Utah 2023 2023 Regular Session

Utah House Bill HB0469 Comm Sub / Analysis

Filed 02/23/2023 

                         
    .
 t     
     !"   #      $! " $!  " %  o
&'' (      !  " '' )* & ''$ !( 
%+ $! "    !' &'' (    !''$ ," !"
!' "" "!  !  &$ '"  %   ,- &d "!
-   !  (
 "#  $ "r    
./  ))S
  !"#$#%&'#()$
*&*#)+,*&H
% "    $ "
 -----------_
 
*)0 
0"'  "
*       .
,', 1# " :
* 
<. /0 1% 2 3/0 4  
'2    0;
<   5
<2 1'1&2. 
+4m;
<6 0  2066 72
2.6 206m ;
<   683/0 4  '2 ;
<20    2 5
9-      
<   /0 4  '2     7 eo
7082 5d
<68 222 
"$  "   ''
*  + 2:  :
</6$% 2 91'1&2. 
+4m7 
C6"+7;77
* ' '!  
* 0  220
2  "  %%
&<#$/:
345597  63' ,  7=>?
34557 23' ,   7= 
34535447 23' ,   7=5
34534567 23' ,?7= >8
34534577  63' , >7=2
3453457  63' , 7=
7856517  63' ,  7= !7!?6
7856527  63' ,  7= !7!?6
78565417  63' ,  7= !7!?6
78565427  63' ,  7= !7!!!?6
78565437  63' ,  7= !7!?6
78565447  63' ,  7= !7!?6
7856517  63' ,  7= !7!?6
78565717  63' ,  7= !7!?6
78565727  63' ,  7= !7!?6
49553(27  63' ,   7= >7@7>7  7 !,
  7? 63== 7' ,   7
=>4
#$&=*:
9 -      
3453587,=&>!
{ 34534577,=&>!
} 7856537,=&>!
785653(57,=&>!
 
 
2234559 6
3455( ! " " % '"    #',  55 ! " " % %i  %
, ".
AB&    2:
ABC'2 60 C6 03i72 7d
2  232 6  30 
ABC'0 28C6  6 6 2n
?99.
A B&2730 763   D 2 
60 :
AB27 :
AB 202:
A&B0 15
AB8E6 20 280 28in
203 ;
A=B02?995r
A/B02?99>@203 ;
AB 32672  3o
2    2A BABAB7 e325r
AB 2266   2A BABA)7 
 0 62    2 5
AB26  266 a37
83728  37 2?9 9!.
A!BAB*1 68    a
2 2 6
9!-      
AB32 60   5d
AB   .
AB*1     s2
A!BAB2   2 AB7A>B7AB.
AB#2 0 2 A>BAB7263  a
 D 2 60 22 2A B6o
2:
AB 03 :
AB3202;
AB32    372 
32 3265r
AB2   37 2w2s
   0 65
AB03 
AB2  &6 62025
AB32    2  &6 m7
2 32 3265r
AB2   2  &6 67e
 22    0 65
A2B3 :
AB2  6 62025
AB32    2  6 mr
 32223265r
AB2   2  6 67e
 22    0 65
AB3
AB2  =6 62025
AB32    2  =6 m7
 32223265r
AB2   2  =6 67e
 22   220 6.
9-      
A>B*263      2A)
  :
AB2660    02  3e
2 70 715r
AB008367 2 !9!9 .
ABAB&263  722 2A B7 D 2 e
60 22 632r2 26l
 7 2?99
AB(2   6 26  a7e
    32 60  63s 722
 2A B7632 203
A2B(2   722 2A B72 6
0 300 3  32727
1    7    63
2 203
A?BAB&2730 763   D i0f
372 72  232t2 :
AB26  3783728l  37s
2?9 9!70
A&B 5
AB1;
A=B6 22 5r
A/B6 22 265
AB 72
A&B 202 26  a e
  D 3 3  3620 Fy
22 5
AB 32  26e  a
   D 3 3  y620s
F322 7 32222
3265
9>-      
A=B 2 26  r e
  D 3 3  3620 Fy
22 7 2    222a
0 6
AB&22  0  6 7 
2>9 !9!7   32726 e
22   02>9 !9>
A@BAB*2 .  26
E202 0  2
AB*2630 630  2 
0 
ABAB*2 63  726 27 D 0ty
72 72  232 76722f
 .
AB*2  6330 3    
266 
A2B*0 7202   62 7 l
 6372 72 i 23a
2 76722 3 2e
2
AB*2 2 326663 22u
22        
ABAB& 63372 7    762i 
 233672 722  2
    2.
AB&32     0 2 ed
0
A2B& 0  2ABAB 32  6 6a
AB     27  
AB02320  85d
AB03
9-      
A BAB& 632D 2 1e

