the 159 third grade, the student shall be [required to attend summer 160 school to receive reading instruction. At the end of such 161 summer school instruction, such student shall be given 162 another reading assessment. If such student is determined 163 to be reading below third -grade level, the district shall 164 notify the student's parents or guardians, and the student 165 shall not be promoted to fifth grade. No student shall be 166 denied promotion more than once solely for inability to meet 167 the reading standards set out in this sect ion. 168 5. The process described in subsections 3 and 4 of 169 this section shall be repeated as necessary through the end 170 of the sixth grade, with the target grade level rising 171 accordingly. Mandatory retention in grade shall not apply 172 to grades subsequent to fourth grade ] referred for an 173 evaluation for an individualized education plan (IEP) and 174 the district shall provide appropriate intensive structured 175 literacy instruction on a one -to-one individualized basis. 176 If the student does not qualify for an IEP under the state 177 SB 681 12 guidelines for qualification, the student shall continue to 178 receive appropriate intensive structured literacy 179 instruction on a one -to-one individualized basis until the 180 student is reading at grade level . 181 [6. The mandatory process of additional reading 182 instruction pursuant to this section shall cease at the end 183 of the sixth grade. The permanent record of students who 184 are determined to be reading below the fifth -grade level at 185 the end of sixth grade shall carry a notation advising that 186 such student has not met minimal reading standards. The 187 notation shall stay on the student's record until such time 188 as the district determines that a student has met minimal 189 reading standards.] 190 7. Each school district and charter school shall be 191 required to offer summer school reading instruction to any 192 student with a reading [improvement] success plan. 193 Districts and charter schools may fulfill the requirement of 194 this section through cooperative arrangements with 195 neighboring districts[; provided that such districts shall 196 timely make all payments provided pursuant to such 197 cooperative agreements ]. 198 8. A school district or charter school may adopt a 199 policy that requires retention in grade of any student who 200 has been determined to require summer school instruction in 201 reading and who does not fulfill the summer school 202 attendance requirement. 203 9. Nothing in this section shall preclude a school 204 district or charter school from retaining any student in 205 grade when a determination is made in accordance with 206 district or charter school policy that retention is in the 207 best interests of the student. 208 SB 681 13 10. The state board of education shall evaluate and 209 give weight to district and charter school reading 210 interventions and compliance with the provisions of this 211 section within the Missouri school improvement program. 212 11. The state board of education shall not incorporate 213 information about the number of students receiving 214 additional instruction pursuant to this sec tion into any 215 element of any standard of the Missouri school improvement 216 program or its successor accreditation program; provided, 217 however, each district or charter school shall make 218 available, upon the request of any parent, patron, advocacy 219 group, or media outlet [within the district], the number and 220 percentage of students receiving remediation pursuant to 221 this section. The information shall be presented in a way 222 that does not permit personal identification of any student 223 or educational personne l. 224 [11.] 12. Each school district and charter school 225 shall make a systematic effort to inform parents of the 226 methods and materials used to teach reading in kindergarten 227 through [fourth] fifth grade, in terms understandable to a 228 layperson [and shall similarly inform parents of students 229 for whom a reading improvement plan is required pursuant to 230 this section]. Notice to the parent or legal guardian of 231 any student for whom a reading success plan is required 232 shall be provided within thirty days. Such communication 233 may be through electronic or other means; however, effort 234 shall be made to ensure a parent received such 235 communication. The notice shall state that the student has 236 been identified as having a deficiency in reading identified 237 through a screening or other method. The communication 238 shall also note if the student screened positive for the 239 SB 681 14 characteristics of dyslexia. Additionally, the 240 communication shall include the following information: 241 (1) That a reading success plan for the student shall 242 be developed by the teacher and other personnel; 243 (2) A description of the current services and 244 proposed, evidence-based structured literacy interventions 245 and supplemental services; 246 (3) That the parent or guardian shall have the 247 opportunity for input regarding the reading success plan; 248 (4) The timing for periodic updates on student 249 progress, which shall be aligned with other normal interim 250 student progress updates to the extent practical; and 251 (5) Suggested strategies for use at home to help the 252 student succeed in reading. 253 13. The department of elementary and secondary 254 education may promulgate rules to implement the provisions 255 of this section. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that 256 term is defined in s ection 536.010, that is created under 257 the authority delegated in this section shall become 258 effective only if it complies with and is subject to all of 259 the provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 260 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable, and 261 if any of the powers vested with the general assembly 262 pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective 263 date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently 264 held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking 265 authority and any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 266 2022, shall be invalid and void. 267 186.080. 1. There is hereby established within the 1 department of elementary and secondary education the 2 "Literacy Advisory Council", which shall be com posed of at 3 least fifteen and no more than twenty members to be 4 SB 681 15 appointed by the commissioner of education. The members of 5 the council shall include at least: 6 (1) One public school board member; 7 (2) One charter school representative; 8 (3) One public school district superintendent; 9 (4) One elementary or secondary school principal; 10 (5) Three teachers with expertise in reading 11 instruction, including at least one teacher selected by each 12 of the three largest statewide teacher organizations, and 13 all of whom shall either be certified by the Center for 14 Effective Reading Instruction or shall have completed all 15 levels of the Language Essentials for Teachers of Reading 16 and Spelling training program; 17 (6) One special educatio n teacher; 18 (7) One parent of an elementary or secondary school 19 student who has been diagnosed with dyslexia; 20 (8) One representative from Decoding Dyslexia Missouri; 21 (9) One representative from an institution of 22 postsecondary education w hich offers approved teacher 23 preparation programs; 24 (10) One representative from an independent private 25 provider or nonprofit organization serving individuals with 26 dyslexia; 27 (11) One representative from the Missouri branch of 28 the International Dyslexia Association; 29 (12) One certified academic language therapist 30 recommended by the Academic Language Therapy Association who 31 is a resident of this state; 32 (13) One professional with experience diagnosing 33 dyslexia, such as a school p sychologist or 34 neuropsychologist, who is licensed under chapter 337; and 35 SB 681 16 (14) One dyslexia specialist from the department of 36 elementary and secondary education. 37 2. The advisory council shall meet biannually to 38 review best practices in litera cy instruction and related 39 policies. 40 3. The advisory council shall periodically provide 41 recommendations to the commissioner and the state board of 42 education regarding any identified improvements to literacy 43 instruction and policy for elementary a nd secondary 44 students. The recommendations may include recommendations 45 for changes to state law, and the commissioner shall furnish 46 any such recommendations to the joint committee on education. 47 4. The department of elementary and secondary 48 education, in conjunction with the advisory council, shall 49 identify and create a list of approved materials, resources, 50 and curriculum programs for public school districts and 51 charter schools. A school district or charter school shall 52 use only materials, re sources, or curriculum programs from 53 such list. 54 Section B. The repeal and reenactment of section 1 167.645 of section A of this act shall become effective on 2 July 1, 2023. 3