EXPLANATION-Matter enclosed in bold-faced brackets [thus] in this bill is not enacted and is intended to be omitted in the law. FIRST REGULAR SESSION SENATE BILL NO. 11 103RD GENERAL ASSEMBLY INTRODUCED BY SENATOR HOUGH. 1191S.01I KRISTINA MARTIN, Secretary AN ACT To repeal sections 172.280, 173.005, 173.030, 173.040, 173.616, 173.750, 174.160, 174.231, 174.251, and 174.310, RSMo, and to enact in lieu thereof ten new sections relating to the authority to confer degrees at public institutions of higher education, with existing penalty provisions. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Missouri, as follows: Section A. Sections 172.280, 173.005, 173.030, 173.040, 1 173.616, 173.750, 174.160, 174.231, 174.251, and 174.310, RSMo, 2 are repealed and ten new sections enacted in lieu thereof, to 3 be known as sections 172.280, 173.005, 173.030, 173.040, 4 173.616, 173.750, 174.160, 174.231, 174.251, and 174.310, to 5 read as follows:6 172.280. The curators shall have the authority to 1 confer, by diploma, under their common seal, on any person 2 whom they may judge worthy thereof, such degrees as are 3 known to and usually granted b y any college or university. 4 [The University of Missouri is the state's only public 5 research university and the exclusive grantor of research 6 doctorates. As such, except as provided in section 175.040, 7 the University of Missouri shall be the only sta te college 8 or university that may offer doctor of philosophy degrees or 9 first-professional degrees, including dentistry, law, 10 medicine, optometry, pharmacy, and veterinary medicine. ] 11 173.005. 1. There is hereby created a "Department of 1 Higher Education and Workforce Development", and the 2 SB 11 2 division of higher education of the department of education 3 is abolished and all its powers, duties, functions, 4 personnel and property are transferred as provided by the 5 Reorganization Act of 19 74, Appendix B, RSMo. 6 2. The commission on higher education is abolished and 7 all its powers, duties, personnel and property are 8 transferred by type I transfer to the "Coordinating Board 9 for Higher Education", which is hereby created, and the 10 coordinating board shall be the head of the department. The 11 coordinating board shall consist of nine members appointed 12 by the governor with the advice and consent of the senate, 13 and not more than five of its members shall be of the same 14 political party. None of the members shall be engaged 15 professionally as an educator or educational administrator 16 with a public or private institution of higher education at 17 the time appointed or during his term. Moreover, no person 18 shall be appointed to the coordinati ng board who shall not 19 be a citizen of the United States, and who shall not have 20 been a resident of the state of Missouri two years next 21 prior to appointment, and at least one but not more than two 22 persons shall be appointed to said board from each 23 congressional district. The term of service of a member of 24 the coordinating board shall be six years and said members, 25 while attending the meetings of the board, shall be 26 reimbursed for their actual expenses. Notwithstanding any 27 provision of law to the contrary, nothing in this section 28 relating to a change in the composition and configuration of 29 congressional districts in this state shall prohibit a 30 member who is serving a term on August 28, 2011, from 31 completing his or her term. The coordinating board may, in 32 order to carry out the duties prescribed for it in 33 subsections 1, 2, 3, 7, and 8 of this section, employ such 34 SB 11 3 professional, clerical and research personnel as may be 35 necessary to assist it in performing those duties, but this 36 staff shall not, in any fiscal year, exceed twenty -five full- 37 time equivalent employees regardless of the source of 38 funding. In addition to all other powers, duties and 39 functions transferred to it, the coordinating board for 40 higher education shall have the followi ng duties and 41 responsibilities: 42 (1) The coordinating board for higher education may 43 approve, not approve, or provisionally approve proposed new 44 degree programs to be offered by the state institutions of 45 higher education. The coordinating board m ay authorize a 46 degree program outside an institution's coordinating board - 47 approved mission only when the coordinating board has 48 received clear evidence that the institution proposing to 49 offer the program: 50 (a) Made a good-faith effort to explore t he 51 feasibility of offering the program in collaboration with an 52 institution the mission of which includes offering the 53 program; 54 (b) Is contributing substantially to the goals in the 55 coordinating board's coordinated plan for higher education; 56 (c) Has the existing capacity to ensure the program is 57 delivered in a high-quality manner; 58 (d) Has demonstrated that the proposed program is 59 needed; 60 (e) Has a clear plan to meet the articulated workforce 61 need; and 62 (f) Such other factors deemed relevant by the 63 coordinating board; 64 (2) [The governing board of each public institution of 65 higher education in the state shall have the power and 66 SB 11 4 authority to confer degrees in chiropractic, osteopathic 67 medicine, and podiatry only in c ollaboration with the 68 University of Missouri, provided that such collaborative 69 agreements are approved by the governing board of each 70 institution and that in these instances the University of 71 Missouri will be the degree -granting institution. Should 72 the University of Missouri decline to collaborate in the 73 offering of such programs, any of these institutions may 74 seek approval of the program through the coordinating board 75 for higher education's comprehensive review process when 76 doing so would not unn ecessarily duplicate an existing 77 program, collaboration is not feasible or a viable means of 78 meeting the needs of students and employers, and the 79 institution has the academic and financial capacity to offer 80 the program in a high quality manner; 81 (3)] The coordinating board for higher education may 82 promote and encourage the development of cooperative 83 agreements between Missouri public four -year institutions of 84 higher education which do not offer graduate degrees and 85 Missouri public four -year institutions of higher education 86 which do offer graduate degrees for the purpose of offering 87 graduate degree programs on campuses of those public four - 88 year institutions of higher education which do not otherwise 89 offer graduate degrees. Such agreements shall identify the 90 obligations and duties of the parties, including assignment 91 of administrative responsibility. Any diploma awarded for 92 graduate degrees under such a cooperative agreement shall 93 include the names of both institutions inscribed thereon. 