85 | | - | Page 3 HB488 |
---|
86 | | - | 1 Public Service Commission, revenue agents, and persons who are |
---|
87 | | - | 2 required by law to comply with the provisions of the Peace |
---|
88 | | - | 3 Officers' Minimum Standards, employees of the Board of |
---|
89 | | - | 4 Corrections, highway camp guards, law enforcement officers of |
---|
90 | | - | 5 the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, all law |
---|
91 | | - | 6 enforcement officers of the Alabama Forestry Commission, |
---|
92 | | - | 7 livestock theft investigators of the Department of Agriculture |
---|
93 | | - | 8 and Industries, Capitol security guards, narcotic agents and |
---|
94 | | - | 9 inspectors of the State Board of Health, any other state, |
---|
95 | | - | 10 county, or municipal officer engaged in quelling a riot, or |
---|
96 | | - | 11 civil disturbance, and university police officers. |
---|
97 | | - | 12 "(7)(10) RESCUE SQUAD MEMBER. A member of an |
---|
98 | | - | 13 organized rescue squad of a city, town, county, or other |
---|
99 | | - | 14 subdivision of the state or of a public corporation, organized |
---|
100 | | - | 15 for the purpose of providing, within the scope of his or her |
---|
101 | | - | 16 practice: First aid, treatment, or transport of the sick or |
---|
102 | | - | 17 injured; rescue or recovery operations at incidents of |
---|
103 | | - | 18 drowning; search and rescue of individuals lost or incapable |
---|
104 | | - | 19 of self rescue; or any other emergency or non-emergency |
---|
105 | | - | 20 incident where the services provided by the rescue squad are |
---|
106 | | - | 21 deemed necessary for incident stabilization. The term includes |
---|
107 | | - | 22 all commanders, officers, and members of organized rescue |
---|
108 | | - | 23 squads that are members of the Alabama Association of Rescue |
---|
109 | | - | 24 Squads. |
---|
110 | | - | Page 4 HB488 |
---|
111 | | - | 1 "(b) For the purposes of this chapter, the following |
---|
112 | | - | 2 described individuals shall be conclusively presumed to be |
---|
113 | | - | 3 wholly dependent: |
---|
114 | | - | 4 "(1) Spouse, unless it be shown that the spouse was |
---|
115 | | - | 5 voluntarily living apart from the peace officer, firefighter, |
---|
116 | | - | 6 or rescue squad member first responder at the time of death, |
---|
117 | | - | 7 or unless it be shown that the peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
118 | | - | 8 rescue squad member first responder was not in any way |
---|
119 | | - | 9 contributing to the spouse's support and had not in any way |
---|
120 | | - | 10 contributed to the spouse's support for more than 12 months |
---|
121 | | - | 11 next preceding the occurrence of the injury causing death. |
---|
122 | | - | 12 "(2) Minor children under the age of 18 19 years and |
---|
123 | | - | 13 those over 18 19 years or more if physically and mentally |
---|
124 | | - | 14 incapacitated from earning. |
---|
125 | | - | 15 "(3) Spouse, child, mother, father, grandmother, |
---|
126 | | - | 16 grandfather, sister, brother, mother-in-law, and father-in-law |
---|
127 | | - | 17 who were wholly supported by a deceased peace officer, |
---|
128 | | - | 18 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder at the |
---|
129 | | - | 19 time of his or her death and for a reasonable period of time |
---|
130 | | - | 20 prior thereto shall be considered his or her dependents and |
---|
131 | | - | 21 payment of compensation may be made to them as hereinafter |
---|
132 | | - | 22 authorized. |
---|
133 | | - | 23 "(c) If a paid or volunteer firefighter, peace |
---|
134 | | - | 24 officer, certified police officer, reserve law enforcement |
---|
135 | | - | 25 officer, or rescue squad member is killed while engaged in the |
---|
136 | | - | Page 5 HB488 |
---|
137 | | - | 1 performance of his or her duties first responder dies in a |
---|
138 | | - | 2 manner described in Section 36-30-2 and there are no |
---|
139 | | - | 3 designated beneficiaries, then the compensation shall be paid |
---|
140 | | - | 4 to his or her dependents or partial dependents in the manner |
---|
141 | | - | 5 prescribed by Section 36-30-3, and if there are none, the |
---|
142 | | - | 6 compensation shall be paid to his or her non-dependent |
---|
143 | | - | 7 children, and if there are none, the compensation shall be |
---|
144 | | - | 8 paid to his or her parents, and if there are none, the |
---|
145 | | - | 9 compensation shall be paid to the estate of the deceased. |
---|
146 | | - | 10 "(d) Any member of the class named in subdivision |
---|
147 | | - | 11 (b)(3) who regularly derived part of his or her support from |
---|
148 | | - | 12 the earnings of the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
149 | | - | 13 rescue squad member first responder, as the case may be, at |
---|
150 | | - | 14 the time of his or her death and for a reasonable time |
---|
151 | | - | 15 immediately prior thereto shall be considered his or her |
---|
152 | | - | 16 partial dependent and payment of compensation may be made to |
---|
153 | | - | 17 the partial dependent as hereinafter authorized. |
---|
154 | | - | 18 "§36-30-2. |
---|
155 | | - | 19 "(a)(1)a. In the event a peace officer, a |
---|
156 | | - | 20 firefighter, a volunteer firefighter who is a member of an |
---|
157 | | - | 21 organized volunteer fire department registered with the |
---|
158 | | - | 22 Alabama Forestry Commission, or a rescue squad member first |
---|
159 | | - | 23 responder is killed, either accidentally or deliberately,; or |
---|
160 | | - | 24 dies as a result of injuries received while engaged in the |
---|
161 | | - | 25 performance of his or her duties,; or dies as a direct and |
---|
162 | | - | Page 6 HB488 |
---|
163 | | - | 1 proximate result of a heart attack or stroke,; or within 14 |
---|
164 | | - | 2 calendar days after being required to report to his or her |
---|
165 | | - | 3 usual place of employment, he or she contracts COVID-19 |
---|
166 | | - | 4 between March 13, 2020, and December 31, 2022, as confirmed by |
---|
167 | | - | 5 a positive test or diagnosis by a licensed medical |
---|
168 | | - | 6 professional, and dies as a result of COVID-19 or |
---|
169 | | - | 7 complications therefrom, his or her beneficiaries or |
---|
