Alabama 2023 Regular Session

Alabama House Bill HB31 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.
OldNewDifferences
11 HB31INTRODUCED
22 Page 0
33 HJGQ66-1
44 By Representative McCampbell
55 RFD: Education Policy
66 First Read: 07-Mar-23
77 PFD: 23-Feb-23
88 1
99 2
1010 3
1111 4
1212 5 HJGQ66-1 02/16/2023 KMS (L)cr 2023-374
1313 Page 1
1414 SYNOPSIS:
1515 Under existing law, a public K-12 school or
1616 school district that is determined to have poor
1717 performance is labeled by the State Superintendent of
1818 Education as failing to make adequate progress or as a
1919 failing school under the school grading system.
2020 Also under existing law, the Alabama
2121 Accountability Act of 2013, provides financial
2222 assistance through an income tax credit to a parent who
2323 transfers a student from a failing public school to a
2424 nonfailing public school or nonpublic school of the
2525 parent's choice.
2626 This bill would change the designation of a
2727 failing school to a fully supported school and the
2828 designation of a nonfailing school to a non-fully
2929 supported school for the purposes of school grading and
3030 the Alabama Accountability Act of 2013, and would
3131 require the State Board of Education to reflect those
3232 changes in terminology when amending or adopting rules.
3333 A BILL
3434 TO BE ENTITLED
3535 AN ACT
3636 1
3737 2
3838 3
3939 4
4040 5
4141 6
4242 7
4343 8
4444 9
4545 10
4646 11
4747 12
4848 13
4949 14
5050 15
5151 16
5252 17
5353 18
5454 19
5555 20
5656 21
5757 22
5858 23
5959 24
6060 25
6161 26
6262 27
6363 28 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
6464 Page 2
6565 To amend Sections 16-6C-2, as amended by Act 2022-374,
6666 2022 Regular Session, 16-6D-3, 16-6D-4, 16-6D-6, 16-6D-8, and
6767 16-6D-9, as amended by Act 2022-390, 2022 Regular Session,
6868 Code of Alabama 1975, relating to the public K-12 school
6969 grading system and the Alabama Accountability Act of 2013; to
7070 change the designation of a failing school to a fully
7171 supported school and the designation of a nonfailing school to
7272 a non-fully supported school; and to require the State Board
7373 of Education to reflect those changes in terminology when
7474 amending or adopting rules.
7575 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA:
7676 Section 1. Sections 16-6C-2, as amended by Act
7777 2022-374, 2022 Regular Session, 16-6D-3, 16-6D-4, 16-6D-6,
7878 16-6D-8, and 16-6D-9, as amended by Act 2022-390, 2022 Regular
7979 Session, of the Code of Alabama 1975, are amended to read as
8080 follows:
8181 "§16-6C-2
8282 (a) In addition to any other labels or designations
8383 assigned to public schools and public school districts
8484 pursuant to a federal, state, school, district, or other
8585 assessment or accountability system, the State Superintendent
8686 of Education, consistent with this chapter, shall develop a
8787 school grading system reflective of school and district
8888 performance. The grading system shall utilize the traditional
8989 A, B, C, D, or F framework.
9090 (1) Schools receiving a grade of "A" are making
9191 excellent progress.
9292 (2) Schools receiving a grade of "B" are making above
9393 29
9494 30
9595 31
9696 32
9797 33
9898 34
9999 35
100100 36
101101 37
102102 38
103103 39
104104 40
105105 41
106106 42
107107 43
108108 44
109109 45
110110 46
111111 47
112112 48
113113 49
114114 50
115115 51
116116 52
117117 53
118118 54
119119 55
120120 56 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
121121 Page 3
122122 average progress.
123123 (3) Schools receiving a grade of "C" are making
124124 satisfactory progress.
125125 (4) Schools receiving a grade of "D" are making less
126126 than satisfactory progress.
127127 (5) Schools receiving a grade of "F" are failing to
128128 make adequate progress fully supported schools .
129129 (b) In developing this school grading system, the State
130130 Superintendent of Education shall seek input from parents,
131131 teachers, school administrators, existing State Department of
132132 Education advisory groups or task forces, and other education
133133 stakeholders on how the system can properly reflect not only
134134 the overall academic proficiency of each public school but
135135 also the academic improvements made by each public school,
136136 along with other key performance indicators that give a total
137137 profile of the school or the school system, or both.
138138 (c) The State Superintendent of Education shall
139139 prescribe the design and content of the school grading system
140140 by not later than December 31, 2012. It is the intent of the
141141 Legislature that the system be in place by no later than the
142142 2013-2014 school year. The system may not be utilized by the
143143 State Superintendent of Education or the State Department of
144144 Education until sufficient rules have been adopted by the
145145 State Board of Education pursuant to the Alabama
146146 Administrative Procedure Act.
147147 (d) Using an easy to understand grading scale, the
148148 school grading system shall describe achievement in the state,
149149 each district, and each school. Additionally, the State
150150 57
151151 58
152152 59
153153 60
154154 61
155155 62
156156 63
157157 64
158158 65
159159 66
160160 67
161161 68
162162 69
163163 70
164164 71
165165 72
166166 73
167167 74
168168 75
169169 76
170170 77
171171 78
172172 79
173173 80
174174 81
175175 82
176176 83
177177 84 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
178178 Page 4
179179 Superintendent of Education shall not be precluded from also
180180 assigning grades to school feeder patterns or grades that
181181 reflect the fiscal health and fiscal efficiency of a school or
182182 school system.
183183 (e) The State Superintendent of Education shall make
184184 these grades available to the general public and shall post
185185 these grades on the website of the State Department of
186186 Education as soon as the grades are available. Additionally,
187187 appropriate grade information shall be delivered to the parent
188188 or guardian of each public school student at least once
189189 annually in the same manner that student report cards are
190190 currently delivered.
191191 (f)(1) Using state-authorized assessments and other key
192192 performance indicators that give a total profile of the school
193193 or the school system, or both, a school's grade, at a minimum,
194194 shall be based on a combination of student achievement scores,
195195 achievement gap, college and career readiness, learning gains,
196196 and other indicators as determined by the State Superintendent
197197 of Education to impact student learning and success.
198198 (2) Commencing with the 2021-2022 school year, the
199199 academic achievement of each student identified as an English
200200 language learner, who has not shown proficiency on ACCESS for
201201 EL, or other state approved English proficiency assessment,
202202 may not be considered in assigning an academic achievement
203203 grade to a school or school system for the first five years of
204204 enrollment of the student. The educational progress of each of
205205 these students shall continue to be measured in the academic
206206 growth category and the progress in English language
207207 85
208208 86
209209 87
210210 88
211211 89
212212 90
213213 91
214214 92
215215 93
216216 94
217217 95
218218 96
219219 97
220220 98
221221 99
222222 100
223223 101
224224 102
225225 103
226226 104
227227 105
228228 106
229229 107
230230 108
231231 109
232232 110
233233 111
234234 112 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
235235 Page 5
236236 proficiency category and, at the end of the five-year period
237237 for the student, his or her proficiency shall again be
238238 considered in assigning an academic achievement grade to a
239239 school or school system on the state A-F school grading
240240 system.
241241 (3) The State Superintendent of Education may not amend
242242 the state Every Student Succeeds Act option for including test
243243 scores of English language learners enrolled in United States
244244 schools. The option provides as follows: For the first year of
245245 enrollment, the test scores shall be reported, but the results
246246 on both the reading/language arts and math tests shall be
247247 excluded from the federal accountability system; for the
248248 second year of enrollment, a measure of student growth on both
249249 tests shall be included in the federal accountability system;
250250 and for the third year of enrollment, proficiency on both
251251 tests shall be included in the federal accountability system.
252252 Additionally, the option requires English language learners
253253 who have successfully left the English language learner
254254 subgroup by attaining English proficiency to be included in
255255 that subgroup for accountability purposes for four years.
256256 (g) The A-F school grading system shall be consistently
257257 applied so that grades of one school or system may be compared
258258 to the grades of any other school or system."
259259 "§16-6D-3
260260 (a) The Legislature finds and declares all of the
261261 following:
262262 (1) To further the goals of public education throughout
263263 the state, each school system should be able to have maximum
264264 113
265265 114
266266 115
267267 116
268268 117
269269 118
270270 119
271271 120
272272 121
273273 122
274274 123
275275 124
276276 125
277277 126
278278 127
279279 128
280280 129
281281 130
282282 131
283283 132
284284 133
285285 134
286286 135
287287 136
288288 137
289289 138
290290 139
291291 140 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
292292 Page 6
293293 possible flexibility to meet the needs of students and the
294294 communities within its jurisdiction.
