Utah House Bill HB0061 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
 


    .
 t     
   ! "  "     #o
$%%&     %%'($ %%"& 
# )"   %$%%& %%"*   
 %    $"%   #  *+$d 
+  &
 !" &,% x    

((./01'
 !"!#$%!&'"
($(!')*($H
#   " &,% -
 +++++++++++_
 
('2
{ ' :
(%!,-.-/ ,&-.--,-- .
% 01: 0r 0  2 
}2 %  
( 
, ,,3$, 4,  }  s ,l
 3 ,3   .

*%*3 !  :
( 
< - 5
<,   ,3, 6-7,3;
<8 ,,3 30 9 ,o
,,3 9 ,:  ,3,:a,
;- 
 

,, ,35
<, ,,3( 4),;
<8  4,08, : : ,y
  ,3,5
<8  
 ,3 , 0}!,<=o
0,,- ,3,  ,
 .--  .-/0/ ,<,--  =5
<8 ,,, , ,, , , 
,}, ,
,,   ;
< ,- 9 -,,  -5
<0 - -, , 0,e d
- :, , ,, 0, 5
<- 8- - ,-> , 5
<-  ,--   >0> ,;
<, ,,8- ,--  
$- 0',.    ,--:3
,--:3- 5d
<-4 ,,,--- 
  "  %%

"(   ,3?:
<!,;.,&0   : ;-

C-&,-():';-:@2::
(%%
"
1   ##
$A!"6:
4565646:  -3% *:.B9
45267681:  -3% *B:.B3
45267682:  -3% *:.C9
45267683:  -3% *B:.B3
;- 
 

45267672:  -3% *:.B9
5661: ,3% *:.B
5662: ,3% *:.B -3
.. :% *:.B0
5696943:  -3% *:. D:B:C?:2?:C,
?9
568698:  -3% *:.2
568698: ,3% *:.B -3
.. :% *:.B0
!"$.(:
4569961:*.$B2
4569962:*.$B2
4569963:*.$B2
4569964:*.$B2
;4526768}45267683.;4}2:*.$B2
45267673:*.$B2
766::*.$B2
 

 
,,4569961 ,

399&
((1/T
456996&  %"66#   .
$   ,
<=E7, ,E-  - - ,2 ;B;2.
<=E, ,,EE#'E- ,-,3
, ,,,,,2 ;D;C.
<=E ,3,E- 03,--  r
,2;;
,,4569962 ,
4569969&"#66  66   &
<=( ,-  ,3,.
;- 
 

<=(  ,3,
<= 3,--  005
<=  >, 0 ,,--  ;
<,=-3-0,--  5
<= 83,,:
<=,    , 35
<=-  ,3,--  5
<=, - ,.
<=(      ,3, t-3
.--  7,3,>,,,3( 4),,n
,2;;?
,,4569963 ,
4569965&  "##  $%s66     .
!,,3  30 9 ,,
 ,3   
n  ,3,f:,3 9 ,:
, ,,  > ,, , ,,y.
,?,4569964 ,
456996:&  %"=. 66$666636-
 66-  .
<=( ,,,3( 4),,-  
2
-- 
<= ,%!,-.-/ ,&-.--t:
  0 ,;
<= ,.-.!0( 4),5
<,=--:3 5
<=--!, ,3-5
<= , 3 , !,5
<=, 3  ,,2;;;
<=,--  6-7,3,--  9 
 ;
<=--*, $  ,: ,3e
;?- 
 

   ,;
<= 
----s. 7,$  ,:-,3
  ,,  -,3::: ,  : ,3
   ,;
<>=--  $  ,:-,3 : ,:
,  -,3:: ,  : ,3p f
  ,5
<4= 0-*$  ,7,.,  l,3
   ,;
<= 0- , ,: ,3,5
<-= 0-0 ,,--3,--  re
6-7,35
<=--,,-,3,--3,--  
6-7,3
<=( 4, 
<=- ,,8, : :   f 
 ,3,,,2;;5
<=,  F8- ,  ,l
 ,, 5
<,=00 :,  3:-,,,  r
-0,2 ;D;D5
<=0  ,0 -,3   , ;
<=,-- 3 ,3,  :, ,:
, ,  , ;
<=0 ,,-  , <=<=,
?   5d
<= 3 0%!,-
.-/ ,&-.--3"0-:
<=<=$->3--  4,,  8-
<=(,->38-,  , 4,
<?=(',% 0# , .  0 a
;2- 
 

