New Jersey Assembly Bill A2316

New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/7/22
• Refer: 2/7/22

Caption

Authorizes award of reasonable costs and attorney fees to farmers prevailing in certain farm management disputes.

Impact

If enacted, A2316 will amend existing New Jersey statutes to reinforce the importance of agricultural management practices. In cases where disputes arise, the bill mandates that a formal process be followed via county boards or state committees that will address complaints about farming operations. The statute seems designed to protect farmers from frivolous lawsuits while ensuring that there is a pathway for legitimate grievances to be heard. Importantly, the bill clarifies that compliance with wildlife management practices is not a violation of animal cruelty laws, thereby safeguarding farmers engaged in such activities from legal repercussions.

Summary

Assembly Bill A2316 aims to provide greater protections for farmers in New Jersey by allowing them to recover reasonable costs and attorney fees if they prevail in disputes related to lawful farming activities. The bill is an amendment to existing legislation, enhancing farmers' legal standing under the 'Right to Farm Act.' It emphasizes that farmers engaging in lawful practices should not be unduly burdened by unfounded complaints and establishes a clearer process for resolving grievances against them. If a complainant cannot prove their case was brought in good faith, they may be liable for the costs incurred by the farmer in defending against the claim.

Contention

The bill may face opposition from animal rights advocates who may argue that the provisions shielding farmers from claims of animal cruelty could inadvertently allow mistreatment of animals under the guise of wildlife management. Additionally, there may be concerns among the public regarding the implications of allowing farmers to recover legal fees, which could dissuade individuals from filing legitimate complaints against potentially harmful farming practices. The balance between protecting farmers and safeguarding animal welfare will likely be a focal point of discussion as A2316 progresses through the legislative process.