Utah House Bill HB0393 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
 
2

    
 t     .
  ! " #  !#    ! $o
%&&'     !&&()% &&# ' 
$ *#  !  &%&&'  &&#+!  !
  & !!!  %#& ! $  +,%d! 
,   '
-!". !' }! 01' && e  g
  
23)45(S
 ! "#$ %&!
'#' &()'#H
$ ! . !' 
  

***********_
}+,#-.e
-   :
! '#
-/+#0n
-"#0
+,

/..r
1,s
2 n
'/-0/
2   n
0s
3/
+/l
2,s
+%4y
-120k
'.2.z
6!2 
30$+r
2 +/
'4$
+$ e
#/ $t
42$
7$/.
#-/3y
2 3  
3027 n
'. 17 
8$7 n
-0700i
2/1, "r
9:- 
 
2
3,05
"7
- /
3,#
"!1
"/610
 
)(6
6!& !
'    
.040..;d
0/./040  .

+&+2 " !:
' 
<; ;0/  .04n
4;
<
4 ;0/./9..
004 =>.4 040a
.04.0/. 0.t
0 90  ;
<4 ?.. 04?004g
=>.4 .04 ;0
./0000. 0 <
<; } 0s00/./0s
.;0/@ .04<d
}
<., 000.0 .
 !# !&&
!
)&& 
!
5  !$$
#3 !6:
{ 78792?  ./$ )?-:
7879'5? 0/$ )?-:3
9- 
 
2
7781?  ./$ )?- :?A
} 77:6?  ./$ )?-:
77:7?  ./$ )?-:
{ 77:8?  ./$ )?- :?A
77:9?  ./$ ):?00  ?-6
 !#-':
77:='7?)-#:A
} 

 
0:0{78792}77:6 .
{ 7879' "!#! $$ $5!! .
C:D 0 4 0 CDCD?400/00 0e
)  ?4 ? 4/ /0
400/00 ?  0.0 00  c400/
:
CD  ./0   00?l
0   00? ./ 0 
CD.00<
CD ./0<
CD./0<r
C4D0;
CD  ./0   00 ./ e
0 0 0 C:DCDCDC4D .a/ 
/04   0.<
C0D   00  0 ./ e
0 0 0C:DCD ./  ./ 0l
0  0 0 0C:DCD<
CD4 0 0/ ;l0/ t
:/ ?.E/ ? 00?../e
 0/? 0 0/<
CD F00#99GE=?0?0;0/,
9- 
 
2
4  :/ ?.E/ 
CD;0/ 00? 040  
 00#99G=? 0;0/;
CD..;0/ .  ;/ 
0;0/  9g0   0n
0#99GE<
CD0  ;.   0?   e ?.e
. ?0 000/?40e0?
0;. <
CD; 000./;. -:B?
).3/&4  8 #0.
CDCD'4./ ./ 00  0
 00  0 0 0C:DC)
:
CD ./04   0. 0n
 0C:D40  0   $ p./
0/<
CD4   0. 0 0C:Dt
2/:?   $ ?; se
0. 0 0C:D$ ./e
0/
CD%$  ? 0CDCD?./le
0/?0. 0 0C:D 4t
4 ? 4/ /0$ 0 pe
./0/?  0.?000h
 0C:D?   00  ./e0 s
 0 0 C:DCDCDC4D
CD# 00  0400/0) 
 
CD000 /0400y
00  000 ../e 9/.
9G- 
 
2
 0 <d
CD400/00 # :/e0n
 0 0CDCD.
CGDCD'4 4./400/
0)  .4 ./$ ,
0. ..0/00 ..
.0 0.
CD'4 0CGDCD  4 )es
 /0
CD400/ /0 0C:DCD<
CD 9/. 0 .
CAD#40400/  0  4
0.0400//000 
CBD#400/0)   00   
CD 0<
CD . 40 4 
) .
007879'5 .
7879'9' "!#! $$ $5!!"'
C:D 0 4 0 CDCGD?400/00 0e
)  4?4 ? 4/ a/0
400/00 ?  0.0 00  c400/
:
CD  ./0   00?l
0   00? ./ 0 
CD.00<
CD ./0<
CD./0<r
C4D0;
CD  ./0   00 ./ e
0 0 0 C:DCDCDC4D .a/ 
9A- 
 