170 | | - | 8 dependents shall be entitled to compensation in the amount of |
---|
171 | | - | 9 one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) to be paid from the |
---|
172 | | - | 10 State Treasury as provided in Section 36-30-3, unless such. |
---|
173 | | - | 11 "b. This subsection does not apply if the first |
---|
174 | | - | 12 responder's death was caused by the willful misconduct of the |
---|
175 | | - | 13 officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder |
---|
176 | | - | 14 or was due to his or her own intoxication or his or her |
---|
177 | | - | 15 willful failure or refusal to use safety appliances provided |
---|
178 | | - | 16 by his or her employer or his or her willful refusal or |
---|
179 | | - | 17 neglect to perform a statutory duty or any other willful |
---|
180 | | - | 18 violation of a law or his or her willful breach of a |
---|
181 | | - | 19 reasonable rule or regulation governing the performance of his |
---|
182 | | - | 20 or her duties or his or her employment of which rule or |
---|
183 | | - | 21 regulation he or she had knowledge. Notwithstanding the |
---|
184 | | - | 22 foregoing, for purposes of deaths caused by COVID-19, the |
---|
185 | | - | 23 dependents or beneficiaries of the deceased first responder |
---|
186 | | - | 24 shall be entitled to the compensation described in paragraph |
---|
187 | | - | 25 (a)(1)a. regardless of the first responder's vaccination |
---|
188 | | - | Page 7 HB488 |
---|
189 | | - | 1 status against COVID-19, and regardless of whether the first |
---|
190 | | - | 2 responder regularly wore masks or other filtration devices in |
---|
191 | | - | 3 the performance of his or her duties. |
---|
192 | | - | 4 "(2) Any peace officer, firefighter, volunteer |
---|
193 | | - | 5 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder whose |
---|
194 | | - | 6 death results proximately from an injury received while |
---|
195 | | - | 7 performing his or her duties, for the purposes of this |
---|
196 | | - | 8 article, shall be deemed to have been killed while in the |
---|
197 | | - | 9 performance of such duties. A volunteer firefighter or a |
---|
198 | | - | 10 member of an organized rescue squad who dies of cardiac |
---|
199 | | - | 11 arrest, cerebrovascular accident, or pulmonary edema within 24 |
---|
200 | | - | 12 hours after preparing to respond to a called emergency or |
---|
201 | | - | 13 responding to an emergency; or after serving in his or her |
---|
202 | | - | 14 capacity at an emergency; or after participating in a required |
---|
203 | | - | 15 physical training exercise shall be presumed to have died in |
---|
204 | | - | 16 the performance of his or her duties. If the State Health |
---|
205 | | - | 17 Officer determines from all available evidence that a |
---|
206 | | - | 18 volunteer firefighter, who is a member of an organized |
---|
207 | | - | 19 volunteer fire department registered with the Alabama Forestry |
---|
208 | | - | 20 Commission, has become totally disabled as a result of any |
---|
209 | | - | 21 injury received while engaged in the performance of his or her |
---|
210 | | - | 22 fire-fighting duties and the disability is likely to continue |
---|
211 | | - | 23 for more than 12 months from the date the injury is incurred, |
---|
212 | | - | 24 then the firefighter shall be entitled to receive disability |
---|
213 | | - | 25 compensation in the amount of one hundred thousand dollars |
---|
214 | | - | Page 8 HB488 |
---|
215 | | - | 1 ($100,000) to be paid from the State Treasury as provided in |
---|
216 | | - | 2 Section 36-30-3. The term total disability shall be |
---|
217 | | - | 3 interpreted to mean that the injured party is medically |
---|
218 | | - | 4 disabled to the extent that he or she cannot perform the |
---|
219 | | - | 5 duties of the job occupation or profession in which he or she |
---|
220 | | - | 6 was engaging at the time the injury was sustained. The State |
---|
221 | | - | 7 Health Officer may seek the assistance of any state agency in |
---|
222 | | - | 8 making the determination of disability and the state agencies |
---|
223 | | - | 9 shall cooperate with the State Health Officer in such regard. |
---|
224 | | - | 10 The State Health Officer shall render a decision within 30 |
---|
225 | | - | 11 days of the time a claim is filed. If such volunteer |
---|
226 | | - | 12 firefighter disagrees with any officer, he or she may appeal |
---|
227 | | - | 13 the determination to the State Board of Adjustment in |
---|
228 | | - | 14 accordance with such board's procedures for such appeals. |
---|
229 | | - | 15 "(b) Beginning in calendar year 2009, the |
---|
230 | | - | 16 compensation amounts payable under this section shall be |
---|
231 | | - | 17 adjusted on January 1 of each year to reflect any increase |
---|
232 | | - | 18 during the preceding calendar year in the consumer price index |
---|
233 | | - | 19 as published by the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor |
---|
234 | | - | 20 Statistics. The adjustment shall equal the percentage change |
---|
235 | | - | 21 in the consumer price index during the preceding calendar |
---|
236 | | - | 22 year. |
---|
237 | | - | 23 "(c) Any person who currently serves or previously |
---|
238 | | - | 24 served as a firefighter or law enforcement officer who dies as |
---|
239 | | - | 25 a result of a firefighter's occupational disease as defined in |
---|
240 | | - | Page 9 HB488 |
---|
241 | | - | 1 Section 11-43-144 or 36-30-40, or law enforcement officer's |
---|
242 | | - | 2 occupational disease as defined in Section 36-30-20 shall be |
---|
243 | | - | 3 qualified for a state death benefit as provided in subsection |
---|
244 | | - | 4 (a) as if the person died in the performance of his or her |
---|
245 | | - | 5 duties, provided he or she satisfies the three years' service |
---|
246 | | - | 6 requirement and physical examination requirements set forth in |
---|
247 | | - | 7 Section 11-43-144, 36-30-22, or 36-30-41, respectively. |
---|
248 | | - | 8 "(d) Any application for the state death benefit |
---|
249 | | - | 9 that was submitted during the period from April 29, 2010, |
---|
250 | | - | 10 until May 27, 2015, and denied because the firefighter or law |
---|
251 | | - | 11 enforcement officer was no longer employed on the date of |