94 Any cooperative agreement in place as of August 28, 2003, 95 shall require no further approval from the coordinating 96 board for higher education. Any costs incurred with respect 97 to the administrative provisions of this subdivision may be 98 SB 11 5 paid from state funds allocated to the institution assigned 99 the administrative authority for the program. The 100 provisions of this subdivision shall not be construed to 101 invalidate the provisions of subdivision (1) of this 102 subsection; 103 [(4)] (3) In consultation with the heads of the 104 institutions of higher education affected and against a 105 background of carefully collected data on enrollment, 106 physical facilities, manpower needs, and institutional 107 missions, the coordinating board for higher education shall 108 establish guidelines for appropriation requests by those 109 institutions of higher education; however, other provisions 110 of the Reorganization Act of 1974 notwithstanding, all funds 111 shall be appropriated by the general assembly to the 112 governing board of each pub lic four-year institution of 113 higher education which shall prepare expenditure budgets for 114 the institution; 115 [(5)] (4) No new state-supported senior colleges or 116 residence centers shall be established except as provided by 117 law and with approval of t he coordinating board for higher 118 education; 119 [(6)] (5) The coordinating board for higher education 120 shall establish admission guidelines consistent with 121 institutional missions; 122 [(7)] (6) The coordinating board for higher education 123 shall require all public two-year and four-year higher 124 education institutions to replicate best practices in 125 remediation identified by the coordinating board and 126 institutions from research undertaken by regional 127 educational laboratories, higher education research 128 organizations, and similar organizations with expertise in 129 the subject, and identify and reduce methods that have been 130 SB 11 6 found to be ineffective in preparing or retaining students 131 or that delay students from enrollment in college -level 132 courses; 133 [(8)] (7) The coordinating board shall establish 134 policies and procedures for institutional decisions relating 135 to the residence status of students; 136 [(9)] (8) The coordinating board shall establish 137 guidelines to promote and facilitate the transfer of 138 students between institutions of higher education within the 139 state and, with the assistance of the committee on transfer 140 and articulation, shall require all public two -year and four- 141 year higher education institutions to create by July 1, 142 2014, a statewide core transfer library of at least twenty - 143 five lower division courses across all institutions that are 144 transferable among all public higher education 145 institutions. The coordinating board shall establish 146 policies and procedures to ensure such cour ses are accepted 147 in transfer among public institutions and treated as 148 equivalent to similar courses at the receiving 149 institutions. The coordinating board shall develop a policy 150 to foster reverse transfer for any student who has 151 accumulated enough hou rs in combination with at least one 152 public higher education institution in Missouri that offers 153 an associate degree and one public four -year higher 154 education institution in the prescribed courses sufficient 155 to meet the public higher education instituti on's 156 requirements to be awarded an associate degree. The 157 department of elementary and secondary education shall 158 maintain the alignment of the assessments found in section 159 160.518 and successor assessments with the competencies 160 previously established under this subdivision for entry - 161 level collegiate courses in English, mathematics, foreign 162 SB 11 7 language, sciences, and social sciences associated with an 163 institution's general education core; 164 [(10)] (9) The coordinating board shall collect the 165 necessary information and develop comparable data for all 166 institutions of higher education in the state. The 167 coordinating board shall use this information to delineate 168 the areas of competence of each of these institutions and 169 for any other purposes deemed a ppropriate by the 170 coordinating board; 171 [(11)] (10) Compliance with requests from the 172 coordinating board for institutional information and the 173 other powers, duties and responsibilities, herein assigned 174 to the coordinating board, shall be a prerequi site to the 175 receipt of any funds which the coordinating board is 176 responsible for administering; 177 [(12)] (11) If any institution of higher education in 178 this state, public or private, willfully fails or refuses to 179 follow any lawful guideline, policy or procedure established 180 or prescribed by the coordinating board, or knowingly 181 deviates from any such guideline, or knowingly acts without 182 coordinating board approval where such approval is required, 183 or willfully fails to comply with any other lawful order of 184 the coordinating board, the coordinating board may, after a 185 public hearing, withhold or direct to be withheld from that 