Utah House Bill HB0021 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
 


    .
 t     
   ! "  "     #o
$%%&     %%'($ %%"& 
# )"   %$%%& %%"*   
 %    $"%   #  *+$d 
+  &
 !, %-&     
(.''./'0''S
 ! "#$ %&!
'#' &()'#H
#   , %-& e
 ***********_
 
('0
{ ' :
'+,& %,-,,.,, 
$ +/: +r +  0 
}0 %  
' , &1.2 #...,,
3, .., .

*%*. !  :
' 
<3 .4, ty
.++.,,,5..p 6{

<3 .4 55..
7- 
 

.,,.,g

};
<, .4. . . +. ..+
....,..., . 6d
<,8 ...,. .
  "  %%
!
(%%
!
/   ##
#2 !9:
123145  ,4$ )5-05
511625  ,4$ )5-;1
51125  ,4$ )05-<7
511645  ,4$ )05-<7
21415  ,4$ )=5-=,
,4$ )=5-0
21415  ,4$ )5- ;050:
214155  ,4$ )5- 050
76
1125  ,4$ )5- <050=3
 !#-':
511675)-#>:
 

 
..12314 ,
12314& %$%" # %11      %".
?@'4,  A.:
?@'5->52.$) 59+,52,#.6
?@A .. .'<5$,1 $.
+,  7$.9 . 5 . +. .'<95-5
.+.9 .#.5.
7- 
 

?@ ,,  524;5;5.d
4. . . +. .6
?@4. .+ +.,. . . +.
 .,  .4t.
 . . +. .5 .+4.
?@%,,,+,,n
 54 . . ,.4.t
,  .B, .
?@'4  A.+4. = 77=5= 77<,
= 77;5= 77>5= 775= 775   A.+d
4'= 5%  -
?0@! .,4. ,+, e
, +.,.4., s
.5  5 5 ,,. +. c4
+.
?:@'4  A.':5-05&1.2 #.,
...,4 .m 
.:707<54
?@ 3  ..6d
?@,4.+.., [n],
 3 [ .:707<?0@D .:707<?:@?@?@. 
..51162 ,
5116&  $8%#  11'$ #$ $.
?@  . +.<77>:5.,,. .
   
?@ +.,,E  .6
?@.  + .?@?@5 
?@ . .6
?@.5 + . .,.
,, ..
?@?@#    .?@
7- 
 

?@F1,F, ,,,   tt
 5 .  ,,.4  5 ,l,, t
,  4..,   .  t..+e
 +., .
?@F 4..,F,  7,4 .:
?#@ .. .;
?@.+  +.,. .6d
?-@ [   ,4 .,4..4e
 .,4    D ..  .a
,4    5 .. . .
#775.
?@%+:G . . ..+ +.f,e
. .  4.., 53, .?@?@ 
.5,,,   5t3,
,,5.[5]:
?@  .+ 5 .+5 +., .6d
?@  .. .5.5+ ,.
,, .
?@?@(  ,, .. .54e4f
. . . 4.455 .l 5s
 .E   r. 5
3, .?@?@,4.43,,,e:
?)   . .t[5,,D6 
?@[]d5.5.l
 ..+ 5 .+5 +., . [.e
r].
?@#,,   +. . .
<77>:?@?@?@?@5 ...4+5 
 A.3,  . .?@?@.. .
4+ .4.
?.@!  .?@?@. + .i?@?@5
70- 
 

.4 +4,4. ..4 +e
4E ,, 5  ,,  rs
 . .?@?@5:
?@.4 +4   . +..y .
?#@,,,5 . <770?@?@6
?@,,,+..45 .#77:?@?@?)r
 .#77:?@6
?@  3. ,4. ,.
 ..  46
?@.4 +4 .3. i,4
. ,6
?+@.4 +4 ,,4. .t
5... .<770?=@ .#77:?@?.@5 :
?#@.4+ .46
?@.,+ .4. ,:Ge
.. .6r
?-@. . ++  .<77=:5.d
,+ .4. ,:G.e
+ . .. +..4.
?@% .  4.   . i.. y
.455 .  . ,,A4,, 
   +. r34
5+ .3. ,4. a+..4e
5.4 +4,4. .,
.4 +4E ,,    43, 
 .?@.
?0@?@ .  +4 5,,, a.
  . . ,,  +,
,,  
?@%  . . ,,, 5e,
,, ,4+.
7:- 
 