2
/04   0.<
C0D   00  0 ./ e
0 0 0C:DCD ./  ./ 0l
0  0 0 0C:DCD<
CD4 0 0/ ;l0/ t
:/ ?.E/ ? 00?../e
 0/? 0 0/<
CD F00#99GE=?0?0;0/,
4  :/ ?.E/ 
CD;0/ 00? 040  
 00#99G=? 0;0/;
CD..;0/ .  ;/ 
0;0/  9g0   0n
0#99GE<
CD0  ;.   0?   e ?.e
. ?0 000/?40e0?
0;. <
CD; 000./;. -:B?
).3/&4  8 #0.
CD'4./ ./ 00  0ia
 00  0 0 0C:DC)
:
CD ./04   0. 0n
 0C:D40  0   $ p./
0/<
CD4   0. 0 0C:Der
2/:?   $ ?; se
0. 0 0C:D$ ./e
0/
CD%$  ? 0CD?./e
0/?0. 0 0C:D 4t
9B- 
 
2
4 ? 4/ /0$ 0 pe
./0/?  0.?000h
 0C:D?   00  ./e0 s
 0 0 C:DCDCDC4D
CGD# 00  0400/0) 
 4400/00 :E/ t
0.
CAD#4 400/  0  4
0.0400/00 .
CBD#400/0)  4 00  
 4:
CD 0<
CD . 40 4 ,
)  " 4 .
007781 .
7788' $! !'
#   0
C:DCDH- 040H.   0t
00/0#9900?
0 0?.0/0?0/0
CDH- 040H .0 :
CDF 0F000<
CD 0;
CD/0/0 <d
C4D.00 00 
CDH- 0H.  0 4?4?
/? ?  .
CDH-0/H.  . . S0
#9E9::
CGDCDH-/0H. 0400  0y
4 /0/
9=- 
 
2
CDH-/0H .:
CD0F 0F/000<
CD0 0;
CD/0/0 ;
C4D/.00 00 <
C4D0) ) " 4
CADH 000;00  H. 
CD   0/ ;f0/?
0    00/ ,. 0
/? 0
CD0#99G;
CD099GA?0 0 #99GACDCAD<d
CD0#9:9:<
CD  ;0/?0  ?t s
00/ ,. 0/? 0
CD0#99GA?0 0 #99GACDCAD<
CD0#99GE<
CD0#9:9:
CBDH(0H. 040) )d
 " 4
C=DH(0H. 
CD4?
CD0) ) " 4<
CD0 0 ;
CD0    4?4
00, 0 0C=DC0DCD;
C0D0/0,?0/0 0 0 00 <
CD0/0,@ 0/ 0?.0/0 <
CD0/0,?.00 <
CD0 00,?0 00 
CEDH$0 00H. 000 0.
9E- 
 
2
CDH$04.0H0 0/0 ?.00 ?0
 00 040  0/4 .04 y
0/
C:DH30;00  H. 0  
   ,. 0/? a 0,s
 / 0/  .
C::DCDH30/0H. 0400s
 0/4 ..0/.
CDH30/0H .
CD0/0;
CD0;
CD0F 0F/000<
C4D0 0;
C4D/0/0 <
C4D/.00 00 
C:DH300H. 040.0/
C:DCDH704 H. 0.00 
00  
CDH704 H0 0/?0/??0 0? 0l
 0? 4 0?0/ 0 0
C:GDHI0/H.  0/
CDCD.  0/40e
. 0/@ 04./<
CD4 0 g 
  0/@ 04;
CD  0/@ 04y
3049./<
C0D F0#99GE=?0?. .. 0
/ , 0/@ ./0t40/..
0  ,./. :
CD ,. 0/@ 040  ?
9- 
 