186 institution any funds the disbursement of which is subject 187 to the control of the coordinating board, or may remove the 188 approval of the institution as an approved institution 189 within the meaning of section 173.1102. If any such public 190 institution willfully disregards board policy, the 191 commissioner of higher education may order such institution 192 to remit a fine in an amount not to exceed one percent of 193 the institution's current fiscal year state operating 194 SB 11 8 appropriation to the board. The board shall hold such funds 195 until such time that the institution, as determined by the 196 commissioner of higher education, corrects the vi olation, at 197 which time the board shall refund such amount to the 198 institution. If the commissioner determines that the 199 institution has not redressed the violation within one year, 200 the fine amount shall be deposited into the general revenue 201 fund, unless the institution appeals such decision to the 202 full coordinating board, which shall have the authority to 203 make a binding and final decision, by means of a majority 204 vote, regarding the matter. However, nothing in this 205 section shall prevent any institut ion of higher education in 206 this state from presenting additional budget requests or 207 from explaining or further clarifying its budget requests to 208 the governor or the general assembly; 209 [(13)] (12) In recognition of institutions that meet 210 the requirements of subdivision (2), (3), or (4) of 211 subsection 1 of section 173.616, are established by name as 212 an educational institution in Missouri, and are authorized 213 to operate programs beyond secondary education for purposes 214 of authorization under 34 CFR 6 00.9, the coordinating board 215 for higher education shall maintain and publish on its 216 website a list of such postsecondary educational 217 institutions; and 218 [(14)] (13) (a) As used in this subdivision, the term 219 "out-of-state public institution of high er education" shall 220 mean an education institution located outside of Missouri 221 that: 222 a. Is controlled or administered directly by a public 223 agency or political subdivision or is classified as a public 224 institution by the state; 225 SB 11 9 b. Receives appropriations for operating expenses 226 directly or indirectly from a state other than Missouri; 227 c. Provides a postsecondary course of instruction at 228 least six months in length leading to or directly creditable 229 toward a degree or certificate; 230 d. Meets the standards for accreditation by an 231 accrediting body recognized by the United States Department 232 of Education or any successor agency; and 233 e. Permits faculty members to select textbooks without 234 influence or pressure by any religious or sect arian source. 235 (b) No later than July 1, 2008, the coordinating board 236 shall promulgate rules regarding: 237 a. The board's approval process of proposed new degree 238 programs and course offerings by any out -of-state public 239 institution of higher educ ation seeking to offer degree 240 programs or course work within the state of Missouri; and 241 b. The board's approval process of degree programs and 242 courses offered by any out -of-state public institutions of 243 higher education that, prior to July 1, 2008, were approved 244 by the board to operate a school in compliance with the 245 provisions of sections 173.600 to 173.618. The rules shall 246 ensure that, as of July 1, 2008, all out -of-state public 247 institutions seeking to offer degrees and courses within the 248 state of Missouri are evaluated in a manner similar to 249 Missouri public higher education institutions. Such out-of- 250 state public institutions shall be held to standards no 251 lower than the standards established by the coordinating 252 board for program approval and the policy guidelines of the 253 coordinating board for data collection, cooperation, and 254 resolution of disputes between Missouri institutions of 255 higher education under this section. Any such out-of-state 256 public institutions of higher education wishi ng to continue 257 SB 11 10 operating within this state must be approved by the board 258 under the rules promulgated under this subdivision. The 259 coordinating board may charge and collect fees from out -of- 260 state public institutions to cover the costs of reviewing 261 and assuring the quality of programs offered by out -of-state 262 public institutions. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that 263 term is defined in section 536.010, that is created under 264 the authority delegated in this section shall become 265 effective only if it co mplies with and is subject to all of 266 the provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 267 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and 268 if any of the powers vested with the general assembly under 269 chapter 536 to review, to delay the e ffective date, or to 270 disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently held 271 unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking authority and 272 any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 2007, shall be 273 invalid and void. 274 (c) Nothing in this subdivision or in section 173.616 275 shall be construed or interpreted so that students attending 276 an out-of-state public institution are considered to be 277 attending a Missouri public institution of higher education 278 for purposes of obtaining student financial assistance. 