Utah House Bill HB0469 Comm Sub / Analysis

                    
     
1

    
 t     .
    ! "# ! $  !!! %" # %" !# &  o
'((!)  ! ! " !# (( *+  ' ((% ") 
 &, %" #    "( '((!)   ! "((% -# "#
"( ## #"! "! '% (#! &   -. 'd #"
.   "!!)
/!#$ !% # 0#  ) #((     e
:
12   ** S
!!"#$#%&'#()$
*&*#)+,*&H
& #!  !% #
   

------------./
 
+*3   
3#( !#
*       0 0.

-(- 4$!#!:
*  
<1 /2 3% . 4/2 5  
'.    2 ;
<   6
<   7. 6
<8 2   .8 6
<. 3'3&.1 586
<8 2  .288 ;
9- 
     
1
<   874/2 5  '. ;
{ <.2    . 6
} <   /2 5  '.     0 eo
027 
. }   6
<2 .s6d
<87 ... 
#%  # ! ((
*  
+ .:} .4r!! 
</8$% . 93'3&.1 
580 :
C8"+0;00
+ ( ("!!
* 2  ..2
5  #! &&
&<#$/:
67780  84' ,!!0=>7
67790  84' ,!!0=?>
67790  84' ,!>0=@7
67766):0  84' ,!>0=@7
67760  84' ,!>0=@7
67760  84' ,!>0=@7
67790  84' ,!>0=@7
6770 .4' ,!!!0=!
/67670676720  
.} 84' , 
!!!!?0=r

?2
676730  84' ,!?0=2
676760 .4' ,>0=!?8
676770  84' ,!?0=2
67670  84' ,!0=
{ :879710  84' ,!!0= 0>6
:879720  84' ,!!0= 0>6
9!- 
     
1
:879710  84' ,!!0= 0>6
:879720  84' ,!!0= 0>6
:879730  84' ,!!0= 0>6
:879740  84' ,!!0= 0>6
} :879710  84' ,!!0= 0>6
{ :8797:10  84' ,!!0= 0>6
:8797:20  84' ,!!0= 0>6
} ;776)20  84' ,!!!0= ?0@0?0!!0!,
!!0> 84== 0' ,!!!0
=?4
#$&=*:
676780,=&?
:879730,=&?
{ :87976):, 5  ## :05#& ( &&:
#$&=*,$=)/(+(#/<&*#%(&'
 

 
..6778 8 
6778. 5! &  "   $  (% "# ((& '
77  ( !.
AB& 84 .82.84.8g
 .88.
A!B& 2  .AB 4.  &8 8.
ABAB&    .AB0C.8C8 2. 
844   [ .eE..8 020
. 82..
AB&.8  . 8s
8 2   7..
A.B&.884 7.
F4/.8.
AB&.8 .J4
9- 
     
1
/.80. 4:
AB2 8 .;
AB88.4. 88.4G 
 ;
AB4.. ..H.2 :
A&B928I;
AB. 6r
A=B 6
A2B8.2. .7c
 . 2 .76
A2B8.4.8  .
[A)EA)(...*"0=0,&8 2%87g
&.03[ lE8y87  .8 
[A.B*2  2$% . 0&.t0
#28(8=88 8....t 
 .AB.]
.
}2. 6779 8 
677) "!#!# & (#!   $(-! 77 "!#!# & &i! &
-!#.
AB&    .:
ABC'. 82 C8 24i0. 0d
.  .4. 8  42 
ABC'2 .7C8  8 8 .n
>99.
A!B&.042 084   G . 
82 :
AB.0 :
AB .2.:
A&B2 36
AB7H8 .2 .72 .7in
.24 ;
9- 
     
