First Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO REVISED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted on Second Reading in the Second House LLS NO. 23-0427.01 Amber Paoloemilio x5497 HOUSE BILL23-1027 House Committees Senate Committees Judiciary Judiciary Appropriations Appropriations A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING FAMILY TIME PROVID ED PURSUANT TO THE CHILDREN 'S101 CODE, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH, MAKING AN102 APPROPRIATION.103 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) The bill defines "family time", changes the term "visitation" to "family time" in various places in statute, creates new requirements for determinations in dependency and neglect court proceedings, and requires the task force on high-quality family time (task force) to commission and evaluate a state study. Specifically during a dependency and neglect SENATE 2nd Reading Unamended April 20, 2023 HOUSE 3rd Reading Unamended March 13, 2023 HOUSE Amended 2nd Reading March 11, 2023 HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Joseph and Weissman, Bradley, English, Marshall, Velasco, Amabile, Bacon, Bockenfeld, Boesenecker, Brown, Dickson, Duran, Epps, Froelich, Garcia, Hamrick, Kipp, Lieder, Lindsay, Lindstedt, Mabrey, Martinez, McCluskie, McLachlan, Michaelson Jenet, Ricks, Sharbini, Soper, Story, Taggart, Titone, Valdez, Weinberg, Willford, Woodrow, Young SENATE SPONSORSHIP Winter F., Marchman Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. proceeding, the bill: ! Requires county departments of human or social services (county departments) to encourage maximum family time; ! Allows the court and the state department of human services (department) to rely on community resources, foster parents, or relatives to provide transportation or supervision for family time; ! Creates a presumption that supervised family time is supervised by relatives, kin, foster parents, or other supports (supports) and occurs in the community. This presumption can be rebutted if the health or safety of the child is at risk or if these supports are unavailable or unwilling to provide supervision. ! Limits the court's ability to restrict or deny family time to situations in which the child's safety or mental, physical, or emotional health is at risk; ! Requires the court to order family time in the least restrictive setting; ! Requires county departments to provide information to the court about proposed family time and participation in family time; ! Requires family time to occur at least every 7 days unless the child's safety or mental, physical, or emotional health is at risk; ! Prohibits the court or department from limiting family time as a sanction for the parent's failure to comply with court-ordered treatment plans so long as the child's safety or mental, physical, or emotional health is not at risk; ! Prohibits the court, department, parent, or support from limiting family time as a sanction for the child's behavior or as an incentive to improve the child's behavior; and ! Gives the department the authority to promulgate rules to implement the provisions. The bill also: ! Extends the task force by one year; ! Requires the task force to commission and evaluate a statewide study to identify the strengths and needs for family time; identify growth areas; inventory funding sources; and make recommendations; and ! Requires a permanency hearing be held within 12 months after a child enters foster care. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 1027-2- SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly1 finds and declares that:2 (a) Family time is essential for healthy child development,3 especially for children or youth placed outside of the home. Family time4 supports parent-child attachment, reduces a child's sense of abandonment,5 reduces traumatic impact of separation and removal, preserves6 connections with siblings and extended family, and preserves a sense of7 family and community belonging. Family time enriches the family,8 including the child and the parent. Early, consistent, and frequent family9 time is crucial for maintaining parent-child relationships, facilitating safe10 reunification of parents and children, and maintaining family connections.11 Regular, meaningful family time increases the chance of sustained12 reunification, improves emotional well-being, provides opportunities to13 strengthen cultural and kinship connections, and enhances personal14 engagement.15 (b) Colorado lacks statewide data on the frequency and duration16 of supervised family time as well as the availability of family time17 services throughout the state. Counties do not have a consistent funding18 mechanism for the provision of family time services, even though these19 services are required by law, are essential to the successful reunification20 of families, and