2
0004  0#99G=<
CD ,./00  ?000p4 s
0#99GE<d
CDCD 0/ 00 /?A..
 3/&09./?0 4
?0/? 0t/ .e
 0/@ 0 0004s 0#99GB<

CD 0/ 00/?0 e
. 0/  0r0#9E9:?r
0? 0/ . 0
/@ 0 0004  0#99GB
C:ADH?H  0 ,.ia
 0/?. 
CD .0;00  ?0 e
00/ 0/. 0 0#99GACD<
CD 000;00  :
CD00 00 0#9:9:CBDC0DCDC#)<
CD0 0000/ 0n
#9:9:CBDC0DCDCD
0G077:6 .
} 77:;' 4 &$ &&#77> !!? !.
'4  /;0/
C:D;0/ ?A. 3/f
&009./?0/4/fr
. 0  .. ./4;l0/@s
0 4 ./4;0/@s
0 ;
CD4  /.;0
/
CD 0 #99GC:DCDCDCDCDCGDCD;
9:9 
 
2
CD 0#99GCADC0D<
C0D0#99GA;
CD 
 F00#99GE=?0?}4.// ,e
.;0// . 00t#99G=?
0#99GE?;
CGD 
 F00#99GE=?0?};0/ l
0./4  0 #99G=?#99GE?#99G;
CAD  0#9B9:C:DCD?C:DCD?CDCD?00c
   00#9B9:0 04.
/;0/:
CD;0/@ .e
?/<
CD; 0/  g/
;0/00 0 0C:D?? 
 ? . ;
CBD  0#9B9C:DCD?000  ?
 0 ?00 ./e;
0/  //;
C=D  0#9B9GC:DCD?000  tt
/ 00 ./;c/s
 /F00@ ..00<
CEDH0 040?H 0#99::C:DCD?so
0 4 000/0#99G=
#99GE00?0 f0?
.0/0?0/0;
CD4 ./? ,.?;d
0/ ;0./ 0#99:C:DC0D<
C:D  0#99GCD?;0/ td
40;0/@ 0 040
./;0/0e00 
0;0/<
C::D 0#99G?00  ?a
9::9 
 
2
./0?;0t/.  
0 040. 00#-9G=?r
.  0 0400e. 
 00#99G=0#99GE:
CD  , 0../.00
 .. 0#99G=<
CD   , 0.?l?/
05 .H' 0 04.0@ 0
//@ .04H;
JC::)KC:D  0#99GCGDCD?4 l
0 4/40/0, :
CD. 0 ;0/?0 ?
.0/?0/0 <
CD.  0 0404.y
;0/ 00/0, 0 00 .
./90<
JC:)KC:D  0#99GCADC0D?0  
040./0;0/ .
//0./<d
JC:)KC:GD 4   0 #99GC:DCD
0#99GA?;0/ 4.  0 
040/e0.
0
A}20 77:7 .
77:<'  !"! !  1! ! ! $> &$ &&
#'
C:D'  0 0 ;. ..;0/
  ,.;0/04i0
;0/@ 040  .
CD!  0#99:C=DCD?.0f
00/..;0/ ./?w  ,g
.?;0/  0   /s
9:9 
 
2
 00#99GEA.
CD!  0#99C:DCD?0 4 0n
#99CGD?..;0/?  0?  e,
.;0/040 t
0? 
CD0 4 0#99C:DC0D?000/n
 0000/e 0
0#99:A<
CD/
CGD!  0#99CDCD?..;0
/?  0?  ,.;0/e
0 0/.0/ 0 0st
0 :
CD000/0/0, c
.0 0 0000/d
 00#99:A<d
CD/
CAD!  0#99CDCDCD?40e
  F90,.4 ./;i
0/?  0?04 ?0af
00/ 00#99:A?000/d
 ..04. 40s
F90,.
CBDCD#;0/. 0  0 
0/.04 c
 0#99C:DCD.
CD'4 0?./00?a
0./ 0 0  ?0
00?.00./;t0/
  0.
C=D!  0#99=:CD? ?00
9:9 
 