295295 (2) There is a critical need for innovative models of
296296 public education that are tailored to the unique circumstances
297297 and needs of the students in all schools and communities, and
298298 especially in schools and communities that are struggling to
299299 improve academic outcomes and close the achievement gap.
300300 (3) To better serve students and better use available
301301 resources, local boards of education, local school systems,
302302 and parents need the ability to explore flexible alternatives
303303 in an effort to be more efficient and effective in providing
304304 operational and programmatic services.
305305 (b) Therefore, it is the intent of the Legislature to
306306 do all of the following:
307307 (1) Allow school systems greater flexibility in meeting
308308 the educational needs of a diverse student population.
309309 (2) Improve educational performance through greater
310310 individual school autonomy and managerial flexibility with
311311 regard to programs and budgetary matters.
312312 (3) Encourage innovation in education by providing
313313 local school systems and school administrators with greater
314314 control over decisions including, but not limited to,
315315 budgetary matters, staffing, personnel, scheduling, and
316316 educational programming, including curriculum and instruction.
317317 (4) Provide financial assistance through an income tax
318318 credit to a parent who transfers a student from a failing
319319 fully supported public school to a nonfailing non-fully
320320 supported public school or nonpublic school of the parent's
321321 141
322322 142
323323 143
324324 144
325325 145
326326 146
327327 147
328328 148
329329 149
330330 150
331331 151
332332 152
333333 153
334334 154
335335 155
336336 156
337337 157
338338 158
339339 159
340340 160
341341 161
342342 162
343343 163
344344 164
345345 165
346346 166
347347 167
348348 168 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
349349 Page 7
350350 choice."
351351 "§16-6D-4
352352 For the purposes of this chapter, the following terms
353353 shall have the following meanings:
354354 (1) ACADEMIC YEAR. The 12-month period beginning on
355355 July 1 and ending on the following June 30.
356356 (2) DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE. The Alabama Department of
357357 Revenue.
358358 (3) EDUCATIONAL SCHOLARSHIP. A grant made by a
359359 scholarship granting organization to an eligible student to
360360 cover all or part of the tuition and mandatory fees for one
361361 academic year charged by a qualifying school to the eligible
362362 student receiving the scholarship; provided, however, that an
363363 educational scholarship shall not exceed six thousand dollars
364364 ($6,000) for an elementary school student, eight thousand
365365 dollars ($8,000) for a middle school student, or ten thousand
366366 dollars ($10,000) for a high school student per academic year.
367367 The term does not include a lump sum, block grant, or similar
368368 payment by a scholarship granting organization to a qualifying
369369 school that assigns the responsibility in whole or in part for
370370 determining the eligibility of scholarship recipients to the
371371 qualifying school or any person or entity other than the
372372 scholarship granting organization.
373373 (4) ELIGIBLE STUDENT.
374374 a. A student who satisfies all of the following:
375375 1. Is a member of a family whose total annual income
376376 the calendar year before he or she receives an educational
377377 scholarship under this program does not exceed 185 percent of
378378 169
379379 170
380380 171
381381 172
382382 173
383383 174
384384 175
385385 176
386386 177
387387 178
388388 179
389389 180
390390 181
391391 182
392392 183
393393 184
394394 185
395395 186
396396 187
397397 188
398398 189
399399 190
400400 191
401401 192
402402 193
403403 194
404404 195
405405 196 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
406406 Page 8
407407 the federal poverty level, the federally recognized threshold
408408 for receiving free or reduced priced lunch, as established
409409 from time to time by the U.S. Department of Health and Human
410410 Services.
411411 2. Was eligible to attend a public school in the
412412 preceding semester or is starting school in Alabama for the
413413 first time.
414414 3. Resides in Alabama while receiving an educational
415415 scholarship.
416416 b. A scholarship granting organization shall determine
417417 the eligibility of a student under subparagraph 1. of
418418 paragraph a. every other academic year in which a student
419419 receives an educational scholarship; provided that if the
420420 annual income of the family of a student who has received at
421421 least one educational scholarship exceeds 185 percent of the
422422 federal poverty level, the existing student shall remain
423423 eligible to receive educational scholarships until and unless
424424 the annual income of the family of the student exceeds 275
425425 percent of the federal poverty level; provided, further that
426426 no student who has received at least one educational
427427 scholarship shall be eligible to receive educational
428428 scholarships if the annual income of his or her family exceeds
429429 275 percent of the federal poverty level.
430430 (5) FAILING SCHOOL. A public K-12 school that is either
431431 of the following:
432432 a. Is designated as a failing school by the State
433433 Superintendent of Education.
434434 b. Does not exclusively serve a special population of
435435 197
436436 198
437437 199
438438 200
439439 201
440440 202
441441 203
442442 204
443443 205
444444 206
445445 207
446446 208
447447 209
448448 210
449449 211
450450 212
451451 213
452452 214
453453 215
454454 216
455455 217
456456 218
457457 219
458458 220
459459 221
460460 222
461461 223
462462 224 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
463463 Page 9
464464 students and is listed in the lowest six percent of public
465465 K-12 schools based on the state standardized assessment in
466466 reading and math.
467467 (6)(5) FAMILY. A group of two or more people related by
468468 birth, marriage, or adoption, including foster children, who
469469 reside together.
470470 (7)(6) FLEXIBILITY CONTRACT. A school flexibility
471471 contract between the local school system and the State Board
472472 of Education wherein a local school system may apply for
473473 programmatic flexibility or budgetary flexibility, or both,
474474 from state laws, regulations, and policies, including
475475 regulations and policies promulgated adopted by the State
476476 Board of Education and the State Department of Education.
477477 (7) FULLY SUPPORTED SCHOOL. A public K-12 school that
478478 is either of the following:
479479 a. Is designated as a fully supported school by the
480480 State Superintendent of Education.
481481 b. Does not exclusively serve a special population of
482482 students and is listed in the lowest sixth percent of public
483483 K-12 schools based on the state standardized assessment in
484484 reading and math.
485485 (8) INNOVATION PLAN. The request of a local school
486486 system for flexibility and plan for annual accountability
487487 measures and five-year targets for all participating schools
488488 within the school system.
489489 (9) LOCAL BOARD OF EDUCATION. A city or county board of
490490 education that exercises management and control of a local
491491 school system pursuant to state law.
492492 225
493493 226
494494 227
495495 228
496496 229
497497 230
498498 231
499499 232
500500 233
501501 234
502502 235
503503 236
504504 237
505505 238
506506 239
507507 240
508508 241
509509 242
510510 243
511511 244
512512 245
513513 246
514514 247
515515 248
516516 249
517517 250
518518 251
519519 252 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
520520 Page 10
521521 (10) LOCAL SCHOOL SYSTEM. A public agency that
522522 establishes and supervises one or more public schools within
523523 its geographical limits pursuant to state law.
524524 (11) NONPUBLIC SCHOOL. Any nonpublic or private school,
525525 including parochial schools, not under the jurisdiction of the
526526 State Superintendent of Education and the State Board of
527527 Education, providing educational services to children. A
528528 nonpublic school provides education to elementary or
529529 secondary, or both, students and has notified the Department
530530 of Revenue of its intention to participate in the scholarship
531531 program and comply with the requirements of the scholarship
532532 program. A nonpublic school does not include home schooling.
533533 (12) PARENT. The parent or guardian of a student, with
534534 authority to act on behalf of the student. For purposes of
535535 Section 16-6D-8, the parent or guardian shall claim the
536536 student as a dependent on his or her Alabama state income tax
537537 return.
538538 (13) QUALIFYING SCHOOL.
539539 a. Either a public school outside of the resident
540540 school district that is not considered failing fully supported
541541 within the meaning of subdivision (5) (7) or any nonpublic
542542 school as defined in subdivision (11) and that satisfies the
543543 requirements of this subdivision. A qualifying nonpublic
544544 school shall be accredited by one of the six regional
545545 accrediting agencies or the National Council for Private
546546 School Accreditation, AdvancEd, the American Association of
547547 Christian Schools, or one of their partner accrediting
548548 agencies. A nonpublic school shall have three years from the
549549 253
550550 254
551551 255
552552 256
553553 257
554554 258
555555 259
556556 260
557557 261
558558 262
559559 263
560560 264
561561 265
562562 266
563563 267
564564 268
565565 269
566566 270
567567 271
568568 272
569569 273
570570 274
571571 275
572572 276
573573 277
574574 278
575575 279
576576 280 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
577577 Page 11
578578 later of the date the nonpublic school notified the Department
579579 of Revenue of its intent to participate in the scholarship
580580 program or June 10, 2015, to obtain the required accreditation
581581 and shall thereafter maintain accreditation as required by
582582 this subdivision. During the three-year period described in
583583 the immediately preceding sentence, a nonpublic school that is
584584 not accredited shall satisfy all of the following conditions
585585 until the nonpublic school obtains accreditation:
586586 1. Has been in existence for at least three years.