---|
252 | | - | 12 death may be resubmitted based on subsection (c) within six |
---|
253 | | - | 13 months of May 27, 2015, and reconsidered and granted by the |
---|
254 | | - | 14 awarding authority. |
---|
255 | | - | 15 "(e) The provisions of this section as amended by |
---|
256 | | - | 16 Act 2021-488 shall be retroactive to any death covered by this |
---|
257 | | - | 17 chapter as amended after January 1, 2019. |
---|
258 | | - | 18 "(f) The provisions of this section as amended by |
---|
259 | | - | 19 this act shall be retroactive to any death caused by COVID-19 |
---|
260 | | - | 20 covered by this chapter as amended between March 13, 2020, and |
---|
261 | | - | 21 December 31, 2022. |
---|
262 | | - | 22 "§36-30-3. |
---|
263 | | - | 23 "The compensation payable to surviving beneficiaries |
---|
264 | | - | 24 or dependents of peace officers, firefighters, or rescue squad |
---|
265 | | - | 25 members first responders who are killed under the |
---|
266 | | - | Page 10 HB488 |
---|
267 | | - | 1 circumstances prescribed in Section 36-30-2 shall be paid to |
---|
268 | | - | 2 the beneficiaries designated by those peace officers, |
---|
269 | | - | 3 firefighters, or rescue squad members first responders. If no |
---|
270 | | - | 4 beneficiaries have been designated, or if none remain, the |
---|
271 | | - | 5 compensation shall be paid to the persons entitled thereto |
---|
272 | | - | 6 without administration or to a guardian or such other person |
---|
273 | | - | 7 as the awarding authority may direct for the use of the |
---|
274 | | - | 8 persons entitled thereto, as follows: |
---|
275 | | - | 9 "(1) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
276 | | - | 10 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
277 | | - | 11 and no other dependents or partial dependents, the total |
---|
278 | | - | 12 amount of the compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 |
---|
279 | | - | 13 shall be paid to the surviving spouse. |
---|
280 | | - | 14 "(2) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
281 | | - | 15 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
282 | | - | 16 and a dependent child or dependent children and no other |
---|
283 | | - | 17 dependents or partial dependents, then the total amount of the |
---|
284 | | - | 18 compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 shall be paid to |
---|
285 | | - | 19 such surviving spouse for the benefit of herself or himself |
---|
286 | | - | 20 and such child or children, or, in its discretion, the |
---|
287 | | - | 21 awarding authority may determine what portion of the |
---|
288 | | - | 22 compensation shall be applied for the benefit of such child or |
---|
289 | | - | 23 children and may order the same paid to a guardian and then |
---|
290 | | - | 24 order only the remainder of such compensation paid to the |
---|
291 | | - | 25 surviving spouse. |
---|
292 | | - | Page 11 HB488 |
---|
293 | | - | 1 "(3) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
294 | | - | 2 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent child |
---|
295 | | - | 3 or children and no dependent spouse or other dependents or |
---|
296 | | - | 4 partial dependents, then such child or children shall be |
---|
297 | | - | 5 entitled to the total amount of the compensation authorized in |
---|
298 | | - | 6 Section 36-30-2, and such compensation shall be paid to a duly |
---|
299 | | - | 7 appointed guardian of such child or children or, in the |
---|
300 | | - | 8 discretion of the awarding authority, such sum may be paid to |
---|
301 | | - | 9 the probate judge of probate of the county of residence of the |
---|
302 | | - | 10 child or children. Any probate judge of probate who receives |
---|
303 | | - | 11 any moneys monies due any child or children under this article |
---|
304 | | - | 12 shall handle and administer all such funds in the manner |
---|
305 | | - | 13 prescribed in Sections 26-7-2 through 26-7-5. |
---|
306 | | - | 14 "(4) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
307 | | - | 15 rescue squad member first responder leaves no dependent spouse |
---|
308 | | - | 16 or dependent child or children but leaves other dependents or |
---|
309 | | - | 17 partial dependents, then such dependents and partial |
---|
310 | | - | 18 dependents jointly shall be entitled to the total amount of |
---|
311 | | - | 19 the compensation provided in Section 36-30-2, and subject to |
---|
312 | | - | 20 the limitations prescribed hereinbelow, such compensation |
---|
313 | | - | 21 shall be paid to them in the amounts and manner ordered by the |
---|
314 | | - | 22 awarding authority. |
---|
315 | | - | 23 "(5) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
316 | | - | 24 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
317 | | - | 25 and other dependents or partial dependents but no dependent |
---|
318 | | - | Page 12 HB488 |
---|
319 | | - | 1 child or children, then the surviving spouse and the other |
---|
320 | | - | 2 dependents and partial dependents jointly shall be entitled to |
---|
321 | | - | 3 the total compensation provided in Section 36-30-2; and, |
---|
322 | | - | 4 subject to the limitations prescribed hereinbelow, such the |
---|
323 | | - | 5 compensation shall be paid to such the dependents in the |
---|
324 | | - | 6 proportions and in the manner ordered by the awarding |
---|
325 | | - | 7 authority; provided, however, that at least 50 percent of such |
---|
326 | | - | 8 the compensation must be awarded to the dependent surviving |
---|
327 | | - | 9 spouse. |
---|
328 | | - | 10 "(6) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
329 | | - | 11 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
330 | | - | 12 and a dependent child or children and other dependents and |
---|
331 | | - | 13 partial dependents, then the awarding authority shall |
---|
332 | | - | 14 determine what portion of such the compensation shall be paid |
---|
333 | | - | 15 to the spouse and child or children and, in its discretion, |
---|
334 | | - | 16 may order all such of the compensation be paid to such the |
---|
335 | | - | 17 spouse and child or children, but must provide that at least |
---|
336 | | - | 18 70 percent thereof of the compensation is paid to them. |
---|
