SOUTH CAROLINA REVENUE AND FISCAL AFFAIRS OFFICE S TATEMENT OF ESTIMATED FISCAL IMPACT WWW.RFA.SC.GOV • (803)734-3793 This fiscal impact statement is produced in compliance with the South Carolina Code of Laws and House and Senate rules. The focus of the analysis is on governmental expenditure and revenue impacts and may not provide a comprehensive summary of the legislation. Page 1 of 4 S. 0076 Fiscal Impact Summary This bill restructures provisions related to criminal gang activity by revising related offenses and the associated penalty schedule. It also creates the Anti-Racketeering Act, which creates new felony offenses and establishes associated penalties. This bill may result in an increase in the number of cases heard in circuit court, the number of cases handled by the Attorney General’s Office, and potentially the number of incarcerations. This may increase the workload of the court system and the Attorney General’s Office, the Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ), the Commission of Indigent Defense, the Commission on Prosecution Coordination, the Department of Corrections (Corrections), and Probation, Parole and Pardon Services (PPP). The potential increase in expenses for each agency will depend upon the increase in the number of cases and number of incarcerations. Most of these agencies indicate that if this bill results in a significant increase in the workload, then an increase in General Fund appropriations may be requested; however, DJJ anticipates any additional increase in caseload due to this bill can be managed within existing appropriations. For information, according to Corrections, in FY 2023-24, the annual total cost per inmate was $40,429, of which $36,553 was state funded. This bill may result in a change in the fines and fees collected in court. Court fines and fees are distributed to the General Fund, Other Funds, and local funds. Therefore, the Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office (RFA) anticipates this bill may result in a change to General Fund, Other Funds, and local funds revenue due to any change in fines and fees collections in court. Explanation of Fiscal Impact Introduced on January 14, 2025 State Expenditure This bill restructures provisions related to criminal gang activity and creates the Anti- Racketeering Act. Criminal Gang Activity Newly added acts that qualify as criminal gang activity include but are not limited to: common law extortion, computer crimes, retail theft, common law obstruction of justice, criminal trespass or criminal property damage, and offenses carrying a potential penalty of at least five years of Bill Number: S. 0076 Introduced on January 14, 2025 Subject: Criminal Gan g and Anti-Racketeering Requestor: Senate Judiciary RFA Analyst(s): Gardner Impact Date: February 13, 2025 Page 2 of 4 S. 0076 imprisonment. The definition of criminal gang has been revised to lower the number of persons comprising the group from five to three and no longer includes the requirement that members knowingly and actively participate in the criminal activity. The bill also specifies that the use or threat of physical violence against another person with the intent to coerce him into actively participating in criminal gang activity is unlawful and restructures the associated penalty schedule. The bill breaks down this general offense into more specific criminal gang activity offenses and provides for a revised penalty schedule as follows: Current: §16-8-240(A) Revised Offenses: §16-8-240 Use of threat to use physical violence against another to coerce participation in criminal gang activity or prevent withdrawal from such activity (A) Unlawful for person associated with criminal gang to conduct or participate in criminal gang activity First offense, misdemeanor Fine of ≤$1,000, imprisonment for ≤2 years, or both (B) Unlawful to cause, encourage, solicit, recruit, or coerce another to become a member or associate of a criminal gang or participate in criminal gang activity Second or subsequent offense, felony Fine of ≤$5,000, imprisonment for ≤5 years, or both (C) Unlawful to convey threat of injury or damage to person or his property, or any associate or relative thereof, with intent to deter person from withdrawin g from criminal gang Current: §16-8-240(B) (D) Unlawful to convey threat of injury or damage to person or his property, or any associate or relative thereof, with intent to punish or retaliate against person for withdrawing from criminal gang Use of a firearm or deadly weapon to commit an act under § 16-8-240(A) (E) Unlawful to convey threat of injury or damage to person or his property, or any associate or relative thereof, with intent to punish or retaliate against person for refusing to become member of criminal gang Enhanced penalty Additional fine of ≤$10,000, imprisonment for ≤10 years, or both (F) Unlawful to convey threat of injury or damage to person or his property, or any associate or relative thereof, with intent to punish or retaliate against person for providing testimony against criminal gang or its members Current: §16-8-240(C) (G) Unlawful to convey threat of injury or damage to person or his property, or any associate or relative thereof, with intent to punish or retaliate against person for