AB*1 02D  22 s
326 6.
A2B*163
AB825
AB0262 5r
AB63   
A!B*0     7 77
230 2  * !7= >71GC62.
AB1!3 320D 0 
   70  /0 4  'c 

AB3605
AB6   .
HA)IA>B*16368 66  2222e
*!"7=!7,&6 0%68&2
2 23455 6
3455.  %' !"",(
AB&    2:
ABC/0 C6 /0 1% 2 .
ABC49262C6   E2
26   626:
AB5
AB  F666 7  .26
26  02 27 2 6726  7 28.
A BHABI&0H 6    2 I{
}63 e9262:
A) 2 2 31;
AB2;
A2B  5
9?-      
AB837836.
HAB*1 376222*!"7=e!7
,&6 0%68&27 2 2 63
 9262.]
A!B*0  0H0fI0e
32  9262 72g
32  ,0 D  $% 2 ,
&27#06(6=663$06  t6
2666
2!23453544 6
3453544. " " " ", '  ' &, , "' .
AB&    2:
ABC=6 CC26 C6 302  ; >s
770777  2 
26266 
ABC%CCC6 60r3
 02  02 a
2  02 
A B#2 0 2 A!BAB7 6326 e
 26266 2an
222866 
A!B& 6326 H I2 7s
2>@9?9 7 28662

AB H I2  r
H*>@7=?7" ) % &2tI*>@7=?,
" ) '2 &2t;
AB   2e
 02  02 7 2>@9?9 5
A2B      2  6 .8g66;
AB    6
9@-      
228665d
AB  626 
026266 2.
AB&H I2  6326 e
 26266 2a
AB 32
 02  02    28662;
AB2     2  6 .8 665
A2B2  6 3    t
8 6 2  665
AB26  60o
26266 22   e2
8662
A>B&0
AB  22  82 !9 9!5d
AB 2AB2  222 >@99>7>@99> ,
>@9?9>
22345358 2
345358( .''% " " . :! " ;/!"<1,m.
AB&    27"mC6 1'1r
&2. +4m2 2A B.
A B* 2 20m8 e
C1'1&2.  +"
A!B*2   
AB633' ;
AB2 7 7 7  7.  7 22
30  22325
A2B060    33
0  1% 2 &222 !9 95d
AB  .
ABAB*   .
9-      
AB*   2 2ABAB  i
.
A>B*}46C20  l 63}2.
   206:
AB22 5
AB02377 5d
A2B2 07272.
(}3B*0  3$% 2 7&27
#06J3& 266g
AB663;
AB6632062 2635d
A2B63 30 .
}0 636
2>23453456 6
345345(  "   55 !"  55 # &$ !"'  " &.
AB*1       2
20662 0 2A ).
A BAB&  20660s
2866032  6)cr
!.
AB&20660   28r
6032 63 2   
AB6)2!5
AB6$06
A2B(222 2 !99@A!B7    2s
 2A B 37   3.
HA BIA!)  636    
HA!BIA)& 0303 72066 2i
2030 322 1
223453457 6
3453456( 1  55 , " '"   $ & "'! 55 1 ", f
99      
&!" .
AB*0  02066F r
 66206672
A B& >K2066F 
 6602066e 
 26 2  2
22 
A!BAB=066 F 66
 2  0
AB& ?>K2 220e
66F 66 o
3 0F .
ABAB*163  66666 t63
  272 0 2ABAB.
AB&2066   286i s
03! 2 20286 
HABIA>)AB*0 63  20666 f
2783766 
AB.325
AB632066.
AB*163 233   la
206662
HA>BIA)AB=066 F2,
8376 2  0224263
22066
AB2 263 30  22  
25
AB22 2  3  3a35
AB22 2  320278376
66E20 
AB(32 22066
99      
AB  2 62 se
.6 25
AB1 2 66 ts
60222 0s
2066
HABIA?)#2  2 :
AB23  3 3  2i6
 2312  2s2
 !9 9ABAB5d
AB023  2F6.
2?2345345 6
345345. 1    " %   " '"   &$ !" 55  " .
AB& 6320660
     