279 3. The coordinating board shall meet at least four 280 times annually with an advisory committee who shall be 281 notified in advance of such meetings. The coordinating 282 board shall have exclusive voting privileges. The advisory 283 committee shall consist of thirty-two members, who shall be 284 the president or other chief administrative officer of the 285 University of Missouri; the chancellor of each campus of the 286 University of Missouri; the president of each state - 287 supported four-year college or university, i ncluding Harris- 288 Stowe State University, Missouri Southern State University, 289 SB 11 11 Missouri Western State University, and Lincoln University; 290 the president of State Technical College of Missouri; the 291 president or chancellor of each public community college 292 district; and representatives of each of five accredited 293 private institutions selected biennially, under the 294 supervision of the coordinating board, by the presidents of 295 all of the state's privately supported institutions; but 296 always to include at least one representative from one 297 privately supported community college, one privately 298 supported four-year college, and one privately supported 299 university. The conferences shall enable the committee to 300 advise the coordinating board of the views of the 301 institutions on matters within the purview of the 302 coordinating board. 303 4. The University of Missouri, Lincoln University, and 304 all other state-governed colleges and universities, chapters 305 172, 174, 175, and others, are transferred by type III 306 transfers to the department of higher education and 307 workforce development subject to the provisions of 308 subsection 2 of this section. 309 5. The state historical society, chapter 183, is 310 transferred by type III transfer to the University of 311 Missouri. 312 6. The state anatomical board, chapter 194, is 313 transferred by type II transfer to the department of higher 314 education and workforce development. 315 7. All the powers, duties and functions vested in the 316 division of public schools and state board of educat ion 317 relating to community college state aid and the supervision, 318 formation of districts and all matters otherwise related to 319 the state's relations with community college districts and 320 matters pertaining to community colleges in public school 321 SB 11 12 districts, chapters 163, 178, and others, are transferred to 322 the coordinating board for higher education by type I 323 transfer. Provided, however, that all responsibility for 324 administering the federal -state programs of vocational - 325 technical education, except for t he 1202a postsecondary 326 educational amendments of 1972 program, shall remain with 327 the department of elementary and secondary education. The 328 department of elementary and secondary education and the 329 coordinating board for higher education shall cooperate in 330 developing the various plans for vocational -technical 331 education; however, the ultimate responsibility will remain 332 with the state board of education. 333 8. All the powers, duties, functions, and properties 334 of the state poultry experiment station, chapter 262, are 335 transferred by type I transfer to the University of 336 Missouri, and the state poultry association and state 337 poultry board are abolished. In the event the University of 338 Missouri shall cease to use the real estate of the poultry 339 experiment station for the purposes of research or shall 340 declare the same surplus, all real estate shall revert to 341 the governor of the state of Missouri and shall not be 342 disposed of without legislative approval. 343 173.030. The coordinating board, in addition, shall 1 have responsibility, within the provisions of the 2 constitution and the statutes of the state of Missouri, for: 3 (1) Requesting the governing boards of all state - 4 supported institutions of higher education, and of major 5 private institutions to submit to the coordinating board any 6 proposed policy changes which would create additional 7 institutions of higher education, additional residence 8 centers, or major additions in degree and certificate 9 SB 11 13 programs, and make pertinent reco mmendations relating 10 thereto; 11 (2) Recommending to the governing board of any 12 institution of higher education in the state the 13 development, consolidation, or elimination of programs, 14 degree offerings, physical facilities or policy changes 15 where that action is deemed by the coordinating board as in 16 the best interests of the institutions themselves and/or the 17 general requirements of the state. Recommendations shall be 18 submitted to governing boards by twelve months preceding the 19 term in which the action may take effect; 20 (3) Recommending to the governing boards of state - 21 supported institutions of higher education, including public 22 community colleges receiving state support, formulas to be 23 employed in specifying plans for general operations , for 24 development and expansion, and for requests for 25 appropriations from the general assembly. Such 26 recommendations will be submitted to the governing boards by 27 April first of each year preceding a regular session of the 28 general assembly of the stat e of Missouri; 29 (4) Promulgating rules to include selected off -campus 30 instruction in public college and university appropriation 31 recommendations where prior need has been established in 32 areas designated by the coordinating board for higher 33 education. Funding for such off -campus instruction shall be 34 included in the appropriation recommendations, shall be 35 determined by the general assembly and shall continue, 36 within the amounts appropriated therefor, unless the general 37 assembly disapproves the a ction by concurrent resolution; 38 (5) Coordinating reciprocal agreements between or 39 among Missouri state institutions of higher education at the 40 request of one or more of the institutions party to the 41 SB 11 14 agreement, and between or among Missouri state i nstitutions 42 of higher education and publicly supported higher education 43 institutions located outside the state of Missouri at the 44 request of any Missouri institution party to the agreement; 45 (6) Entering into agreements for interstate 46 reciprocity regarding the delivery of postsecondary distance 47 education, administering such agreements, and approving or 48 disapproving applications to participate in such agreements 49 from a postsecondary institution that has its principal 50 