 4,.
<2=<=   --  4,   l
,,,:
<=,;;5
<=% 0/# :(2:.:%:A:( 
!  5d
<=% 0/# :(2:.:% .- 
<=$-- 4,  -3,0,- tn
--9 4  , 4,-3,0i-
- -0  , -- 4,s
  360 ),:
<=, $;;$;;C5
<= -360 ),,,,, $;;d
$;;C
<=(  4, 6,-:.
,2,4565646 -
456564&   %% " % #     66%= g
 "&
<=$    ,:
<=E6 ,3,E- ,3, ,-m3
 , , ,,     .
<=E%,-,3E-  - - ,n
CC;C;
<,=EAE-  - - ,2 ;;.
<=E',-,03E-  ,,-t,
-   :,
<= , F3#'5
<=  ,,-,5
<=  ,,4 -- ;
<0=8,35r
<0=,.
;- 
 

<=E,    E-  3,, ,l
,,  ,, , ,,,0y
-- .
<=<=E,;  ,03E- ,03: 0:,b:,-,
,,:0,03 F3 ,,, ,:,,%!A
0,3:    , :
<$=,03 - 0 3 , ,:, ,:c
 ,-35
<=,03   , ,, ,, :8p-:
 , , 5
<.=,03    F:-, 83:3pc
 :,, ,9 ,03 A--,7- 
<=E,;  ,03E, 00-,
-,:, :,,-:- : 3:,,t03
<=E ,,EE#'E-  - - 
,2 ;D;C
<=/3::  0
, ,, ,  ,    a
 ,;  ,03
<=  -5
<=,-,0 5
<,= ,3, 
<=7  :,-,  ,r
 %!$ 00-,  3,-e
 , ,<=: 8 3%!$ a.
<?=( , ,<= ,-n
  3,%!$:
<=-  -:, 3-  ;
<=-,-,0 :,-
,,
<= ,-,035d
;C- 
 

<=3,-,03 5
<,=- ,3, - :,:
<=  ,3,5
<=3 ,3,5
<=-#' -35d
}
<=,:-, 0  >,: g
,2 ;B;:3:F:,3;3:.
<2=( , ,<= ,-:n
:,- , , <?=<=<,=
<=;
<=0;
<,=,5
<= 5d
<= 3  .
<=&-, , ,<= ,-y
:
<=.B:7:67,5
<=.B:7:70,35
<,=)-3!,# 70,3$,:*., 
<C= &,,,( :.:*$- 0#-4$,:
  -4 ,- , ,<=.
<D=(  0 , ,<):
<) ,,,,2!;;, ,,
0  ,3[.H5
<=.--  .-/0/ ,/3,h
3, ,,0  ,3.
,
2}6, 45267681 -
4526768& #   &
$   :
<=E%,-,3E-  - - ,i
2;;.
;D- 
 

<=E7, ,E-  - - ,2 ;B;2.
G<=H<)E, ,,EE#'E- ,-,: 
,2;;:,,  ,-,3,, 
%!$0,- 0, %!$
{ ,,4526768&5 ,
4526768&4&  %  ##66> %%  "  %&
!,, ,3 , 0  , ,,.
} ,C,45267682 -
45267689&   %  ##  *66%.
<=&,,,( :.:*$- 0#-4$,:e
  -4 -40- ,
, : , : , ,, .
<=(,,,-- - ,n
 ,<=:  
<=4,>,.--  .-/0/ ,e
,,A;C;;
<= ,-, , :, ,0 :e
*, 65
<,=, 3,FF0  , 
 , ,, 5
G<,=H<) ,-,,- ,--y
 4 5d
G<=H<), ,* 6-!,,-- 
 , , , ,,.
<=(- , ,<=-3,e