587587 2. Has daily attendance of at least 85 percent over a
588588 two-year period.
589589 3. Has a minimum 180-day school year, or its hourly
590590 equivalent.
591591 4. Has a day length of at least six and one-half hours.
592592 5. Requires all students to take the Stanford
593593 Achievement Test, or its equivalent.
594594 6. Requires all candidates for graduation to take the
595595 American College Test before graduation.
596596 7. Requires students in high school in grades nine
597597 through 12 to earn a minimum of 24 credits before graduating,
598598 including 16 credits in core subjects, and each awarded credit
599599 shall consist of a minimum of 140 instructional hours.
600600 8. Does not subject special education students to the
601601 same testing or curricular requirements as regular education
602602 students if it is not required in the individual plan for the
603603 student.
604604 9. Maintains a website that describes the school, the
605605 instructional program of the school, and the tuition and
606606 281
607607 282
608608 283
609609 284
610610 285
611611 286
612612 287
613613 288
614614 289
615615 290
616616 291
617617 292
618618 293
619619 294
620620 295
621621 296
622622 297
623623 298
624624 299
625625 300
626626 301
627627 302
628628 303
629629 304
630630 305
631631 306
632632 307
633633 308 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
634634 Page 12
635635 mandatory fees charged by the school, updated prior to the
636636 beginning of each semester.
637637 10. Annually affirms on forms prescribed by the
638638 scholarship granting organization and the Department of
639639 Revenue its status financially and academically and provide
640640 other relative information as required by the scholarship
641641 granting organization or as otherwise required in this
642642 chapter.
643643 b. A nonpublic school that is not accredited and that
644644 has not been in existence for at least three years shall
645645 nevertheless be considered a qualifying school if, in addition
646646 to satisfying the requirements in subparagraphs 2. to 10.,
647647 inclusive, of paragraph a., the nonpublic school operates
648648 under the governance of the board of directors or the
649649 equivalent thereof of an accredited nonpublic school. For
650650 purposes of the immediately preceding sentence, the term
651651 governance shall include, but not be limited to, curriculum
652652 oversight, personnel and facility management, and financial
653653 management. If, at the conclusion of the three-year period in
654654 which a nonpublic school is required to obtain accreditation,
655655 a nonpublic school is not accredited, the nonpublic school
656656 shall not be considered a qualifying school and shall not
657657 receive any funds from a scholarship granting organization
658658 until the nonpublic school obtains the accreditation required
659659 by this subdivision.
660660 (14) SCHOLARSHIP GRANTING ORGANIZATION. An organization
661661 that provides or is approved to provide educational
662662 scholarships to eligible students attending qualifying schools
663663 309
664664 310
665665 311
666666 312
667667 313
668668 314
669669 315
670670 316
671671 317
672672 318
673673 319
674674 320
675675 321
676676 322
677677 323
678678 324
679679 325
680680 326
681681 327
682682 328
683683 329
684684 330
685685 331
686686 332
687687 333
688688 334
689689 335
690690 336 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
691691 Page 13
692692 of their parents' choice."
693693 "§16-6D-6
694694 (a) The innovation plan of a local school system shall
695695 include, at a minimum, all of the following:
696696 (1) The school year that the local school system
697697 expects the school flexibility contract to begin.
698698 (2) The list of state laws, regulations, and policies,
699699 including rules, regulations, and policies promulgated adopted
700700 by the State Board of Education and the State Department of
701701 Education, that the local school system is seeking to waive in
702702 its school flexibility contract.
703703 (3) A list of schools included in the innovation plan
704704 of the local school system.
705705 (b) A local school system is accountable to the state
706706 for the performance of all schools in its system, including
707707 innovative schools, under state and federal accountability
708708 requirements.
709709 (c) A local school system may not, pursuant to this
710710 chapter, waive requirements imposed by federal law,
711711 requirements related to the health and safety of students or
712712 employees, requirements imposed by ethics laws, requirements
713713 imposed by the Alabama Child Protection Act of 1999, Chapter
714714 22A of this title, requirements imposed by open records or
715715 open meetings laws, requirements related to financial or
716716 academic reporting or transparency, requirements designed to
717717 protect the civil rights of students or employees,
718718 requirements related to the state retirement system or state
719719 health insurance plan, or requirements imposed by Act
720720 337
721721 338
722722 339
723723 340
724724 341
725725 342
726726 343
727727 344
728728 345
729729 346
730730 347
731731 348
732732 349
733733 350
734734 351
735735 352
736736 353
737737 354
738738 355
739739 356
740740 357
741741 358
742742 359
743743 360
744744 361
745745 362
746746 363
747747 364 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
748748 Page 14
749749 2012-482. This chapter may not be construed to allow a local
750750 school system to compensate an employee at an annual amount
751751 that is less than the amount the employee would otherwise be
752752 afforded through the State Minimum Salary Schedule included in
753753 the annual Education Trust Fund Appropriations Act. No local
754754 school system shall involuntarily remove any rights or
755755 privileges acquired by any employee under the Students First
756756 Act of 2011, Chapter 24C of this title. Except as provided for
757757 a failing fully supported school pursuant to subsection (e),
758758 no plan or program submitted by a local board of education may
759759 be used to deny any right or privilege granted to a new
760760 employee pursuant to the Students First Act of 2011.
761761 (d) No provision of this chapter shall be construed or
762762 shall be used to authorize the formation of a charter school.
763763 (e) Any provision of subsection (c) to the contrary
764764 notwithstanding, nothing in this chapter shall be construed to
765765 prohibit the approval of a flexibility contract that gives
766766 potential, current, or future employees of a failing fully
767767 supported school within the local school system the option to
768768 voluntarily waive any rights or privileges already acquired or
769769 that could potentially be acquired as a result of attaining
770770 tenure or nonprobationary status, provided, however, that any
771771 employee provided this option is also provided the option of
772772 retaining or potentially obtaining any rights or privileges
773773 provided under the Students First Act, Chapter 24C of this
774774 title.
775775 (f) The State Department of Education shall finalize
776776 all school data and the local school system shall seek
777777 365
778778 366
779779 367
780780 368
781781 369
782782 370
783783 371
784784 372
785785 373
786786 374
787787 375
788788 376
789789 377
790790 378
791791 379
792792 380
793793 381
794794 382
795795 383
796796 384
797797 385
798798 386
799799 387
800800 388
801801 389
802802 390
803803 391
804804 392 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
805805 Page 15
806806 approval of the local board of education before final
807807 submission to the State Department of Education and the State
808808 Board of Education.
809809 (g) The final innovation plan, as recommended by the
810810 local superintendent of education and approved by the local
811811 board of education, shall accompany the formal submission of
812812 the local school system to the State Department of Education.
813813 (h) Within 60 days of receiving the final submission,
814814 the State Superintendent of Education shall decide whether or
815815 not the school flexibility contract and the innovation plan
816816 should be approved. If the State Superintendent of Education
817817 denies a school flexibility contract and innovation plan, he
818818 or she shall provide a written explanation for his or her
819819 decision to the local board of education. Likewise, a written
820820 letter of approval by the State Superintendent of Education
821821 shall be provided to the local board of education that
822822 submitted the final school flexibility contract and innovation
823823 plan.
824824 (i) The State Board of Education shall promulgate adopt
825825 any necessary rules and regulations required to implement this
826826 chapter including, but not limited to, all of the following:
827827 (1) The specification of timelines for submission and
828828 approval of the innovation plan and school flexibility
829829 contract of a local school system.
830830 (2) An authorization for the State Department of
831831 Education, upon approval by the State Board of Education after
832832 periodic review, to revoke a school flexibility contract for
833833 noncompliance or nonperformance, or both, by a local school
834834 393
835835 394
836836 395
837837 396
838838 397
839839 398
840840 399
841841 400
842842 401
843843 402
844844 403
845845 404
846846 405
847847 406
848848 407
849849 408
850850 409
851851 410
852852 411
853853 412
854854 413
855855 414
856856 415
857857 416
858858 417
859859 418
860860 419
861861 420 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
862862 Page 16
863863 system.
864864 (3) An outline of procedures and necessary steps that a
865865 local school system shall follow, upon denial of an original
866866 submission, to amend and resubmit an innovation plan and
867867 school flexibility contract for approval."
