Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB420

Pennsylvania 2025-2026 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/10/25
• Refer: 3/10/25

Caption

Providing for disclosure of complaints filed against physicians.

Impact

The bill's passage could result in greater privacy for physicians concerning complaints that are ultimately deemed unfounded. Proponents argue this could help prevent unjust reputational damage to physicians by limiting the disclosure of resolved complaints. However, it raises questions about patient safety, as it may obscure information regarding physicians' past conduct from patients or other entities that might rely on such disclosures when making informed decisions about medical care.

Summary

Senate Bill 420 aims to amend the Osteopathic Medical Practice Act concerning the disclosure of complaints filed against physicians. Specifically, it proposes that if the State Board of Osteopathic Medicine determines that no disciplinary or corrective action is necessary and closes the complaint file, the physician is not required to disclose the existence of that complaint to any person or entity. This bill potentially alters the way physician accountability and transparency are managed in Pennsylvania.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB 420 appears to be mixed. Supporters of the bill highlight the importance of protecting physicians from unnecessary disclosure of complaints that do not lead to any disciplinary action. They argue that this protection fosters a constructive environment for physicians, potentially encouraging them to continue practicing without the fear of perpetual reputational harm. Conversely, opponents are concerned that the bill could lead to decreased accountability and transparency in the medical field, undermining patient trust and safety.

Contention

Notable points of contention revolve around the balance between protecting physicians and ensuring public safety. Critics argue that reducing the requirements for disclosure could hide poor practices from the public, ultimately harming patients. Meanwhile, the bill's supporters contend that maintaining a fair practice environment necessitates ensuring that complaints that do not result in discipline do not tarnish a physician’s record. This legislative discourse reflects a broader debate over transparency and privacy rights within the healthcare system.