1
A=B2.>996r
A/B2.>99?@.24 ;
AB 4.80.  4o
.    .A!BABAB0 e4.6r
AB ..88   .A!BABA)0 
 2 8.    . 6
AB.8  .88 a40
740.7  40 .>9!9.
ABAB*3 87    a
. . 8 
AB4. 82   6d
AB   .
AB*3     s.
ABAB.   . AB0A?B0AB.
AB#. 2 . A?BAB0.84  a
 G . 82 .. .A!B8o
.:
AB 24 :
AB4.2.;
AB4.    40. 
4. 4.86r
AB.   40 .w.s
   2 86
AB24  
AB.  &8 8.2.6
AB4.    .  &8 m0
. 4. 4.86r
AB.   .  &8 80e
 ..    2 86
A.B4 :
AB.  8 8.2.6
9?- 
     
1
AB4.    .  8 mr
 4...4.86r
AB.   .  8 80e
 ..    2 86
AB4 
AB.  =8 8.2.6
AB4.    .  =8 m0
 4...4.86r
AB.   .  =8 80e
 ..   ..2 8.
A?B*.84      .A)
  :
AB.882    2.  4e
. 02 036r
AB227480 .!99!.
ABAB&.84  0.. .A!B0 G . e
82 .. 84.r. .8l
 0 .>99
AB(.   8 .8  a0e
    4. 82  84s 0..
 .A!B084. .24
A.B(.   0.. .A!B0. 8
2 422 4  4.0.0
3    0    84
. .24
A>BAB&.042 084   G i2f
40. 0.  .4.t. :
AB.8  40740.7l  40s
.>9!902 
A&B 6
AB3;
9- 
     
1
A=B8 .. 6r
A/B8 .. .86
AB 0. 
A&B .2. .8  a e
  G 4 4  48.2 Iy
.. 6
AB 4.  .8e  a
   G 4 4  y8.2s
I4.. 0 4....
4.86
A=B . .8  r e
  G 4 4  48.2 Iy
.. 0 .    ...a
2 8
AB&..  2  8 0 
.?9!90   4.0.8 e
..   2.?9!9?
A@BAB*. 1  .8
H.2. 2  .
AB*.842 842  . 
2 
ABAB*. 84  0.8 .0 G 2ty
0. 0.  .4. 080..f
 .
AB*.  8442 4    
.88 
A.B*2 0.2.   8. 0 l
 840. 0. i .4a
. 080.. 4 .e
.
AB*. . 4.8884 ..u
9>- 
     
1
..        
ABAB& 8440. 0    08.i 
 .4480. 0..  .
    ..
AB&4.     2 . ed
2
A.B& 2  .ABAB 4.  8 8a
AB     .0   
AB2.4.2  76d
AB24
A!BAB& 84.G . 3e

AB*3 2.G  .. s
4.8 8.
A.B*384 
AB7.6
AB2.8. 6r
AB84   
AB*2     0 00
.42 .  *!0=!?03JC8..
AB34 4.2G 2  
   02  /2 5  'c 
 
AB4826
AB8   .
DA)EA?B*38487 88  ....e
*"0=0,&8 2%87&.
..6779 8 
6779. !# &!#- # "##- (#! 77 5! & &.
AB& 04  4308a40 
243G  0.8. :
9@- 
     
1
AB 6
AB 886

A.BD]
A.B.F4n
/.86
DA.BEA)480[.,]0748
A!B,;.8. 84 .n
84:
AB . ;
AB   .I 286
A.B8. . 6r
AB8..8.
ABAB,?. .8. 84 8
8:
AB.19  6r
AB. 8 . .
AB*.8. 2 8my
 .ABAB 4.8. 284 
88 24. !99!99>
..67766): 8 
67766):. /"-  '0 "##- )
AB& !4 04[.r]8
  43    2.8a. ,
84487 [.r] 24 
.8 3
A!B& 4 844[.r]8
.  18  .AB G !4 
.4.8   
AB).[.r]8..8  e
 .8
.?.6776 8 
9- 
     
1
6776. !# "##- (#! 77 5! & &.
AB& 04  4308a4
. 
A!B&. I . 0.. 3e
G  .8  
AB7 886