?:@(4.. .5,,, lf
   , .:
?@. . . 4 .n
<77?@?@5?@5?.@56r
?@. . . 4  .n
<77?@?@?@5 
?=@?@( . .5,,, s 
,4.47 +  .
?@!.,,,    .?=@?@
,4
?@+ .?0@6r
?@ + ,4,,.
..5112 ,
511& #   &
#   .
?@F#3  F,   ,44
?@ +4
?@ ..;
?@.+  :G+.l6d
?@ 3+ :G++4e
.6r
?@ +  .3, :G
,+ . .. f) 
, ..  .
?@F#.F, :
?@ . . +. .5.le
  . +. .6
?@   . +. c5a
 ;
?.@  +. +. +. +4 .l
 +. .5. . +. .6
7=- 
 

?@ .  . +. . 5.l.
 . +. . . .
?@F(.4FF. F. 4 .55 4 ,555
5 43+ +. . +.
 . B+5.4 ,r7745
,+,545 .5 855.553,5 g.
?0@FF:
?@,  .44, .4+,4
 :
?@+
?#@4.4,.4. . +. .   
6d
?@4 . +. .6d
?@.  +,4 . .46d
?@ .
?@ 7,;
?@+.6r
?@ .    ,.
?:@F+4F, 
?@ +4.4,.4.  c +.e
 .5.4,. +4 y
, +...<9776
?@, +. . +. .5e
.4,. +4 4, i+.
..<977
?=@F F,  
?@  4 . +. .6
?@ +.. 4,4 y
 . +. .
?<@F$. .F  ,, .<77.
?;@F"+F
7<- 
 

?@, 4,  + d
+,4 .4,.4. . +. .;
d
?@ .
?@.   ,.e
.  4,;
?@+.6r
?@ .    ,.
?>@F 4..,F,  7,4 .
?@ . . +. .;
?@.+  +., . +. .6d
?.@ ..  .,4    5es
.. . .#77:.
[?>)D?@F.    ,F,     ,+ 44l
.  ,8,+, 4.
[?@D?@F.    ,F, 4, .    , 
[?@D?@F. +. .F, , .+,t45
  ..<9775
?@ .4)- #.H%5.<6d
?@ 5  A.5    ..
[?@D?@F'+.F, :
?@  ... + .,i
 + 6
?@,  , .4  .4.t 
  .
.0.51164 ,
51164& 9%#   # !   %$ $11 f
 ##.
?@?@ . + .?@?@5.,,, +
. :
?@ + . +. .6
7;- 
 

?@.,4.4,.4. . +.e
 .6
?@ [+:G .  . +. .  4
.., 5 .<7755.
5.+  +. , . +. . .
 . +. .5+,,,  
 .?@?@?@.,    3,.D5t
.5. . +. .r.+ 5r
 .+5 +., . +. .5
?#@ =G .  . +. .  4
.., 6
?@,:G5  =G5 .  . +.e
 .  4.., 5,,, s
 .?@?@?@?@.,    3,
?@ .?@?@ 4:
?@ >G 4 . +.e .t
 +  . +. .6r
?@,,  .<977?@?0@.
?@?@ . + .?@?@5,.,,n
, +. 4 .
?@', .    ,, ,i +
.5. 45 4 .
.
}5. :2141  :
}51167 .
51165& * # !   %$ .
?@?@ .,, +. .,4't:5
-05&1.2 #.
?@A. .?@5, +. 
?@ .+.,, r+e
.6
?@...,... .
7>- 
 

 . .?@?@?@6
?@,8 . . .?@?@?@+
.
?#@.,, +.6d
?@ . +. . . 5 i.
?@ .?@?@ ., +.E 4.,4
':5-05&1.2 #..
.=.2141 ,
2141.  *   $%11<  &
?@#, .  . . :70705:707:,
:707=.
?@?@#, .. 8 .+e
   .4.3,  5  . ...is
.
?@#8 .+   .4.3,  t
  ,4 4 ..,b.4,4
4..4 4 .lc
,  :
?@8 .+    ..by
  4 .., 545l4 ..
, .6
?@4,  ,4  + +5in
... .5.. +;
?@8 .+    ..,....io
3, .:707<6
?+@ ....8 .+   g
..4E , ,.4ry
.., . 
?@?@?@#.4, . a
 4.++.,, ,.s
.  ,.
77 
 

