Utah House Bill HB0393 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
 


    .
 t     
  !"# !#  !$o
%&&'  !&&()% &&#   ' 
$*# !  &%&&'  &&#+!  !
  & !!!      %#&!$ +,%d ! 
,  '
!"-!'  r    
./)01(S
 ! "#$ %&!
'#' &()'#H
$!-!'  
 ***********_
 
)(2
2!& !
'    +,-,++.fd
,/

+&+."!:
' 
<. .,/  +,-n
-;
<- .,/+/1++a
,

o,- 23+- ,-,
+,-+,/+ ,+t
, 1,  ;
<- 4++ ,-4,,-g
15- 
 

23+- +,- .,
+/,,,,+ , 0
}
<. ,,/+/, m
.,/6 +,-0
<+7 ,,,+, .
!#!&&
!
) && 
!
1 !$$ 
#8 !9:
343524  +/$ )4:5
3435'54 ,/$ )4:53
33414  +/$ )4: 54;
33664  +/$ )4:5
33674  +/$ )4:5
33684  +/$ )4: 54;
33694  +/$ )54,,  4:6
 !#:':
3369'74):#5;
 

 
,5,34352 +
3435' " ! #!$$ $1!!.
=5> , - , =>=>4-,,/,, ,e
)  4- 4 -/ /,
-,,/,, 4  ,+, ,,  c-,,/
:
=>  +/,   ,,4l
,   ,,4 +/ , 
=>+,,0
1- 
 

=> +/,0
=>+/,0r
=->,;
=>  +/,   ,, +/ e
, , , =5>=>=>=-> +a/ 
/,-   ,+0
=,>   ,,  , +/ e
, , ,=5>=> +/  +/ ,l
,  , , ,=5>=>0
=>- , ,/ .l,/ t
5/ 4+?/ 4 ,,4++/e
 ,/4 , ,/0
=> @,,#11A?24,, 
},.,/,
-  5/ 4+?/ 
=>.,/ ,,4 ,-,  
 ,,#11A24 ,.,/;
=>++.,/ +  ./ 
,.,/  1g,   ,n
,#11A?0
=>,  .+   ,4   e 4+e
+ 4, ,,,/4-,e,4
,.+ 0
=>. ,,,+/.+ :5<4
)+8/&-  B #,.
=>=>'-+/ +/ ,,  ,
 ,,  , , ,=5>=)
:
=> +/,-   ,+ ,n
 ,=5>-,  ,   $ p+/
,/0
=>-   ,+ , ,=5>t
1- 
 

C/54   $ 4. se
,+ , ,=5>$ +/e
,/
=>%$  4 ,=>=>4+/le
,/4,+ , ,=5> -t
- 4 -/ /,$ , pe
+/,/4  ,+4,,,h
 ,=5>4   ,,  +/e, s
 , , =5>=>=>=->
=># ,,  ,-,,/,) 
 
=>,,, /,-,,y
,,  ,,, ++/e 1/+
 , 0d
=>-,,/,, # 5/e,n
 , ,=>=>.
=A>=>'- -+/-,,/
,)  +- +/$ ,
,+ ++,/,, ++
+, ,.
=>'- ,=A>=>  - )es
 /,
=>-,,/ /, ,=5>=>0
=> 1/+ , .
=;>#-,-,,/  ,  -
,+,-,,//,,, 
=<>#-,,/,)   ,,   
=> ,0
=> + -, - 
) .
,,3435'5 +
1A- 
 

3435'5' " ! #!$$ $1!!"'
=5> , - , =>=A>4-,,/,, ,e
)  -4- 4 -/ a/,
-,,/,, 4  ,+, ,,  c-,,/
:
=>  +/,   ,,4l
,   ,,4 +/ , 
=>+,,0
=> +/,0
=>+/,0r
=->,;
=>  +/,   ,, +/ e
, , , =5>=>=>=-> +a/ 
/,-   ,+0
=,>   ,,  , +/ e
, , ,=5>=> +/  +/ ,l
,  , , ,=5>=>0
=>- , ,/ .l,/ t
5/ 4+?/ 4 ,,4++/e
 ,/4 , ,/0
=> @,,#11A?24,, 
},.,/,
-  5/ 4+?/ 
=>.,/ ,,4 ,-,  
 ,,#11A24 ,.,/;
=>++.,/ +  ./ 
,.,/  1g,   ,n
,#11A?0
=>,  .+   ,4   e 4+e
+ 4, ,,,/4-,e,4
,.+ 0
=>. ,,,+/.+ :5<4
1;- 
 

