First Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO INTRODUCED LLS NO. R23-0807.02 Jery Payne x2157 HJR23-1022 House Committees Senate Committees HOUSE JOINT RESOLUTION 23-1022 C ONCERNING THE EFFECT OF SECTION 216 OF PRESIDENT BIDEN'S101 E XECUTIVE ORDER 14008 ON COLORADO.102 WHEREAS, Colorado has been blessed with some of the most1 beautiful, pristine, and productive land in the United States; and2 WHEREAS, Coloradans and tourists enjoy this beautiful land,3 publicly and privately, every year, using it responsibly for its recreation4 and its resources; and5 WHEREAS, Coloradans steward the land as much as they love6 using the land, with deep enjoyment shared by the many adventure7 seekers, backpackers, bird watchers, campers, explorers, farmers,8 fishermen, hikers, homeowners, homesteaders, hunters, miners, mountain9 climbers, photographers, ranchers, skiers, stargazers, thrill seekers, and10 so many more; and11 HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Winter T., Armagost, Bockenfeld, Bottoms, Bradfield, Bradley, Catlin, DeGraaf, Evans, Frizell, Hartsook, Holtorf, Luck, Lynch, Pugliese, Soper, Taggart, Weinberg, Wilson SENATE SPONSORSHIP Pelton R., Baisley, Liston, Pelton B. Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. WHEREAS, Coloradans have used and continue to use this great1 land to raise some of the finest crops, the greatest livestock, and the best2 timber; to safely produce energy; and to properly mine resources for3 ourselves and our neighbors, enjoyed every day by nearly all of us; and4 WHEREAS, While the federal government already shares some of5 the responsibility of stewarding part of our land through various national6 parks and other designations, Coloradans recognize that this land is7 largely and rightly our responsibility because it is not merely land that8 Coloradans use and enjoy, it is also the land that we call home; and9 WHEREAS, Coloradans recognize that nature is best guarded10 through good stewardship; and11 WHEREAS, Nature left to itself is not naturally balanced but12 destructive, requiring proper and reasonable management, including best13 practices for its use, to safeguard the land, the plants, and the wildlife that14 live in it; and15 WHEREAS, Land that is returned to an unmanaged, purely wild16 state is more susceptible to catastrophic forest fires and invasive17 infestations and disease and to other dangers to plants and wildlife; and18 WHEREAS, Coloradans care for this land because of the19 understanding that each individual has been given responsibility under20 God to be good stewards of this earth and of Colorado, and our duty in21 caring for the planet includes wise use of the land with which we have22 been entrusted, and that we must cultivate it well for us, our families, our23 posterity, our communities, and the environment we wish to protect; and24 WHEREAS, In the United States, governments are instituted by25 the people, deriving their just power from the consent of the governed, to26 secure the people's inherent and inalienable rights, which rights are27 granted by the one who made the laws of nature that we so enjoy,28 including protection of our property; and29 WHEREAS, Private property rights are recognized by and30 guaranteed protection under the Constitution of Colorado and the31 Constitution of the United States, both of which prohibit the violation of32 these rights for a public purpose; and33 HJR23-1022 -2- WHEREAS, On January 27, 2021, President Joseph R. Biden, Jr.,1 issued Executive Order 14008, which is titled "Tackling the Climate2 Crisis at Home and Abroad", 86 Fed. Reg. 7619 (Feb. 1, 2021); and3 WHEREAS, In section 216 of Executive Order 14008, President4 Biden directs the Secretary of the Interior, in consultation with the5 Secretary of Agriculture and other officials, to develop a program to6 preserve and conserve at least 30 percent of the lands and waters in the7 United States by 2030, and this order is commonly referred to as the "308 by 30" program; and9 WHEREAS, The 30 by 30 program intends to set aside10 approximately 700 million additional acres of United States land,11 threatening to permanently isolate and limit such land from responsible12 and necessary use and enjoyment; and13 WHEREAS, Colorado contains 66.6 million acres of land, of14 which 24.1 million acres are already owned by the United States15 government, representing 36.2 percent of all Colorado land, most of16 which is managed by the United States Forest Service; and17 WHEREAS, Many Coloradans privately and carefully steward18 their lands without the need for the federal government to intervene or19 direct their use; nevertheless, the federal government has already20 impacted or otherwise taken an estimated 6 percent of privately owned21 Colorado land, according to Colorado State University, in addition to the22 36.2 percent of federally owned land, subjecting it to perpetual23 conservation easements; and24 WHEREAS, Although more than 30 percent of Colorado is25 currently preserved and conserved in some way by the federal26 government itself, and although much more of Colorado is properly27 stewarded by private citizens, the Biden administration has, nevertheless,28 stated that, to reach the 30 percent target by 2030, the administration will29 use all the tools in existing law to both restrict the public land we30 currently