?@ .?@?@?@ 4:
?#@, 8   .4;
}
?@.,,  ,'5->515$d
) 1+  5'<5-<515$) 1+ s
}6
?-@.4  4+ 44.
?@!I455.4  55.e
+  4.++.,, n
,.4:
?@ .6
?@. .?@?@ .
?.@ 
!  . ?@?@?@5 + +.
.,,.,}' 55. . .
?@?@,4,.+.,, . ,. o
. ,.
?0@ .?@ 4o$ 
, +.,,5
4  +..
.<.2141 ,
2141. .$%   # *11* " *&
?@?@?@#.4 +  0 E...h
,
?@# .4 +  0 E...,e
 .4 ..,
?@'..3 .?@?@ .,i:
?@6
?@;
?@,6
?+@.
?@?@%3,  .?@5.4. 
,  .+.+. 4 +.
. ..4 , . +  .
?@'.. .?@?@  .45,e5.
77 
 

 ., .
?@?@#.4 .4   3,u..4:
?@ .
?#@...,..C .n
:707<?0)D .:707<?:@5...4 .d
45..  5, 6
?@)1.!.J ..=#7=7=6
?@+.
?#@  ...A .
.46r
?@.,. .
?@#.4 .4 .,.+   .n
?@?@?@4+. .,. + s
 .=#7=7=?0@?@.
?.@#.4 , . ,8.,. .tn
?@?@?@?@.,43 9+ #.+ ". +.5.n
.=#775+..   ..4 
.,4.
?0@#.4 .4.+ 
.., +.,  .?@
?:@?@'.3, .?@,4 
?@.  .., .  .  4c4 .
4,.4,. , ,.46d
?@.4 .4+  ..c
?#@,.,.4,6d
?@. . ,.4,
?@#,.4,.4,4  
?@, ,4,, .4;
?@,A4,, .4+,.
?=@?@#.. 3. .?@ a
+  ..44. . b. e
77 
 

, ..  ,,
?@A.+   .?=@?.@5 .e 
,,.45. 4.,4 c  
,5+. 4. .a+.c
.,.
?.@ . + .?:@5,.4,s5.
4,48..,  . :
?@ , 34 .?=@?@6
?@.+...34  ..
?<@ . +  .5 . 4 .4.
.;.21415 ,
21415. %   *11 =  118 .
?@ .  +. ..:707>5.
4,4.+....,...  ..
?@?@#.4,4..,  .b4s
 55.+ .., 
?@# 55. . .?@?@+ 
..,C9.,5,D   . .
,,, ...3,
?.@# 55. . .?@?@,4:
?@,..,  5..45 .
.  ;
?@33,.4:
?#@  ..,6
?@++  ,..,.r
,, .4....6
?@33 ..,,4,,c
44 ,, ,f
..,;
?+@ ., .. ,, c4
.., +3,.y;
77 
 

?+@.4  4B,,u.4
.445  . .,,,4+8.4
46r
?+@  . 5, 5. +..ms
..  .
?@#.4.+ .. .., 
?@+....,....:7076
?@..., . .?:@5 i.
..,..6
?.@.  +$ .e.
45 0 ..,  .5+.h
,,.4 ...4..m.
?0@?@ . + .?:@5.4.+ ..s
.., + .. ..,, f
. ,
?@#.4.+ .. ..,,4+e
, 4.,, .C4 .4 ..n]
,4,,44.., 
?:@ .?0@?@ 4..,
?@?@..4, 
?#@.., + .?0@?@     8
 4    a.r
.6
?@..4,4, .l 
. 4  6d
?@..,. :
?#@ , ..E , .?:@?@?@;
?@ ,,4. ..E ,  6
?-@,,,.,4,,4y
.., 6Cr]
?@?@. ..,5.
707 
 

?#@, ....., +
 .?0@?@     8 4  e
..6
?@. ..,.E , .n
?:@?@?@?#@   ,,4. ., ,6
?@.+..,5.4 +, 4.
,, .4 .4 ..i,4e
..,,44.., C.D6
?.@?@.4 . .    '<,
-515'  ;
?@ E ,, .   
?#@ ,, .  5
 . 5. . c
<77?@?@6r
?@ ,, . 5
 .5. . .tn
<77?@?@?@6
?@..3 .:707?@?@?@?@e.c
,. ,,,.,4,g,y
4.., 6
?+@   ,, .,t4
,.., .,6r
?@?@.4  . +. ., +e.
  '<95-515#, +-;
?@, +.E ,, .   
?#@ ,, . 5
 .5. . .tn
<9770?@?@?@?#@?@5 .6r
?@,, 34.,. s
4 . +. .,.r . .d
 .<9770?@?@?@;
7:7 
 

