Arizona 2023 Regular Session

Arizona House Bill HR2003 Compare Versions

Version 1 (Old)

Version 2 (New)

Old	New		Differences
1	1		House Engrossed Liz Harris; expulsion State of Arizona House of Representatives Fifty-sixth Legislature First Regular Session 2023 HOUSE RESOLUTION 2003 A Resolution expelling representative liz harris from the ARizona house of representatives. (TEXT OF BILL BEGINS ON NEXT PAGE)
	2	+
	3	+
	4	+
	5	+
2	6
3	7
4	8
5	9		House Engrossed Liz Harris; expulsion
6	10		State of Arizona House of Representatives Fifty-sixth Legislature First Regular Session 2023
7	11		HOUSE RESOLUTION 2003
8	12
9	13		House Engrossed
10	14
11	15
12	16
13	17		Liz Harris; expulsion
	18	+
	19	+
14	20
15	21
16	22
17	23
18	24
19	25
20	26
21	27		State of Arizona
22	28
23	29		House of Representatives
24	30
25	31		Fifty-sixth Legislature
26	32
27	33		First Regular Session
28	34
29	35		2023
30	36
31	37
32	38
33	39
34	40
35	41
36	42
37	43		HOUSE RESOLUTION 2003
	44	+
	45	+
	46	+
	47	+
	48	+
	49	+
	50	+
	51	+
	52	+
	53	+
	54	+
	55	+
	56	+
	57	+
38	58
39	59
40	60
41	61
42	62
43	63		A Resolution
44	64
45	65
46	66
47	67		expelling representative liz harris from the ARizona house of representatives.
48	68
49	69
50	70
51	71
52	72
53	73		(TEXT OF BILL BEGINS ON NEXT PAGE)
54	74
55	75
56	76
57	77		Whereas, on February 23, 2023, at the request and organization of Representative Liz Harris, the House and Senate Special Joint Elections Committee held a Special Joint Hearing ("Joint Hearing") relating to election integrity, which consisted of presentations by various individuals. At this Joint Hearing, Jacqueline Breger, a member of the public, purported to present "findings" of an investigation that alleged the existence of numerous schemes within Arizona, including money laundering, drug trafficking and sales, public corruption, bribing of public officials and election fraud; and Whereas, Ms. Breger presented information and distributed materials at the Joint Hearing that she claimed showed this alleged criminal activity to have been overseen by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints and committed by various private citizens, government employees, and appointed and elected officials, including current Arizona legislators; and Whereas, on March 6, 2023, Representative Stephanie Stahl Hamilton filed a complaint against Representative Liz Harris in connection with the Joint Hearing and in particular Ms. Breger's presentation. The complaint alleged that Representative Harris personally invited Ms. Breger to present at the Joint Hearing and, in so doing, not only brought "disrepute and embarrassment to the House of Representatives" but also "allowed the impugning of other members" in violation of House Rule 1. The complaint requested that the House of Representatives Committee on Ethics ("Ethics Committee") investigate Representative Harris's actions; and Whereas, the Ethics Committee formally convened on March 23, 2023, and on March 30, 2023, the Ethics Committee held an evidentiary hearing at which various relevant exhibits and Representative Harris's testimony were considered; and Whereas, on April 11, 2023, the Ethics Committee issued its report, which unanimously concluded that Representative Harris committed disorderly behavior, thereby violating Rule 1 of the Rules of the Arizona House of Representatives and damaging the institutional integrity of the House; and Whereas, specifically, the Ethics Committee found that Ms. Breger made criminal allegations during the Joint Hearing, which was an inappropriate venue for such serious claims; and Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris knew or was aware that Ms. Breger would present these criminal allegations at the Joint Hearing; and Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris failed to comply with internal House of Representatives deadlines requiring disclosure of presentation materials in advance of the Joint Hearing; and Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris was not surprised or upset by the information revealed in Ms. Breger's presentation; and Whereas, the Ethics Committee found that, as the primary organizer of the Joint Hearing and the Acting Vice Chair during Ms. Breger's presentation, Representative Harris violated the inherent obligation to protect the integrity of the House of Representatives and used her elected position to provide Ms. Breger with a legislative platform as a substitute for a criminal court; and Whereas, the members of the Ethics Committee unanimously found the fact-intensive evidence to show that Representative Harris engaged in disorderly behavior in violation of House Rule 1, thereby eroding the public trust in the legislative process, and that it was appropriate for the House of Representatives as a whole to determine what, if any, disciplinary measures should be taken; and Whereas, on April 12, 2023, the members of the full House of Representatives adopted the Report of the Ethics Committee as the findings of the House of Representatives. Therefore Be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the State of Arizona: 1. That the Members of the House of Representatives find that Representative Liz Harris violated House of Representatives Rule 1 and engaged in disorderly behavior. 2. That Representative Liz Harris's conduct relating to the February 23, 2023 Joint Hearing of the House and Senate Special Joint Elections Committee undermined the public's confidence in this institution and violated the order and decorum necessary to complete the people's work in the State of Arizona. 3. That in the exercise of the power granted to the House of Representatives by Article IV, part 2, section 11, Constitution of Arizona, the House of Representatives, with the concurrence of two-thirds of its members, hereby condemns the actions of Representative Liz Harris and expels her from the Arizona House of Representatives. 4. That the seat of the member of the House of Representatives, legislative district 13, occupied by Liz Harris, is now vacant.
