Texas House Bill HB327

Texas 2015 - 84th Regular

• Filed: 11/18/14

Caption

Relating to a study on the availability of information regarding convictions and deferred dispositions for certain fine-only misdemeanors.

Impact

The bill aims to provide insights into the handling and accessibility of misdemeanor records across counties, potentially leading to legislative action aimed at standardizing practices. By evaluating the public access to records and the criteria for record destruction, it seeks to improve the understanding of how different jurisdictions manage misdemeanor records. This could impact state policies related to the retention and dissemination of criminal records, ultimately leading to improved access for the public and agencies that require this information for legal or employment purposes.

Summary

House Bill 327 is an act that mandates the Office of Court Administration of the Texas Judicial System to conduct a comprehensive study on the availability of records relating to Class C misdemeanors, particularly those that are fine-only and exclude traffic offenses. The bill outlines specific aspects that the study must cover, including how conviction records and records of deferred dispositions are maintained in various Texas counties. Additionally, it addresses the public availability of such records, indicating a notable emphasis on transparency in the judicial system regarding misdemeanor cases.

Sentiment

The sentiment around HB 327 appears to be supportive, as the emphasis on studying the availability of records suggests a legislative intent to enhance transparency and accountability in the judicial process. Legislative discussions indicate that stakeholders recognize the importance of public access to criminal records, especially in contexts impacting employment and societal reintegration of offenders. However, detailed commentary highlights occasional concerns about how the study's findings might influence future policy changes regarding the handling of misdemeanor convictions.

Contention

While the bill's introduction has been generally welcomed, some contention may arise from apprehensions regarding privacy implications and the treatment of sensitive information. The approach to record retention and the criteria for record destruction are likely to be points of discussion, particularly concerning vulnerable populations such as minors. As the study progresses, it may uncover variations in local practices that could lead to differing opinions on how records should be managed and accessed.