Texas Senate Bill SB369

Texas 2015 - 84th Regular

Caption

Relating to jury instructions regarding the insanity defense in a criminal case.

Impact

The impact of SB369 is primarily on the judicial handling of insanity defenses in criminal cases. By requiring jurors to be instructed on the consequences of an acquittal due to insanity, the bill seeks to mitigate misconceptions regarding the legal repercussions of this verdict. This change aims to improve the understanding of jurors, potentially leading to fairer and more informed verdicts. It also designates that the new jury instruction applies only to offenses committed on or after the bill's effective date, ensuring clarity in the law's application.

Summary

SB369 relates to the jury instructions provided in cases where the insanity defense is raised. The bill amends Article 46C.154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to mandate that courts inform jurors about the consequences if they return a verdict of 'not guilty by reason of insanity.' This provision aims to ensure that jurors are aware of the legal and procedural outcomes that follow such a verdict, particularly the potential for involuntary commitment hearings.

Contention

Debate surrounding SB369 could center on concerns regarding the balance between legal procedure and defendants' rights. Some stakeholders may worry that informing jurors about potential consequences could influence their decision-making, particularly if jurors might conflate knowledge of consequences with the guilt or innocence of the defendant. There may also be discussions on how this change might impact the administration of justice, particularly for defendants whose mental health status is a focal point in their trials.