Utah House Bill HB0412 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
     
2

    
 t     .
     !"   #      $! " $!  " %  o
&'' (      !  " '' )* & ''$ !( 
%+ $! "    !' &'' (    !''$ ," !"
!' "" "!  !  &$ '"  %   ,- &d "!
-   !  (
 "# .$ /(  %% "    
 0*1) 2*)
 !"!#$%!&'"
($(!')*($H
% "   .$ /(  %% n
 !+,-./ 
 
*)3 
3"'  "
( 0 +   010.

,', 0# " :
( 
<+ .. +.01 0/+1.o
.+. +.0  2
<0 +    .3i+ f
0# .402
<0  .1550.00s1 02
<  1. .1550.e
1550.00 1 0;
<    .$6  . +.0 ;
5- 
     
2
<+ 01  .. +.   
+t
.0+1..0. +.0
01s
  . .$6 }2d
<0 +  01 1 
"$  "   ''
"
* ' '!  
( +  ..+
4  "  %%
$4!"3:
56767  01% *789
56765 8%%# 799)7  01% *78 
::7:97;;79
5676 8%%# 799)7 .1% *789
56767  01% *789
56767  01% *78:9
567677  01% *78 :99
 

 
..5676 0
5676. %"" (
$   .
<=>$.1>0 10* +01o
01 .
<=>8 +.>0    . .
:$5;5.
<=>8 +.01>0 01?  ..  1.0@
<=,177 ..  1.0 1 +.
 .+1. +.?@2
?<=>8 +.  >0   01  ..  1
.01 .0+. +. i ]
5- 
     
2
<=,177 +1
<=..0   00. +c2r
<=..+  00. +.
<=>8 +.  >0   017,17
7 ..  1.0 .1.m+.r
 +. .
<A=>8   +.>0     B..  i.
.0 +  .:$5;5;
<:=>8  .>0 .  . .AC5;5.
<;=<=>30>0  .1. .
01D ...
<=>30> 0
<= .10+001 .
..2
<=.  .01D  +   .n
:$5;5;<= 010.
<C=>3.>0 .+ .
<9=>3 1>0 1 .0 1 .
$0. 3  $.7*8. E
<=>3+ >0 3+ 0# .407.
.:$5;5A.
<=>!01>0 1+  .+1. +.r
.   +.+   .
<=>!0 0 >0 1 ..1  
<=>0 ..>0       .
<=.:$5;5:2
<= + 2d
<.=  
<=>4/.01B 0>0  1B 0e0d
.  10/ +1 1+0
<A=>F'(5.01>0 01
5- 
     
2
<= 01 E 01+.+g
..(A78:7F7F.'.(8.$.2
<=.+.. . .<A=<=;
<.=0 .. . .<A=<=te
01D 010 E 01+.e+g
.. . .<A=<=
[<A=@<:=>F101>0 01 +1e
. +.  +. +.  .
[<:=@<;=>F1>0 001+ 
01 + . +.   .  .r
 +.   01
[<;=@<C=>F1  >0   01e
01D . +.  
[<C=@<9=>.B 0>0 + 0. 1 
[<9=@<=>(0101>0 ?. +.001s@
01 . .:$5;5<=?<=@< =7. +.0 s.
[<=@<=>(.0 >0    7  7+7p
 . 707  0y  .0 o
/ .
..56765 8%%# 799) 0
56765 8%%# 799:(  " &'  %  .
<=$    .7>0 .>0   ..s 
 7   .1
<=(. +  1..10 
 0 .00 1 0
<=!. +.:$5;57.10100
 .. . ..
<=0 .00 01+ ...e
(: 787*$0 +#0/$.7 /..e
 ...1 7. 7.. 
<A=(+ 01  +..1...h
5- 
     
2
.:,550 .. + + .
<:=(. 
<=+70070  00 .e
00:
<=....1;
<= . . +.E01 2d
<=   . . 00  s;
<= 0  12
<.= 0  .  . 1 0. f0
 .  0 ;
<= 0  .0 . 1 02
<=0 .10 ...  .0.
7 7 0 . 7.E010t12
<=. . .  ..01..+.d
 .;
<=0. . 2
<=0 . .  100 .   e
  ;
<=0   1+7.+.7 ;
<B=0/ 0 .007...(: 78r
7*$0 +#0/$.2
</=  0000 1 0 t
+7% 7. .0G i 7
170 .. 0 . 2
<=.. ..+ :
<=0 0 . ;
<=+0 0+.0 .002d
<= .1. +;
<0= 1..7.  7 .0 010
+  00 .   s
+E0101010;
5A- 
     