<=, ,0-5
<= ;3  5
<,=4   5
<=,8 ; , 0,,5
<=,  5
;B- 
 

<= 0> ,,, ;
<=3  0,- o
 , 5
<= 0,3 5
<=0, 8,   ,300->0
,-> , 3 - ;
<>=  ,>0> ,00-;
<4=  ,  , ,, , f
4 , ,5
<=0  ,,      5
<-=-  ,8    ,3.
<?=(  46-7,3:
.--  .-/0/ ,: ,,-  h
, ,GdH, ,G0nH8- r , ,, 
,D,45267683 -
45267685&   $   % #  #   % 
 ##!66> .
<=$%!$G-3H l,,,,-,3G
0H0 , ,, 0, %!$G%!$0 d
0 0 ,,tH
<=(%!$0,,-,3 0a
-3,,#'.
G<=H<)G&%!$,, H$%!$,,t,-,3Gn
0H0#' 0, %!$G:%!$0H 8
,,:
<=,4-3,-,3G0lH#O
,, :
<=0- :3:,00-a
 ,;
<=,  0-  ;
<=4,,0:,0:-; 0 n
;; 
 

,-%!$5
<0=- F  0,   005d
<0=8 %!$:,0,,-,  ;
<= ,  %!$,-t
,3G0l H    ,-%!A
:
<=-  , ;
<=-0 ,,-5d
<= ,   5
<,=    t:,,,,2 ;D;,
#O:
<=-3>0,;
<=G#'] ,%!$ 0e[:,
G} 
H
  }H5
[<= 
G} 
H}-05]
[<=0 
G} s
H  },--3
5]
[<)H<)[    - 0   #']
  ,-   [,,,,2 ;D;]

:} - 0   #'-
,-- 0  e;
[<)H<) ,   w
:
<= , 5
<=8 5
<=  ;
G<=H<0=-0,35
[<)H<) ,
<=>  -d G;H:,:
<$= 
%!$} ,,h#'  d
};
<=  #' ,  
%!$} ,;
;; 
 

<.=,, 
%!$} ,;
<6= ,,   0,0-5d
<!=3 , 4:3-5
<=8- 5
<=, #' ,- w
,-%!$;
[<)H<)#' ,,, ,l
#'4:,9  :>3,m#O
 ,,2 ;D;C5Gd]
G<=,, %!$,-,3::]
G<=H(
}g=t >3 ,  #', 5
G<)H(
}h)
},-,3: 3: 4d
,,,4-%!$#'9 -,.
,B,{45267672}45267685&2 
-},d:
45267685&9&$%  #( %"663$%  &
<=$%!$   #',3
<=(#',3 , ,<= ,
<=,, ,,2 ;D;C5d
<=, 8- 0 t%!$
#'.
<=--#',3 , ,<=:%E$ l
 #',3,-,0,,--e#',3.
,, 45267672 -
45267679& #"  3 *66$ 66A
.
<=( ,37-.
<=(  :
<=0,>,60  ,$ A
-  3 , %!$:,
<=0,; ,     -00
 0   , 3;
;; 
 

<=,  ,-5
<=,  ,--3 0, 3:-3 
F:,00-5
<=0
<= , 35
<=0,; , -0 ,,-  ,ct
305
<=0,; , 30-3 rt
 ,,--35
<0=0,; , 30-3 
   3-- -  5
<0=- ,   ,- 
 0, )-3!,# 70,3$,:*.,;
<0=-,, *.,,s
2!;B;2!;B;25
<0=-   , 
<$=.B:7:3F5
<=(1&.0# $,B?:?*., 85
<.=(&I!,$-- BC:*.,D 8;
<6=,2?#$,BC:B*.,C 85d
<!=&0 6  !,$,:*.,? 85
<,=,,  -0,;  , , 3,, ;
<=  --,0 , 30 5
<=,  ,0 , p- , 3;
<=0,,   ,%!$0---
 , 30 5
<=,>,6-7,3:0-40a
%!$-,,,  -, :
<), ,,    -:  ,3g
,5
d}
<= F  ,-3  5
;; 
 