868868 "§16-6D-8
869869 (a) To provide educational flexibility and state
870870 accountability for students in failing fully supported
871871 schools:
872872 (1) For tax years beginning on and after January 1,
873873 2013, an Alabama income tax credit is made available to the
874874 parent of a student enrolled in or assigned to attend a
875875 failing fully supported school to help offset the cost of
876876 transferring the student to a nonfailing non-fully supported
877877 public school or nonpublic school of the parent's choice. The
878878 income tax credit shall be an amount equal to 80 percent of
879879 the average annual state cost of attendance for a public K-12
880880 student during the applicable tax year or the actual cost of
881881 attending a nonfailing non-fully supported public school or
882882 nonpublic school, whichever is less. The actual cost of
883883 attending a nonfailing non-fully supported public school or
884884 nonpublic school shall be calculated by adding together any
885885 tuition amounts or mandatory fees charged by the school to the
886886 student as a condition of enrolling or of maintaining
887887 enrollment in the school. The average annual state cost of
888888 attendance for a public K-12 student shall be calculated by
889889 dividing the state funds appropriated to the Foundation
890890 Program pursuant to Section 16-13-231(b)(2) by the total
891891 421
892892 422
893893 423
894894 424
895895 425
896896 426
897897 427
898898 428
899899 429
900900 430
901901 431
902902 432
903903 433
904904 434
905905 435
906906 436
907907 437
908908 438
909909 439
910910 440
911911 441
912912 442
913913 443
914914 444
915915 445
916916 446
917917 447
918918 448 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
919919 Page 17
920920 statewide number of pupils in average daily membership during
921921 the first 20 scholastic days following Labor Day of the
922922 preceding school year. For each student who was enrolled in
923923 and attended a failing fully supported school the previous
924924 semester whose parent receives an income tax credit under this
925925 section, an amount equal to 20 percent of the average annual
926926 state cost of attendance for a public K-12 student during the
927927 applicable tax year shall be allocated, for as long as the
928928 parent receives the tax credit, to the failing fully supported
929929 school from which the student transferred if the student
930930 transfers to and remains enrolled in a nonpublic school. No
931931 such allocation shall be made in the event the student
932932 transfers to or enrolls in a nonfailing non-fully supported
933933 public school. The Department of Education shall determine the
934934 best method of ensuring that the foregoing allocation
935935 provisions are properly implemented. A parent is allowed a
936936 credit against income tax for each taxable year under the
937937 terms established in this section. If income taxes owed by
938938 such a parent are less than the total credit allowed under
939939 this subsection, the taxpayer shall be entitled to a refund or
940940 rebate, as the case may be, equal to the balance of the unused
941941 credit with respect to that taxable year.
942942 (2) Any income tax credit due a parent under this
943943 section shall be granted or issued to the parent only upon his
944944 or her making application therefor, at such time and in such
945945 manner as may be prescribed from time to time by the
946946 Department of Revenue. The application process shall include,
947947 but not be limited to, certification by the parent that the
948948 449
949949 450
950950 451
951951 452
952952 453
953953 454
954954 455
955955 456
956956 457
957957 458
958958 459
959959 460
960960 461
961961 462
962962 463
963963 464
964964 465
965965 466
966966 467
967967 468
968968 469
969969 470
970970 471
971971 472
972972 473
973973 474
974974 475
975975 476 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
976976 Page 18
977977 student was enrolled in or was assigned to attend a failing
978978 fully supported school, certification by the parent that the
979979 student was subsequently transferred to, and was enrolled and
980980 attended, a nonfailing non-fully supported public school or
981981 nonpublic school of the parent's choice, and proof,
982982 satisfactory to the Department of Revenue, of the actual cost
983983 of attendance for the student at the nonfailing non-fully
984984 supported public school or nonpublic school. For purposes of
985985 the tax credit authorized by this section, costs of attendance
986986 does not include any such costs incurred for an academic year
987987 prior to the 2013-2014 academic year. The Department of
988988 Revenue shall also prescribe the various methods by which
989989 income tax credits are to be issued to taxpayers. Income tax
990990 credits authorized by this section shall be paid out of sales
991991 tax collections made to the Education Trust Fund, and set
992992 aside by the Comptroller in the Failing Fully Supported
993993 Schools Income Tax Credit Account created in subsection (c),
994994 in the same manner as refunds of income tax otherwise provided
995995 by law, and there is hereby appropriated therefrom, for such
996996 purpose, so much as may be necessary to annually pay the
997997 income tax credits provided by this section.
998998 (3) An application for an income tax credit authorized
999999 by this section shall be filed with the Department of Revenue
10001000 within the time prescribed for filing petitions for refund
10011001 under Section 40-2A-7.
10021002 (4) The Department of Revenue shall promulgate adopt
10031003 reasonable rules to effectuate the intent of this subsection.
10041004 (b)(1) The parent of a public school student may
10051005 477
10061006 478
10071007 479
10081008 480
10091009 481
10101010 482
10111011 483
10121012 484
10131013 485
10141014 486
10151015 487
10161016 488
10171017 489
10181018 490
10191019 491
10201020 492
10211021 493
10221022 494
10231023 495
10241024 496
10251025 497
10261026 498
10271027 499
10281028 500
10291029 501
10301030 502
10311031 503
10321032 504 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
10331033 Page 19
10341034 request and receive an income tax credit pursuant to this
10351035 section to reimburse the parent for costs associated with
10361036 transferring the student from a failing fully supported school
10371037 to a nonfailing non-fully supported public school or nonpublic
10381038 school of the parent's choice, in any of the following
10391039 circumstances:
10401040 a. By assigned school attendance area, if the student
10411041 spent the prior school year in attendance at a failing fully
10421042 supported school and the attendance of the student occurred
10431043 during a school year in which the designation was in effect.
10441044 b. The student was in attendance elsewhere in the
10451045 Alabama public school system and was assigned to a failing
10461046 fully supported school for the next school year.
10471047 c. The student was notified that he or she was assigned
10481048 to a failing fully supported school for the next school year.
10491049 (2) This section does not apply to a student who is
10501050 enrolled in the Department of Youth Services School District.
10511051 (3) For the purposes of continuity of educational
10521052 choice, the tax credit shall be available to parents for those
10531053 grade levels of the failing fully supported school from which
10541054 the student transferred. The parent of a student who transfers
10551055 from a failing fully supported school may receive income tax
10561056 credits for those grade levels enrolled in and attended in the
10571057 nonfailing non-fully supported public school or nonpublic
10581058 school of the parent's choice transferred to that were
10591059 included in the failing fully supported school from which the
10601060 student transferred, whether or not the failing fully
10611061 supported school becomes a nonfailing non-fully supported
10621062 505
10631063 506
10641064 507
10651065 508
10661066 509
10671067 510
10681068 511
10691069 512
10701070 513
10711071 514
10721072 515
10731073 516
10741074 517
10751075 518
10761076 519
10771077 520
10781078 521
10791079 522
10801080 523
10811081 524
10821082 525
10831083 526
10841084 527
10851085 528
10861086 529
10871087 530
10881088 531
10891089 532 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
10901090 Page 20
10911091 school during those years. The parent of such a student shall
10921092 no longer be eligible for the income tax credit after the
10931093 student completes the highest grade level in which he or she
10941094 would otherwise have been enrolled at the failing fully
10951095 supported school. Notwithstanding the foregoing, as long as
10961096 the student remains enrolled in or assigned to attend a
10971097 failing fully supported school, the parent may again transfer
10981098 the student to a nonfailing non-fully supported public school
10991099 or nonpublic school of the parent's choice and request and
11001100 receive an income tax credit as provided in this section.
11011101 (4) A local school system, for each student enrolled in
11021102 or assigned to a failing fully supported school, shall do all
11031103 of the following:
11041104 a. Timely notify the parent of the student of all
11051105 options available under this section as soon as the school of
11061106 attendance is designated as a failing fully supported school.
11071107 b. Offer the parent of the student an opportunity to
11081108 enroll the student in another public school within the local
11091109 school system that is not a failing a non-fully supported
11101110 school or a failing fully supported school to which the
11111111 student has been assigned.
11121112 (5) The parent of a student enrolled in or assigned to
11131113 a school that has been designated as a failing fully supported
11141114 school, who decides to transfer the student to a nonfailing
11151115 non-fully supported public school, shall first attempt to
11161116 enroll the student in a nonfailing non-fully supported public
11171117 school within the same local system in which the student is
11181118 already enrolled or assigned to attend before attempting to
11191119 533
11201120 534
11211121 535
11221122 536
11231123 537
11241124 538
11251125 539
11261126 540
11271127 541
11281128 542
11291129 543
11301130 544
11311131 545
11321132 546
11331133 547
11341134 548
11351135 549
11361136 550
11371137 551
11381138 552
11391139 553
11401140 554
11411141 555
11421142 556
11431143 557
11441144 558
11451145 559
11461146 560 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
11471147 Page 21
11481148 enroll the student in a nonfailing non-fully supported public
11491149 school that has available space in any other local school
11501150 system in the state. A local school system may accept the
11511151 student on whatever terms and conditions the system
11521152 establishes and report the student for purposes of the local
11531153 school system's funding pursuant to the Foundation Program.