campus in the state of Misso uri: 51 (a) The coordinating board shall establish standards 52 for institutional approval. Those standards shall include, 53 but are not limited to the: 54 a. Definition of physical presence for non -Missouri 55 institutions serving Missouri residents con sistent with 56 other states' definitions of physical presence; and 57 b. Establishment of consumer protection policies for 58 distance education addressing recruitment and marketing 59 activities; disclosure of tuition, fees, and other charges; 60 disclosure of admission processes and procedures; and 61 student complaints; 62 (b) The coordinating board shall establish policies 63 for the review and resolution of student complaints arising 64 from distance education programs offered under the agreement; 65 (c) The coordinating board may charge fees to any 66 institution that applies to participate in an interstate 67 postsecondary distance education reciprocity agreement 68 authorized pursuant to this section. Such fees shall not 69 exceed the coordinating board for hig her education's cost of 70 reviewing and evaluating the applications; and 71 (d) The coordinating board shall promulgate rules to 72 implement the provisions of this subdivision. Any rule or 73 SB 11 15 portion of a rule, as that term is defined in section 74 536.010, that is created under the authority delegated in 75 this section shall become effective only if it complies with 76 and is subject to all of the provisions of chapter 536 and, 77 if applicable, section 536.028. This section and chapter 78 536 are nonseverable and if any of the powers vested with 79 the general assembly pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to 80 delay the effective date, or to disapprove and annul a rule 81 are subsequently held unconstitutional, then the grant of 82 rulemaking authority and any rule propose d or adopted after 83 August 28, 2014, shall be invalid and void; 84 (7) Administering the nurse training incentive fund; 85 (8) Conducting, in consultation with each public four - 86 year institution's governing board and the governing board 87 of technical colleges and community colleges, a review every 88 five years of the mission statements of the institutions 89 comprising Missouri's system of public higher education. 90 This review shall be based upon the needs of the citizens of 91 the state as well as the re quirements of business, industry, 92 the professions and government. The purpose of this review 93 shall be to ensure that Missouri's system of higher 94 education is responsive to the state's needs and is focused, 95 balanced, cost-effective, and characterized b y programs of 96 high quality as demonstrated by student performance and 97 program outcomes. As a component of this review, each 98 institution shall prepare, in a manner prescribed by the 99 coordinating board, a mission implementation plan for the 100 coordinating board's consideration and approval. If the 101 coordinating board determines that an institution has 102 qualified for a mission change or additional targeted 103 resources pursuant to review conducted under this 104 subdivision and subdivision (9) of this subsecti on, the 105 SB 11 16 coordinating board shall submit a report to the general 106 assembly that outlines the proposed mission change or 107 targeted state resources. No change of mission for an 108 institution under this subdivision establishing a statewide 109 mission shall become effective until the general assembly 110 approves the proposed mission change by concurrent 111 resolution, except for the institution defined pursuant to 112 subdivision (1) of section 174.010, and has been approved by 113 the coordinating board and the institutio ns for which the 114 coordinating board has recommended a statewide mission prior 115 to August 28, 1995. The effective date of any mission 116 change under this subdivision shall be the first day of July 117 immediately following the approval of the concurrent 118 resolution by the general assembly as required under this 119 subdivision, and shall be August 28, 1995, for any 120 institution for which the coordinating board has recommended 121 a statewide mission which has not yet been implemented on 122 such date. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude an 123 institution from initiating a request to the coordinating 124 board for a revision of its mission; and 125 (9) Reviewing applications from institutions seeking a 126 statewide mission. Such institutions shall provide evidence 127 to the coordinating board that they have the capacity to 128 discharge successfully such a mission. Such evidence shall 129 consist of the following: 130 (a) That the institution enrolls a representative 131 cross-section of Missouri students. Examples of evidence 132 for meeting this requirement which the institution may 133 present include, but are not limited to, the following: 134 enrolling at least forty percent of its Missouri resident, 135 first-time degree-seeking freshmen from outside its historic 136 statutory service region; enrolling its Missouri 137 SB 11 17 undergraduate students from at least eighty percent of all 138 Missouri counties; or enrolling one or more groups of 139 special population students such as minorities, economically 140 disadvantaged, or physically disadvantaged fro m outside its 141 historic statutory service region at rates exceeding state 142 averages of such populations enrolled in the higher 143 educational institutions of this state; 144 (b) That the institution offers one or more programs 145 of unusual strength which re spond to a specific statewide 146 need. Examples of evidence of meeting this requirement 147 which the institution may present include, but are not 148 limited to, the following: receipt of national, discipline - 149 specific accreditation when available; receipt of 150 independent certification for meeting national or state 151 standards or requirements when discipline -specific 152 accreditation is not available; for occupationally specific 153 