337 | | - | 19 "(7) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
338 | | - | 20 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent child |
---|
339 | | - | 21 or children and other dependents and partial dependents but no |
---|
340 | | - | 22 dependent spouse, then the awarding authority shall determine |
---|
341 | | - | 23 what portion of such the compensation such the child or |
---|
342 | | - | 24 children are entitled to receive and, in its discretion, may |
---|
343 | | - | 25 order all such of the compensation awarded to such the child |
---|
344 | | - | Page 13 HB488 |
---|
345 | | - | 1 or children, but must award at least 60 percent thereof of the |
---|
346 | | - | 2 compensation to such the child or children. |
---|
347 | | - | 3 "(8) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
348 | | - | 4 rescue squad member first responder leaves no dependent spouse |
---|
349 | | - | 5 or child or children but leaves other dependents and partial |
---|
350 | | - | 6 dependents, the awarding authority shall determine what |
---|
351 | | - | 7 portion of such the compensation each dependent and each |
---|
352 | | - | 8 partial dependent shall be entitled to receive, but such the |
---|
353 | | - | 9 awarding authority may not award to a partial dependent a |
---|
354 | | - | 10 greater percent of such the compensation than the percent of |
---|
355 | | - | 11 the deceased peace officer's, firefighter's, or rescue squad |
---|
356 | | - | 12 member's first responder's average monthly income which was |
---|
357 | | - | 13 regularly contributed toward such the partial dependent's |
---|
358 | | - | 14 support for a reasonable time immediately prior to the death |
---|
359 | | - | 15 of such officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member the first |
---|
360 | | - | 16 responder. In its discretion, the awarding authority may award |
---|
361 | | - | 17 all of the compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 to |
---|
362 | | - | 18 such the total dependents of the deceased officer, |
---|
363 | | - | 19 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder to the |
---|
364 | | - | 20 exclusion of partial dependents. |
---|
365 | | - | 21 "§36-30-4. |
---|
366 | | - | 22 "Compensation pursuant to this article for the death |
---|
367 | | - | 23 of a peace officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member first |
---|
368 | | - | 24 responder shall be paid only to his or her designated |
---|
369 | | - | 25 beneficiaries or dependents who at the time of such officer's, |
---|
370 | | - | Page 14 HB488 |
---|
371 | | - | 1 firefighter's, or rescue squad member's the first responder's |
---|
372 | | - | 2 death were actually residents of the United States. |
---|
373 | | - | 3 "§36-30-5. |
---|
374 | | - | 4 "(a) All claims for compensation as provided in this |
---|
375 | | - | 5 article shall be presented to the awarding authority within |
---|
376 | | - | 6 two years from the date of the death of the peace officer, |
---|
377 | | - | 7 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder or the |
---|
378 | | - | 8 claims are forfeited. All such claims shall be presented in |
---|
379 | | - | 9 the form prescribed by the awarding authority, and proof of |
---|
380 | | - | 10 the facts and circumstances of the peace officer's, |
---|
381 | | - | 11 firefighter's, or rescue squad member's first responder's |
---|
382 | | - | 12 death and, if necessary, the claimant's relationship to and |
---|
383 | | - | 13 dependence upon such peace officer, firefighter, or rescue |
---|
384 | | - | 14 squad member the first responder shall be made in the manner |
---|
385 | | - | 15 prescribed by the awarding authority. |
---|
386 | | - | 16 "(b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection |
---|
387 | | - | 17 (a), any person who was previously ineligible to claim the |
---|
388 | | - | 18 compensation provided in this article, but is now eligible to |
---|
389 | | - | 19 claim the compensation provided in this article because of the |
---|
390 | | - | 20 enactment of Act 2008-480, and who is making a claim based |
---|
391 | | - | 21 upon the death of a peace officer or firefighter who died on |
---|
392 | | - | 22 or after January 1, 2006, but prior to the enactment of Act |
---|
393 | | - | 23 2008-480, shall be able to present his or her claim for |
---|
394 | | - | 24 compensation to the awarding authority within one year of the |
---|
395 | | - | 25 date of enactment of Act 2008-480 regardless of whether the |
---|
396 | | - | Page 15 HB488 |
---|
397 | | - | 1 claim was presented within one year from the date of the death |
---|
398 | | - | 2 of the peace officer or firefighter. |
---|
399 | | - | 3 "(c) The awarding authority is hereby authorized to |
---|
400 | | - | 4 may prescribe such forms and adopt such rules of evidence and |
---|
401 | | - | 5 procedure as it deems necessary or proper, not inconsistent |
---|
402 | | - | 6 with the provisions of this article, for the proper |
---|
403 | | - | 7 determination of all claims for compensation under this |
---|
404 | | - | 8 article." |
---|
405 | | - | 9 "§36-30-7. |
---|
406 | | - | 10 "(a) This article shall not be construed to give any |
---|
407 | | - | 11 person a right of action against the State of Alabama in any |
---|
408 | | - | 12 court for the recovery of the compensation authorized by this |
---|
409 | | - | 13 article. This article shall not be construed to take away any |
---|
410 | | - | 14 right of action in any court under any other law for the |
---|
411 | | - | 15 recovery of damages for the death of a peace officer, |
---|
412 | | - | 16 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder; nor, in |
---|
413 | | - | 17 the event of the death of a peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
414 | | - | 18 rescue squad member first responder who was an employee of the |
---|
415 | | - | 19 State of Alabama at the time of the injury which proximately |
---|
416 | | - | 20 caused his or her death, shall this article be construed to |
---|
417 | | - | 21 take away the right or privilege of the surviving dependents |
---|
418 | | - | 22 of such peace officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member the |
---|
419 | | - | 23 first responder to file a claim for damages with the State |