ABD]
AB.F4n
/.86
DABEA.)480[.,]0748
AB,;. 84 .8
ABAB,?. . 84 8
8:
AB.19  6r
AB. 8 . .
AB*. 2 884
 .ABAB 4. 284 
88 24. !99!99>
..6776 8 
6776. *#!# "##- (#! 77 5! & &)
AB& 04  43084
. 
A!B&. I . 0.. 3e
G  .8  
AB7 886

ABD]
AB.F4n
/.86
DABEA.)480[.,]0748
ABAB,?. . 84 8
8:
99 
     
1
AB.19  6r
AB. 8 . .
AB*. 2 884
 .ABAB 4. 284 
88 24. !99!99>
.>.6779 8 
6779. 4# & $#" & (#!, , !, & &
-!#, # 1((& 
- & &! ! # 1((& 
' "#.
AB+4. .4.   8  ae
 3&....!99 
AB94 . 6
AB94  8.
A!B* 4. .4.  
8   3&...c!99 
AB . 0.494 . ;
AB. ;
A.B.8. ;
AB. 6
AB 80.4  8.
AB+  2492. .4
..  08 03..   
3&....!99:
AB.. .80...
   8. ;
AB88;
A.B8;
[AB.8;]
[A)EA)7486
[A)EA)8 786
[A)EA)3..
.
!}8. 677 8 
99 
     
1
677.  &( "##-)
AB&    .:
ABC/2 C8 /2 3% . .
ABC59.8.C8   H.
.8   8.8:
AB6
AB  I888!0  1.8
.8  2. .0 . 80.8  0 .7.
A!BDABE&2D 8    . ]
84 e9.8.:
A) . . 43;
AB.;
A.B  6
AB740748.
DAB*3 408...*"0=e0
,&8 2%87&.0 . . 84
 9.8..]
AB*2  2D2fE2e
4.  9.8. 0.g
4.  ,2 G  $% . ,
&.0#28(8=884$28!!t8
.888
.
}9. {6767}67678 
8:
6767. # # #!#- (  ( '- - #(!.
AB&    .:
ABC=8 CC.8 C8 42.  ;!?s
002000  . 
.8.88 
ABC%CCC8 82r4
 2.  2. a
.  2. 
9!9 
     
1
A!B#. 2 . ABAB0 84.8 e
 .8.88 .an
...788 
AB& 84.8 D E. 0s
.?@9>9!0 .788.
 
AB D E.  r
D*?@0=>0" ) % &.E*?@0=>0
" ) '. &.t;
AB   .e
 2.  2. 0 .?@9>9!6
A.B      .  8 17g88;
AB    8
..7886d
AB  8.8 
2.8.88 ..
AB&D E.  84.8 e
 .8.88 .a 
AB 4.
 2.  2.    .788.;
AB.     .  8 17 886
A.B.  8 4    t
7 8 .  886
AB.8  82o
.8.88 ..   e.
788.
A?B&2 
AB  ..  7.!9!96d
AB .AB.  ... ?@99?0?@99?!,
?@9>9?
..67678 . 
99 
     
1
}. 
67678) 1((& # # 1 <"!# 4-.
AB&    .0C8C8 3'3&.1 i
58. .A!B
A!B* .87 C3'3&.1 i
58C.2 
 }84 .1   
.28:
AB.. 6
AB2.400 6d
A.B. 20.0..
AB(87.   .1   0e
2  :
AB. 2 .4 .88;
ABI  .1  22 
AB H.442 6
AB2 ..  .;
A.B288  8.  th
.!9!9!6
AB.I 88.  8m
 . .ABA.B.
(
}4B*2  4$% . 0&.0
#28K4& .882 

s848
.. 67672 8 
67676) &##!)
&   . 
ABC=288CCC8 4.is
 8800 [.,]7408.s
 ... . 3.
A!BABC=288C8  4a
0  .0  .8cs
99 
     