2
<=E 1. . . 70. 7.l
 +   7+.. +.7.00 7+.
0 .00.01.;
<=  .0 . . 1+10;
<=. . 0 .. 
. ;
<E= 0.+.7+7% 2
d
<=   +0+. E e.n
:,55<=<=<+=
<;=<=$. .+.7+7 f
. 7.   . 0 7
. . .<;=<=
<=(0 +  .<;= +.me
.1
<.=(+ 01  0 01 m
1 .G..B  / .
<=(+   10 .  c<;=
.0 (: 787(8.#E0 .
<=<=$    .<;=<=:
<$=>!01>0  0 0 .:$5;5
<=>+ >0 + .17 .i
:$5;57E  + 0.+0l1.
<=$ +  :
<$= 0 0  + 2
<= 1.
<=?(.e@80.+ 
0.  . + + DsB
0.
<+=( .:
<$=.+0100+0  1
5:- 
     
2
0.00 1 0 ..:$5;52
<= .0+ + 01.00. ;
<8= .. .G5001 2
<3= ..   5001 2d
<!=10. 1+ 0+e
00G.+  .
<C=<=<=(+ 01..  G1  .
<C=
<=(0 )    e
00.
<=$01.+0   ...y
0   +0
<+=( 0. .  +7.7
 +00 7  ..   0 
<=<=) 0 .1 0e
 .
<=!.17  .  7%  +
0  0 .10171 7rE
0  .
<9=#  . .<:=<B= + /1 f
+0+01:
<=01D .1110 . ;

<=+D .1110 .r
 7:
<=01 +D   2
<=<$=01 +D 0  2
<=01+.. e e
.12
<=01+ .0 +e
01+7 0 .;C5:57cn
5;- 
     
2
  .12
<+=+ 0...(;C78A7F
C7  $0701+.  
.1
..5676 8%%# 799) 0
5676 8%%# 799:(  0$ % %" ","  $  6-
'$   % %".
<=$    .:
<=<=>$.1>0 7. + .<=<=<=7s0 t
0 .:$5;5
<=>$.1> .!.7'.e
( 7'.$7'.$1 a7*1 0f
!.7% 7B.17?7 .:!55,@
1.
<=<=>!01>0 01.1.
<=>!01> .
<$)+ .$ n7  ..:$5;5?7
 .@2
<=+  .+0 (i9,
*#0& .$.2r
<8=+    . .+e
0 .
<.=>&1>0  0 0 .:!552.
?<.=@<)>F10.>0 :
<).+G01?0.g@0.d
.0. ?7.n@2
<= 5/ ?7/ ,@2
<=. ..  010?,@d
0 0. .?7 ...+ +i 
 0t@
?<=@<)>F10.00 1 0>0  1 0 .n
5C- 
     
2
 .?<)@<).
<=(+    7...(: 787*
$0 +#0/$.70/ 0 10.e
00 1 0
<=(10.00 1 0 .:
<= ..110.l. d
0 1 01D 0...1D 0  ;
<=010. 2
<.=E0 010.  .t ;
<= + +./   0.d
+01D 0.2
<=E1+01D 0..
<=&. + 7,177..1 
<=10..  0.0a0 1 02
d
<= B.+  .  17B 01D e.
<= B. .<A=7.   +.017 1
 .  01D  2d
<=. 7. 7.01D :
<$=.00 01D 0. .101Ds
+.....10.00 1 t02d
<=0 ... .  ea
.10.00 1 0.
<A=<="  .<=<=<=7101. o
10.. ...0.e00 1 0
  1+   ..
<=$1.  10..s:
<= +.+ 1D ..;
d
<=  B.  .+  0  . 0e
 .1 . .<=<=<=
59- 
     
2
?<A=@<:)&...(: 787*$0 +#0/g
$.7+  0/ G.   +.01.+
.  1.   +.01D  .  
 .  01D 0.
..5676 0
5676.   # 66 ;  "  66 !'  % #'  #e
 "  66 #, %   # # " .
<=!. + .<=<=7  0p0
. +.+   .  . :
<= .$$. +700 % 7r
. . ;
<= .$. .+ .00  .+s
0.:;552
<.= .$8. 01 . 
<=. .+;
<=F.% F.18'.2
<='.$2d
<+='.( 2
<= .$3. 01 
<=. .1.00  2
<=.17 + 1707.00  7
1..1 E+;
<= .$!. .01!.te
!.   00. +.+  t .2
<= .$ . 01 '.$1 e
. +.1. :;5A5;:;5A52
<= .$. 
<=.    2
<=01 *. 3:
<$=.  .  1+ 2r
<=.  1.A!5C5;
55 
     