programs, placement rates significantly higher than average; 154 for programs for which s tate or national licensure is 155 required or for which state or national licensure or 156 registration is available on a voluntary basis, licensure or 157 registration rates for graduates seeking such recognition 158 significantly higher than average; or quality of p rogram 159 faculty as measured by the percentage holding terminal 160 degrees, the percentage writing publications in professional 161 journals or other appropriate media, and the percentage 162 securing competitively awarded research grants which are 163 higher than average; 164 (c) That the institution has a clearly articulated 165 admission standard consistent with the provisions of 166 subdivision [(6)] (5) of subsection 2 of section 173.005 or 167 section 174.130; 168 SB 11 18 (d) That the institution is characterized by a focused 169 academic environment which identifies specific but limited 170 areas of academic emphasis at the undergraduate, and if 171 appropriate, at the graduate and professional school levels, 172 including the identification of programs to be continued, 173 reduced, terminated or targeted for excellence. The 174 institution shall, consistent with its focused academic 175 environment, also have the demonstrable capacity to provide 176 significant public service or research support that address 177 statewide needs for constituencies beyo nd its historic 178 statutory service region; and 179 (e) That the institution has adopted and maintains a 180 program of continuous quality improvement, or the equivalent 181 of such a program, and reports annually appropriate and 182 verifiable measures of institu tional accountability related 183 to such program. Such measures shall include, but not be 184 limited to, indicators of student achievement and 185 institutional mission attainment such as percentage of 186 students meeting institutional admission standards; success 187 of remediation programs, if offered; student retention rate; 188 student graduation rate; objective measures of student, 189 alumni, and employer satisfaction; objective measures of 190 student learning in general education and the major, 191 including written and o ral communication skills and critical 192 thinking skills; percentage of students attending graduate 193 or professional schools; student placement, licensure and 194 professional registration rates when appropriate to a 195 program's objectives; objective measures of successful 196 attainment of statewide goals as may be expressed from time 197 to time by the coordinating board or by the general 198 assembly; and objective measures of faculty teaching 199 effectiveness. In the development and evaluation of these 200 SB 11 19 institutional accountability reports, the coordinating board 201 and institutions are expected to use multiple measures of 202 success, including nationally developed and verified as well 203 as locally developed and independently verified assessment 204 instruments; however, prefer ence shall be given to 205 nationally developed instruments when they are available and 206 if they are appropriate. Institutions which serve or seek 207 to serve a statewide mission shall be judged to have met the 208 prerequisites for such a mission when they demon strate to 209 the coordinating board that they have met the criteria 210 described in this subdivision. As a component of this 211 process, each institution shall prepare, in a manner 212 prescribed by the coordinating board, a mission 213 implementation plan for the co ordinating board's 214 consideration and approval. 215 173.040. The coordinating board is directed to submit 1 a written report to the governor or governor -elect at least 2 forty-five days prior to the opening of each regular session 3 of the general assembly and to submit the same report to the 4 general assembly within five days after the opening of each 5 regular session. The report shall include: 6 (1) A statement of the initial coordinated plan for 7 higher education in Missouri, together w ith subsequent 8 changes and implementations; 9 (2) A review of recent changes in enrollments and 10 programs among institutions of higher education in the state; 11 (3) A review of requests and recommendations made by 12 the coordinating board to instit utions of higher education 13 in accordance with section 173.030 and of the college's or 14 university's response to requests and recommendations, 15 including noncompliance therewith; 16 SB 11 20 (4) The coordinating board's recommendations for 17 development and coord ination in state-supported higher 18 education in the forthcoming biennium, within the context of 19 the long-range coordinated plan; 20 (5) The coordinating board's budget recommendations 21 for each state-supported college or university for the 22 forthcoming biennium; and 23 (6) The campus-level data on student persistence and a 24 description, including the basis of measurement, of progress 25 towards implementing revised remediation, transfer, and 26 retention practices under subdivisions [(7) and (9)] (6) and 27 (8) of subsection 2 of section 173.005. 28 173.616. 1. The following schools, training programs, 1 and courses of instruction shall be exempt from the 2 provisions of sections 173.600 to 173.618: 3 (1) A public institution; 4 (2) Any college or university represented directly or 5 indirectly on the advisory committee of the coordinating 6 board for higher education as provided in subsection 3 of 7 section 173.005; 8 (3) An institution that is certified by the board as 9 an approved private institution under subdivision (2) of 10 subsection 1 of section 173.1102; 11 (4) A not-for-profit religious school that is 12 accredited by the American Association of Bible Colleges, 13 the Association of Theological Schools in the United States 14 and Canada, or a regional accrediting association, such as 15 the North Central Association, which is recognized by the 16 Council on Postsecondary Accreditation and the United States 17 Department of Education; and 18 SB 11 21 (5) Beginning July 1, 2008, all out -of-state public 19 institutions of higher education, as such term is defined in 20 subdivision [(14)] (13) of subsection 2 of section 173.005. 