Arizona 2023 Regular Session

Arizona House Bill HB2189

Caption

Textbooks; adverse representation; prohibition

Impact

The bill amends existing statutes to enhance the accountability of school districts regarding educational materials. By ensuring that textbooks undergo a rigorous approval process, the bill seeks to foster an inclusive educational environment. However, it could also lead to challenges regarding defining what constitutes 'adverse representation,' potentially leading to limitations on diverse content that educators wish to include in their curricula.

Summary

House Bill 2189 addresses the selection and approval process for textbooks used in Arizona's common and high schools, specifically aiming to prohibit the inclusion of any instructional materials that reflect adversely on individuals based on their race, ethnicity, sex, religion, disability, nationality, sexual orientation, or gender identity. The bill mandates that the governing boards of school districts enforce a strict approval process for textbooks, which includes public transparency and community input.

Contention

Debate surrounding HB 2189 has surfaced some concern regarding academic freedom and the representation of diverse perspectives in education. Critics argue that the bill's stringent measures may inadvertently censor materials that address critical social issues or historical contexts relevant to minority groups. Proponents, however, contend that it is crucial to protect students from materials that could perpetuate stereotypes or bias.

Summary_narrative

Ultimately, HB 2189 represents an intersection of educational policy and social equity, seeking to align state educational standards with a more equitable representation in school curricula. It reflects an ongoing dialogue about the role of education in promoting diversity and the responsibilities of educational institutions in choosing appropriate materials for student learning.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

AZ SB1380

Textbooks; adverse representation; prohibition.

AZ HB2566

Firearm regulation; prohibition; repeal

AZ HCR2021

Schools; English language learners; requirements

AZ HB2420

Schools; corporal punishment; prohibition

AZ HCR2043

Expenditure limitation; school districts

AZ HB2761

Citizenship status; licensure; documentation

AZ HB2170

Full-day kindergarten students; ADM

AZ HB2363

Study committee; educator health insurance

AZ HB2757

Appropriations; Arizona Holocaust education center

AZ HB2863

School facilities; replacement; renovation; funding

Similar Bills

AZ SB1549

Textbooks; adverse representation; prohibition.

AZ SB1380

Textbooks; adverse representation; prohibition.

AZ SB1479

Textbooks; adverse representation; prohibition

AZ HB2439

School library; review; policy

AZ HB2535

Schools; curricula; website; posting

TX SB6

Relating to the foundation curriculum, the establishment of the instructional materials allotment, and the adoption, review, and purchase of instructional materials and technological equipment for public schools.

TX HB6

Relating to the foundation curriculum, the establishment of the instructional materials allotment, and the adoption, review, and purchase of instructional materials and technological equipment for public schools.

AZ SB1540

Textbooks; representation; disabilities; sexual orientation