<=,  3 5
<0=,--  38- , ,- 3 f
   ;
<=0 ,, 3  ,,2;;
 ,; - ,  ,,$;2;5
<=,- ,,- 03-3 3%!$  ss
 4, ,0-:,,,( :.r,
*$- 0#-4$,: 
<=8%!$:
<$=,  - ,,- 035d
<=  - ,,- 03;
<=,-- -: 038,3: - F
 035d
<= ,3 , ,,- 035d
<>=,, ,,- 03  -,%!A.
<="  ,8 0  ,,- 03
<?=(  8%!$:
<=<=0- ;, 03 , ,,-e
, ,%!$5
<= 0 , ,<?=<=<=
<$=0 ,, :, :-  -a ,-n
, ,%!$5
<=  -; ,-;5d
<.= ,0   - -   
 ,<?=<=<=<=;
<=-, ,3: ,, :e,
%!$ -- %!$9 ,---- ,c- 
  - ,-5
<,= :
<=$ ::%!$9  ,n
<?=<=<=<=5
;?; 
 

<=$ ::3%!$9 --
  .
,, 45267673 ,
45267675&  %#"  2 3 *66%= *&
<=( -3%!$  %!$8 
 0 ,
<= , ,, 0, 5
<= ;4 ,  - 5
<,=,4 .
<=$%!$-33  , 0, 3
,:%!$-3 -8     0, 
<=(  F
<=, :?:2:,  5
<=, :?:2,  5d
<,= .
<?=( -3 ,,,( :.:*
$- 0#-4$,:-   ,
,, 5661 -
566& #   &
$   :
<=E.--  E- .--  .-/0/ ,e
,,A;C;.
<=E.-> ,,3E- ,3 ,300
 : ,:,,000,-,03:
,,-:,,, :> :, ::.
<=E6 E- [.-/ ,6 eH,->0> ,e
 , 
<?=E60 E- 60 (,30, ,,
$;;.
,, 5662 -
5669&  % ;?$< @! %@$e.
;2; 
 

<=(,--   0 ,-- [.-/ ,
6 H,->0> , -8
,--  :F3,3:,,  ,-> ,, 
 .
<=(0     0--- .
<=(0 :,,--  : ,
<=-   - - - 5
<=:: :- 0e
-5
<,=- -- 3 -   0i-
 5
<=,,,  - ,-  
0,3 5
<=,;-,3,,  y
, ,:  : .
<?=!,,-> ,,3,-,m-  n
 0- - ,3t,--  
<2=(   3 38s,
<=,;2;:,0 -8- 5
<=,C;;:,3>8- 5
<,=,C;22;:.-/ ,.., ;
<=,?;?;D:8- ;
<=,?;;2:, ,,-5
<=,A;C;?:,-,3;
<=,A;C;: ,,,5
<=,?;;: 0  , ,,--35
<=,?;;2:  - 5
<>=,?;;?2:-8- ;
<4=,?;;?:  3-  -a 5
<=,CC;C;D2: ,, 5
<-=,CC;;: 8- 5
;; 
 

<=,CC;;2:, ,-0  ;
<=,CD$;;B2:,-, ;
<=,D;;?:,,  ,--3- ;
[<)H<8)3  ,8,, ,,
,--  .
<=(,--   :
<=   :,,:,::
%!,-.-/ ,&-.--"0m5d
<=,, 6,-::%!,-.-
/ ,&-.--: %!,-.-/ ,eg
.--:/,3:%!,-.-/ ,ag
.--/3:
,
?, 5696943 -
5696945& %%45 *452&
<=,2;;? 6,-:.
<)<= ,2;;D<2=:, ,- 
,,,  : /3:
<=J ,2;;D<2=:',% 0# ,
 .  : 3 ,;;<=:-4
,  3,   ,-,  , .
G<=H<),2;;2C /3:?.
G<=H<?),2;C;CC-,-, ,,, s
/3:
G<?=H<2),2;D;? /3:?.
G<2=H<)(0  :# 9 , -:e
/3::
<= ,2;D;2<=:  :E3 , p
  , 2;D;2;D;2E5
<=,2;D;;
<,=,2;D;;
<=,2;D;?5d
;C; 
 

