Arizona 2022 Regular Session

Arizona Senate Bill SCR1042

Caption

Commission on appellate court appointments

Impact

The amendment seeks to improve the appointment process of appellate court judges in Arizona by involving both attorney and non-attorney members in a structured manner. Attorney members will be nominated through the state bar and will serve staggered four-year terms, while non-attorney members will be appointed by various legislative leaders and will also represent diverse viewpoints. The structure of the commission ensures that political affiliations do not skew the selection process, aiming for an impartial judicial system.

Summary

SCR1042 proposes an amendment to Article VI, Section 36 of the Arizona Constitution to establish a nonpartisan commission focused on appellate court appointments. This commission would include members from diverse backgrounds, ensuring a representation that mirrors the state's population. The intent is to create a system of appointments that minimizes political influence and emphasizes merit-based selections. This amendment reflects a movement towards increasing transparency and public involvement in judicial nominations.

Contention

While proponents of SCR1042 argue that it enhances the judicial appointment process by fostering diversity and reducing political clout, opponents may raise concerns regarding the complexities of having multiple appointing authorities and the potential for disagreements among commission members. Another point of contention could revolve around whether the existing processes are sufficient or if such a significant change is warranted to address issues of judicial independence and political influence.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

AZ SCR1026

Appointment commissions; membership

CO HB1298

Judicial Performance Commissions

SC H3486

Student and Administration Equality Act

AZ HCR2017

Constitutional property tax exemptions; consolidation

AZ SCR1044

Judicial retention elections

AZ HCR2018

Judges; merit selection; population

IN HB1479

Student disciplinary proceedings.

CT HB05263

An Act Permitting A Nonattorney Sole Shareholder Of A Corporation Or A Nonattorney Sole Member Of A Limited Liability Company To Represent Such Corporation Or Company In A Legal Proceeding.