)+8/&-  B #,.
=>'-+/ +/ ,,  ,ia
 ,,  , , ,=5>=)
:
=> +/,-   ,+ ,n
 ,=5>-,  ,   $ p+/
,/0
=>-   ,+ , ,=5>er
C/54   $ 4. se
,+ , ,=5>$ +/e
,/
=>%$  4 ,=>4+/e
,/4,+ , ,=5> -t
- 4 -/ /,$ , pe
+/,/4  ,+4,,,h
 ,=5>4   ,,  +/e, s
 , , =5>=>=>=->
=A># ,,  ,-,,/,) 
 --,,/,, 5?/ t
,.
=;>#- -,,/  ,  -
,+,-,,/,, .
=<>#-,,/,)  - ,,  
 -:
=> ,0
=> + -, - 7
)  " - .
,,3341 +
3344' $!!'
#   ,
=5>=>D: ,-,D+   ,t
1<- 
 

,,/,#11,,4
, ,4+,/,4,/,
=>D: ,-,D +, :
=>@ ,@,,,0
=> ,;
=>/,/, 0d
=->+,, ,, 
=>D: ,D+  , -4-4
/4 4  .
=>D:,/D+  + + S,
#1?155
=A>=>D:/,D+ ,-,,  ,y
- /,/
=>D:/,D +:
=>,@ ,@/,,,0
=>, ,;
=>/,/, ;
=->/+,, ,, 0
=->,) ) " -
=;>D ,,,.,,  D+ 
=>   ,/ .f,/4
,    ,,/ 7+ ,
/4 ,
=>,#11A;
=>,11A;4, , #11A;=>=;>0d
=>,#15150
=>  .,/4,  4t s
,,/ 7+ ,/4 ,
=>,#11A;4, , #11A;=>=;>0
=>,#11A?0
=>,#1515
12- 
 

=<>D(,D+ ,-,) )d
 " -
=2>D(,D+ 
=>-4
=>,) ) " -0
=>, , ;
=>,    -4-
,,7 , ,=2>=,>=>;
=,>,/,74,/, , , ,, 0
=>,/,76 ,/ ,4+,/, 0
=>,/,74+,, 0
=>, ,,74, ,, 
=?>D$, ,,D+ ,,, ,.
=>D$,-+,D, ,/, 4+,, 4,
 ,, ,-,  ,/- +,- y
,/
=5>D8,.,,  D+ ,  
   7+ ,/4 a ,7s
 / ,/  .
=55>=>D8,/,D+ ,-,,s
 ,/- ++,/.
=>D8,/,D +
=>,/,;
=>,;
=>,@ ,@/,,,0
=->, ,;
=->/,/, 0
=->/+,, ,, 
=5>D8,,D+ ,-,+,/
=5>=>DE,- D+ ,+,, 
,,  
1?- 
 

=>DE,- D, ,/4,/44, ,4 ,l
 ,4 - ,4,/ , ,
=5A>DF,/D+  ,/
=>=>+  ,/-,e
+ ,/6 ,-+/0
=>- , g 
  ,/6 ,-;
=>  ,/6 ,-y
8,-1+/0
=,> @,#11A?24,, 
}+ ++ 
,/ 7 ,/6 +i/,-,/e
++,  7+/+ 
=> 7+ ,/6 ,-,  4
,,,-  ,#11A20
=> 7+/,,  4,,,p- s
,#11A?0d
=>=> ,/ ,, /4;+.
 8/&,1+/4, -
4,/4 ,t/ +e
 ,/6 , ,,,-s ,#11A<0

