California 2023-2024 Regular Session

California Senate Bill SB625

Introduced
2/16/23  
Refer
3/1/23  
Report Pass
4/20/23  
Report Pass
4/20/23  
Refer
4/24/23  
Refer
4/24/23  
Refer
1/3/24  
Refer
1/3/24  
Report Pass
1/11/24  
Refer
1/11/24  
Refer
1/11/24  
Refer
1/11/24  
Refer
1/11/24  
Failed
2/1/24  

Caption

Newborn screening: genetic diseases: blood samples collected.

Impact

If passed, SB 625 would significantly shift the existing framework regarding how newborn screening blood samples are handled. The bill prohibits releasing any residual specimens for law enforcement purposes, addressing privacy concerns. It mandates that parents receive comprehensive information about their rights related to consent for the retention and use of blood samples and outlines a clear process for parents to request the destruction or non-use of their child's samples in research. The bill obligates the State Department of Public Health to prepare and provide clear informational materials by specified deadlines to ensure that parents are well-informed.

Summary

Senate Bill 625, introduced by Senator Nguyen, focuses on amending existing laws concerning newborn screening programs related to genetic diseases in California. It seeks to enhance parental control over newborn blood samples collected during screening, allowing parents and guardians to refuse consent for the storage and retention of these samples for medical research. This reflects an increasing emphasis on patient rights and parental consent in healthcare practices, particularly concerning sensitive medical data of newborns.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 625 appears to be largely positive among advocates for parental rights and medical privacy. Supporters argue that it empowers parents by giving them more control over their child's medical data. Conversely, there are concerns that such legislation might hinder medical research initiatives that rely on genetic testing and blood samples, as the limits on specimen retention could reduce the available data for studies on genetic diseases. Thus, while many view the bill as a necessary step towards safeguarding the rights of families, others caution that it could impede advancements in genetic research.

Contention

Notable points of contention around SB 625 revolve around the balance between parental rights and the needs of medical research. While proponents argue for enhanced parental control, detractors suggest that the restrictions placed on the use of blood samples could negatively impact research into genetic disorders and development of treatments. Additionally, the legislation imposes new duties on health facilities regarding the informational brochures that need to be provided, which some may view as an additional administrative burden. Addressing these concerns will be crucial in gaining broader support for the bill.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

MI SB0953

Health: screening; newborn hearing screening for congenital cytomegalovirus; require. Amends sec. 5431 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.5431) & adds sec. 5433.

MI HB4402

Health: diseases; dissemination of information about cytomegalovirus (CMV) to certain individuals and in certain situations; provide for. Amends secs. 5431 & 5432 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.5431 & 333.5432) & adds sec. 5143.

MI HB5140

Health: diseases; dissemination of information about cytomegalovirus (CMV) to certain individuals and in certain situations; provide for. Amends secs. 5431 & 5432 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.5431 & 333.5432) & adds sec. 5143.

MI HB5314

Health: screening; Krabbe disease; include in list of disorders and diseases screened for at birth. Amends sec. 5431 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.5431).

MI HB4078

Health: screening; gene screening for MTHFR for newborns; require, and require department to provide certain notices. Amends sec. 5431 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.5431) & adds sec. 5431a. TIE BAR WITH: HB 4049'23

FL H1441

Department of Health

CA AB2326

Lead poisoning prevention: laboratory reporting.

CA SB1094

Sexual assault: medical evidentiary examinations.