---|
420 | | - | 24 Board of Adjustment pursuant to any other law. |
---|
421 | | - | Page 16 HB488 |
---|
422 | | - | 1 "(b) The decision of the awarding authority shall be |
---|
| 87 | + | 26 Public Service Commission, revenue agents, and persons who are |
---|
| 88 | + | 27 required by law to comply with the provisions of the Peace |
---|
| 89 | + | Page 3 1 Officers' Minimum Standards, employees of the Board of |
---|
| 90 | + | 2 Corrections, highway camp guards, law enforcement officers of |
---|
| 91 | + | 3 the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, all law |
---|
| 92 | + | 4 enforcement officers of the Alabama Forestry Commission, |
---|
| 93 | + | 5 livestock theft investigators of the Department of Agriculture |
---|
| 94 | + | 6 and Industries, Capitol security guards, narcotic agents and |
---|
| 95 | + | 7 inspectors of the State Board of Health, any other state, |
---|
| 96 | + | 8 county, or municipal officer engaged in quelling a riot, or |
---|
| 97 | + | 9 civil disturbance, and university police officers. |
---|
| 98 | + | 10 "(7)(10) RESCUE SQUAD MEMBER. A member of an |
---|
| 99 | + | 11 organized rescue squad of a city, town, county, or other |
---|
| 100 | + | 12 subdivision of the state or of a public corporation, organized |
---|
| 101 | + | 13 for the purpose of providing, within the scope of his or her |
---|
| 102 | + | 14 practice: First aid, treatment, or transport of the sick or |
---|
| 103 | + | 15 injured; rescue or recovery operations at incidents of |
---|
| 104 | + | 16 drowning; search and rescue of individuals lost or incapable |
---|
| 105 | + | 17 of self rescue; or any other emergency or non-emergency |
---|
| 106 | + | 18 incident where the services provided by the rescue squad are |
---|
| 107 | + | 19 deemed necessary for incident stabilization. The term includes |
---|
| 108 | + | 20 all commanders, officers, and members of organized rescue |
---|
| 109 | + | 21 squads that are members of the Alabama Association of Rescue |
---|
| 110 | + | 22 Squads. |
---|
| 111 | + | 23 "(b) For the purposes of this chapter, the following |
---|
| 112 | + | 24 described individuals shall be conclusively presumed to be |
---|
| 113 | + | 25 wholly dependent: |
---|
| 114 | + | 26 "(1) Spouse, unless it be shown that the spouse was |
---|
| 115 | + | 27 voluntarily living apart from the peace officer, firefighter, |
---|
| 116 | + | Page 4 1 or rescue squad member first responder at the time of death, |
---|
| 117 | + | 2 or unless it be shown that the peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 118 | + | 3 rescue squad member first responder was not in any way |
---|
| 119 | + | 4 contributing to the spouse's support and had not in any way |
---|
| 120 | + | 5 contributed to the spouse's support for more than 12 months |
---|
| 121 | + | 6 next preceding the occurrence of the injury causing death. |
---|
| 122 | + | 7 "(2) Minor children under the age of 18 19 years and |
---|
| 123 | + | 8 those over 18 19 years or more if physically and mentally |
---|
| 124 | + | 9 incapacitated from earning. |
---|
| 125 | + | 10 "(3) Spouse, child, mother, father, grandmother, |
---|
| 126 | + | 11 grandfather, sister, brother, mother-in-law, and father-in-law |
---|
| 127 | + | 12 who were wholly supported by a deceased peace officer, |
---|
| 128 | + | 13 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder at the |
---|
| 129 | + | 14 time of his or her death and for a reasonable period of time |
---|
| 130 | + | 15 prior thereto shall be considered his or her dependents and |
---|
| 131 | + | 16 payment of compensation may be made to them as hereinafter |
---|
| 132 | + | 17 authorized. |
---|
| 133 | + | 18 "(c) If a paid or volunteer firefighter, peace |
---|
| 134 | + | 19 officer, certified police officer, reserve law enforcement |
---|
| 135 | + | 20 officer, or rescue squad member is killed while engaged in the |
---|
| 136 | + | 21 performance of his or her duties first responder dies in a |
---|
| 137 | + | 22 manner described in Section 36-30-2 and there are no |
---|
| 138 | + | 23 designated beneficiaries, then the compensation shall be paid |
---|
| 139 | + | 24 to his or her dependents or partial dependents in the manner |
---|
| 140 | + | 25 prescribed by Section 36-30-3, and if there are none, the |
---|
| 141 | + | 26 compensation shall be paid to his or her non-dependent |
---|
| 142 | + | 27 children, and if there are none, the compensation shall be |
---|
| 143 | + | Page 5 1 paid to his or her parents, and if there are none, the |
---|
| 144 | + | 2 compensation shall be paid to the estate of the deceased. |
---|
| 145 | + | 3 "(d) Any member of the class named in subdivision |
---|
| 146 | + | 4 (b)(3) who regularly derived part of his or her support from |
---|
| 147 | + | 5 the earnings of the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 148 | + | 6 rescue squad member first responder, as the case may be, at |
---|
| 149 | + | 7 the time of his or her death and for a reasonable time |
---|
| 150 | + | 8 immediately prior thereto shall be considered his or her |
---|
| 151 | + | 9 partial dependent and payment of compensation may be made to |
---|
| 152 | + | 10 the partial dependent as hereinafter authorized. |
---|
| 153 | + | 11 "§36-30-2. |
---|
| 154 | + | 12 "(a)(1)a. In the event a peace officer, a |
---|
| 155 | + | 13 firefighter, a volunteer firefighter who is a member of an |
---|
| 156 | + | 14 organized volunteer fire department registered with the |
---|
| 157 | + | 15 Alabama Forestry Commission, or a rescue squad member first |
---|
| 158 | + | 16 responder is killed, either accidentally or deliberately,; or |
---|
| 159 | + | 17 dies as a result of injuries received while engaged in the |
---|
| 160 | + | 18 performance of his or her duties,; or dies as a direct and |
---|
| 161 | + | 19 proximate result of a heart attack or stroke,; or within 14 |
---|
| 162 | + | 20 calendar days after being required to report to his or her |
---|
| 163 | + | 21 usual place of employment, he or she contracts COVID-19 |
---|
| 164 | + | 22 between March 13, 2020, and December 31, 2022, as confirmed by |
---|
| 165 | + | 23 a positive test or diagnosis by a licensed medical |
---|
| 166 | + | 24 professional, and dies as a result of COVID-19 or |
