Virginia Senate Bill SB990

Virginia 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/6/23
• Refer: 1/6/23

Caption

Ministers of religion; communications between persons they counsel or advise.

Impact

The bill will directly amend sections of the Code of Virginia, specifically §§8.01-400 and 19.2-271.3, enhancing legal protections around religious communications. By doing so, it not only fortifies the rights of individuals seeking spiritual guidance but also reinforces the role of ministers as trusted confidants. This change is expected to have implications in various legal contexts, particularly in how religious communications are treated during legal proceedings, potentially reducing the instances where ministers are required to testify against the confidentiality principle.

Summary

SB990 aims to strengthen the confidentiality of communications between ministers of religion and individuals seeking their counsel. This bill modifies existing state laws to ensure that no minister, priest, rabbi, or accredited practitioner under specified conditions shall be compelled to disclose any confidential communication made during the course of spiritual counseling. The amendments provided in the bill apply across both civil and criminal proceedings, offering protections for those who seek religious counsel and ensuring the sanctity of those communications is preserved.

Contention

Although supporters of SB990 argue that it is essential for maintaining the integrity of spiritual counsel, there may be significant contention regarding the balance between spiritual confidentiality and legal accountability. Some lawmakers and advocates may express concerns about potential abuses of this confidentiality, particularly in cases where criminal actions or legal disputes arise from disclosures made in religious settings. The discussions surrounding the bill are likely to include arguments about the responsibilities of spiritual leaders versus the rights of individuals affected by the outcomes of such communications.