=> ,/ ,,/4, e
+ ,/  ,r,#1?154r
,4 ,/ + ,
/6 , ,,,-  ,#11A<
=5;>D4D  , 7+ia
 ,/4+ 
=> +,.,,  4, e
,,/ ,/+ , ,#11A;=>0
=> ,,,.,,  :
=>,, ,, ,#1515=<>=,>=>=#)0
1- 
 

=>, ,,,,/ ,n
#1515=<>=,>=>=>
,A,3366 +
3367' 0 &$& &#33: !!;!.
'-  /.,/
=5>.,/ 4;+ 8/f
&,,1+/4,/-/fr
+ ,  ++ +/-.l,/6s
, - +/-.,/6s
, ;
=>-  /+.,
/
=> , #11A=5>=>=>=>=>=A>=>;
=> ,#11A=;>=,>0
=,>,#11A;;
=> @,,#11A?24,, 
}-+// 7e
+.,// + ,,t#11A24
,#11A?4;
=A> @,,#11A?24,, 
}.,/ l
,+/-  , #11A24#11A?4#11A;
=;>  ,#1<15=5>=>4=5>=>4=>=>4,,c
   ,,#1<15, ,-+
/.,/:
=>.,/6 + 4/0
=>. ,/  g/
.,/,, , ,=5>44 
 4 + ;
=<>  ,#1<1=5>=>4,,,  4
 , 4,, +/e.
,/  //;
=2>  ,#1<1A=5>=>4,,,  tt
151 
 

/ ,, +/.c/s
 /@,,6 ++,,0
=?>D, ,-,4D ,#1155=5>=>4so
, - ,,,/,#11A2
#11A?,,4, f,4
+,/,4,/,;
=>- +/4 7+4.d
,/ .,+/ ,#115=5>=,>0
=5>  ,#11A=>4.,/ td
-,.,/6 , ,-,
+/.,/,e,, 
,.,/0
=55> ,#11A4,,  4a
+/,4.,t/+  
, ,-,+ ,,#-1A24r
+  , ,-,,e+ 
 ,,#11A2,#11A?:
=>  7 ,++/+,,
 ++ ,#11A20
=>   7 ,+4l4/
,G +D' , ,-+,6 ,
//6 +,-D;
[=55>I=5>  ,#11A=A>=>4- l
, -/-,/,7 :
=>+ , .,/4, 4
+,/4,/, 0
=>+  , ,-,-+y
.,/ ,,/,7 , ,, +
+/1,0
[=5>I=5>  ,#11A=;>=,>4,  
,-,+/,.,/ +
1551 
 

//,+/0d
[=5>I=5A> -   , #11A=5>=>
,#11A;4.,/ -+  , 
,-,/e,.
,;,3367 +
3368' !"!! <!!!$: &$& &
#'
=5>'  , , .+ ++.,/
  7+.,/,-i,
.,/6 ,-,  .
=>!  ,#115=2>=>4+,f
,,/++.,/ +/4w  7g
+4.,/  ,   /s
 ,,#11A?;.
=>!  ,#11=5>=>4, - ,n
#11=A>4++.,/4  ,4  e7
+.,/,-, t
,4 
=>, - ,#11=5>=,>4,,,/n
 ,,,,/e ,
,#115;0
=>/
=A>!  ,#11=>=>4++.,
/4  ,4  7+.,/e
, ,/+,/ , ,st
, :
=>,,,/,/,7 c
+, , ,,,,/d
 ,,#115;0d
=>/
=;>!  ,#11=>=>=>4-,e
151 
 

  @1,7+- +/.i
,/4  ,4,- 4,af
,,/ ,,#115;4,,,/d
 ++,-+ -,s
@1,7+
=<>=>#.,/+ ,  , 
,/+,- c
 ,#11=5>=>.
=>'- ,4+/,,4a
,+/ , ,  4,
,,4+,,+/.t,/
  ,.
=2>!  ,#1125=>4 4,,
 +/.,/  ,4 t.,
/+,.
=?>#.,/+ +,  s,
 ,/,-  - ,
 ,#11=5>=>.
=>' ,, ,-   , ,=?> ,4r
,,+,:
=>+,,-, 7/6 +
,;
=>-+ /.,/o
++,-, ,0d
=,>,- ,-/,,,-
,<,3368 +
3369' +! 3+!+ <!!!$: &$d
& &#'
=5>'  , , .+ ++.,/
  7+.,/,-,e
 1,   ,  ,
151 
 

