Virginia House Bill HB1584

Virginia 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/6/23
• Refer: 1/6/23

Caption

Biological evidence; storage, preservation, and retention of evidence in felony cases.

Impact

If enacted, HB 1584 will significantly influence the practices surrounding evidence management within Virginia’s criminal justice system. By mandating the retention of biological evidence for a longer period than previously established, the bill aims to provide greater opportunities for exoneration in cases where DNA testing could provide new insights. Furthermore, the bill establishes responsibilities for governmental entities, including a requirement to transfer evidence to the Department of Forensic Science for proper custody, thereby centralizing forensic evidence management in Virginia.

Summary

House Bill 1584 seeks to amend the Code of Virginia regarding the storage, preservation, and retention of biological evidence in felony cases. This bill ensures that biological evidence, defined to include items like blood, saliva, and other bodily fluids, is stored and preserved for up to 15 years following the incarceration of the convicted individual or until the expiration of the statute of limitations for unsolved felonies. The legislation aims to enhance the integrity of evidence preservation, allowing for potential re-examination through DNA testing in the future.

Contention

During discussions surrounding HB 1584, several points of contention emerged. Proponents argued that longer retention periods for biological evidence are crucial for justice, especially in light of wrongful convictions that have been overturned through DNA evidence. Critics, however, raised concerns about the financial implications for law enforcement agencies and forensic laboratories in managing and storing evidence for extended periods. They questioned whether the proposed measures would necessitate additional funding for facilities and resources necessary to comply with the new requirements, thereby increasing the burden on state resources.