11541154 (6) For students in the local school system who are
11551155 participating in the tax credit program, the local school
11561156 system shall provide locations and times to take all statewide
11571157 assessments required by law.
11581158 (7) Students with disabilities who are eligible to
11591159 receive services from the local school system under federal or
11601160 state law, and who participate in the tax credit program,
11611161 remain eligible to receive services from the local school
11621162 system as provided by federal or state law.
11631163 (8) If a parent enrolls a student in a nonfailing
11641164 non-fully supported public school within the same local school
11651165 system, and that system provides transportation services for
11661166 other enrolled students, transportation costs to the
11671167 nonfailing non-fully supported public school shall be the
11681168 responsibility of the local school system. Local school
11691169 systems may negotiate transportation options with a parent to
11701170 minimize system costs. If a parent enrolls a student in a
11711171 nonpublic school or in a nonfailing non-fully supported public
11721172 school within another local school system, regardless of
11731173 whether that system provides transportation services for other
11741174 enrolled students, transportation of the student shall be the
11751175 responsibility of the parent.
11761176 561
11771177 562
11781178 563
11791179 564
11801180 565
11811181 566
11821182 567
11831183 568
11841184 569
11851185 570
11861186 571
11871187 572
11881188 573
11891189 574
11901190 575
11911191 576
11921192 577
11931193 578
11941194 579
11951195 580
11961196 581
11971197 582
11981198 583
11991199 584
12001200 585
12011201 586
12021202 587
12031203 588 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
12041204 Page 22
12051205 (9) The State Department of Education shall promulgate
12061206 adopt reasonable rules to effectuate the intent of this
12071207 subsection. Rules shall include penalties for noncompliance.
12081208 (c) There is created within the Education Trust Fund a
12091209 separate account named the Failing Fully Supported Schools
12101210 Income Tax Credit Account. The Commissioner of Revenue shall
12111211 certify to the Comptroller the amount of income tax credits
12121212 due to parents under this section and the Comptroller shall
12131213 transfer into the Failing Fully Supported Schools Income Tax
12141214 Credit Account only the amount from sales tax revenues within
12151215 the Education Trust Fund that is sufficient for the Department
12161216 of Revenue to use to cover the income tax credits for the
12171217 applicable tax year. The Commissioner of Revenue shall
12181218 distribute the funds in the Failing Fully Supported Schools
12191219 Income Tax Credit Account to parents pursuant to this section.
12201220 (d)(1) Nothing in this section or chapter shall be
12211221 construed to force any public school, school system, or school
12221222 district or any nonpublic school, school system, or school
12231223 district to enroll any student.
12241224 (2) A public school, school system, or school district
12251225 or any nonpublic school, school system, or school district may
12261226 develop the terms and conditions under which it will allow a
12271227 student whose parent receives an income tax credit pursuant to
12281228 this section to be enrolled, but such terms and conditions may
12291229 not discriminate on the basis of the race, gender, religion,
12301230 color, disability status, or ethnicity of the student or of
12311231 the student's parent.
12321232 (3) Nothing in this section shall be construed to
12331233 589
12341234 590
12351235 591
12361236 592
12371237 593
12381238 594
12391239 595
12401240 596
12411241 597
12421242 598
12431243 599
12441244 600
12451245 601
12461246 602
12471247 603
12481248 604
12491249 605
12501250 606
12511251 607
12521252 608
12531253 609
12541254 610
12551255 611
12561256 612
12571257 613
12581258 614
12591259 615
12601260 616 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
12611261 Page 23
12621262 authorize the violation of or supersede the authority of any
12631263 court ruling that applies to the public school, school system,
12641264 or school district, specifically any federal court order
12651265 related to the desegregation of the local school system's
12661266 student population."
12671267 "§16-6D-9
12681268 (a)(1) An individual taxpayer who files a state income
12691269 tax return and is not claimed as a dependent of another
12701270 taxpayer, a taxpayer subject to the corporate income tax
12711271 levied by Chapter 18 of Title 40, an Alabama S corporation as
12721272 defined in Section 40-18-160, or a Subchapter K entity as
12731273 defined in Section 40-18-1 may claim a credit for a
12741274 contribution made to a scholarship granting organization. If
12751275 the credit is claimed by an Alabama S corporation or
12761276 Subchapter K entity, the credit shall pass through to and may
12771277 be claimed by any taxpayer eligible to claim a credit under
12781278 this subdivision who is a shareholder, partner, or member
12791279 thereof, based on the taxpayer's pro rata or distributive
12801280 share, respectively, of the credit.
12811281 (2) The tax credit may be claimed by an individual
12821282 taxpayer or a married couple filing jointly in an amount equal
12831283 to 100 percent of the total contributions the taxpayer made to
12841284 a scholarship granting organization for educational
12851285 scholarships during the taxable year for which the credit is
12861286 claimed, up to 100 percent of the tax liability of the
12871287 individual taxpayer, not to exceed one hundred thousand
12881288 dollars ($100,000) per individual taxpayer or married couple
12891289 filing jointly. For purposes of this section, an individual
12901290 617
12911291 618
12921292 619
12931293 620
12941294 621
12951295 622
12961296 623
12971297 624
12981298 625
12991299 626
13001300 627
13011301 628
13021302 629
13031303 630
13041304 631
13051305 632
13061306 633
13071307 634
13081308 635
13091309 636
13101310 637
13111311 638
13121312 639
13131313 640
13141314 641
13151315 642
13161316 643
13171317 644 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
13181318 Page 24
13191319 taxpayer includes an individual who is a shareholder of an
13201320 Alabama S corporation or a partner or member of a Subchapter K
13211321 entity that made a contribution to a scholarship granting
13221322 organization.
13231323 (3) The tax credit may be claimed by a taxpayer subject
13241324 to the Alabama corporate income tax in an amount equal to 100
13251325 percent of the total contributions the taxpayer made to a
13261326 scholarship granting organization for educational scholarships
13271327 during the taxable year for which the credit is claimed, up to
13281328 100 percent of the tax liability of the taxpayer.
13291329 (4) A taxpayer subject to the Alabama corporate income
13301330 tax, an individual taxpayer, or a married couple filing
13311331 jointly may carry forward a tax credit earned under the tax
13321332 credit scholarship program for up to three taxable years.
13331333 (5) The cumulative amount of tax credits issued
13341334 pursuant to subdivision (2) and subdivision (3) shall not
13351335 exceed thirty million dollars ($30,000,000) annually, based on
13361336 the calendar year. A taxpayer making one or more otherwise
13371337 tax-creditable contributions before the due date, with
13381338 extensions, of a timely filed 2014 tax return may elect to
13391339 treat all or a portion of such contributions as applying to
13401340 and creditable against its 2014 Alabama income tax liability,
13411341 if the taxpayer properly reserves the credit on the website of
13421342 the Department of Revenue or another method provided by the
13431343 Department of Revenue. The amount creditable against the
13441344 taxpayer's 2014 income tax liability shall be limited to the
13451345 lesser of the amount so designated or the remaining balance,
13461346 if any, of the cumulative amount of the twenty-five million
13471347 645
13481348 646
13491349 647
13501350 648
13511351 649
13521352 650
13531353 651
13541354 652
13551355 653
13561356 654
13571357 655
13581358 656
13591359 657
13601360 658
13611361 659
13621362 660
13631363 661
13641364 662
13651365 663
13661366 664
13671367 665
13681368 666
13691369 667
13701370 668
13711371 669
13721372 670
13731373 671
13741374 672 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
13751375 Page 25
13761376 dollars ($25,000,000) of tax credits available for the 2014
13771377 calendar year. No such contribution and election by a taxpayer
13781378 to reserve tax credits against the remaining balance of the
13791379 cumulative amount of tax credits available for 2014 shall
13801380 preclude the taxpayer from making additional contributions in
13811381 2015 and reserving those amounts against the cumulative amount
13821382 of tax credits available for 2015. The Department of Revenue
13831383 shall develop a procedure to ensure that this cap is not
13841384 exceeded and shall also prescribe the various methods by which
13851385 these credits are to be issued.
13861386 (6) No credit may be claimed for a contribution made to
13871387 a scholarship granting organization if the contribution is
13881388 restricted or conditioned in any way by the donor including,
13891389 but not limited to, requiring the scholarship granting
13901390 organization to direct all or part of the contribution to a
13911391 particular qualifying school or to grant an educational
13921392 scholarship to a particular eligible student.