21 2. The coordinating board shall exempt the following 22 schools, training programs and courses of instruction from 23 the provisions of sections 173.600 to 173.618: 24 (1) A not-for-profit school owned, controlled and 25 operated by a bona fide religious or denominational 26 organization which offers no programs or degrees and grants 27 no degrees or certificates other than tho se specifically 28 designated as theological, bible, divinity or other 29 religious designation; 30 (2) A not-for-profit school owned, controlled and 31 operated by a bona fide eleemosynary organization which 32 provides instruction with no financial charge to its 33 students and at which no part of the instructional cost is 34 defrayed by or through programs of governmental student 35 financial aid, including grants and loans, provided directly 36 to or for individual students; 37 (3) A school which offers instructi on only in subject 38 areas which are primarily for avocational or recreational 39 purposes as distinct from courses to teach employable, 40 marketable knowledge or skills, which does not advertise 41 occupational objectives and which does not grant degrees; 42 (4) A course of instruction, study or training program 43 sponsored by an employer for the training and preparation of 44 its own employees; 45 (5) A course of study or instruction conducted by a 46 trade, business or professional organization with a closed 47 membership where participation in the course is limited to 48 bona fide members of the trade, business or professional 49 organization, or a course of instruction for persons in 50 SB 11 22 preparation for an examination given by a state board or 51 commission where the s tate board or commission approves that 52 course and school; 53 (6) A school or person whose clientele are primarily 54 students aged sixteen or under; 55 (7) A yoga teacher training course, program, or school. 56 3. A school which is otherwise licens ed and approved 57 under and pursuant to any other licensing law of this state 58 shall be exempt from sections 173.600 to 173.618, but a 59 state certificate of incorporation shall not constitute 60 licensing for the purpose of sections 173.600 to 173.618. 61 4. Any school, training program or course of 62 instruction exempted herein may elect by majority action of 63 its governing body or by action of its director to apply for 64 approval of the school, training program or course of 65 instruction under the provisions of sections 173.600 to 66 173.618. Upon application to and approval by the 67 coordinating board, such school training program or course 68 of instruction may become exempt from the provisions of 69 sections 173.600 to 173.618 at any subsequent time, except 70 the board shall not approve an application for exemption if 71 the approved school is then in any status of noncompliance 72 with certification standards and a reversion to exempt 73 status shall not relieve the school of any liability for 74 indemnification or any p enalty for noncompliance with 75 certification standards during the period of the school's 76 approved status. 77 173.750. 1. By July 1, 1995, the coordinating board 1 for higher education, within existing resources provided to 2 the department of higher education and workforce development 3 and by rule and regulation, shall have established and 4 implemented a procedure for annually reporting the 5 SB 11 23 performance of graduates of public high schools in the state 6 during the student's initial year in t he public colleges and 7 universities of the state. The purpose of such reports 8 shall be to assist in determining how high schools are 9 preparing students for successful college and university 10 performance. The report produced pursuant to this 11 subsection shall annually be furnished to the state board of 12 education for reporting pursuant to subsection 4 of section 13 161.610 and shall not be used for any other purpose until 14 such time that a standard process and consistent, specific 15 criteria for determinin g a student's need for remedial 16 coursework is agreed upon by the coordinating board for 17 higher education, higher education institutions, and the 18 state board of education. 19 2. The procedures shall be designed so that the 20 reporting is made by the na me of each high school in the 21 state, with individual student data to be grouped according 22 to the high school from which the students graduated. The 23 data in the reports shall be disaggregated by race and sex. 24 The procedures shall not be designed so th at the reporting 25 contains the name of any student. No grade point average 26 shall be disclosed under subsection 3 of this section in any 27 case where three or fewer students from a particular high 28 school attend a particular college or university. 29 3. The data reported shall include grade point 30 averages after the initial college year, calculated on, or 31 adjusted to, a four point grade scale; the percentage of 32 students returning to college after the first and second 33 half of the initial college year, or after each trimester of 34 the initial college year; the percentage of students taking 35 noncollege level classes in basic academic courses during 36 the first college year, or remedial courses in basic 37 SB 11 24 academic subjects of English, mathematics, or reading; and 38 other such data as determined by rule and regulation of the 39 coordinating board for higher education. 40 4. The department of elementary and secondary 41 education shall conduct a review of its policies and 42 procedures relating to remedial education in light of the 43 best practices in remediation identified as required by 44 subdivision [(7)] (6) of subsection 2 of section 173.005 to 45 ensure that school districts are informed about best 46 practices to reduce the need for remediation. The 47 department shall present its results to the joint committee 48 on education by October 31, 2017. 