<=,2;D;2.
G<=H<C),2;; /3:C.
G<C=H<D)(2:.D:7?:* $K3# ,7>,:s
/3:
G<D=H<B) ,2!;;<=< =3!,
&( 0, 7,-$0 3., a/3:?.
G<B=H<=,2!;;:7,!,$ 
,--0,-- : /3:?.
G<)H<= ,2!;;B<C=:7#&A!-: d
/3:?.
G<)H<=& , 2);;2<?=<2=:f
!,9  , ---- ,0 -
 -:  E2);;2: ,E /3:
.
G<)H<=,2);;B:,,,333:
 /3:?.
G<)H<?= ,2);;<=:3  , ,:s
/3:
G<?)H<2=,2);;:!- .,3
7-: /3:
G<2)H<= ,2);;?<?=:;-e
; 4J7*;0 ; 4: /3:?.
G<)H<C=,2);;2?:,  4  - :
 /3:?.
G<C)H<D=& ,2);;22<=:  E2);;2: 
,E /3:.
G<D)H<B= ,2);?;?<=<=:,
-4: /3:.
G<B)H<=& ,2);?;??<?=<,=:  E!, 0d
 ,<?=<=E /3:.
G<)H<= ,2);?;??<?=<= /3:
;D; 
 

G<)H<=& ,2);B;<=:  E2);;2: 
,E /3:.
G<)H<=& ,2);B;2<=<=:  E2);;2:s
,E /3:.
G<)H<?=& ,2);B;<=<=:  E2);;2:s
,E /3:.
G<?)H<2=& ,2 ;;?<=<,=<=:  E2);;2,
 ,E /3:
G<2)H<='/3::-4,   ,:',f
% 0# , .  :,9 i3
 ,;;<=:-4,, ,  3  ,  s,s
  ,,- , ,,3,,9 ,f
% 9 .
,2, 568698 -
568697& ?! %@ !*66%*  66##!&
<=(.--  .-/0/ , :
<= -- 0,; >0> ,-s
,, :,   ,--y:83  ,:
0;
<=--4,--  ;3 
-3F   --  -,; d
,, 3 -F ,<=<-=;
<,=0 0--,-  ,4>0> t,- :
 3 4-30-,e
-  ;
<=0,3,,- >0> ,e 3 m
,,8-  -:,, :-e
,, : , ,0 -,;
<=00,  -, ;;-,- >0> ,
3,60 /0/ ,0, 60 .d
)-30, :-4,-- F0 --f
;B; 
 

 , ,--3; - 30-:,
<=  
<$=>0,0, : ,D;;5
<=-,  ,- : ,$;2;5
<.=3, 5
<6=0,-;-;
<= --  ,    -;
<= 030,; - ,i, ,g
,00-33- -     y0 4d
     - - 45
<0=-- ,   33f
0,; >0> ,- :, ,  : :d
 5d
<0=30-  , -3 - :-3
 0, :0,30 5
<=   $- 0',. 0- a
  ,    - : : : 3-9s
-335
<=3F- ,     , ,
 , 30 0, :,0, :0s:-4e
,-- ,,  :,,,e,D;2;?;
<=,-3,,8- ,n
D;;?;
G<=  30
 :,:]
G<=  3>, ,;]
G<=--  >0> , 3 -:,lg
- ,> ,:,--3 0 :,
;;-,-5]
G<=,0 -- 0>,> -r
,D;;?- -   ,D;;C,
;; 
 