13931393 (b)(1) ADMINISTRATIVE ACCOUNTABILITY STANDARDS. All
13941394 scholarship granting organizations shall do all of the
13951395 following:
13961396 a. Notify the Department of Revenue of their intent to
13971397 provide educational scholarships to eligible students.
13981398 b. Demonstrate to the Department of Revenue that they
13991399 have been granted exemption from the federal income tax as an
14001400 organization described in Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal
14011401 Revenue Code, as in effect from time to time.
14021402 c. Distribute periodic educational scholarship payments
14031403 as checks made out and mailed to or directly deposited with
14041404 673
14051405 674
14061406 675
14071407 676
14081408 677
14091409 678
14101410 679
14111411 680
14121412 681
14131413 682
14141414 683
14151415 684
14161416 685
14171417 686
14181418 687
14191419 688
14201420 689
14211421 690
14221422 691
14231423 692
14241424 693
14251425 694
14261426 695
14271427 696
14281428 697
14291429 698
14301430 699
14311431 700 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
14321432 Page 26
14331433 the school where the student is enrolled.
14341434 d. Provide a Department of Revenue approved receipt to
14351435 taxpayers for contributions made to the scholarship granting
14361436 organization.
14371437 e. Ensure that all determinations with respect to the
14381438 eligibility of a student to receive an educational scholarship
14391439 shall be made by the scholarship granting organization. A
14401440 scholarship granting organization shall not delegate any
14411441 responsibility for determining the eligibility of a student
14421442 for an educational scholarship or any other requirements it is
14431443 subject to under this chapter to any qualifying school or an
14441444 entity affiliated therewith.
14451445 f. Ensure that at least 95 percent of their revenue
14461446 from donations is expended on educational scholarships, and
14471447 that all revenue from interest or investments is expended on
14481448 educational scholarships. A scholarship granting organization
14491449 may expend up to five percent of its revenue from donations on
14501450 administrative and operating expenses in the calendar year of
14511451 the donation or in any subsequent calendar year.
14521452 g. Ensure that scholarship funds on hand at the
14531453 beginning of a calendar year are expended on educational
14541454 scholarships within three calendar years. Any scholarship
14551455 funds on hand at the beginning of a calendar year that are not
14561456 expended on educational scholarships within three calendar
14571457 years shall be turned over to and deposited with the State
14581458 Department of Education for the benefit of its At-Risk Student
14591459 Program to be distributed to local boards of education on the
14601460 basis determined by the State Department of Education in
14611461 701
14621462 702
14631463 703
14641464 704
14651465 705
14661466 706
14671467 707
14681468 708
14691469 709
14701470 710
14711471 711
14721472 712
14731473 713
14741474 714
14751475 715
14761476 716
14771477 717
14781478 718
14791479 719
14801480 720
14811481 721
14821482 722
14831483 723
14841484 724
14851485 725
14861486 726
14871487 727
14881488 728 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
14891489 Page 27
14901490 furtherance of support to underperforming schools.
14911491 h. Ensure that at least 75 percent of first-time
14921492 recipients of educational scholarships were not continuously
14931493 enrolled in a private school during the previous academic
14941494 year.
14951495 i. Cooperate with the Department of Revenue to conduct
14961496 criminal background checks on all of their employees and board
14971497 members and exclude from employment or governance any
14981498 individual who may reasonably pose a risk to the appropriate
14991499 use of contributed funds.
15001500 j. Ensure that educational scholarships are portable
15011501 during the academic year and can be used at any qualifying
15021502 school that accepts the eligible student according to the
15031503 wishes of the parent. If an eligible student transfers to
15041504 another qualifying school during an academic year, the
15051505 educational scholarship amount may be prorated.
15061506 k. Publicly report to the Department of Revenue by
15071507 September 1 of each year all of the following information
15081508 prepared by a certified public accountant regarding their
15091509 educational scholarships funded in the previous academic year:
15101510 1. The name and address of the scholarship granting
15111511 organization.
15121512 2. The total number and total dollar amount of
15131513 contributions received during the previous academic year.
15141514 3. The total number and total dollar amount of
15151515 educational scholarships awarded and funded during the
15161516 previous academic year, the total number and total dollar
15171517 amount of educational scholarships awarded and funded during
15181518 729
15191519 730
15201520 731
15211521 732
15221522 733
15231523 734
15241524 735
15251525 736
15261526 737
15271527 738
15281528 739
15291529 740
15301530 741
15311531 742
15321532 743
15331533 744
15341534 745
15351535 746
15361536 747
15371537 748
15381538 749
15391539 750
15401540 751
15411541 752
15421542 753
15431543 754
15441544 755
15451545 756 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
15461546 Page 28
15471547 the previous academic year for students qualifying for the
15481548 federal free and reduced-price lunch program, and the
15491549 percentage of first-time recipients of educational
15501550 scholarships who were enrolled in a public school during the
15511551 previous academic year.
15521552 l. Publicly report to the Department of Revenue, by the
15531553 15th day after the close of each calendar quarter, all of the
15541554 following information about educational scholarships granted
15551555 during the quarter:
15561556 1. The total number of scholarships awarded and funded.
15571557 2. The names of the qualifying schools that received
15581558 funding for educational scholarships, the total amount of
15591559 funds paid to each qualifying school, and the total number of
15601560 scholarship recipients enrolled in each qualifying school.
15611561 3. The total number of eligible students zoned to
15621562 attend a failing fully supported school who received
15631563 educational scholarships from the scholarship granting
15641564 organization.
15651565 4. The total number of first time scholarship
15661566 recipients who were continuously enrolled in a nonpublic
15671567 school prior to receiving an educational scholarship from that
15681568 scholarship granting organization.
15691569 m. Ensure that educational scholarships are not
15701570 provided for eligible students to attend a school with paid
15711571 staff or board members, or relatives thereof, in common with
15721572 the scholarship granting organization.
15731573 n. Ensure that educational scholarships are provided in
15741574 a manner that does not discriminate based on the gender, race,
15751575 757
15761576 758
15771577 759
15781578 760
15791579 761
15801580 762
15811581 763
15821582 764
15831583 765
15841584 766
15851585 767
15861586 768
15871587 769
15881588 770
15891589 771
15901590 772
15911591 773
15921592 774
15931593 775
15941594 776
15951595 777
15961596 778
15971597 779
15981598 780
15991599 781
16001600 782
16011601 783
16021602 784 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
16031603 Page 29
16041604 or disability status of the scholarship applicant or his or
16051605 her parent.
16061606 o. Ensure that educational scholarships are provided
16071607 only to eligible students who are zoned to attend a failing
16081608 fully supported school so that the eligible student can attend
16091609 a qualifying school. To ensure compliance with the immediately
16101610 preceding sentence, the local board of education for the
16111611 county or municipality in which an eligible student applying
16121612 for an educational scholarship resides, upon written request
16131613 by a parent, shall provide written verification that a
16141614 particular address is in the attendance zone of a specified
16151615 public school. The State Department of Education shall provide
16161616 written verification of enrollment in a failing fully
16171617 supported school under this chapter. With respect to first
16181618 time educational scholarship recipients, scholarship granting
16191619 organizations shall give priority to eligible students zoned
16201620 to attend failing fully supported schools over eligible
16211621 students not zoned to attend failing fully supported schools.
16221622 Any scholarship funds unaccounted for on July 31st of each
16231623 calendar year may be made available to eligible students to
16241624 defray the costs of attending a qualifying school, whether or
16251625 not the student is zoned to attend a failing fully supported
16261626 school. Any provision of this section to the contrary
16271627 notwithstanding, once an eligible student receives an
16281628 educational scholarship under this program, scholarship funds
16291629 may be made available to the student for educational
16301630 scholarships until the student graduates from high school or
16311631 reaches 19 years of age, regardless of whether the student is
16321632 785
16331633 786
16341634 787
16351635 788
16361636 789
16371637 790
16381638 791
16391639 792
16401640 793
16411641 794
16421642 795
16431643 796
16441644 797
16451645 798
16461646 799
16471647 800
16481648 801
16491649 802
16501650 803
16511651 804
16521652 805
16531653 806
16541654 807
16551655 808
16561656 809
16571657 810
16581658 811
16591659 812 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
16601660 Page 30
16611661 zoned to attend a failing fully supported school, subject to
16621662 the income eligibility requirements of paragraph b. of
16631663 subdivision (4) of Section 16-6D-4.
16641664 p. Ensure that no donations are directly made to
16651665 benefit specifically designated scholarship recipients or to
16661666 particular qualifying schools.