service providers contracted to provide these services21 often lack sufficient funding. In addition, transportation and lack of staff22 present significant barriers to providing consistent and high-quality23 supervised family time services.24 (c) For these reasons, it is important to determine how regions of25 the state can effectively and efficiently fund high-quality family time26 services that reunify families.27 1027 -3- (2) Therefore, the general assembly finds it necessary to conduct1 a statewide study of best practices and funding models to provide and2 increase capacity for high-quality family time services. The general3 assembly also adopts the recommendations of the task force on4 high-quality family time to modernize language throughout the children's5 code and establish clear and consistent standards for family time6 throughout the state.7 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-1-103, add (64.5)8 as follows:9 19-1-103. Definitions. As used in this title 19 or in the specified10 portion of this title 19, unless the context otherwise requires:11 (64.5) "F AMILY TIME" MEANS ANY FORM OF CONTACT OR12 ENGAGEMENT BETWEEN PARENTS , LEGAL CUSTODIANS, GUARDIANS,13 SIBLINGS, AND CHILDREN OR YOUTH FOR THE PURPOSES OF PRESERVING14 AND STRENGTHENING FAMILY TIES .15 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-208, amend16 (2)(b)(IV) as follows:17 19-3-208. Services - county required to provide - out-of-home18 placement options - rules - definitions. (2) (b) The following services19 must be available and provided, as determined necessary and appropriate20 by individual case plans:21 (IV) Visitation FAMILY TIME services for parents with children or22 youth in out-of-home placement;23 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-217, amend (1),24 (3), and (4); and add (1.5), (5), and (6) as follows: 25 19-3-217. Family time upon removal - rules. (1) At any hearing26 held pursuant to section 19-3-403 (2) or (3.5), the court shall enter27 1027 -4- temporary orders for reasonable visitation FAMILY TIME with the child's1 OR YOUTH'S parent that is consistent with the age and developmental2 needs of a child OR YOUTH if the court finds that visitation is in a child's3 OR YOUTH'S best interests. The court shall order contact between the4 parent and child OR YOUTH, which contact may include, but is not limited5 to, telephone, virtual, or in-person visits, commencing within seventy-two6 hours after any hearing pursuant to section 19-3-403 (2) or (3.5),7 excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and any court holiday. The court may8 authorize an extension of time for contact to commence if the delay is9 agreed upon by the parent, county department, and guardian ad litem or10 if the court finds that a delay in contact is in the child's OR YOUTH'S best11 interests.12 (1.5) W HEN A CHILD OR YOUTH IS PLACED OUT OF THE HOME , THE13 FOLLOWING CONSIDERATIONS APPLY WHEN MAKING DECISIONS14 REGARDING FAMILY TIME:15 (a) T HE COUNTY DEPARTMENT SHALL ENCOURAGE THE MAXIMUM16 PARENT, CHILD, AND SIBLING CONTACT POSSIBLE, INCLUDING REGULAR17 FAMILY TIME AND PARTICIPATION BY THE PARENTS IN THE CARE OF THE18 CHILD OR YOUTH, WHEN IT IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD OR19 YOUTH. THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT SHALL ENCOURAGE PARENTAL20 ATTENDANCE AND PARTICIPATION IN THE CHILD 'S OR YOUTH'S LIFE, SUCH21 AS SCHOOL, EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES, AND MEDICAL APPOINTMENTS,22 WHEN IT IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD OR YOUTH.23 (b) T HE COURT AND THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT MAY RELY ON24 INFORMAL RESOURCES SUCH AS COMMUNITY MEMBERS , RELATIVES, OR KIN25 TO PROVIDE TRANSPORTATION AND SUPERVISION FOR FAMILY TIME IF26 THOSE RESOURCES ARE AVAILABLE , APPROPRIATE, AND DO NOT27 1027 -5- COMPROMISE THE CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S MENTAL, EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL1 HEALTH OR SAFETY.2 3 (c) (I) THERE IS A PRESUMPTION THAT SUPERVISED FAMILY TIME4 MUST:5 (A) B E SUPERVISED BY INFORMAL SUPPORTS IDENTIFIED BY THE6FAMILY WHO VOLUNTEER TO SUPERVISE FAMILY TIME, INCLUDING7 RELATIVES, OR OTHER PERSONS IDENTIFIED BY THE FAMILY; AND8 (B) O CCUR IN THE COMMUNITY, A HOMELIKE ENVIRONMENT , OR9 OTHER AGREED-UPON LOCATION.10 (II) T HE PRESUMPTION DESCRIBED IN SUBSECTION (1.5)(d)(I) OF11 THIS SECTION MAY BE REBUTTED IF THE COURT FINDS THAT THE CHILD 'S OR12 YOUTH'S SAFETY OR MENTAL, EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL HEALTH REQUIRES13 PROFESSIONAL SUPERVISION OR THAT RELATIVES , OR OTHER FAMILY14 SUPPORTS ARE UNAVAILABLE OR UNWILLING TO PROVIDE SUPERVISION15 AFTER THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT HAS EXERCISED DUE DILIGENCE TO16 CONTACT AND ENGAGE THE RELATIVES , KIN, OR OTHER FAMILY17 SUPPORTS. NOTHING