The bill mandates the creation of the position of Director of In-Custody Death Review within the Board of State and Community Corrections, who will oversee investigations of death incidents in detention facilities. This director will make recommendations for policy changes and improvements related to medical and behavioral health services in these facilities. Following this, the sheriffs or administrators of local detention facilities must respond to the director's recommendations and outline implementation plans, enhancing accountability within local correctional systems.
Senate Bill 519, introduced by Senator Atkins, amends California's Penal Code to enhance the transparency and accountability regarding death incidents in local detention facilities. Starting July 1, 2024, the bill requires that investigations into any deaths occurring in custody be made available for public inspection. This provision creates a notable shift by making such sensitive information publicly accessible, counter to existing privacy protections for police and custodial personnel records. This move aims to balance the public's right to know with the need for confidentiality during ongoing investigations.
The sentiment surrounding SB 519 appears to be mixed, with proponents advocating for increased transparency and accountability in the wake of rising concerns about in-custody deaths and the treatment of inmates. Detractors express concerns regarding the potential implications for the confidentiality of personnel records and the operational difficulties local facilities may face in meeting the newly imposed requirements. The discussions highlight the ongoing tension between public accountability and the operational realities of detention facilities.
Notably, the bill faces contention regarding its potential to impose additional burdens on local governments, particularly concerning the costs associated with implementing the recommendations made by the new director. Furthermore, there are concerns about the adequacy of resources to meet the demands for hiring licensed medical and mental health professionals to ensure compliance with the new standards set forth by the legislation.