16671667 q. Submit to the Department of Revenue annual
16681668 verification of the scholarship granting organization's
16691669 policies and procedures used to determine scholarship
16701670 eligibility. The verification shall confirm that the
16711671 scholarship granting organization, and not one or more
16721672 qualifying schools accepting educational scholarship
16731673 recipients or scholarship funds, is determining whether
16741674 scholarship applicants are eligible to receive educational
16751675 scholarships. The verification shall also confirm that the
16761676 scholarship granting organization is giving priority to
16771677 receive an educational scholarship to eligible students zoned
16781678 to attend failing fully supported schools.
16791679 r. Submit to the Department of Revenue annual
16801680 verification that none of its actions or policies restricts a
16811681 parent's educational choice by limiting or prohibiting the
16821682 enrollment of eligible students in a qualifying school if
16831683 those eligible students received educational scholarships from
16841684 other scholarship granting organizations.
16851685 (2) FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY STANDARDS.
16861686 a. All scholarship granting organizations shall
16871687 demonstrate their financial accountability by doing all of the
16881688 following:
16891689 813
16901690 814
16911691 815
16921692 816
16931693 817
16941694 818
16951695 819
16961696 820
16971697 821
16981698 822
16991699 823
17001700 824
17011701 825
17021702 826
17031703 827
17041704 828
17051705 829
17061706 830
17071707 831
17081708 832
17091709 833
17101710 834
17111711 835
17121712 836
17131713 837
17141714 838
17151715 839
17161716 840 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
17171717 Page 31
17181718 1. Annually submitting to the Department of Revenue a
17191719 financial information report for the scholarship granting
17201720 organization that complies with uniform financial accounting
17211721 standards established by the Department of Revenue and
17221722 conducted by a certified public accountant.
17231723 2. Having the auditor certify that the report is free
17241724 of material misstatements.
17251725 b. All qualifying nonpublic schools shall demonstrate
17261726 financial viability, if they are to receive donations of fifty
17271727 thousand dollars ($50,000) or more during the academic year,
17281728 by doing either of the following:
17291729 1. Filing with the scholarship granting organization
17301730 prior to receipt of the first educational scholarship payment
17311731 for that academic year a surety bond payable to the
17321732 scholarship granting organization in an amount equal to the
17331733 aggregate amount of scholarship funds expected to be received
17341734 during the academic year.
17351735 2. Filing with the scholarship granting organization
17361736 prior to receipt of the first educational scholarship payment
17371737 for that academic year financial information that demonstrates
17381738 the financial viability of the qualifying nonpublic school.
17391739 (c)(1) Each scholarship granting organization shall
17401740 annually collect and submit to the Department of Revenue with
17411741 the annual report required by paragraph k. of subdivision (1)
17421742 of subsection (b) written verification from qualifying
17431743 nonpublic schools that accept its educational scholarship
17441744 students that those schools do all of the following:
17451745 a. Comply with all health and safety laws or codes that
17461746 841
17471747 842
17481748 843
17491749 844
17501750 845
17511751 846
17521752 847
17531753 848
17541754 849
17551755 850
17561756 851
17571757 852
17581758 853
17591759 854
17601760 855
17611761 856
17621762 857
17631763 858
17641764 859
17651765 860
17661766 861
17671767 862
17681768 863
17691769 864
17701770 865
17711771 866
17721772 867
17731773 868 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
17741774 Page 32
17751775 otherwise apply to nonpublic schools.
17761776 b. Hold a valid occupancy permit if required by the
17771777 municipality.
17781778 c. Certify compliance with nondiscrimination policies
17791779 set forth in 42 U.S.C. § 1981.
17801780 d. Conduct criminal background checks on employees and
17811781 then do all of the following:
17821782 1. Exclude from employment any person not permitted by
17831783 state law to work in a public school.
17841784 2. Exclude from employment any person who may
17851785 reasonably pose a threat to the safety of students.
17861786 (2) By August 1 of each year, each qualifying nonpublic
17871787 school shall provide to each scholarship granting organization
17881788 from which it receives educational scholarships verification
17891789 that the qualifying nonpublic school is in compliance with the
17901790 Alabama Child Protection Act of 1999, Chapter 22A of this
17911791 title. Any qualifying nonpublic school failing to timely
17921792 provide such annual verification shall be prohibited from
17931793 participating in the scholarship program. Each scholarship
17941794 granting organization shall annually submit to the Department
17951795 of Revenue with the annual report required by paragraph k. of
17961796 subdivision (1) of subsection (b) copies of the written
17971797 verifications it receives from each qualifying nonpublic
17981798 school.
17991799 (3) ACADEMIC ACCOUNTABILITY STANDARDS. There shall be
18001800 sufficient information about the academic impact educational
18011801 scholarship tax credits have on students participating in the
18021802 tax credit scholarship program in order to allow parents and
18031803 869
18041804 870
18051805 871
18061806 872
18071807 873
18081808 874
18091809 875
18101810 876
18111811 877
18121812 878
18131813 879
18141814 880
18151815 881
18161816 882
18171817 883
18181818 884
18191819 885
18201820 886
18211821 887
18221822 888
18231823 889
18241824 890
18251825 891
18261826 892
18271827 893
18281828 894
18291829 895
18301830 896 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
18311831 Page 33
18321832 taxpayers to measure the achievements of the tax credit
18331833 scholarship program, and therefore:
18341834 a. Each scholarship granting organization shall ensure
18351835 that qualifying schools that accept its educational
18361836 scholarship students shall do all of the following:
18371837 1. Annually administer either the state achievement
18381838 tests or nationally recognized norm-referenced tests that
18391839 measure learning gains in math and language arts to all
18401840 students receiving an educational scholarship in grades that
18411841 require testing under the accountability testing laws of the
18421842 state for public schools, in order that the state can compare
18431843 the academic achievement and learning gains of students
18441844 receiving educational scholarships with students of the same
18451845 socioeconomic and educational backgrounds who are taking the
18461846 state achievement tests or nationally norm-referenced tests.
18471847 2. Allow the costs of the testing requirement to be
18481848 covered by the educational scholarships distributed by the
18491849 scholarship granting organizations.
18501850 3. Provide the parents of each student who was tested
18511851 with a copy of the results of the tests on an annual basis,
18521852 beginning with the first year of testing.
18531853 4. Provide the test results to the Department of
18541854 Revenue on an annual basis, beginning with the first year of
18551855 testing.
18561856 5. Report student information that allows the state to
18571857 aggregate data by grade level, gender, family income level,
18581858 and race.
18591859 6. Provide graduation rates of those students
18601860 897
18611861 898
18621862 899
18631863 900
18641864 901
18651865 902
18661866 903
18671867 904
18681868 905
18691869 906
18701870 907
18711871 908
18721872 909
18731873 910
18741874 911
18751875 912
18761876 913
18771877 914
18781878 915
18791879 916
18801880 917
18811881 918
18821882 919
18831883 920
18841884 921
18851885 922
18861886 923
18871887 924 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
18881888 Page 34
18891889 benefitting from educational scholarships to the Department of
18901890 Revenue or an organization chosen by the state in a manner
18911891 consistent with nationally recognized standards.
18921892 7. Ensure that a student who receives an educational
18931893 scholarship conforms to the attendance requirements of the
18941894 qualifying school. If a student fails to conform, the
18951895 qualifying school shall immediately communicate the failure to
18961896 the applicable scholarship granting organization.
18971897 b.1. The Department of Revenue shall select an
18981898 independent research organization, which may be a public or
18991899 private entity or university, to analyze the results of the
19001900 testing required by paragraph a. every other academic year.
19011901 The cost of analyzing and reporting on the test results to the
19021902 Department of Revenue by the independent research organization
19031903 shall be borne by all scholarship granting organizations in
19041904 proportion to the total scholarship donations received for the
19051905 two calendar years prior to the report being published.
19061906 Scholarship granting organizations may receive and use funds
19071907 from outside sources to pay for its share of the biennial
19081908 report.
19091909 2. The independent research organization shall report
19101910 to the Department of Revenue every other year on the learning
19111911 gains of students receiving educational scholarships and the
19121912 report shall be aggregated by the grade level, gender, family
19131913 income level, number of years of participation in the tax
19141914 credit scholarship program, and race of the student receiving
19151915 an educational scholarship. The report shall also include, to
19161916 the extent possible, a comparison of the learning gains of
19171917 925
19181918 926
19191919 927
19201920 928
19211921 929
19221922 930
19231923 931
19241924 932
19251925 933
19261926 934
19271927 935
19281928 936
19291929 937
19301930 938
19311931 939
19321932 940
19331933 941
19341934 942
19351935 943
19361936 944
19371937 945
19381938 946
19391939 947
19401940 948
19411941 949
19421942 950
19431943 951
19441944 952 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
19451945 Page 35
19461946 students participating in the tax credit scholarship program
19471947 to the statewide learning gains of public school students with
19481948 socioeconomic and educational backgrounds similar to those
19491949 students participating in the tax credit scholarship program.