58	78
59	79		Whereas, on February 23, 2023, at the request and organization of Representative Liz Harris, the House and Senate Special Joint Elections Committee held a Special Joint Hearing ("Joint Hearing") relating to election integrity, which consisted of presentations by various individuals. At this Joint Hearing, Jacqueline Breger, a member of the public, purported to present "findings" of an investigation that alleged the existence of numerous schemes within Arizona, including money laundering, drug trafficking and sales, public corruption, bribing of public officials and election fraud; and
60	80
61	81		Whereas, Ms. Breger presented information and distributed materials at the Joint Hearing that she claimed showed this alleged criminal activity to have been overseen by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints and committed by various private citizens, government employees, and appointed and elected officials, including current Arizona legislators; and
62	82
63	83		Whereas, on March 6, 2023, Representative Stephanie Stahl Hamilton filed a complaint against Representative Liz Harris in connection with the Joint Hearing and in particular Ms. Breger's presentation. The complaint alleged that Representative Harris personally invited Ms. Breger to present at the Joint Hearing and, in so doing, not only brought "disrepute and embarrassment to the House of Representatives" but also "allowed the impugning of other members" in violation of House Rule 1. The complaint requested that the House of Representatives Committee on Ethics ("Ethics Committee") investigate Representative Harris's actions; and
64	84
65	85		Whereas, the Ethics Committee formally convened on March 23, 2023, and on March 30, 2023, the Ethics Committee held an evidentiary hearing at which various relevant exhibits and Representative Harris's testimony were considered; and
66	86
67	87		Whereas, on April 11, 2023, the Ethics Committee issued its report, which unanimously concluded that Representative Harris committed disorderly behavior, thereby violating Rule 1 of the Rules of the Arizona House of Representatives and damaging the institutional integrity of the House; and
68	88
69	89		Whereas, specifically, the Ethics Committee found that Ms. Breger made criminal allegations during the Joint Hearing, which was an inappropriate venue for such serious claims; and
70	90
71	91		Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris knew or was aware that Ms. Breger would present these criminal allegations at the Joint Hearing; and
72	92
73	93		Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris failed to comply with internal House of Representatives deadlines requiring disclosure of presentation materials in advance of the Joint Hearing; and
74	94
75	95		Whereas, the Ethics Committee also found that Representative Harris was not surprised or upset by the information revealed in Ms. Breger's presentation; and
76	96
77	97		Whereas, the Ethics Committee found that, as the primary organizer of the Joint Hearing and the Acting Vice Chair during Ms. Breger's presentation, Representative Harris violated the inherent obligation to protect the integrity of the House of Representatives and used her elected position to provide Ms. Breger with a legislative platform as a substitute for a criminal court; and
78	98
79	99		Whereas, the members of the Ethics Committee unanimously found the fact-intensive evidence to show that Representative Harris engaged in disorderly behavior in violation of House Rule 1, thereby eroding the public trust in the legislative process, and that it was appropriate for the House of Representatives as a whole to determine what, if any, disciplinary measures should be taken; and
80	100
81	101		Whereas, on April 12, 2023, the members of the full House of Representatives adopted the Report of the Ethics Committee as the findings of the House of Representatives.
82	102
83	103		Therefore
84	104
85	105		Be it resolved by the House of Representatives of the State of Arizona:
86	106
87	107		1. That the Members of the House of Representatives find that Representative Liz Harris violated House of Representatives Rule 1 and engaged in disorderly behavior.
88	108
89	109		2. That Representative Liz Harris's conduct relating to the February 23, 2023 Joint Hearing of the House and Senate Special Joint Elections Committee undermined the public's confidence in this institution and violated the order and decorum necessary to complete the people's work in the State of Arizona.
90	110
91	111		3. That in the exercise of the power granted to the House of Representatives by Article IV, part 2, section 11, Constitution of Arizona, the House of Representatives, with the concurrence of two-thirds of its members, hereby condemns the actions of Representative Liz Harris and expels her from the Arizona House of Representatives.
92	112
93	113		4. That the seat of the member of the House of Representatives, legislative district 13, occupied by Liz Harris, is now vacant.
94		-
95		-	PASSED BY THE HOUSE APRIL 12, 2023. FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE APRIL 12, 2023.
96		-
97		-
98		-
99		-
100		-
101		-
102		-
103		-	PASSED BY THE HOUSE APRIL 12, 2023.
104		-
105		-
106		-
107		-	FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE APRIL 12, 2023.