AB02066F6tr
6 F35d
AB2  32  7 7 6 
A B&2066F6
AB 3 2F6it
  26 1 to
3025d
AB2  6      .2 !9 9
A!B&206663  60 a
2066663 2 26 72
2066 7666726
2263220666i.
2@2;3453457   "  :
3453457. ", # ''% "," !" (
=>   # "  ''  "    ,   '," "," c 
&" # ''% "," !"   &  .
=3> =>   # "  '' "'!   ,   & " !& e" => "
9 9      
   "," '" % # ''% "," !" (
=&>     "," '" % # ''% "," !"  s
 !&?   #' %  .''% (
=4>    ,   & " !& " =>  '' #  $ % &e",
# ''% "," !"   ", ''% !'"  "  n" 
  " ",#'$   ,'  %  # ''% "," !"t.
" (  " 78565   "  :
}785651 6
1 6( 2))0 02 ) *2/ ))0 T
1 ( 0"' 1# " 
78565( '(
* 2 8 C" ) H% nI'2 g
&2"
292 785652 6
785653( %"" (
( 2>@99 7   2
ABCC6 " ) '2 2n
2>@9?9 >
A )C=6 C6 326202  ; ,
77077 n
2   02 76 73.
HA BIA!)CC6 27 72 72272778.
HA!BIA)CC6 0
AB 0  02 2 26 5
AB 26 3
HABIA>)C 02 C6 77   0n
.
HA>BIA)C)C6 0 0 
 02 26 02a 
HABIA?)ABC) 02 C6 072 
AB 7.67  7625
9!9      
AB28727 0  02 5
AB 02 
ABC) 02 C 220 83/0 
1% 2  63 7  2 70 722 7 r
3* !71% 2 =,.
HA?BIA@)ABC42 C6 3 3, 7 7
2 0 3 b2  
203.
ABC42 C 2 3, 7 7
2 0 3 22e0
66 2 !9 !9?A>B  
 02  320666 2s
 223F3/0 1% 2sD 
66
HA@BIA)C1C6 27766   2tn
 !9!9 AB.
22 785653 2
785654(!"", ,! " !% !' (
27677 636s
272632>@99*!"7=!7,
&6 0%68&270  2 /0 1i
% 2 
2 2 785653(5 2
1 3( !"", 0!  " *!%  " ", d
785653(7((
AB* 2" ) '2 2  f
066   
AB  2  222is
25
AB661722 !99 7 23
15d
99      
A2B 31
A B#266  2317 ae
 02222>@99 
A!B*66  231632 
3 2
ABAB*  2222 >@99  
>@99 !.
AB*  D 66 6tg
  :
AB   0 026 22r
  22  5
AB0 0 0 D 0  26  2e
 2ABABAB.
A>B&66 7 2ABAB7026r
0 0 D 0 63 .62d
 0   2E2022c
26
2! 2 7856541 6
1 4( " "g
785654( " ! :!.
ABL37H  I  !72 02 >@99!?d
>@9?9!7HI}2  .d0 02 
H70 . 0 0   
2rI
A B*0    0. H0  fI 
2H nI2 e2  2
AB5
AB.
A!B*0  6220 H dI2 
0  
2!2 7856542 6
9>9      
7856543( @!'%"  %  '" .
ABH* rI&22  H0I 
AB 626 230 5
AB36362!L99>5Hd]
A2B     83 ;
AB 22  326 22.6  a 3e
30 25
AB60 . 30 5
HA2BIA)6 230 7 60s
2033 20 02  s  3n
 2263  2F 2    6
630 6222*!"7=!7,
&6 0%68&2
A BH* rI&22  H0lI 
AB 626 230 5
AB36362!L99>5Hd]
A2B     83 5
AB 22  326 22.6  a 3e
30 25
AB60 . 30 5
HA2BIA)6 230 7 60s
2033 20 02  i   3
 2263  2F 2    6
630 6222*!"7=!7,
&6 0%68&2
2>2 7856543 6
7856544(  % '"  55 A" 55 "'.
ABA)*0    2H nI2 e 2
22293232  3.
AB*0 633 2323 62 3
 2320 6  
99      
A B#2H nI2 e623  
H       a66 2 e
 2 I2   2  2 222h
2>@99!@.
2>2 7856544 6
785654( A"  % '" (
*6 6H nI2 e 26:
AB  2 2>@99!?5
A B63 :
A)63    
23 23.22a
2  HI5
AB63D  D  2  2
2?2 785651 6
1 ( " ", "' "  '"e
78565( 0!"  % "' % '" ! 55  '"$ ", (