49 174.160. The board of regents of each state college 1 and each state teachers college shall have power and 2 authority to confer upon students, by diploma un der the 3 common seal, such degrees as are usually granted by such 4 colleges, and additional degrees only when authorized by the 5 coordinating board for higher education in circumstances in 6 which offering such degree would not unnecessarily duplicate 7 an existing program, collaboration is not feasible or a 8 viable means of meeting the needs of students and employers, 9 and the institution has the academic and financial capacity 10 to offer the program in a high -quality manner. In the case 11 of nonresearch doctoral degrees in allied health 12 professions, an institution may be authorized to offer such 13 degree independently if offering it in collaboration with 14 another institution would not increase the quality of the 15 program or allow it to be delivered more effic iently. [Such 16 boards shall have the power and authority to confer degrees 17 in engineering only in collaboration with the University of 18 Missouri, provided that such collaborative agreements are 19 approved by the governing board of each institution and tha t 20 SB 11 25 in these instances the University of Missouri will be the 21 degree-granting institution. Should the University of 22 Missouri decline to collaborate in the offering of such 23 programs, one of these institutions may seek approval of the 24 program through the coordinating board for higher 25 education's comprehensive review process when doing so would 26 not unnecessarily duplicate an existing program, 27 collaboration is not feasible or a viable means of meeting 28 the needs of students and employers, and the institu tion has 29 the academic and financial capacity to offer the program in 30 a high-quality manner.] 31 174.231. 1. On and after August 28, 2005, the 1 institution formerly known as Missouri Southern State 2 College located in Joplin, Jasper Coun ty, shall be known as 3 "Missouri Southern State University". Missouri Southern 4 State University is hereby designated and shall hereafter be 5 operated as a statewide institution of international or 6 global education. The Missouri Southern State Universit y is 7 hereby designated a moderately selective institution which 8 shall provide associate degree programs except as provided 9 in subsection 2 of this section, baccalaureate degree 10 programs, and graduate degree programs pursuant to 11 subdivisions (1) and [(3)] (2) of subsection 2 of section 12 173.005. The institution shall develop such academic 13 support programs and public service activities it deems 14 necessary and appropriate to establish international or 15 global education as a distinctive theme of its miss ion. 16 2. As of July 1, 2008, Missouri Southern State 17 University shall discontinue any and all associate degree 18 programs unless the continuation of such associate degree 19 programs is approved by the coordinating board for higher 20 SB 11 26 education pursuant t o subdivision (1) of subsection 2 of 21 section 173.005. 22 174.251. 1. On and after August 28, 2005, the 1 institution formerly known as Missouri Western State College 2 at St. Joseph, Buchanan County, shall hereafter be known as 3 the "Missouri Western State University". Missouri Western 4 State University is hereby designated and shall hereafter be 5 operated as a statewide institution of applied learning. 6 The Missouri Western State University is hereby designated 7 an open enrollment instit ution which shall provide associate 8 degree programs except as provided in subsection 2 of this 9 section, baccalaureate degree programs, and graduate degree 10 programs pursuant to subdivisions (1) and [(3)] (2) of 11 subsection 2 of section 173.005. The institution shall 12 develop such academic support programs as it deems necessary 13 and appropriate to an open enrollment institution with a 14 statewide mission of applied learning. 15 2. As of July 1, 2010, Missouri Western State 16 University shall discontinue any and all associate degree 17 programs unless the continuation of such associate degree 18 program is approved by the coordinating board for higher 19 education pursuant to subdivision (1) of subsection 2 of 20 section 173.005. 21 174.310. 1. There shall be a period of orderly 1 transition which shall begin with the appointment of the 2 board of regents, during which the St. Louis board of 3 education shall convey by gift, the buildings, facilities, 4 equipment, and adjoining eight acres, more or le ss, of 5 realty located at 3026 Laclede Avenue, St. Louis, Missouri, 6 which currently serves as the campus of Harris -Stowe State 7 College, to the board of regents, and during which time the 8 St. Louis board of education, at its own expense, shall 9 SB 11 27 continue to provide necessary supporting services to Harris - 10 Stowe State College. The transition period shall terminate 11 no later than July 1, 1979, at which time the regents shall 12 be responsible for every aspect of the college's operation. 13 2. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this 14 chapter to the contrary, the board of regents of Harris - 15 Stowe State College is authorized to offer baccalaureate 16 degree programs and graduate degree programs that will meet 17 the needs of the St. Louis metropolitan area. Such programs 18 shall be subject to approval by the coordinating board for 19 higher education as provided for in subdivisions (1) and 20 [(3)] (2) of subsection 2 of section 173.005. 21 3. The state shall, effective July 1, 1978, provide 22 the necessary funds to fully staff and operate Harris -Stowe 23 State College and to make appropriate capital improvements. 24 4. On and after August 28, 2005, Harris -Stowe State 25 College shall be known as Harris -Stowe State University, and 26 the provisions contained in subs ections 1 to 3 of this 27 section shall continue to apply to the institution. 28