---|
| 167 | + | 25 complications therefrom, his or her beneficiaries or |
---|
| 168 | + | 26 dependents shall be entitled to compensation in the amount of |
---|
| 169 | + | Page 6 1 one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) to be paid from the |
---|
| 170 | + | 2 State Treasury as provided in Section 36-30-3, unless such. |
---|
| 171 | + | 3 "b. This subsection does not apply if the first |
---|
| 172 | + | 4 responder's death was caused by the willful misconduct of the |
---|
| 173 | + | 5 officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder |
---|
| 174 | + | 6 or was due to his or her own intoxication or his or her |
---|
| 175 | + | 7 willful failure or refusal to use safety appliances provided |
---|
| 176 | + | 8 by his or her employer or his or her willful refusal or |
---|
| 177 | + | 9 neglect to perform a statutory duty or any other willful |
---|
| 178 | + | 10 violation of a law or his or her willful breach of a |
---|
| 179 | + | 11 reasonable rule or regulation governing the performance of his |
---|
| 180 | + | 12 or her duties or his or her employment of which rule or |
---|
| 181 | + | 13 regulation he or she had knowledge. Notwithstanding the |
---|
| 182 | + | 14 foregoing, for purposes of deaths caused by COVID-19, the |
---|
| 183 | + | 15 dependents or beneficiaries of the deceased first responder |
---|
| 184 | + | 16 shall be entitled to the compensation described in paragraph |
---|
| 185 | + | 17 (a)(1)a. regardless of the first responder's vaccination |
---|
| 186 | + | 18 status against COVID-19, and regardless of whether the first |
---|
| 187 | + | 19 responder regularly wore masks or other filtration devices in |
---|
| 188 | + | 20 the performance of his or her duties. |
---|
| 189 | + | 21 "(2) Any peace officer, firefighter, volunteer |
---|
| 190 | + | 22 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder whose |
---|
| 191 | + | 23 death results proximately from an injury received while |
---|
| 192 | + | 24 performing his or her duties, for the purposes of this |
---|
| 193 | + | 25 article, shall be deemed to have been killed while in the |
---|
| 194 | + | 26 performance of such duties. A volunteer firefighter or a |
---|
| 195 | + | 27 member of an organized rescue squad who dies of cardiac |
---|
| 196 | + | Page 7 1 arrest, cerebrovascular accident, or pulmonary edema within 24 |
---|
| 197 | + | 2 hours after preparing to respond to a called emergency or |
---|
| 198 | + | 3 responding to an emergency; or after serving in his or her |
---|
| 199 | + | 4 capacity at an emergency; or after participating in a required |
---|
| 200 | + | 5 physical training exercise shall be presumed to have died in |
---|
| 201 | + | 6 the performance of his or her duties. If the State Health |
---|
| 202 | + | 7 Officer determines from all available evidence that a |
---|
| 203 | + | 8 volunteer firefighter, who is a member of an organized |
---|
| 204 | + | 9 volunteer fire department registered with the Alabama Forestry |
---|
| 205 | + | 10 Commission, has become totally disabled as a result of any |
---|
| 206 | + | 11 injury received while engaged in the performance of his or her |
---|
| 207 | + | 12 fire-fighting duties and the disability is likely to continue |
---|
| 208 | + | 13 for more than 12 months from the date the injury is incurred, |
---|
| 209 | + | 14 then the firefighter shall be entitled to receive disability |
---|
| 210 | + | 15 compensation in the amount of one hundred thousand dollars |
---|
| 211 | + | 16 ($100,000) to be paid from the State Treasury as provided in |
---|
| 212 | + | 17 Section 36-30-3. The term total disability shall be |
---|
| 213 | + | 18 interpreted to mean that the injured party is medically |
---|
| 214 | + | 19 disabled to the extent that he or she cannot perform the |
---|
| 215 | + | 20 duties of the job occupation or profession in which he or she |
---|
| 216 | + | 21 was engaging at the time the injury was sustained. The State |
---|
| 217 | + | 22 Health Officer may seek the assistance of any state agency in |
---|
| 218 | + | 23 making the determination of disability and the state agencies |
---|
| 219 | + | 24 shall cooperate with the State Health Officer in such regard. |
---|
| 220 | + | 25 The State Health Officer shall render a decision within 30 |
---|
| 221 | + | 26 days of the time a claim is filed. If such volunteer |
---|
| 222 | + | 27 firefighter disagrees with any officer, he or she may appeal |
---|
| 223 | + | Page 8 1 the determination to the State Board of Adjustment in |
---|
| 224 | + | 2 accordance with such board's procedures for such appeals. |
---|
| 225 | + | 3 "(b) Beginning in calendar year 2009, the |
---|
| 226 | + | 4 compensation amounts payable under this section shall be |
---|
| 227 | + | 5 adjusted on January 1 of each year to reflect any increase |
---|
| 228 | + | 6 during the preceding calendar year in the consumer price index |
---|
| 229 | + | 7 as published by the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor |
---|
| 230 | + | 8 Statistics. The adjustment shall equal the percentage change |
---|
| 231 | + | 9 in the consumer price index during the preceding calendar |
---|
| 232 | + | 10 year. |
---|
| 233 | + | 11 "(c) Any person who currently serves or previously |
---|
| 234 | + | 12 served as a firefighter or law enforcement officer who dies as |
---|
| 235 | + | 13 a result of a firefighter's occupational disease as defined in |
---|
| 236 | + | 14 Section 11-43-144 or 36-30-40, or law enforcement officer's |
---|
| 237 | + | 15 occupational disease as defined in Section 36-30-20 shall be |
---|
| 238 | + | 16 qualified for a state death benefit as provided in subsection |
---|
| 239 | + | 17 (a) as if the person died in the performance of his or her |
---|
| 240 | + | 18 duties, provided he or she satisfies the three years' service |
---|
| 241 | + | 19 requirement and physical examination requirements set forth in |
---|
| 242 | + | 20 Section 11-43-144, 36-30-22, or 36-30-41, respectively. |
---|
| 243 | + | 21 "(d) Any application for the state death benefit |
---|
| 244 | + | 22 that was submitted during the period from April 29, 2010, |
---|
| 245 | + | 23 until May 27, 2015, and denied because the firefighter or law |
---|
| 246 | + | 24 enforcement officer was no longer employed on the date of |