1
 ..!9!9.
AB+   .0.2888y
 
AB42  ;
AB842 6
AB.2.8 82  . .2e
886r
A2B. ..84 ..14s
..*?0=05.).=  .s.
ABC=288IC8 .0l0.7,
4.8I     88
.288.
ABC=2888C8 8tI
    [.,]7y[,]8.288.
A?BC/2 C8 /2 3% . .
ABC'  .C8 I 
2  .288
A>BABC'  .C8   4wr
  ..288
AB+   .0  .84 
AB42 6r
AB842 
.. 67673 8 
6767) "(=#- "% & 1((& .
*3 I87. ..2
88 I 8800[.,]
7408 H8.  48 c2  
 .
.
?}!. 67676 8 
6767) !# ! 77 "#! 77 $ '% "#(! # '.
AB*3       .
9?9 
     
1
.288. 2 .A!).
A!BAB&  .2882s
.78824.  8)cr
.
AB&.2882   .7r
824. 84 .    
AB8).6
AB8$28
A.B(... .!99@AB0    .s
 .A!B 40   4.
DA!BEA)  848    
DABEA)& 2424 0.288 .i
.242 4.. 3
.
}. 67677 8 
67679) 4! 77 - # (#!  % ' #(" 77 4!#- f
'"#!.
AB*2  2.288I r
 88.2880.
A!B& ?L.288I 
 882.288e 
 .8 .  .
.. 
ABAB=288 I 88
 .  2
AB& >?L. ..2e
88I 88 o
4 2I .
ABAB*384  88888 t84
  .0. 2 .ABAB.
AB&.288   .78i s
24!. .2.78 
99 
     
1
DABEA?)AB*2 84  .2888 f
[.,]7y[,]88 :
AB14.6
AB84.288.
AB*384 .44   la
.2888.
DA?BEA)AB=288 I[.,]
74[,]8 .  2..5.84e
..288 
AB. .84 42  ..  
.6
AB.. .  4  4a46
AB.. .  4.2 [.,]7y[,]8
88H.2 
AB(4. ..288 
AB  . 8. se
18 .6
AB3 . 88 ts
82... 2s
.288
DABEA>)#.  . :
AB.4  4 4  .i8
 .43.  .s.
!9!9ABAB6d
AB2.4  .I8.
.
>}. 6767 8 
6767. 4!!!!# & ! # (#!! '% "# 77 !#!.
AB& 84.2882
      
AB2.288I8tr
8 I46d
9>9 
     
1
AB.  4.  0 0 8 
A!B&.288I8 
AB 4 .I8it
  .8 3 to
42.6d
AB.  8      1.!9!9
AB&.28884  82 a
.288884 . .8 0.
.288 08880.8
..84..2888i.
.
@}?. {:87971}:87973 
8:

4  9) 
5* *3 35 * +5 2   **3 T
4 ) 3#( 4$!#!
:8797)  ()
* . 7 C" ) D% E'.e g
&."
..:87972 8 
:87976) &##!)
( .?@99!0   . 
ABCC8 " ) '. .n
.?@9>9!?
A!)C=8 C8 4.8.2.  ; ,
00200 n
.   2. 08 04.
DA!BEA)CC8 .0 0. 0..0.007.
DABEA)CC8 2 
AB 2  2. . .8 6
AB .8 4
DABEA?)C 2. C8 00   2n
.
DA?BEA)C)C8 2 2 
9@9 
     
1
 2. .8 2.a 
DABEA>)ABC) 2. C8 20.  
AB 0180  08.6
AB.70.0 2  2. 6
AB 2. 
ABC) 2. C ..2 74/2 
3% .  84 0  . 02 0.. 0 r
4*!03% . =,.
DA>BEA@)ABC5. C8 4 4, 0 0
. 2 4 b.  
.24.
ABC5. C . 4, 0 0
. 2 4 ..e2
88 .!9!9>A?B  
 2.  4.2888 .s
 ..4I4/2 3% .sG 
88
DA@BEA)C3C8 .0088   .tn
!99!AB.
.. :87973 . 
}. 
:8797)
"##- -" # "& "(!)
.0800 848s
.0.84.?@99*"0=0,
&8 2%87&.02  . /2 3i
% . 
{ .. :87976)5 . 
4 6) 
"##- 3"! # +"&! #!#- d
:87976):))
AB* ." ) '. .  f
288    
99 
     