,,4- ,,  3 -5]
G<0=, 40 --- ,0 0,e :
 0 :;;-,-5]
G<0= --5]
<=0 -,--0t- n
>0> , 3 -- 0,; ,  ,i, s
,0,,0 -3 F-05
<>=0 , 3$- 0',. d
60 /0/ ,0, 0 , 3$- 0
',. 60 /0/ ,0, 0s,
  0>0> ,- ;
<4=0- -0- >0> ,- ,0e
, ,0 -0 -0 ,   d
,-;
<= >, ,<=:   0->0> ,
 4 :,, :,-, : :> :60 
/0/ ,0,  :60 .)-30,  :-
0 5
<-= >, ,<=:   0--,; 
,, 3 -:, 03$- 0',. d
60 /0/ ,0, ,, 0, ,--3
,,;;-,-0 ;
<=   0-0 4    -G 
H 003$- 0',. 
60 /0/ ,0,  0,D;2;G/3,
DH5
<=3  -4,0: e,
 4 # 0 :,> ,*-.e
  - 3 0.
<=( , ,<=<= , ,
0,; - , >0> ,: ,  4: :  03:
;; 
 

3:  -3, 
<= ,0-5
<=3 ,0 , ;
<,=-, ;
<=,,-,3;
<=   ;
<=*>0> , 3 -,- 5
<= .
<=( 3 - , ,<=<-= 0,0 
<= 0,; >0> ,- ,,  ,0e
3  ,,,, ,<=<>=;
<= ;-- -,-5d
<,=0,; - ,, - 0-l .
<?=(.--  .-/0/ ,-3 
-   , ,--  3.-- 
.-/0/ ,,,, ,A;C;?<=.
G<2= , <=<=<,=4,$ :C(- 
 ,4 ,/3:D]
,, 568698 -
568697& * > .
/3::,--  -33  3
3 >,:,-,:8-  , 
$;;<2=<=G<=H<).
,C, 766: ,
766:. %%     ##  $"  66  *
> &
<=$    ,:
<=E)-E-  - - ,C;;2.
<=E)-; E- ,- 00-
<,=E,    E-  - - ,2!;;2
<=E,;  ,03E-  - - ,
;; 
 

2!;;2
<=/3,3:$- 0',.   -e
.--  .-/0/ ,:4y
>, ,:,,3:
<=- >0,;
<=-- 0>,> -;
<,=--   3, >,> -5
<=-- - >0,;
<=-- -- >0,;
<=-- 0 ,,3>0,;
<=-   ,--3-  -i y
>0,;
<=->, >0,  ,--3-o ;
<=-3 3- >0,;
<>=-     ,,:,--3; ,-:
-:4;
<4=,-,>0,-; :
<=-9 -  ,--3,--i;
<=-9 F,-  >0,;
<=-  ,  ,C;;2<=<=(0=
<=<=<=;
<0=3 ,- ,;
<0=,--9 , >0,:,-s
0 ,,>,3>0,5
<0=   3>0,:   
 ,,:,--3; ,-:-:4r
<=(.--  .-/0/ , ,4  tn
,  --; ,--:l3,--:3a
--     - ,    a
 ,;  ,03
<?=&,$- 0',. :0 :d
;; 
 

, :.--  .-/0/ , ,e,e
,,3:
<=--  >0> , 3 -:,g
---  >0,> ,:,--y
 0 :,;;-,-;
<=,0 -- 0>,> -- r
-   3>0,:,,4- t
,,  3 -;
<,=,  40 --- ,0 0, :
 0 :;;-,-5
<=  --
<2='',,3:.--  .-d
/0/ ,  -/,3&-.--e
%!,-.-/ ,&-.--, :
<=,,3.--  .-/0/ ,s
 ,5
<=,,3!,,2!;;25
<,=,--  0, , , 
 ,<2=.
,D    &
( - -3 ,3/3:
:/:?(  - 0 3
 ,3?*- , (/:.:37,es
$,:%   - -3- a,,s
,  0- *.
&(!A
(!,;.,&0  s
)-&,-():';-	2::
,7- :
.,   	2::
(%  :
;?; 
 

<= - - ,,
2 ;D;D 5d
<=,/;;:;-0 -
 ,  ,3? 3   -
   , ,<= -
;2;