SB 539 - HB 753 FISCAL NOTE Fiscal Review Committee Tennessee General Assembly February 22, 2025 Fiscal Analyst: Justin Billingsley | Email: justin.billingsley@capitol.tn.gov | Phone: 615-741-2564 SB 539 - HB 753 SUMMARY OF BILL: Establishes a process for assessment and valuation of low-income housing properties for property tax purposes. Applies to residential property and projects developed on or after January 1, 2026. FISCAL IMPACT: OTHER FISCAL IMPACT The amount of total recurring foregone local revenue beginning in FY26-27 cannot be quantified with certainty but is reasonably estimated to exceed $100,000. Assumptions: • The proposed legislation will create an assessment process for multi-unit rental housing that receive a federal, state, or local incentive based on low-income renter restrictions. • A government incentive includes: a low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC); financing derived from exempt facility bonds for qualified residential rental projects; a low-interest loan under the National Housing Act or the Housing Act of 1949; a rent subsidy; a guaranteed loan; a grant; a guarantee; or an agreement entered into for payments in lieu of ad valorem taxes. • The LIHTC program provides a credit against federal income tax liability each year for 10 years for owners and investors in low-income rental housing. The amount of tax credits is based on reasonable costs of development and the number of low-income units. • The proposed assessment process requires an assessor to use a specific methodology for valuing low-income housing that includes a capitalization rate based on the risks associated with such housing and that excludes the amount of LIHTCs or other state or federal subsidies each property received. • Beginning in tax year 2026, the Comptroller of the Treasury’s (COT’s) Division of Property Assessments would be required to determine the capitalization rate in consultation with the Tennessee Housing Development Agency (THDA) and to publish the rate range on its website as soon as practicable after the rates become available. • The COT and THDA will absorb the additional responsibility with existing staff and resources; any fiscal impact to state government is estimated to be not significant. • The proposed legislation takes effect January 1, 2026 and applies to low-income housing projects developed on or after that date. SB 539 - HB 753 2 • Excluding LIHTCs from the valuation of new low-income housing properties will result in a recurring increase in foregone property tax revenue beginning in FY26-27. • According to the THDA, nine low-income subsidized housing projects were awarded in late 2023 and anticipated to begin development in 2024. • Pursuant to State Board of Equalization Rule 0600-10-.03-(3), taxpayers of LIHTC properties are given two options for valuing the subsidies: o A decreasing term method using the present value of all future tax credits for each of the unused tax credit years remaining; or o A leveling method using the average annual present value of the credits. • Based on information provided by the COT: o The decreasing term method resulted in a total present value of $11,451,700 for the nine projects with a property tax levy of $152,089; ▪ Under the proposed language, there would have been an increase in foregone local revenue of $152,089 in FY24-25 that would steadily decrease over each of the subsequent nine fiscal years; o The leveling method resulted in a net present value of the subsidies of $8,215,690 with a property tax levy of $109,203; and ▪ Under the proposed legislation, there would have been an increase in foregone local revenue of $109,203 in FY24-25 and each of the subsequent nine fiscal years. • Beginning in FY26-27, the fiscal impact of the proposed legislation will compound every year for a 10-year period as new projects are added each year; in the eleventh year, the first- year projects will drop off and new ones will be added. This trend will continue in subsequent years. • Each year’s fiscal impact will depend on the total amount of LIHTCs awarded to new projects and the respective property tax rates applied to those properties, which cannot be predicted. • Therefore, the total amount of recurring foregone local revenue beginning in FY26-27 and recurring in subsequent years cannot be estimated with certainty but is assumed to exceed $100,000. CERTIFICATION: The information contained herein is true and correct to the best of my knowledge. Bojan Savic, Executive Director