1
AB  .  ...is
.6
AB8830..!99!0 .4
36d
A.B 43
A!B#.88  .430 ae
 2....?@99!
AB*88  .4384. 
4 .
ABAB*  .... ?@99!!
?@99!.
AB*  G 88 8tg
  :
AB   2 2.8 ..r
  ..  6
AB2 2 2 G 2  .8  .e
 .ABABAB.
A?B&88 0 .ABAB02.8r
2 2 G 2 84 18.d
 2   .H.2..c
.8
.!. :87971 8 
4 ) #!#g
:8797) #!" <".
ABF40D!!E!!0. 2. ?@99>d
?@9>90DE.  1d2 2. 
D02 1 2 2   
.E.
A!B*2    21 D2  Es
.D E. .  . 
AB6
9!9 
     
1
AB.
AB*2  8..2 D E.s
2  
.. :87972 8 
:87976) >"(&#! &  (#!.
ABD* E&.. e D2E  
AB 8.8 .42 6
AB4848.F99?6DE
A.B     74 ;
AB ..  4.8 ..18  a 4e
42 .6
AB82 1 42 6
DA.BEA)8 .42 0 82s
.244 .2 2.  s  4n
 ..84  .I .    8
842 8...*"0=0,
&8 2%87&.
A!BD* E&.. e D2E :
AB 8.8 .42 6
AB4848.F99?6DE
A.B     74 6
AB ..  4.8 ..18  a 4e
42 .6
AB82 1 42 6
DA.BEA)8 .42 0 82s
.244 .2 2.  i   4
 ..84  .I .    8
842 8...*"0=0,
&8 2%87&.
.. :87973 8 
:8797)   & (#! 77 ?# 77 #(.
9!9 
     
1
ABA)*2    .D E.  .
...94.4.  4.
AB*2 844 .4.4 8. 4
 .4.2 8  
A!B#.D E. 8.4  
D       a88 . e
 . E.   .  . .c.
.?@99@.
.?. :87974 8 
:8797) ?#! & (#!)
*8 8D E.  .8:
AB  . .?@99>6
A!B84 :
A)84    
.4 .41..a
.  DE6
AB84G  G  .  .
} .. :87971 8 
{4 ) #!#- #( # !(#e
} :8797) 3"#! & #( & /(#!"}-!# 77 !(#%
#-!)
{ }A)"    
D} 
E. }.,
 
D}  
E. . }027,
  0 .0. 
D}  
E. a
. }0  .28 
D} 
E. e}0r
  .    . ...
D}2  
.. 
E}.?@99
A!BAB*2     
. } .
   27
. } 
.  g
8/2 3% .    .G 

. G  G 2 *!03% . =f
9!!9 
     
1
,.
AB(/2 3% .    2 r
*!03% . =,0..2.t4r
..
.  2  2. 
 2. 08..2.G 2  
  02     
. } . l
  27
. } 
.  .
A.B(/2 3% .    2 r
*!03% . =,0
.  ..t
 
.  2  2.  2. 08

. G  G 2    02  l
   
. } .   27e

. . .
.>. :8797:1 8 
4 :) 5#(&"( # 5#&!!#( #"t
:8797:) 5#(&"( #".
C,..C. 0.?@99?0 g
CCCC4 .e
2 . 0  
2D .4 E ..  fr
 ..
.@. :8797:2 8 
:8797:6) 5#&!!#( #".
C,  ..C. 0.?@99?,
 8442 :
AB.24.D G E. Gs.0 .2
.04G  4 70.I 7   c
.2424  7 ;
A!B  0.208 2 2 2i.  
;
AB8   2. 0.8 0. 0180 .
9!9 
     