?@..3 .:707?@?@?@?@e.c
,. ,,,.,4,g,y
4.., 6
?+@, +. ,, .i
,4,.., .,.
?=@#, .?:@?@?@ 4 4.
..4,8 ,.
?<@-,.+    .4.4.  d
.,.,.4.4. +  f.s
:707:707
?;@)  .4  55. .s.
?@?.@?+@5.4 ....,,4w,,
+ .44.
?>@ ., +5.4 ....
, 8+ 4.
.>.76
112 ,
76
11& %$%" # %.
?@#    .:
?@F 4F, 4  4 .y 
.:707.
?@F 4F, +4  4.
?@'4A.  A.:
?@'5->52.$) 59+,52,#.;
?@'<5-<5-4$) 59+,52,#.;
?.@.  .4,.45. o
 55   . 5. 6
?@A .. .'<5$,1 $.
+,  7$.9 . 5 . +. .'<95-5
.+.9 .#..
?@'4  A.+4. = 77=5= 77<,
= 77;5= 77>5= 775= 775   A.+d
7=7 
 

4'= 5%  -
?0@?@' .:<7;74  .?0@
?@! +  ':<5-;5-,,& p
#.54+ :
?@,4 A...,,rA.t
 . .5,4 3 5.5..a
.,,A.6
?@.,,A. 4,44
4 ,4K  .45.4.,,n
. , , .  
?#@.,,  A.4 ':<5-;5
-,,& #.6
?@.,,  ,.,,..,m
A.,44,.4,.,, s,
   B+.6d
?-@.,,A.,4  +. 
.,, 
?:@! 4+ 53 . .
+,54 . 4A.
?=@?@#,5+ 5.4 . +i 
  .4   ++
 5,5   .43    b4.  4o
44E     s..
?@ .?=@?@ 4. +  +a4f
A..4. + 
?<@?@'4  4 A.':5-05&
1.2 #.5.:
?@ .:70705,y
,,   4,, 3, ':5-p05&n
1.2 #.5,4,4
?#@.546r
7<7 
 

?@  4.5  46
?@4 ,4+ ..,s
.:707<55 .=77?@5 4 t
6
?@..,4  4a e
., .:707<54  45 .i+4:
?#@ 3  ..6d
?@,4.+..,CnD,n
 3C .:707<?0@D .:707<?:@?@?@.
?@ . + .?<@?.@54 34s.4
 . 4+ .
?.@'4 4 .4 .... .n
:707?@?@?@
?;@'4  4 A.'=5-5+,t
". #..  2,#.5.:
?@ .=77<:
?@4,4   .   ,, ;
?@    .?;@?@?@ .e:
?#@4,, 4+6
?@4,,4 6a
?-@4,,4 8 
" + 6
?@.    ..5 +n
.=77005.". -,, 46
?@..44  4.
. .=77?@?+@ ..'=5C,
+,". #..  2,#..
?>@'4  4.. .n
=77?@?+@ ,.+,.7+ 
  ,.E 8 .
?@?@?@#  4. . . c'<95
7;7 
 

-051.% .9 .#.5,45 A., '<95-
051.% .9 .#.5+44 ,.
. . .E . .,+, 5 A.a
,,,:.
?@#+4 .?@?@?@,4 ,. .e
 .4+4
?@%  4. . . .  :
?@  4,4
?#@4.+4+4
.B 4, 6d
?@.+ .,4+46d
?@ + .4'<95-051c
% .9 .#.54+4f,4.
 ,+34 +. 
, +.  5 A.,,,
?.@?@#  4. . . .'<95-
051.% .9 .#.5,4. 5 .:>775
. . .4e4.5
 A.,,,,  . . ?@?@?@?@?@?@
?@%  4.4. . .t    5  y
,4    .44 ,:
?#@. . .6
?@, . . ..
?@?@', .:<774  .?@.
?@':<5-5)),$ 1.. #.5 4an
      e
A.4:
?@?#@ +,+.,,    l;
?@.    3+5 5d
 5.+   5.45 4 5d
.6
7>7 
 

?-@+,+,  . .?@?@?@?@ 
.,,. ..46d
?@,  5 +    .y
  ..,,+,  . .?@?@?i@?-@.
?@?@#    .?@5F.F,  , .wn
,)- #.%/5.
?@#...,4+ .r
8.
77