IN THIS SECTION PRECLUDES SUPPLEMENTAL18 PROFESSIONALLY COACHED OR SUPERVISED FAMILY TIME TO IMPROVE19 PARENTING SKILLS.20 (d) THE COURT MAY ONLY RESTRICT OR DENY FAMILY TIME IF IT IS21 NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE CHILD 'S OR YOUTH'S SAFETY OR MENTAL,22 EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL HEALTH. THE COURT SHALL ORDER FAMILY23 TIME IN THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE SETTING AND SUPERVISION AT THE LEAST24 RESTRICTIVE LEVEL TO SATISFY THE CHILD 'S OR YOUTH'S SAFETY OR25 MENTAL, EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL HEALTH.26 (e) (I) AT THE FIRST HEARING THAT OCCURS AFTER THE27 1027 -6- EMERGENCY HEARING REQUIRED PURSUANT TO SECTION 19-3-403, OR NO1 LATER THAN THIRTY DAYS AFTER THE REMOVAL DATE , THE COUNTY2 DEPARTMENT SHALL PROVIDE THE COURT WITH A PROPOSED FAMILY TIME3 PLAN ON THE RECORD, INCLUDING:4 (A) F REQUENCY AND LENGTH ;5 (B) P ERSONS WHO MAY BE PRESENT ;6 (C) W HETHER THE FAMILY TIME MUST BE SUPERVISED ; AND7 (D) T HE CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S OPPORTUNITY TO COMMUNICATE8 WITH A PARENT, SIBLING, OR OTHER RELATIVE.9 (II) F OR GOOD CAUSE, OR BY AGREEMENT BY THE PARTIES , THE10 COURT MAY WAIVE THE REQUIREMENT TO PROVIDE OR EXTEND THE TIME11 FOR PROVIDING THE FAMILY TIME PLAN DESCRIBED IN SUBSECTION12 (1.5)(f)(I) OF THIS SECTION. A LACK OF STAFF OR FINANCIAL RESOURCES13 IS NOT GOOD CAUSE. ANY SUBSEQUENT WRITTEN FAMILY SERVICES PLAN14 SUBMITTED TO THE COURT PURSUANT TO SECTION 19-3-507 OR 19-3-70215 MUST INCLUDE AN UPDATE ON PARTICIPATION IN AND PROVISION OF16 FAMILY TIME AND BARRIERS TO EXPANDING FAMILY TIME .17 18 (f) THE COURT OR THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT SHALL NOT LIMIT19 FAMILY TIME AS A SANCTION FOR A PARENT 'S FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH20 COURT ORDERS OR SERVICES IF THE CHILD 'S OR YOUTH'S SAFETY OR21 MENTAL, EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL HEALTH IS NOT AT RISK AS A RESULT22 OF THE FAMILY TIME.23 (g) THE COURT, THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT , THE PARENT, OR24 OTHER SUPPORT SHALL NOT LIMIT FAMILY TIME OR CONTACT BETWEEN A25 CHILD OR YOUTH AND THE CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S PARENT OR SIBLING AS A26 SANCTION FOR THE CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S BEHAVIOR OR AS AN INCENTIVE TO27 1027 -7- CHANGE THE CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S BEHAVIOR.1 (h) THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT AND THE COURT SHALL CONSIDER2 A PARENT'S PREFERENCES WHEN DETERMINING SUPERVISION, LOCATION,3 AND TIMING OF FAMILY TIME.4 (i) THE COUNTY DEPARTMENT AND THE COURT SHALL CONSIDER5 A CHILD'S OR YOUTH'S PREFERENCES WHEN DETERMINING SUPERVISION,6 LOCATION, AND TIMING OF FAMILY.7 (3) Absent the issuance of an emergency order, a parent granted8 visitation FAMILY TIME is entitled to a hearing prior to an ongoing9 reduction in, suspension of, or increase in the level of supervision,10 including a change from in-person visitation FAMILY TIME to virtual11 visitation FAMILY TIME. If the court issues an emergency order12 suspending, reducing, or restricting visitation FAMILY TIME, a parent is13 entitled to a hearing within seventy-two hours after the order is issued,14 excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and court holidays. The court need not15 hold a hearing if there is agreement by the petitioner, guardian ad litem16 or counsel for youth, and parent to the reduction, suspension, or increase17 in level of supervision of visits FAMILY TIME. Any such agreement must18 be reduced to writing and filed with the court. Nothing in this section19 prevents the county department from canceling a visit SCHEDULED FAMILY20 TIME if the child's health or welfare OR YOUTH'S SAFETY OR MENTAL,21 EMOTIONAL, OR PHYSICAL HEALTH would be endangered or if the parent22 consents to the cancellation of the visit FAMILY TIME.23 (4) Nothing in this section requires or permits a county department24 to arrange a visit FAMILY TIME if the visit FAMILY TIME would violate an25 existing protection order in any case pending in this state or any other26 state. The county department is not required to produce a child OR YOUTH27 1027 -8- for court-ordered visitation FAMILY TIME if the visitation FAMILY TIME is1 made impossible due to the policies of a facility where the parent is2 incarcerated or in treatment.3 (5) A PERSON'S INCLUSION IN FAMILY TIME DOES NOT CONFER4 RIGHTS NOT OTHERWISE GRANTED BY LAW , INCLUDING THE RIGHT TO5 APPEAL DENIAL OF PARTICIPATION IN FAMILY TIME .6 (6) T HE STATE BOARD OF HUMAN SERVICES SHALL PROMULGATE7 RULES IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION .8 SECTION 5. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-904, add (5) as9 follows:10 19-3-904. Task force - purposes - issues to study - written11 reports. (5) O N OR BEFORE DECEMBER 1, 2024, THE TASK FORCE SHALL12 COMMISSION AND EVALUATE A STATEWIDE STUDY TO :13 (a) I DENTIFY THE CURRENT STRENGTHS AND NEEDS FOR PROVIDING14 HIGH-QUALITY SUPERVISED FAMILY TIME SERVICES ACROSS THE STATE ;15 (b) I DENTIFY NECESSARY MEASURES TO BUILD CAPACITY TO16 PROVIDE HIGH- QUALITY SUPERVISED FAMILY TIME SERVICES ACROSS THE17 STATE;18 (c) I NVENTORY CURRENT FUNDING SOURCES AND ALLOWABLE19 COSTS FOR PROVIDING SUCH SERVICES; AND20 (d) M AKE RECOMMENDATIONS REGARDING BEST PRACTICES FOR21 FUNDING HIGH-QUALITY PARENTING TIME. THE TASK FORCE SHALL22 PROVIDE THE STUDY AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE TASK FORCE TO THE23 GOVERNOR; THE STATE DEPARTMENT ; THE CHILD WELFARE TRAINING24 ACADEMY; THE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE ; AND THE HOUSE OF25 REPRESENTATIVES PUBLIC AND BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND HUMAN26 SERVICES COMMITTEE AND THE SENATE HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES27 1027 -9- COMMITTEE, OR ANY SUCCESSOR COMMITTEES .1 SECTION 6. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-1-107, amend2 (2.5) as follows:3 19-1-107. Social study and other reports. (2.5) For purposes of4 determining the appropriate treatment plan in connection with the5 disposition of a child who is under six years of age at the time a petition6 is filed in accordance with section 19-3-501 (2), the report shall include7 a list of services available to families that are specific to the needs of the8 child and the child's family and that are available in the community where9 the family resides. The report shall establish a priority of the services if10 multiple services are recommended. The services may include, but are not11 limited to, transportation services, visitation FAMILY TIME services,12 psychological counseling, drug screening and treatment programs,13 marriage and family counseling, parenting classes, housing and day care14 assistance, and homemaker services.15 SECTION 7. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-1-114, amend16 (2)(a) and (2)(b) as follows:17 19-1-114. Order of protection. (2) The order of protection may18 require any such person:19 (a) To stay away from a child or his A CHILD'S residence;20 (b) To permit a parent to visit a child at stated periods COMPLY21 WITH A FAMILY TIME SCHEDULE;22 SECTION 8. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-1-115, amend (6)23 introductory portion, (6)(d), (6.5) introductory portion, and (6.5)(c) as24 follows:25 19-1-115. Legal custody - guardianship - placement out of the26 home - petition for review for need of placement. (6) Any time the27 1027 -10- court enters an order awarding legal custody of a child OR YOUTH to the1 department of human services or to a county department pursuant to the2 provisions of this title TITLE 19, even temporarily, said THE order shall3 MUST contain specific findings, if warranted by the evidence, as follows:4 (d) That procedural safeguards with respect to parental rights have5 been applied in connection with the removal of the child OR YOUTH from6 the home, a change in the child's OR YOUTH'S placement out of the home,7 and any determination affecting parental visitation FAMILY TIME.8 (6.5) Any time the court enters an order continuing a child OR9 YOUTH in a placement out of the home pursuant to this title, said TITLE 19,10 THE order shall MUST contain specific findings, if warranted by the11 evidence, as follows:12 (c) That procedural safeguards with respect to parental rights have13 been applied in connection with the continuation of the child OR YOUTH14 in out-of-home placement, a change in the child's OR YOUTH'S placement15 out of the home, and any determination affecting parental visitation 16 FAMILY TIME.17 SECTION 9. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-1-208, amend (2)18 as follows:19 19-1-208. Duties of CASA volunteer. (2) Recommendations.20 Unless otherwise ordered by the court, the CASA volunteer, with the21 support and supervision of the CASA program staff, shall make22 recommendations consistent with the best interests of the child OR YOUTH23 regarding placement, visitation FAMILY TIME, and appropriate services for24 the child OR YOUTH and family and shall prepare a written report to be25 distributed to the parties of the action.26 SECTION 10. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-2.5-305, amend27 1027 -11- (3)(a)(XI)(C) as follows:1 19-2.5-305. Detention and shelter - hearing - time limits -2 findings - review - confinement with adult offenders - restrictions.3 (3) (a) (XI) If the court orders further detention of a juvenile pursuant to4 this section, the order must contain specific findings as follows:5 (C) Whether procedural safeguards to preserve parental rights6 have been applied in connection with the removal of the juvenile from the7 home, any change in the juvenile's placement in a community placement,8 or any determination affecting parental visitation FAMILY TIME of the9 juvenile.10 SECTION 11. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-2.5-1116,11 amend (4)(a) introductory portion and (4)(a)(VIII) as follows:12 19-2.5-1116. Orders - community placement - reasonable13 efforts required - reviews. (4) (a) If the juvenile is in the legal custody14 of a county department of human or social services and is placed in a15 community placement for a period of twelve months or longer, the district16 court, another court of competent jurisdiction, or an administrative body17 appointed or approved by the court that is not under the county18 department's supervision shall conduct a permanency hearing within said19 twelve months and every twelve months thereafter for as long as the20 juvenile remains in community placement. At the permanency hearing,21 the entity conducting the hearing shall determine whether:22 (VIII) Procedural safeguards to preserve parental rights have been23 applied in connection with the removal of the juvenile from the home, any24 change in the juvenile's community placement, or any determination25 affecting parental visitation FAMILY TIME.26 SECTION 12. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-2.5-1518,27 1027 -12- amend (1)(b)(VIII) as follows:1 19-2.5-1518. Commitment to department of human services.2 (1) (b) When a juvenile is placed in a community placement for a period3 of twelve months or longer, a court of competent jurisdiction or an4 administrative body appointed or approved by the court that is not under5 the supervision of the department of human services shall conduct a6 permanency hearing pursuant to the federal "Social Security Act", 427 U.S.C. sec. 675 (5)(C) no later than the twelfth month of the community8 placement and at least every twelve months thereafter while the juvenile9 remains in a community placement. At the permanency hearing, the entity10 conducting the hearing shall determine whether:11 (VIII) Procedural safeguards to preserve parental rights have been12 applied in connection with the removal of the juvenile from the home, any13 change in the juvenile's community placement, or any determination14 affecting parental visitation FAMILY TIME.15 SECTION 13. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-208, amend16 (2)(b)(IV) as follows:17 19-3-208. Services - county required to provide - out-of-home18 placement options - rules - definitions. (2) (b) The following services19 must be available and provided, as determined necessary and appropriate20 by individual case plans:21 (IV) Visitation FAMILY TIME services for parents with children or22 youth in out-of-home placement;23 SECTION 14. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-210.5, amend24 (1)(b) as follows:25 19-3-210.5. Foster parents' bill of rights. (1) A foster parent has26 the right to:27 1027 -13- (b) Promote the reasonable and prudent parent standard for the1 child or youth and the continuance of positive family patterns and2 routines to the extent possible without interfering with court-ordered3 visitation FAMILY TIME or services required pursuant to section 19-3-208;4 SECTION 15. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-403, amend5 (7) as follows:6 19-3-403. Temporary custody - hearing - time limits -7 restriction - rules. (7) The court may also issue temporary orders for8 legal custody as provided in section 19-1-115. The court shall enter9 visitation FAMILY TIME orders consistent with section 19-3-217.10 SECTION 16. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-604, amend11 (1)(c) introductory portion, (1)(c)(I) introductory portion, and (1)(c)(I)(A)12 as follows:13 19-3-604. Criteria for termination. (1) The court may order a14 termination of the parent-child legal relationship upon the finding by clear15 and convincing evidence of any one of the following:16 (c) That the child OR YOUTH is adjudicated dependent or neglected17 and all of the following exist:18 (I) That an appropriate treatment plan approved by the court has19 not been reasonably complied with by the parent or parents or has not20 been successful or that the court has previously found, pursuant to section21 19-3-508 (1)(e), that an appropriate treatment plan could not be devised.22 In a county designated pursuant to section 19-1-123, if a child OR YOUTH23 is under six years of age at the time a petition is filed in accordance with24 section 19-3-501 (2), no parent or parents shall be found to be THE COURT25 SHALL NOT FIND THAT A PARENT IS OR PARENTS ARE in reasonable26 compliance with or to have been successful at a court-approved treatment27 1027 -14- plan when:1 (A) The parent has not attended visitations FAMILY TIME with the2 child OR YOUTH as set forth in the treatment plan, unless good cause can3 be shown for failing to visit ATTEND; or4 SECTION 17. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-612, amend5 (10) and (11)(a)(II) as follows:6 19-3-612. Reinstatement of the parent-child legal relationship7 - circumstances - petition - hearings - legislative declaration. (10) At8 the conclusion of the initial hearing, the court shall either dismiss the9 petition because the threshold conditions for reinstatement set forth in10 subsection (9) of this section have not been met or enter an order finding11 that the threshold conditions for reinstatement set forth in subsection (9)12 of this section have been met and that it is in the best interests of the child13 OR YOUTH to work toward reinstatement of the parent-child legal14 relationship. If the court finds that it is in the best interests of the child OR15 YOUTH to pursue reinstatement of the parent-child legal relationship, the16 court must approve a transition plan developed by the county department17 and designed for reinstatement of the parent-child legal relationship,18 including visitation FAMILY TIME or placement of the child OR YOUTH19 with the former parent for a designated trial period of up to six months,20 during which time legal custody of the child OR YOUTH remains with the21 county department. As part of the transition plan, the county department22 shall provide transition services, as needed. The county department shall23 assess the visitation FAMILY TIME or temporary placement of the child OR24 YOUTH with the former parent and prepare a report about the success of25 the visitation FAMILY TIME or temporary placement. The county26 department shall submit the report to the court, the former parent, and the27 1027 -15- guardian ad litem not later than thirty days prior to the expiration of the1 designated trial period. The county department may stop the visitation2 FAMILY TIME or remove the child OR YOUTH from placement with the3 former parent at any time, in accordance with the procedures outlined in4 sections 19-3-401 and 19-3-403, if it deems that the child OR YOUTH is5 not safe or that it is no longer in the best interests of the child OR YOUTH6 for the child OR YOUTH to remain with the former parent.7 (11) (a) The court shall schedule a final hearing prior to the8 expiration of the designated trial period. At the final hearing, the court9 shall consider the following:10 (II) Whether the trial period of visitation FAMILY TIME or11 placement of the child OR YOUTH with the former parent was successful;12 SECTION 18. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-702, amend13 (1)(a) and (3)(a) as follows:14 19-3-702. Permanency hearing. (1) (a) In order to provide15 stable, permanent homes for every child or youth placed out of the home,16 in as short a time as possible, a court shall conduct a permanency17 planning hearing. The court shall hold the permanency planning hearing18 as soon as possible following the initial hearing held pursuant to a19 proceeding pursuant to part 3 of article 7 of this title 19 or the initial20 dispositional hearing pursuant to this article 3; except that the21 permanency planning hearing must be held no later than ninety-one days22 after the initial decree of disposition. After the initial permanency23 planning hearing, the court shall hold additional hearings at least every24 six months while the case remains open or more often in the discretion of25 the court, or upon the motion of any party. T HE INITIAL PERMANENCY26 HEARING MUST BE HELD WITHIN TWELVE MONTHS AFTER THE CHILD OR27 1027 -16- YOUTH ENTERS FOSTER CARE, EVEN WHEN A DISPOSITIONAL DECREE HAS1 NOT YET BEEN ENTERED . When possible, the permanency planning2 hearing must be combined with the in-person six-month review as3 provided for in section 19-1-115 (4)(c), subsection (6)(a) of this section,4 or section 19-7-312. The court shall hold all permanency planning5 hearings in person, provide proper notice to all parties, and provide all6 parties the opportunity to be heard. The court shall consult with the child7 or youth in a developmentally appropriate manner regarding the child's or8 youth's permanency goal.9 (3) At any permanency planning hearing, the court shall first10 determine if the child or youth should be returned to the child's or youth's11 parent, named guardian, or legal custodian and, if applicable, the date on12 which the child or youth must be returned. If the child or youth cannot be13 returned home, the court shall also determine whether reasonable efforts14 have been made to find a safe and stable permanent home for the child or15 youth. The court shall not delay permanency planning by considering the16 placement of children or youth together as a sibling group. At any17 permanency planning hearing, the court shall make the following18 determinations, when applicable:19 (a) Whether procedural safeguards to preserve parental rights have20 been applied in connection with any change in the child's or youth's21 placement or any determination affecting parental visitation FAMILY TIME22 of the child or youth;23 SECTION 19. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-3-903, amend24 (1) as follows:25 19-3-903. Task force on high-quality parenting time - creation26 - steering committee - membership. (1) There is created in the state27 1027 -17- department OFFICE OF RESPONDENT PARENTS ' COUNSEL CREATED IN1 SECTION 13-92-103 the task force on high-quality parenting time, for the2 purpose of studying the issues set forth in section 19-3-904 and making3 findings and recommendations to the governor, the state department; the4 child welfare training academy, and the general assembly on5 administrative and legislative changes to improve high-quality parenting6 time services and practices in dependency and neglect cases.7 SECTION 20. In Colorado Revised Statutes,19-3-904, amend8 (1)(c), (1)(d), and (2)(a) as follows:9 19-3-904. Task force - purposes - issues to study - written10 reports. (1) The purpose of the task force is to:11 (c) Study best practices for judicial review of visitation FAMILY12 TIME and parenting time plans;13 (d) Evaluate the rights and remedies for parents and children or14 youth pertaining to parenting time, including sibling visitation FAMILY15 TIME;16 (2) In carrying out the purposes set forth in subsection (1) of this17 section, the task force shall consider:18 (a) The United States constitution and state constitution, case law,19 statutes, rules, practices, and standards that govern family parenting time20 or visitation FAMILY TIME in Colorado;21 SECTION 21. In Colorado Revised Statutes, amend 19-3-905 as22 follows:23 19-3-905. Repeal of part. This part 9 is repealed, effective July24 1, 2023 2025.25 SECTION 22. In Colorado Revised Statutes,19-5-105, amend26 (3.4)(c) as follows:27 1027 -18- 19-5-105. Proceeding to terminate parent-child legal1 relationship. (3.4) (c) If the child OR YOUTH has been out of his or her 2 THE birth parents' care for more than one year, irrespective of incidental3 communications or visits from the relinquishing or nonrelinquishing4 parent, there is a rebuttable presumption that the best interests of the child5 OR YOUTH will be served by granting custody to the person in whose care6 the child OR YOUTH has been for that period. Such presumption may be7 overcome by a preponderance of the evidence.8 SECTION 23. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-5-208, amend9 (4.5)(b) as follows:10 19-5-208. Petition for adoption - open adoption - post-adoption11 contact agreement. (4.5) (b) Only the petitioner may request a12 post-adoption contact agreement for contact between a child OR YOUTH13 and the birth parent or parents; a birth relative, as set forth in section14 19-3-605 (1); or an Indian tribe if the child OR YOUTH is a member of the15 Indian tribe. A post-adoption contact agreement may include provisions16 for contact, visitation FAMILY TIME, or the exchange of information, and17 the grounds, if any, on which the adoptive parent may decline to permit18 visits CONTACTS or cease providing contact or information. If a child OR19 YOUTH is available for adoption through an expedited relinquishment20 pursuant to section 19-5-103.5, the contact agreement must be limited to21 contact between the child OR YOUTH and the birth parents and THE CHILD'S22 OR YOUTH'S biological siblings. of the child. 23 SECTION 24. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-5-210, amend24 (7) as follows:25 19-5-210. Hearing on petition. (7) In cases involving the26 adoption of a child OR YOUTH who is part of a sibling group but who is27 1027 -19- not being adopted with his or her THE CHILD'S siblings, in addition to1 issuing a final decree of adoption, if the adoptive parents are willing, the2 court may encourage reasonable visitation FAMILY TIME among the3 siblings when visitation FAMILY TIME is in the best interests of the child,4 YOUTH, or the children. The court shall review the record and inquire as5 to whether the adoptive parents have received counseling regarding6 children OR YOUTH in sibling groups maintaining or developing ties with7 each other.8 SECTION 25. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-7-203, amend9 (1)(l) and (1)(m) as follows:10 19-7-203. Foster care sibling rights. (1) Sibling youth in foster11 care, except youth in the custody of the division of youth services created12 pursuant to section 19-2.5-1501 or a state hospital for persons with13 behavioral or mental health disorders, have the following rights, unless14 they are not in the best interests of each sibling, regardless of whether the15 parental rights of one or more of the foster youth's parents have been16 terminated:17 (l) To expect that the youth's guardian ad litem advocate on behalf18 of the youth for frequent contact and visits FAMILY TIME with siblings,19 unless the guardian ad litem determines through the guardian ad litem's20 independent investigation that the contact is not in the best interests of the21 youth;22 (m) To have contact FAMILY TIME with siblings encouraged in any23 adoptive or guardianship placement; and24 SECTION 26. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 19-7-204, amend25 (1), (2) introductory portion, (2)(a), (2)(c), (2)(d), (3), (4), (5), and (6) as26 follows:27 1027 -20- 19-7-204. Foster care sibling family time - contact plan - rules1 - definition. (1) The department of human services shall provide2 information on sibling contact in the visitation FAMILY TIME plan for a3 youth. In doing so, the DEPARTMENT SHALL ASK THE youth shall be 4 consulted about the youth's wishes as to sibling contact.5 (2) As written in the visitation FAMILY TIME plan, the department6 of human services shall, if it is in the best interests of each sibling: 7 (a) Promote frequent contact between siblings in foster care,8 which may include telephone calls, text messages, social media, video9 calls, and in-person visits FAMILY TIME;10 (c) Clarify that restriction of sibling visits FAMILY TIME should not11 be a consequence for behavioral problems. Visits FAMILY TIME should12 only be restricted if contrary to the best interests of a sibling.13 (d) Ensure timing and regularly scheduled sibling visits FAMILY14 TIME are outlined in case plans based on individual circumstances and15 needs of the youth.16 (3) If a youth in foster care requests an opportunity to visit FOR17 FAMILY TIME WITH a sibling, the county department that has legal custody18 of the youth shall arrange the visit FAMILY TIME within a reasonable19 amount of time and document the visit FAMILY TIME.20 (4) If a youth in foster care requests an opportunity to visit FOR21 FAMILY TIME WITH a sibling on a regular basis, the county department that22 has legal custody of the youth shall arrange the visits FAMILY TIME and23 ensure that the visits occur FAMILY TIME OCCURS with sufficient24 frequency and duration to promote continuity in the siblings' relationship.25 (5) If, in arranging sibling visits FAMILY TIME pursuant to this26 section, a county department determines that a requested visit FAMILY27 1027 -21- TIME between the siblings would not be in the best interests of one or both1 of the siblings, the county department shall deny the request, document2 its reasons for making the determination, and provide the siblings with an3 explanation for the denial, as permitted under state and federal law. In4 determining whether a requested visit FAMILY TIME would be in the best5 interests of one or both of the siblings, the county department shall6 ascertain DETERMINE whether there is pending in any jurisdiction a7 criminal action in which either of the siblings is either a victim or a8 witness. If such a criminal action is pending, the county department,9 before arranging any visit FAMILY TIME between the siblings, shall consult10 with the district attorney for the jurisdiction in which the criminal action11 is pending to determine whether the requested visit FAMILY TIME may12 have a detrimental effect upon the prosecution of the pending criminal13 action.14 (6) Nothing in this section requires or permits a county department15 to arrange a sibling visit FAMILY TIME if such visit would violate an16 existing protection order in any case pending in this state or any other17 state.18 SECTION 27. Appropriation. (1) For the 2023-24 state fiscal19 year, $142,000 is appropriated to the judicial department for use by the20 office of the respondent parents' counsel. This appropriation is from the 21 general fund. To implement this act, the office may use this appropriation22 for personal services.23 (2) For the 2023-24 state fiscal year, $13,879 is appropriated to24 the department of human services for use by the division of child welfare.25 This appropriation is from the general fund. To implement this act, the26 division may use this appropriation for Colorado trails.27 1027 -22- (3) For the 2023-24 state fiscal year, the general assembly1 anticipates that the department of human services will receive $7,473 in2 federal funds for use by the division of child welfare to implement this3 act. The appropriation in subsection (2) of this section is based on the4 assumption that the department will receive this amount of federal funds,5 which is subject to the "(I)" notation as defined in the annual general6 appropriation act for the same fiscal year.7 SECTION 28. Effective date. This act takes effect upon passage;8 except that section 4 of this act takes effect January 1, 2024.9 SECTION 29. Safety clause. The general assembly hereby finds,10 determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate11 preservation of the public peace, health, or safety.12 1027 -23-