2
<= .$". 01 % ;
<= .$'. 01 B.1;
<B= .$F. B B.12
</= .$H. 
<=00  . .. 1+d
+ . ;
<=.00  .;5A52
<=..  +...12d
<+=. 7.1701  +   te
  .;
<= .$#. 01   ++  1:
<=0.12
<=01..1 .2
<=1. +.7 01t.1h
....2
<0= .$. 101:
<= 0 E1 . +.02
<= .1  B. .2r
<= .1 10/ 0.7
.0 7   01 2
<= .$(. 01 3+ (.1+. ,
  .+I    1.3+ (.1
+. ....+ 2
<= .$*.  0 01   2
<=01 30J/.+. 7   .$J
<=0101 1Ek
1E0.  .1.t2
<=0  1/ +70 7 .
 7+11..130J/ce
+. /10.0 130J/.e
+. ....+ 2
55 
     
2
<E= B. .<:=7 .$K. 01   :
<=E + 0.+0
01 2
<= 00. +.1 . cd
  .<=2?]
?<=01   017  700t7g
07+7 .. 0   e1
+ 10 +]
<= B. .<;=7 .$6. 017. F'(-
.01 01  B. .<=<=7 a
   1 . .  .<)s
00. +.2d
< =01  017  70507i50,
+ 7 .. 0   1+i y
.
<=(.+ +. .   .   :
<=<=.$  ..     .<=.
<=#0+01+  .$7   e
1 7  . t
<=. .0+. +. .7.  
<=  .0+ ..  1
.2
<=  + +55B0o
E  17+...(t;78
7- F.
<=<=(.7.  ...+.
0 . ++7 . i 
 .   ..
<=$.1  0/E  +0.fe
. .  0 1 .
<.=*  .D .  + 1+7.e 
55 
     
2
.1D E 7.D .  
<=<=$.101+ E  . t
  .  .$ 
<=(+  +E  .<=<=<=r+e
E 1. .  1.0E00 s.
.. 
<=<=80 01 %    1
.  +. ....:55;
<=80 01 B.1   1 .
0 ....;C$55;.
<.=80 . 7.1701  +  
  .    +(A787
 +.7F 7# 7#   7(A787& i 
!..
<=*   +17.0  .$
01    1 ?7 +1,
d@
<). .?@2
<=  +1.2d
<=+000 1 101D   .
<A=$01    .$8 .r
 +.  ,77 . +.  0y:
<=0  01 ,72
<= ..+. +.0  ...
01+ .
<:=<=$01  .$K ,177
 00. +.  .
<=$01,177 . +.0101
 .   . .$K ,177? l
0@0s01D . +.  01D 
010 0   01+1.+ . +.
55 
     
2
0  ,17
<.=<=B. .<:=<.=<=701 00c +.e
  
<$=,17701 101 .
 .012d
<=,177 . .101s
01  . ? .d@ .$K .
<=$01 . .<:=<.=<=
<$= 101,172d
<= 00. +.  ,177  01
. 010 . 
<=(+    0.01 . .<:=(=
0..+ +1.+ .5 +.0t
  .
<=$.17 .:$5;5701.17.
. + 7.1+.00  .$X
01   707 0  0010
<;=<=
$01 .$6 ,17 
00. +..
<=$017$    .<;=7>01>0 
01:
<=,177 . +.01 . 7
,177  . .$6 
70 01D .
 +.  01D 010 0 i  e
01+1. 74.77.+   mm
. +.
<.=B. .<;=<=701 00. +.
01:
<=<$=}2
<=<$=,177 101 . 2d
<=
}1,177.01
2}.
55 
     
2
(
=,177 . .01 01s
 . }=$01r .$6 n,17 
00. +..
(
}.=<i=$01 . .<;=(
.=<=:
<= 101,172
<==<=0 01D . +.  
01D 010 0   01+1. 7e
4.77.+  t 00. +.
,17
7.
<=$01 . .<;=<=<= ..  1.0p e
10 01D . +.  7a.0n
1701D 010 0 
  01
. 010 . .
<}+1. 74.77.+   0m
. +..
<=(+    0. 01
 . .n
<;=<=}0..+ 01+1.+o
   00. +.
.A.5676 0
5676. 0" 66 '  %" 66 < =! ".
<=?<=@&01 001D   .  a
 10007.1 .01?in@+e
000 1f y?@r 
?<=$.101 01D  1:]
?<=000 12r]
?<=000 1 ]
<=$.1 B  101  1 
+1% 0/.01B 0. i  .n
:$5;5;<A=<=<=
<= .12
<=.   01% 
5A5 
     