19501950 3. The first report under this paragraph shall be
19511951 submitted to the Department of Revenue by September 1, 2016.
19521952 Each biennial report thereafter shall be submitted to the
19531953 Department of Revenue on September 1 of the year the report is
19541954 due. All biennial reports required by this paragraph shall be
19551955 published on the website of the Department of Revenue.
19561956 4. Each scholarship granting organization shall collect
19571957 all test results from qualifying schools accepting its
19581958 scholarship recipients and turn over such test results to the
19591959 independent research organization described in this paragraph
19601960 by August 15 of each calendar year.
19611961 5. The sharing and reporting of student learning gain
19621962 data under this paragraph shall conform to the requirements of
19631963 the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, 20 U.S.C.
19641964 § 1232g., and shall be for the sole purpose of creating the
19651965 biennial report required by this paragraph. All parties shall
19661966 preserve the confidentially of such information as required by
19671967 law. The biennial report shall not disaggregate data to a
19681968 level that could identify qualifying schools participating in
19691969 the tax credit scholarship program or disclose the academic
19701970 level of individual students.
19711971 6. At the same time the biennial report under
19721972 subparagraph 2. is submitted to the Department of Revenue, it
19731973 shall be submitted to the Chair of the Senate Education Policy
19741974 953
19751975 954
19761976 955
19771977 956
19781978 957
19791979 958
19801980 959
19811981 960
19821982 961
19831983 962
19841984 963
19851985 964
19861986 965
19871987 966
19881988 967
19891989 968
19901990 969
19911991 970
19921992 971
19931993 972
19941994 973
19951995 974
19961996 975
19971997 976
19981998 977
19991999 978
20002000 979
20012001 980 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
20022002 Page 36
20032003 Committee and the Chair of the House Education Policy
20042004 Committee.
20052005 (d)(1) The Department of Revenue shall adopt rules and
20062006 procedures consistent with this section as necessary.
20072007 (2) The Department of Revenue shall provide a
20082008 standardized format for a receipt to be issued by a
20092009 scholarship granting organization to a taxpayer to indicate
20102010 the value of a contribution received. The Department of
20112011 Revenue shall require a taxpayer to provide a copy of the
20122012 receipt when claiming the tax credit pursuant to this section.
20132013 (3) The Department of Revenue shall provide a
20142014 standardized format for a scholarship granting organization to
20152015 report the information required in paragraphs k. and l. of
20162016 subdivision (1) of subsection (b).
20172017 (4) The Department of Revenue may conduct either a
20182018 financial review or audit of a scholarship granting
20192019 organization.
20202020 (5) The Department of Revenue may bar a scholarship
20212021 granting organization or a qualifying school from
20222022 participating in the tax credit scholarship program if the
20232023 Department of Revenue establishes that the scholarship
20242024 granting organization or the qualifying school has
20252025 intentionally and substantially failed to comply with the
20262026 requirements in subsection (b) or subsection (c).
20272027 (6) If the Department of Revenue decides to bar a
20282028 scholarship granting organization or a qualifying school from
20292029 the tax credit scholarship program, the Department of Revenue
20302030 shall notify affected educational scholarship students and
20312031 981
20322032 982
20332033 983
20342034 984
20352035 985
20362036 986
20372037 987
20382038 988
20392039 989
20402040 990
20412041 991
20422042 992
20432043 993
20442044 994
20452045 995
20462046 996
20472047 997
20482048 998
20492049 999
20502050 1000
20512051 1001
20522052 1002
20532053 1003
20542054 1004
20552055 1005
20562056 1006
20572057 1007
20582058 1008 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
20592059 Page 37
20602060 their parents of the decision as quickly as possible.
20612061 (7) The Department of Revenue shall publish and
20622062 routinely update, on the website of the department, a list of
20632063 scholarship granting organizations in the state, by county.
20642064 (8) The Department of Revenue shall publish and make
20652065 publicly available on its website all annual and quarterly
20662066 reports required to be filed with it by scholarship granting
20672067 organizations under paragraphs k. and l. of subdivision (1) of
20682068 subsection (b).
20692069 (e)(1) All schools participating in the tax credit
20702070 scholarship program shall be required to operate in Alabama.
20712071 (2) All schools participating in the tax credit
20722072 scholarship program shall comply with all state laws that
20732073 apply to public schools regarding criminal background checks
20742074 for employees and exclude from employment any person not
20752075 permitted by state law to work in a public school.
20762076 (3) All qualifying nonpublic schools participating in
20772077 the tax credit scholarship program shall maintain a website
20782078 that describes the school, the instructional program of the
20792079 school, and the tuition and mandatory fees charged by the
20802080 school, updated prior to the beginning of each semester.
20812081 (4) The amount of a scholarship awarded a student to
20822082 attend a nonpublic school may not exceed the total sum of
20832083 tuition and mandatory fees normally charged a student to
20842084 attend the nonpublic school for the same attendance period.
20852085 The amount of a scholarship awarded a student to attend a
20862086 public school may not exceed the total state appropriation
20872087 provided for a student to attend the public school for the
20882088 1009
20892089 1010
20902090 1011
20912091 1012
20922092 1013
20932093 1014
20942094 1015
20952095 1016
20962096 1017
20972097 1018
20982098 1019
20992099 1020
21002100 1021
21012101 1022
21022102 1023
21032103 1024
21042104 1025
21052105 1026
21062106 1027
21072107 1028
21082108 1029
21092109 1030
21102110 1031
21112111 1032
21122112 1033
21132113 1034
21142114 1035
21152115 1036 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
21162116 Page 38
21172117 same attendance period.
21182118 (f) The tax credit provided in this section may be
21192119 first claimed for the 2013 tax year, but may not be claimed
21202120 for any tax year prior to the 2013 tax year.
21212121 (g)(1) Nothing in this section shall be construed to
21222122 force any public school, school system, or school district or
21232123 any nonpublic school, school system, or school district to
21242124 enroll any student. No qualifying school may enter into any
21252125 agreement, whether oral or written, with a scholarship
21262126 granting organization that would prohibit or limit an eligible
21272127 student from enrolling in the school based on the identity of
21282128 the scholarship granting organization from which the eligible
21292129 student received an educational scholarship.
21302130 (2) A public school, school system, or school district
21312131 or any nonpublic school, school system, or school district may
21322132 develop the terms and conditions under which it will allow a
21332133 student who receives a scholarship from a scholarship granting
21342134 organization pursuant to this section to be enrolled, but such
21352135 terms and conditions may not discriminate on the basis of the
21362136 race, gender, religion, disability status, or ethnicity of the
21372137 student or of the student's parent.
21382138 (3) Nothing in this section shall be construed to
21392139 authorize the violation of or supersede the authority of any
21402140 court ruling that applies to the public school, school system,
21412141 or school district, specifically any federal court order
21422142 related to the desegregation of the local school system's
21432143 student population.
21442144 (h) Nothing in this chapter shall affect or change the
21452145 1037
21462146 1038
21472147 1039
21482148 1040
21492149 1041
21502150 1042
21512151 1043
21522152 1044
21532153 1045
21542154 1046
21552155 1047
21562156 1048
21572157 1049
21582158 1050
21592159 1051
21602160 1052
21612161 1053
21622162 1054
21632163 1055
21642164 1056
21652165 1057
21662166 1058
21672167 1059
21682168 1060
21692169 1061
21702170 1062
21712171 1063
21722172 1064 HB31 INTRODUCEDHB31 INTRODUCED
21732173 Page 39
21742174 athletic eligibility rules of student athletes governed by the
21752175 Alabama High School Athletic Association or similar
21762176 association."
21772177 Section 2. Commencing on the effective date of this
21782178 act, the State Board of Education shall refer to any public
21792179 K-12 school or school district that is determined to have poor
21802180 performance or is failing to make adequate progress as a fully
21812181 supported school, in lieu of a failing school, and shall refer
21822182 to a nonfailing school as a non-fully supported school, when
21832183 amending rules or adopting rules.
21842184 Section 3. This act shall become effective on the first
21852185 day of the third month following its passage and approval by
21862186 the Governor, or its otherwise becoming law.
21872187 1065
21882188 1066
21892189 1067
21902190 1068
21912191 1069
21922192 1070
21932193 1071
21942194 1072
21952195 1073
21962196 1074
21972197 1075
21982198 1076
21992199 1077