share and to take portions of the land or the rights that we31 privately enjoy, including using conservation easements in perpetuity,32 establishing federal conservation programs, designating areas as national33 heritage sites, establishing wildlife corridors, listing species as34 endangered, and designating areas as critical habitats; and35 WHEREAS, There is no constitutional or statutory authority36 HJR23-1022 -3- referenced in section 216 of Executive Order 14008 for the President, the1 Department of the Interior, the Department of Agriculture, or any other2 federal agency to set aside and permanently preserve 30 percent of all3 land and water in the United States; and4 WHEREAS, The goal of preserving and conserving at least 305 percent of the land and water in the United States from the people was not6 voted on or consented to by the people, the Congress, or the Colorado7 General Assembly; and8 WHEREAS, Historically, federal conservation programs9 artificially drive up the cost of owning land, making it and the housing10 upon it less affordable, and they directly compete with working11 landowners who depend on the ability to lease or purchase land for the12 production of food, fiber, energy, and minerals; and13 WHEREAS, Placing a parcel of land under a permanent14 conservation easement reduces the value of the parcel, restricts its use,15 impacts its individual tax assessment, and invariably increases the tax16 burden on other Coloradans, especially neighboring landowners, to make17 up the lost revenue; and18 WHEREAS, Many Colorado businesses and citizens are involved19 in or otherwise dependent on industries that use United States lands and20 their resources, representing an important component of Colorado's21 economy and contributing to the entire state's economic and social22 welfare; and23 WHEREAS, One of these industries, cattle ranching, provides for24 Colorado's largest export, which is beef; and25 WHEREAS, The 30 by 30 program, if implemented, is likely to26 cause significant harm to the economy of Colorado, injuring Colorado's27 businesses and Colorado's citizens by depriving them of access to public28 lands and national forests and preventing the productive use of land; and29 WHEREAS, The withdrawal of approximately 700 million acres30 of federal land from beneficial use and the placement of the lands in31 permanent conservation status will cause dramatic and irreversible harm32 to the economies of many western states, including Colorado; and33 WHEREAS, The 30 by 30 program, if implemented, will conflict34 HJR23-1022 -4- with the plans, policies, and programs of Colorado; interfere with our1 ways of life; harm our economy; restrict the enjoyment of recreational2 activities; and not materially benefit the land and environment we protect;3 now, therefore,4 Be It Resolved by the House of Representatives of the5 Seventy-fourth General Assembly of the State of Colorado, the Senate6 concurring herein:7 (1) That Colorado opposes the 30 by 30 program, including its8 main objective of conserving and preserving 30 percent of the nation's9 land in its natural state or any similar program that will prevent the10 productive use of Colorado land;11 (2) That Colorado opposes the designation of public lands and12 national forests in Colorado as wilderness, wilderness study areas,13 wildlife preserves, or open space as well as other designations that restrict14 public access to those lands and prevent the productive use of the15 resources of the lands;16 (3) That Colorado supports the continued management of public17 lands, including national forests, under the principles of multiple use and18 sustained yield, recognizing the need for domestic sources of minerals,19 energy, timber, food, and fiber;20 (4) That Colorado supports maintaining and enhancing public21 access to public lands, including national forests, and opposes road22 closures, road decommissioning, moratoria on road construction, and23 other limits on public access to meet the 30 by 30 program's goals;24 (5) That Colorado recognizes and supports Colorado's water rights25 system, including the doctrine of prior appropriation, and opposes any26 federal designation of waters and watercourses that would impair or27 restrict water diversions and uses authorized by Colorado law;28 (6) That Colorado supports reasonable national, regional, and29 global environmental stewardship policies and goals that are30 comprehensive, practical, and cost-effective and that do not unnecessarily31 single out specific industries or activities, but Colorado opposes using32 climate change as a reason to set aside large tracts of land as preserves or33 open space under the 30 by 30 program; and34 HJR23-1022 -5- (7) That Colorado holds that the federal designation of public1 lands and national forest lands as wilderness, wilderness study areas, open2 space, or other conservation programs is subject to fundamental3 constitutional protections against unjust and improper takings by4 government actors.5 Be It Further Resolved, That copies of this Joint Resolution be sent6 to President Joseph R. Biden, Jr.; Deb Haaland, United States Secretary7 of the Interior; Thomas J. Vilsack, United States Secretary of Agriculture;8 Colorado's congressional delegation; Jared Polis, Colorado Governor; and9 Phil Weiser, Colorado Attorney General.10 HJR23-1022 -6-