=>!  ,#115=2>=>4+,f
,,/++.,/ +/4w  7g
+4.,/  ,   /s
 ,,#11A?;.
=>!  ,#11=5>=>4, - ,n
#11=A>4++.,/4  ,4  e7
+.,/,-, t
, :
=>,,,/ ,,#115;4
    ,4,em
-/-,  ,a,/t
, :
=>++++,+, d
,/  ,;
=>+ ,/,++  7
+;
=>,,++  7,+,0
=->  +++0d
=->+./-;
=>, - ,#11=5>=,>4,,,/,
 4,,,,/r ,
,#115;0
=,>/
=A>!  ,#11=>=>4++.,
/4  ,4  7+.,/e
, ,/+,/ , ,st
, :
=>,,,/ ,,#115;4
    ,4,em
-/-,  ,a,/t
, :
15A1 
 

=>++++,+, d
,/  ,;
=>+ ,/,++  7
+;
=>,,++  7,+,0
=->  +++0d
=->+./-;
=>, - ,#11=5>=,>4,,,/,
 4,,,,/r ,
,#115;0
=,>/
=;>!  ,#11=>=>=>4-,e
  @1,7+- +/.i
,/4  ,4,- 4,af
,,/ ,,#115;4,,,/d
 ++,-+ -,s
@1,7+
=<>H'eI@,,#11A?24,4- 
 ,, , ,#1125=5> , +
,,+/.,/  ,.
=2>!  ,#1125=>4 4,,
 +/.,/  ,4 t.,
/+,.
=?>HAI@,,#11A?24,4++.,
/+/ 7+.,/,-,/:
=>,+/.+  ,  ,0d
=>,,  4+-/-,+s
 ,#11A;=>4/,++
 ,  ;+5A/ yn
,.,/6 ,-, 4l+ :
=> ,4?4   -  
15;1 
 

+/.,/-.,/6 , 
+/,;
=>,   ,,424   - 
  ,   ,+/. ,/-e
.,/6 , +/,;
=>  ,,44   - 
    ,+/.,/-r
.,/6 , +/,;
=->   ,,454   - 
     ,+/.,/-
.,/6 , +/,;
=-> ,,4  
=#>4   -   
 , ,+/.,y-.
,/6 , +/,0
=>3 - .,/s e
, , ,0d
=->,/,,4  3 - s 
+-,/,+/.l,l
/-.,/6 , +/,.
=>=>'  ,=> /+,.,p,  .
=>H%I@,,#11A?24,4n++
.,/./ ,.t,/6 +n
,-,  ,4 +,.,p,  4e
++ :
=>,,  +-/-4  a+
,,-,.+  ,, #121A#121;0
=> +  ,,;+5A/s
/,.,/ /6 ,- ,
, 4,-,4.,/6 +
=,>)+/,   , , =?>(>=>4
15<1 
 

,, 45A/ /,e,n
,,-   4//,.l,/
 ,- ,+,-,, p,7 
:
=>,,7+,-,+ -, e
,7+,-  )  5?/e 0
=> ++,- , ,=>=,>=>s
)   5?/ /,//0
=>+,   - . e
4  ++4 ,,#121<4 -/ e
0
=->,/,+  - .se
 ,7.
=5>=>'  ,=5> /,,,.,a
,  
=>H%I@,,#11A?24,4n++
.,/./ ,.t,/6 +n
,-,  ,4++ 4;+r5A/s
/,.,/ /6 ,- ,
, 4,-,4.,/6 +4,,
  ,,/
=>,,,,#15150d
=>   - , 4+-/-4
,+  ,#11A;=A>
=,>)+/,   , , =?>(>=>4
,, 45A/ /,e,n
,,-   4//,.l,/
 ,- ,+,-,, p,7 
:
=>,,7+,-,+ -, to
+,-  )  5?/ 0a
1521 
 