---|
| 247 | + | 25 death may be resubmitted based on subsection (c) within six |
---|
| 248 | + | 26 months of May 27, 2015, and reconsidered and granted by the |
---|
| 249 | + | 27 awarding authority. |
---|
| 250 | + | Page 9 1 "(e) The provisions of this section as amended by |
---|
| 251 | + | 2 Act 2021-488 shall be retroactive to any death covered by this |
---|
| 252 | + | 3 chapter as amended after January 1, 2019. |
---|
| 253 | + | 4 "(f) The provisions of this section as amended by |
---|
| 254 | + | 5 this act shall be retroactive to any death caused by COVID-19 |
---|
| 255 | + | 6 covered by this chapter as amended between March 13, 2020, and |
---|
| 256 | + | 7 December 31, 2022. |
---|
| 257 | + | 8 "§36-30-3. |
---|
| 258 | + | 9 "The compensation payable to surviving beneficiaries |
---|
| 259 | + | 10 or dependents of peace officers, firefighters, or rescue squad |
---|
| 260 | + | 11 members first responders who are killed under the |
---|
| 261 | + | 12 circumstances prescribed in Section 36-30-2 shall be paid to |
---|
| 262 | + | 13 the beneficiaries designated by those peace officers, |
---|
| 263 | + | 14 firefighters, or rescue squad members first responders. If no |
---|
| 264 | + | 15 beneficiaries have been designated, or if none remain, the |
---|
| 265 | + | 16 compensation shall be paid to the persons entitled thereto |
---|
| 266 | + | 17 without administration or to a guardian or such other person |
---|
| 267 | + | 18 as the awarding authority may direct for the use of the |
---|
| 268 | + | 19 persons entitled thereto, as follows: |
---|
| 269 | + | 20 "(1) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 270 | + | 21 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
| 271 | + | 22 and no other dependents or partial dependents, the total |
---|
| 272 | + | 23 amount of the compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 |
---|
| 273 | + | 24 shall be paid to the surviving spouse. |
---|
| 274 | + | 25 "(2) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 275 | + | 26 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
| 276 | + | 27 and a dependent child or dependent children and no other |
---|
| 277 | + | Page 10 1 dependents or partial dependents, then the total amount of the |
---|
| 278 | + | 2 compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 shall be paid to |
---|
| 279 | + | 3 such surviving spouse for the benefit of herself or himself |
---|
| 280 | + | 4 and such child or children, or, in its discretion, the |
---|
| 281 | + | 5 awarding authority may determine what portion of the |
---|
| 282 | + | 6 compensation shall be applied for the benefit of such child or |
---|
| 283 | + | 7 children and may order the same paid to a guardian and then |
---|
| 284 | + | 8 order only the remainder of such compensation paid to the |
---|
| 285 | + | 9 surviving spouse. |
---|
| 286 | + | 10 "(3) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 287 | + | 11 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent child |
---|
| 288 | + | 12 or children and no dependent spouse or other dependents or |
---|
| 289 | + | 13 partial dependents, then such child or children shall be |
---|
| 290 | + | 14 entitled to the total amount of the compensation authorized in |
---|
| 291 | + | 15 Section 36-30-2, and such compensation shall be paid to a duly |
---|
| 292 | + | 16 appointed guardian of such child or children or, in the |
---|
| 293 | + | 17 discretion of the awarding authority, such sum may be paid to |
---|
| 294 | + | 18 the probate judge of probate of the county of residence of the |
---|
| 295 | + | 19 child or children. Any probate judge of probate who receives |
---|
| 296 | + | 20 any moneys monies due any child or children under this article |
---|
| 297 | + | 21 shall handle and administer all such funds in the manner |
---|
| 298 | + | 22 prescribed in Sections 26-7-2 through 26-7-5. |
---|
| 299 | + | 23 "(4) If the deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 300 | + | 24 rescue squad member first responder leaves no dependent spouse |
---|
| 301 | + | 25 or dependent child or children but leaves other dependents or |
---|
| 302 | + | 26 partial dependents, then such dependents and partial |
---|
| 303 | + | 27 dependents jointly shall be entitled to the total amount of |
---|
| 304 | + | Page 11 1 the compensation provided in Section 36-30-2, and subject to |
---|
| 305 | + | 2 the limitations prescribed hereinbelow, such compensation |
---|
| 306 | + | 3 shall be paid to them in the amounts and manner ordered by the |
---|
| 307 | + | 4 awarding authority. |
---|
| 308 | + | 5 "(5) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 309 | + | 6 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
| 310 | + | 7 and other dependents or partial dependents but no dependent |
---|
| 311 | + | 8 child or children, then the surviving spouse and the other |
---|
| 312 | + | 9 dependents and partial dependents jointly shall be entitled to |
---|
| 313 | + | 10 the total compensation provided in Section 36-30-2; and, |
---|
| 314 | + | 11 subject to the limitations prescribed hereinbelow, such the |
---|
| 315 | + | 12 compensation shall be paid to such the dependents in the |
---|
| 316 | + | 13 proportions and in the manner ordered by the awarding |
---|
| 317 | + | 14 authority; provided, however, that at least 50 percent of such |
---|
| 318 | + | 15 the compensation must be awarded to the dependent surviving |
---|
| 319 | + | 16 spouse. |
---|
| 320 | + | 17 "(6) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 321 | + | 18 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent spouse |
---|
| 322 | + | 19 and a dependent child or children and other dependents and |
---|
| 323 | + | 20 partial dependents, then the awarding authority shall |
---|
| 324 | + | 21 determine what portion of such the compensation shall be paid |
---|
| 325 | + | 22 to the spouse and child or children and, in its discretion, |
---|
| 326 | + | 23 may order all such of the compensation be paid to such the |
---|
| 327 | + | 24 spouse and child or children, but must provide that at least |
---|
| 328 | + | 25 70 percent thereof of the compensation is paid to them. |
---|