1
 .2.6d
AB22 .2...8
4 4. D G E. G ..8t 2
2 D E. D E.  
.
.}  .
.>. ;776)2 8 
;776)6) ! & ##(!#- #!  -!)
& 88  :
AB*' ' G .88 
A!B*#.0. . 0i8 ,
8 H .#.0...h
.?+99
AB*5.99&58..99
AB*'%4<.& =.'= 258..n

99}99.
A?B*,'7&4..9?9!
AB/.. ..,<=88   2
 .>99!A!BABAB
A>B*/2 3% .  .  r
5.<8&.0 2.!9!9
A@B*3'3&.1 58..!9!9@
DA@BEA)*#8.4<.2. "58.!9@9!>
DABEAB*84.8..!99!.
DA)EAB. .. .. 8<.2 
 .!9@9A>B
DA)EA!B*,=37.+.&   .58.
.!99!
DA!)EAB*%54 .'%4858..n
!99.
DA)EAB*))2 ).558..!9??9>
9!9 
     
1
DA)EA?B*,<.#.=.:
AB8 ,<.#.58..
!996
AB2 8. .4  ..!99>6
A.B2  . 4..  .e.n
!99@
DA?)EAB+ /8&..22.  n
... .!9!9A@BABAB
DA)EA>B*"&   .88 4/8
37.2. 0 2.?&99.
DA>)EA@B*,$"0.*0<&8 .
DA@)EAB**=88  .99! 
AB.  .  . 6
AB8 .882. 18 .
DA)EA!B*.% .+.&   .580 2
.?9!9!.
DA!)EA!B*<.4.%#.580 2.?99?
DA!)EA!!B*,#..8 0s
2.?99
DA!!)EA!B(2 .?"99@0. 2n
 .?"99@AB.
DA!)EA!B*/2 2. 5/  0 2n
.!&9?9!
DA!)EA!?B*/2 +)  d
 7 .&99
DA!?)EA!B*, 8.4=88  0 2.=99.
DA!)EA!>B*/2 *.42. .42 2d
.&99.
DA!>)EA!@B*).&8 2%  0 2.n
"99!
DA!@)EA!B*=%2&4,0.*<0=,
9!?9 
     
1
=%2&4,&..
DA!)EAB*"2G ).#.8.)4# 
M&.0 2*$0=!05!0# M&..
DA)EAB*"2G ).#.8.)4G %#848
# 580  .*$0=050%#848t
# 58
DA)EA!B58 F%2%.&  ..n
?&9!9@
DA!)EAB*/2 8% .<8 80s
2.&9>9.
DA)EAB&. 4 G 8.4.88.  e2.e
0 2.9!9
DA)EA?B**.$ &858..>!99!
DA?)EAB*848$2H3% $n
&../2 3% 0..>9!90  f
. 8 2.8 .
DA)EA>B*F.=..8  . . 0 2
.>>99.
DA>)EA@B& 284880 2.n
>@&99!
DA@)EAB*,".240 2.>99
DA)EAB*2*58..>9?9?
DA)EAB&.8..   2. >@990>@990
>@99?
DA)EA!B(  2*>@0=!!050,(
/ =88  .
DA!)EAB*8  4/2 +. = .
<8.&9?9>. . .2n
4 48  ...4 4/2 
+. = .<8.
DA)EAB**=88  8 . y
9!9 
     
1
 ....?9!9@!.
.@ $!# & 1((& !"! &!)
*'  /8$% . 0/2 3
% .  I. 8   
AB 2  .4
40;6
A!B .;.
.
! #)
* 8 84 .4F40
!!0F0!!*  8 2 4
 .4!!,8 . *F0=045.es
&.0'   8 848 a..s
.  28 ,.
(*#<
*/8$% . 993'3&.1 5m
+8"+d	000
.58 :
3'3&.1 5m 000
*'  3'3t
&.1 580. 0 e4
  3'3&.1 58
.
!! &&$ .
AB#. 2 .n A!B0 7 .<40!!.
A!B*. . . 7.& 0!! 
AB.!9!9;
AB.!9!9>6d
A.B.!9!9 
9!>9