A)"    H nI2 e27r
 H  tI2 2 e708,
  7 272H  I2 
2 7  206H I2 7  a
2    2 222H0s 2e
2 rI2>@99.
A BAB*0     2 2 s
 082 2 6/0 1e
% 2    2D 2 D 0*l !71
% 2 =,.
AB(/0 1% 2    0* !,
1% 2 =,7220232n
22 0  02  02 7r6
2202D 0   70s  
  2 2   08c e
9?9      
2 .
A2B(/0 1% 2    0* !,
1% 2 =,72 222 0 
 02  02 762e D 0
   70     2 2  
 082 2 .
2@?2 7856571 6
1 7( 2"'%!' " 2"%  "' "!t
785657( 2"'%!' "!.
C,22C2 72>@99>7 g
CCCC3 2e
0 2 7  
0H 23 dI 22 e 
 2.
2@2 7856572 6
7856573( 2"%  "' "!.
C,  22C2 72>@99>,
 6330 :
AB2032H DsI2 D 27 20
273D  3 872F 8   c
20303  8 ;
A B  72076 0 0 0i2  
;
A!B6   02 726 72 7.67 2
 2025d
AB00 202226!
3 32 H D I2 D 226 0e
0 H nI2 eH I2 e g
.
22 49553(2 6
49553(3(   % ""' ", "   , (
9@9      
& 66  :
AB*' ' D 266 
A B*#272 2 7i6 ,
6 E 2#27222h
2>!+99!
A!B*4299&462299
AB*'%3<2& =2'= 04622n
99!
A>B*,'8&3229>9 
AB/22 22,<=66   0
 2?99 A BABAB
A?B*/0 1% 2  2  r
42<6&27 02 !9 9
A@B*1'1&2. 4622 !9 9@
HA@BIA)*#623<202 "462 9@9 ?
HABIAB*632622 99 .
HA)IAB2 22 22 6<20 
 2 9@9!A?B
HA)IA B*,=182+2&   2462
2 99 
HA )IA!B*%43 2'%364622n
 99!.
HA!)IAB*))0 )244622 9>>9?
HA)IA>B*,<2#2=2:
AB6 ,<2#24622
 99!5
AB0 62 23  22 99?5
A2B0  2 322  2e2n
 99@
HA>)IAB+ /6&22002  n
222 2! 9 9!A@BABAB
99      
HA)IA?B*"&   266 3/6
18202 7 02!>&9!9.
HA?)IA@B*,$"72*!7<&6 .
HA@)IAB**=66  299 
AB2  2  2 5
AB6 26602 .6 .
HA)IA B*2% 2+2&   2467 0
2>!9 9 .
HA )IA B*<232%#2467 02>!9!9>
HA )IA  B*,#226 7s
02>!99
HA  )IA !B(0 2>!"99@72 0n
 2>!"99@AB.
HA !)IA B*/0 02 4/  7 0n
2 &9>9 
HA )IA >B*/0 +)  d
 8 2!&99
HA >)IA B*, 623=66  7 02!=99.
HA )IA ?B*/0 *2302 230 0d
2!&99!.
HA ?)IA @B*)2&6 0%  7 02n
!"9!9 
HA @)IA B*=%0&3,72*!<7=,
=%0&3,&2.
HA )IA!B*"0D )2#262)3# 
M&27 0*!$7= 74 7# M&2.
HA!)IA!B*"0D )2#262)3D %#636
# 467  2*!$7=747%#636t
# 46
HA!)IA! B46 L%0%2&  22n
>&9 9@
9 9      
HA! )IA!!B*/0 6% 2<6 67s
02!&9?9.
HA!!)IA!B&2 3 D 6232662  e02e
7 029 9!
HA!)IA!>B**2$ &64622? 99 
HA!>)IA!B*636$0E1% $n
&22/0 1% 722?!9 97  f
2 6 026 .
HA!)IA!?B*L2=226  2 2 7 0
2??99.
HA!?)IA!@B& 063667 02n
?@&99 
HA!@)IA!B*,"2037 02?9!9
HA!)IAB*0*4622?9>9>!
HA)IAB&2622   02 ?@997?@997
?@99>
HA)IA B(  0*?@7=  747,(
/ =66  .
HA )IA!B*6  3/0 +2 = 2
<62!&9>9?!2 2 20n
3 36  2223 3/0 
+2 = 2<6.
HA!)IAB**=66  6 2 y
 2222>9 9@ .
2  "(
* 6 63 23L37
  !7L!7  *  6 0 3
 23  ,6 2 *!L7=7342es
&27'   6 636 a22s
2  06 ,.
(*#<
9 9      
*/6$% 2 991'1&2. +4m
+6"+d	770
246 :
1'1&2. +d}4m 770
2  %%# .
AB#2 0 2n}A B7 8 2<3!7  !.
A B*2 2 2 82& 7  
AB2 !9 !9;
AB2 !9 !9?;
A2B2 !9 !905}. 
{ AB2 !9 !9> 
}
9  9