Arizona Senate Bill SR1002

Arizona 2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/5/24

Caption

Article V; recall and sanctions

Impact

If enacted, SR1002 will significantly influence the mechanisms by which Arizona engages with the process of constitutional amendments. The requirement for commissioners to take an oath pledging to vote according to the instructions of the voters at a ratification convention aims to enhance accountability and prevent the adoption of 'runaway amendments'—those that stray from the original application or legislative instructions. This aligns with efforts to ensure citizens have more control over the constitutional amendment process, addressing past concerns that amendments could be detached from the voters' intentions.

Summary

SR1002 is a legislative resolution introduced in Arizona, focusing on the requirements for commissioners attending an article V convention. The resolution outlines a process for selecting these commissioners, emphasizing the necessity of bipartisan involvement from Arizona's legislative leadership. It aims to formalize the role of the commissioners who are responsible for either proposing amendments to the United States Constitution or participating in the ratification of such amendments. The intent of this resolution is to ensure that commissioners represent the will of the people and adhere strictly to the directives provided by the state legislature and the voters.

Contention

The resolution also includes penalties for commissioners who violate their oaths, which has sparked discussions about the implications for political accountability and the overall dynamics of how legislative instructions might be interpreted. Supporters argue that these provisions will foster a more responsible selection process for commissioners and prevent potential political machinations during the amendment process. However, critics express concerns that imposing strict penalties could deter qualified individuals from serving and may lead to political conflicts regarding what constitutes a 'runaway amendment.'