2
 ./;0/  0? t;0
/.0.
CED#;0/. .0  s0
 0/04  4 0
 0#99C:DCD.
CD'0004   0 0CED 0l?
00.0:
CD.0040 ,/@ .
0;
CD4. /;0/o
..040 0<d
C0D04 04/0004
{ 0B077:8 .
77:=' +! 7+!+  1! ! ! $> &$d
 &&#'
C:D'  0 0 ;. ..;0/
  ,.;0/040e
 90   0  0
CD!  0#99:C=DCD?.0f
00/..;0/ ./?w  ,g
.?;0/  0   /s
 00#99GEA.
CD!  0#99C:DCD?0 4 0n
#99CGD?..;0/?  0?  e,
.;0/040 t
0 :
CD000/ 00#99:A?
    0?0em
4/40  0a0/t
0 :
CD....0.0 d
9:G9 
 
2
0/  0;
CD. 0/0..  ,
.;
CD00..  ,0.0<
C4D  ...<d
C4D.;/4;
CD0 4 0#99C:DC0D?000/,
 ?0000/r 0
0#99:A<
C0D/
CGD!  0#99CDCD?..;0
/?  0?  ,.;0/e
0 0/.0/ 0 0st
0 :
CD000/ 00#99:A?
    0?0em
4/40  0a0/t
0 :
CD....0.0 d
0/  0;
CD. 0/0..  ,
.;
CD00..  ,0.0<
C4D  ...<d
C4D.;/4;
CD0 4 0#99C:DC0D?000/,
 ?0000/r 0
0#99:A<
C0D/
CAD!  0#99CDCDCD?40e
  F90,.4 ./;i
9:A9 
 
2
0/?  0?04 ?0af
00/ 00#99:A?000/d
 ..04. 40s
F90,.
CBDJ'KF00#99GE=?0?e4 
 00 0 0#99=:C:D 0 .
00./;0/  0.
C=D!  0#99=:CD? ?00
 ./;0/  0? t;0
/.0.
CEDJ#KF00#99GE=?0?a..;0
/./ ,.;0/040/:
CD0./;.  0  0<d
CD00  ?.4/40.s
 0#99GACD?/0..
 0  A.:G/ yn
0;0/@ 040 ?l. :
CD 0?E?   4  
./;0/4;0/@ 0 
./0;
CD0   00?=?   4 
  0   0./; 0/4e
;0/@ 0 ./0;
CD  00??   4 
    0./;0/4r
;0/@ 0 ./0;
C4D   00?:?   4 
     0./;0/4
;0/@ 0 ./0;
C4D 00?  
C#D?   4   
9:B9 
 
2
 0 0./;0y4;
0/@ 0 ./0<
CD> 4 ;0/s e
0 0 0<d
C4D0/00?  > 4 s 
.40/0./;l0l
/4;0/@ 0 ./0.
CDCD'  0CD /.0;0p0  .
CDJ%KF00#99GE=?0?n..
;0/;/ 0;t0/@ .n
040  0? .0;0p0  ?e
.. :
CD00  .4/4?  a.
0040;.  00 #9=9G#9=9A<
CD .  00A.:G/s
/0;0/ /@ 04 0
0 ?040?;0/@ .
C0D)./0   0 0 CED(DCD?
00 ?:G/ /0e0n
004   ?//0;l0/
 04 0.0400 p0, 
:
CD00,.040. 40 e
0,.04  )  :E/e <
CD ..04 0 0CDC0DCDs
)   :E/ /0//<
CD.0   4 ; e
?  ..? 00#9=9B? 4/ e
<
C4D0/0.  4 ;se
 0,.
9:=9 
 