=> ++,- , ,=5>=,>=> 
)   5?/ /,//
=55>=>#-+/    ,
- ,  ,,/ ,  ,.
=>#- ,  ,,/,
 , ,=>=>=A>=>4 4/,- 
,  ,,/
=>.,+/.+ ,, 
.,+/0
=> @, +,+-  4,-,+e 4t
/,,.+  ,r ,
=55>=>=>.
=,>)+/,   , , =?>(>=>4r
 , =?>=5>=>4,, 4/e/n
,.,/ ,- ,+,-e
,, ,7 4/.,a/e
-+,++.,y. 
 +.,/4  ,4,i-,,
,- .
=>),,  ,,/ ,e
  ,4-  ,  
,,/-6   +,a-r
  ,,,/.
,2,3369'7 ,
3369'8'&!!$ !!!%#+! 3+!+'
=5>#.,/+/,+, p ,-
,,,,,+,   , s,.
=>=>@, ,=>4.,/+ ,

 ,-,,#11A24,+i,
+ /, . ,+ +/
,#11A8,f
4}:
15?1 
 

=> 
/,,- +;3}-4{
- , /- ,-4},,-  23-s
, /
- s
,-},-0
=> ,  .-4,,-  23f
- , / ,-4++/,if
-4 , ,-, +/
 0
=>#.,/4 
 +},,
,4 ,.,/6 +e, ,-e
,,,, ,=>=>
=>;+ 8/&,,1+/0
d
=>,-+1+-,,/,)  a
)  -4;+ //,
-   ,+ , ,#151;=5> ,n
#151;;=5>.
=,>=>#.,/ 
+/-s 
 +},
t , ,=>=>=>+/,4t
,,+,  4.i,/- 
,,,;+!-+/r
, 
 +}, 
=>#.,/+/ 
 +},
 ,=>=>=>
=>',+,   , ,=>=>/ 
=>.,/+/ 
 +}, ,n
 ,=>=>=>=>4 ,0
=>+/,4.,/ 

 +}, , ,=>=,>=>.
,?,3369 +
336' .#& !"!&!+: &$& &#'
=5>'+/,  ,,#15-5;
151 
 

=>=>#.,/+ +, ,-
,,#11A2 -,./ ,
,,#11A?4+/4 .4,+a/,n
,
=>#.,/ /,./ ,an
,-,,#11A? +,,e
,#11A24+/4 .4,+/,r
,
=,>#.,/+ /,,t-,
,#11A2 +, ./ ,,e
,#11A?4+/4 .4,+/,r
,:
=>.,/+ , ,-f,e
,+,   ,,#11A?20d
=>+,, ./,-ce
,#11A?4 
 }r,#11A?24+/

+a,+,,#11A2.
H=,>I=)#.,/+ +, 
,-,,#11A2 +, ./ ,e
,,#11A? ,+/c,.
H=>I=)#.,/ +, ./ 
, ,-,,#11A? +,e
,,#11A2 ,+/c,.
=>!  ,=>41,/4 ,n
521;15521;14.,/ ,r+/,
,/,++  ,
=> +
=>  ,521;150r
=>++-,,/ ,521;150d
=>+, +,#11A2.
,#11A? ,-  ++-,, , +r
11 
 

 ,-  ++-,, 
=A>=>#    ,=A>4, D D:
=>-,,- ,,4+pe
,4+/,,'  ,/
,,-,0
=>,+- ,+4e
+, ,-,,4+g,4e
+/,,6  ,/ ,
+, ,+,
=> , ,=A>=,>4- :
=>-,/,7 
=#> + , 4, 4+1,/4 
,/4,/, -,-,, +,4
 ,  +  +/,n
,,,,#1<1;0
=>  , ,-,-+/
 ,/0d
=> ,,/,7 , , ++y
,
=,>' , ,=A>=> ;+ J /r
/#.
151