Utah 2024 Regular Session

Utah House Bill HB0460

Introduced
2/5/24  
Refer
2/14/24  
Report Pass
2/23/24  
Engrossed
2/26/24  
Enrolled
3/11/24  

Caption

Government Employee Conscience Protection Amendments

Impact

The legislation is expected to modify existing state laws governing employee rights and workplace accommodations significantly. By creating a legislative framework for employees to bring forth their religious or conscientious objections, the bill encourages a more inclusive work environment within government entities. It also creates a cause of action for employees who face retaliation after filing such requests, providing legal recourse for those who encounter negative repercussions for acting on their beliefs. Over time, this could lead to changes in how public agencies manage employee requests related to conscience-based objections.

Summary

House Bill 0460, titled the Government Employee Conscience Protection Amendments, is aimed at providing specific protections and rights for government employees who decline to perform tasks based on sincerely held religious beliefs or personal conscience. The bill stipulates that when an employee requests to be relieved from a specific task due to these beliefs, the governmental entity must accommodate this request as long as it does not impose an undue hardship on the entity. This adds an important layer of protection for employees who may feel their jobs conflict with their personal values.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 0460 appears to be mixed, with supporters championing it as a vital step toward protecting individual rights and freedoms in the workplace. Opponents, however, have raised concerns about potential abuses of the law and the implications it might have for public service roles, especially amongst those in positions critical to public safety. Critics worry that the bill could allow individuals to refuse duties in essential areas, potentially harming public trust and safety.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the balance between an employee's religious freedoms and the operational needs of governmental entities. Some legislators and advocacy groups oppose the bill, fearing it might lead to a situation where government employees could decline to perform essential functions based solely on their beliefs, effectively undermining the responsibilities they are hired to fulfill. The debate hinges on whether the protections are necessary or if they invite unnecessary complications in civil service operations.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

UT SB0228

Property Amendments

UT HB0097

Government Records Access Amendments

UT HB0303

Elections Record Amendments

UT HB0501

Legal Services Amendments

UT SB0110

Background Check Modifications

UT SB0231

Government Records Access and Management Act Amendments

UT HB0537

Voting Amendments

UT SB0262

Government Records Amendments

UT SB0070

Victim Amendments

UT HB0491

Amendments Related to the Great Salt Lake

Similar Bills

TX SB132

Relating to prohibited retaliation against state or local public employees for reporting certain violations of law.

TX HB550

Relating to prohibited retaliation against state or local public employees for reporting certain violations of law.

UT HB0060

Vaccine Passport Amendments

MI HB4475

Civil rights: employment discrimination; discrimination based on certain vaccination status; prohibit. Amends title of 1976 PA 453 (MCL 37.2101 - 37.2804) & adds art. 5A.

UT HB0411

Local Governmental Entity Drug-free Workplace Policies Amendments

TX HB1001

Relating to prohibited retaliation against state or local public employees for reporting certain violations of law.

UT HB0131

Vaccine Passport Prohibition

IN HB1001

Administrative authority; COVID-19 immunizations.