2
<=3+ 5+   .  . 1 0t 
. ..   1 :
<=01 .  . 0
012d
<=00+   .<=
.:.56767 0
56767.  $ '"  66 '&'$ %  " 66 ;"  66 !  %
.
<=<=(  .7 01+   .71.h
..01 ..10 .<=.
<=&0 .<=701 . . sd
 +.
<=(01 00  .
<=00 %  +01 2
<=00 B.1B.01 ;
<.=.00 .+.01    .$8
 + .:$5;5<=<.=2
<=01 !.;
<=. 7.1701    .2
<=01    .1 0p0s
 .<=;
<=01 '.$1 ;
<=0   1+ 2
<= .$01  + .:$5;5<=<0=;
<B=01. 7+ . 701  s
 .$3 + .:$5;5<=<=2
</=01 0..1   .$#s
+ .:$5;5<=<=;
<=. 7. 7.    .e$ 
+ .:$5;5<=<=;
<0=0101  . .:$5;5<=<=2
5:5 
     
2
<= 0    .$* + .
:$5;5<=<=011   2
<=00  . .. 01  s
 .$H + .:$5;5<=</=
<=<=(. 707+  .  .
.01 0 .<=+E1rE
/.
<=8  .     01 0d
     07  0BE0  0 a17 B.t
.:$5;5701E1.  0.  .
<.=(. .. .01e.  d
 +..   .  ..
<=<=(+  ...  + +e
.  .0  1..    s
  0101 .
<=(. 0  + . 
.  . .       .1G 
<=<=J+.+.+7. l
+1 . .   +.
<=(.  .1.+7 0,
.01  1 0/ r0+ e
.010 0/.
<.=(. +.1
<=.1 .   . 1 
<$=0E 10+ .   s e
.  .2
<=.0.+101 .  .
<=(.    0 1 .
<=(   1 .+1 pe
+.. F:7 +.F+  7(:;7897
 +.F. 7 .
5;5 
     
2
<=(. 0/ 7...(: 787*
$0 +#0/$.7+:
<=.1+ 1B 0 ?+ 1 @7.n
0 + 1B 02d
<= .B 0 01 1 7.. +i
B 00/.01B 0
<A=<=''..17.  0
.0 .+.+. e.+
.
<=( . .<A=<=01..00 7.i:
<= 1.  1.01 7.e. r
0. ;
<= 1.    .0    E.1
..;
<= .B 0 7.. +B 00/t
.01B 02
<+=. 01 .
<.=<=<$=B. .<A=<.=<=<=<8=7. l.e
   1 +1 .   ..0 i +
.010 .0 .
<=( 1 +1.0.7 .A557
...7 .A557 .7 .i
A5:57 000. . +   t
017 .+17.0  .
<8=( 1 +10 +  .(;78,
F730).&  7 000.)a3 t
& .87)# +7"8*$0 .
<=(.01..1 +1.. 1
.+01 .
<=(. 0 . . +y
03+ J/.&0F10+.  .01
5C5 
     
2
070  01101701..0B
 7.1.7 1+.
<+=(+  .E.. .0.
+  .A$55
<=(.01.1+0 .id
 .<A=<=7.0 +7.07tl
0/ 
<=(. 
<=  .  E.1...1 0/
.00  .  .<A=2d
<=.00  ..0 .E 
 0.    + .
<=<=*E  B. .<A=<=<=7+  0a/
+0 1+ . 
 . .<A=<=7.
<$=0.0/02
<=001+2
<8= 102
<3=0.02
<!=..
<=(+ 01+ .<A=<=<=0a
 1 .0 ..r1
<=(+ 
<=.  1 .B 0 .00 .<A=<=n
.+ .000 e
B 0 2
<= 0.0 .00 % 2d
<= .00 . .. +
0  . 
<=& +1%  c7
B 0 /.,1.0   i.
595 
     
2
<:=<=(. 0/ 7...(: 787*h
$0 +#0/$.7.+ 7.w . t
 +. 7 .00. 10170/5 o
.01 
<=$.1010/5    + ly
+1+ .
<.=&... .<:=<=7.1E + D +l
0/5   0E .07 B. .n
<:=<=7+ 
<=&.0E .<:=<.=7E .1 
1+ 
<=10/5 +.17.
<$=1+ 2r
<=.0+ 2
<=0  ...E / m/2

<=1+.1Ga
0/5 .
<;=<=(. 1+.0 0 
01 .   +.
<=(+  001 .0 
1+.01  00:
<= 1..151. 2
<=0 .1.G  +1.
.;%%# .
<=!. + .<=7 / .417
<=(00 . :$5;5::$5;5/.,17.
55