2
C:DCD'  0C:D /000;0a
0  
CDJ%KF00#99GE=?0?n..
;0/;/ 0;t0/@ .n
040  0?.. ?A.r:G/s
/0;0/ /@ 04 0
0 ?040?;0/@ .?00
  00/
CD0000#9:9:<d
CD   4 0 ?.4/4?
0.  0#99GACGD
C0D)./0   0 0 CED(DCD?
00 ?:G/ /0e0n
004   ?//0;l0/
 04 0.0400 p0, 
:
CD00,.040. 40 to
.04  )  :E/ <a
CD ..04 0 0C:DC0DCD 
)   :E/ /0//
C::DCD#4./    0
4 0  00/ 0  0.
CD#4 0  00/,
 0 0CDCDCGDCD? ?/04 
0  00/
CD;0./;. 00 
;0./<
CD F0 .0.4  ?040.e ?t
/00;.  0r 0
C::DCDCD.
C0D)./0   0 0 CED(DCD?r
9:E9 
 
2
 0 CEDC:DCD?00 ?/e/n
0;0/ 04 0.04e
00 0, ?/;0a/e
4.0..;0y; 
 .;0/?  0?0i400
04 .
CD)00  00/ 0e
  0?4  0  
00/4@   .0a4r
  000/.
0=077:='7 0
77:='<'&! ! $!! !%#+! 7+!+'
C:D#;0/./0.0 p 04
00000.0   0 s0.
CDCDF0 0CD?;0/. 0
 0400#99G=?0.i0
. /0 ; 0. ./
0#99GE?
CD 4?004  =>4 0 y
 04<r
CD 0  ;4?004  =>f
4 0 / 04?../0if
4? 0 040 ./
 <
CD#;0/?000? 
0;0/@ .0 r040
000 0CDCD
CDA. 3/&009./<
d
CD04.9.400/0)  a
)  4?A.//0e
9:9 
 
2
4   0. 0 0#9:9AC:D 0n
#9:9AAC:D.
C0DCD#;0/4 0 0
 0CDCDCD./0?0i0e
.0  ?;0/4 0
00A.!4./00
 
CD#;0/./0r
 0CDCDCD
CD'0.0   0 0CDCD/ 
CD;0/./ 0 0 0
CDCDCDCD? 0<d
CD./0?;0/ 
0 0 0CDC0DCD.
0E077:9 .
77:' 2#& ! " !&!+ > &$ &&#'
C:D'./0  00#9:-:A
CDCD#;0/. .0 04
00#99G= 40;/ 0
00#99GE?./? ;?0.a/0n
0
CD#;0/ /0;/ 0an
0400#99GE .00e
0#99G=?./? ;?0./0r
0
C0D#;0/. /00t40
0#99G= .0 ;/ 00e
0#99GE?./? ;?0./0r
0:
CD;0/. 0 04f0e
0.0   00#99GE=<d
99 
 
2
CD.00 ;/04ce
0#99GE?0#99GE=?./0.d
00#99G=
JC0DKC)#;0/. .0 
0400#99G= .0 ;/ 0e
00#99GE 0./c0.
JCDKC)#;0/ .0 ;/ 
0 0400#99GE .0e
00#99G= 0./c0.
CD!  0CD?90/? 0n
:=9A9::=9A9?;0/ 0r./0
0/0..  0
CD .
CD  0:=9A9:<r
CD..400/ 0:=9A9:<d
CD.0 .0#99G=;
0#99GE 04  ..400 0 .r
 04  ..400 
CGDCD#    0CGD?0 H H:
CD4004 00?.pe
0?./00'  0/
0040<
CD0.4 0.?e
.0 0400?.g0?e
./00@  0/ 0
.0 0.0
CD 0 0CGDC0D?4 :
CD40/0, 
C#D . 0 ?0 ?.90/? 
0/?0/0 40400 .0?
 0  .  ./0n
9:9 
 
2
0000#9B9A<
CD  0 0404./
 0/<d
CD 00/0, 0 0 ..y
0
C0D' 0 0CGDCD A. 1 /r
/#.
}
99