| 329 | + | 26 "(7) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 330 | + | 27 rescue squad member first responder leaves a dependent child |
---|
| 331 | + | Page 12 1 or children and other dependents and partial dependents but no |
---|
| 332 | + | 2 dependent spouse, then the awarding authority shall determine |
---|
| 333 | + | 3 what portion of such the compensation such the child or |
---|
| 334 | + | 4 children are entitled to receive and, in its discretion, may |
---|
| 335 | + | 5 order all such of the compensation awarded to such the child |
---|
| 336 | + | 6 or children, but must award at least 60 percent thereof of the |
---|
| 337 | + | 7 compensation to such the child or children. |
---|
| 338 | + | 8 "(8) If a deceased peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 339 | + | 9 rescue squad member first responder leaves no dependent spouse |
---|
| 340 | + | 10 or child or children but leaves other dependents and partial |
---|
| 341 | + | 11 dependents, the awarding authority shall determine what |
---|
| 342 | + | 12 portion of such the compensation each dependent and each |
---|
| 343 | + | 13 partial dependent shall be entitled to receive, but such the |
---|
| 344 | + | 14 awarding authority may not award to a partial dependent a |
---|
| 345 | + | 15 greater percent of such the compensation than the percent of |
---|
| 346 | + | 16 the deceased peace officer's, firefighter's, or rescue squad |
---|
| 347 | + | 17 member's first responder's average monthly income which was |
---|
| 348 | + | 18 regularly contributed toward such the partial dependent's |
---|
| 349 | + | 19 support for a reasonable time immediately prior to the death |
---|
| 350 | + | 20 of such officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member the first |
---|
| 351 | + | 21 responder. In its discretion, the awarding authority may award |
---|
| 352 | + | 22 all of the compensation provided for in Section 36-30-2 to |
---|
| 353 | + | 23 such the total dependents of the deceased officer, |
---|
| 354 | + | 24 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder to the |
---|
| 355 | + | 25 exclusion of partial dependents. |
---|
| 356 | + | 26 "§36-30-4. |
---|
| 357 | + | Page 13 1 "Compensation pursuant to this article for the death |
---|
| 358 | + | 2 of a peace officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member first |
---|
| 359 | + | 3 responder shall be paid only to his or her designated |
---|
| 360 | + | 4 beneficiaries or dependents who at the time of such officer's, |
---|
| 361 | + | 5 firefighter's, or rescue squad member's the first responder's |
---|
| 362 | + | 6 death were actually residents of the United States. |
---|
| 363 | + | 7 "§36-30-5. |
---|
| 364 | + | 8 "(a) All claims for compensation as provided in this |
---|
| 365 | + | 9 article shall be presented to the awarding authority within |
---|
| 366 | + | 10 two years from the date of the death of the peace officer, |
---|
| 367 | + | 11 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder or the |
---|
| 368 | + | 12 claims are forfeited. All such claims shall be presented in |
---|
| 369 | + | 13 the form prescribed by the awarding authority, and proof of |
---|
| 370 | + | 14 the facts and circumstances of the peace officer's, |
---|
| 371 | + | 15 firefighter's, or rescue squad member's first responder's |
---|
| 372 | + | 16 death and, if necessary, the claimant's relationship to and |
---|
| 373 | + | 17 dependence upon such peace officer, firefighter, or rescue |
---|
| 374 | + | 18 squad member the first responder shall be made in the manner |
---|
| 375 | + | 19 prescribed by the awarding authority. |
---|
| 376 | + | 20 "(b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection |
---|
| 377 | + | 21 (a), any person who was previously ineligible to claim the |
---|
| 378 | + | 22 compensation provided in this article, but is now eligible to |
---|
| 379 | + | 23 claim the compensation provided in this article because of the |
---|
| 380 | + | 24 enactment of Act 2008-480, and who is making a claim based |
---|
| 381 | + | 25 upon the death of a peace officer or firefighter who died on |
---|
| 382 | + | 26 or after January 1, 2006, but prior to the enactment of Act |
---|
| 383 | + | 27 2008-480, shall be able to present his or her claim for |
---|
| 384 | + | Page 14 1 compensation to the awarding authority within one year of the |
---|
| 385 | + | 2 date of enactment of Act 2008-480 regardless of whether the |
---|
| 386 | + | 3 claim was presented within one year from the date of the death |
---|
| 387 | + | 4 of the peace officer or firefighter. |
---|
| 388 | + | 5 "(c) The awarding authority is hereby authorized to |
---|
| 389 | + | 6 may prescribe such forms and adopt such rules of evidence and |
---|
| 390 | + | 7 procedure as it deems necessary or proper, not inconsistent |
---|
| 391 | + | 8 with the provisions of this article, for the proper |
---|
| 392 | + | 9 determination of all claims for compensation under this |
---|
| 393 | + | 10 article." |
---|
| 394 | + | 11 "§36-30-7. |
---|
| 395 | + | 12 "(a) This article shall not be construed to give any |
---|
| 396 | + | 13 person a right of action against the State of Alabama in any |
---|
| 397 | + | 14 court for the recovery of the compensation authorized by this |
---|
| 398 | + | 15 article. This article shall not be construed to take away any |
---|
| 399 | + | 16 right of action in any court under any other law for the |
---|
| 400 | + | 17 recovery of damages for the death of a peace officer, |
---|
| 401 | + | 18 firefighter, or rescue squad member first responder; nor, in |
---|
| 402 | + | 19 the event of the death of a peace officer, firefighter, or |
---|
| 403 | + | 20 rescue squad member first responder who was an employee of the |
---|
| 404 | + | 21 State of Alabama at the time of the injury which proximately |
---|
| 405 | + | 22 caused his or her death, shall this article be construed to |
---|
| 406 | + | 23 take away the right or privilege of the surviving dependents |
---|
| 407 | + | 24 of such peace officer, firefighter, or rescue squad member the |
---|
| 408 | + | 25 first responder to file a claim for damages with the State |
---|
| 409 | + | 26 Board of Adjustment pursuant to any other law. |
---|
| 410 | + | Page 15 1 "(b) The decision of the awarding authority shall be |
---|