providing testimony against criminal gang or its members to law enforcement or those involved with judicial s ystem Page 3 of 4 S. 0076 Commission of an act under § 16-8- 240(A) and/or (B) where the person coerced is under the age of 18 Revised Penalty Schedule: §16-8-240(H)(1), Felony Offense Additional term of imprisonment Expanded prison sentence of an additional 3 years Offenses (A)-(B) Imprisonment for ≥5 years but ≤20 years, to be served consecutively to any other sentence impose d Current: §16-8-240(D) Revised Penalty Schedule: §16-8-240(H)(2), Felony Offense Commission of an act under § 16-8- 240(A), (B), and/or (C) creates a civil cause of action by an affected person against a criminal gang or criminal gang member Offenses (C)-(G) Fine of ≥$10,000 but ≤$15,000, imprisonment for ≥5 years but ≤20 years, or both, plus restitutio n Enhanced Penalty: §16-8-240(H)(3) Offenses (A)-(G), where solicitation or coercion was of person under 18 years of age Expanded prison sentence of an additional 3 years, served consecutively to any other sentence impose d Racketeering In addition, the bill creates the Anti-Racketeering Act, which makes conforming changes to relevant sections of law with regard to illegal activity conducted for monetary gain. The bill also makes it unlawful for a person to conspire or engage in the affairs of an enterprise through racketeering or to invest income derived from such activities and establishes the following penalty schedule: New Felony Offense: §16-8-540, Unlawful Racketeering First Offense Fine not to exceed the greater of $25,000 or 3 times amount of any pecuniary value gained from violation, imprisonment for ≥5 years but ≤20 years—no part of which may be suspended nor probation granted—or both Second or Subsequent Offense Fine not to exceed the greater of $25,000 or 3 times amount of any pecuniary value gained from violation, imprisonment for ≥10 years but ≤20 years—no part of which may be suspended nor probation granted—or both __________________________________ Frank A. Rainwater, Executive Director DISCLAIMER: THIS FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT REPRESENTS THE OPINION AND INTERPRETATION OF THE AGENCY OFFICIAL WHO APPROVED AND SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT. IT IS PROVIDED AS INFORMATION TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSIDERED AS AN EXPRESSION OF LEGISLATIVE INTENT. Page 4 of 4 S. 0076 The circuit court, which must determine the amount of the fine assessed for an act of unlawful racketeering, may enjoin violations, require a defendant to divest himself of any interest in unlawfully seized property, restrict a defendant’s future activities or investments, order dissolution or reorganization of any enterprise, or suspend or revoke any license, permit, or prior approval granted to any enterprise by any agency or subdivision of the state. The bill provides that an aggrieved person may institute a civil action to request injunctive relief from threatened loss or damage and allows for the issuance of a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction before a final determination is made as to the merits of the civil action. Persons affected by unlawful racketeering are provided with a cause of action for three times the actual damages sustained and awarding of punitive damages under certain circumstances and may request a jury trial. The bill also provides that, for purposes of a criminal proceeding, racketeering will be considered to have occurred in the county in which the offense was committed or where an interest or control of an enterprise or real or personal property is acquired or maintained. This bill may result in an increase in the number of cases heard in circuit court, the number of cases handled by the Attorney General’s Office, and potentially the number of incarcerations. This may increase the workload of the court system and the Attorney General’s Office, DJJ, the Commission of Indigent Defense, the Commission on Prosecution Coordination, Corrections, and PPP. The potential increase in expenses for each agency will depend upon the increase in the number of cases and number of incarcerations. Most of these agencies indicate that if this bill results in a significant increase in the workload, then an increase in General Fund appropriations may be requested; however, DJJ anticipates any additional increase in caseload due to this bill can be managed within existing appropriations. For information, according to Corrections, in FY 2023-24, the annual total cost per inmate was $40,429, of which $36,553 was state funded. State Revenue This bill may result in a change in the fines and fees collected in court. Court fines and fees are distributed to the General Fund, Other Funds, and local funds. Therefore, RFA anticipates this bill may result in a change to General Fund and Other Funds revenue due to any change in fines and fees collections in court. Local Expenditure N/A Local Revenue This bill may result in a change in the fines and fees collected in court. Court fines and fees are distributed to the General Fund, Other Funds, and local funds. Therefore, RFA anticipates this bill may result in a change to local funds revenue due to any change in fines and fees collections in court.