Colorado 2024 Regular Session

Colorado House Bill HB1048 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
1+Second Regular Session
2+Seventy-fourth General Assembly
3+STATE OF COLORADO
4+REREVISED
5+This Version Includes All Amendments
6+Adopted in the Second House
7+LLS NO. 24-0363.01 Christopher McMichael x4775
18 HOUSE BILL 24-1048
2-BY REPRESENTATIVE(S) McCormick and Martinez, McLachlan,
3-Amabile, Bacon, Bird, Boesenecker, Brown, Catlin, Clifford, Epps,
4-Froelich, Garcia, Hamrick, Jodeh, Kipp, Lindsay, Lindstedt, Lukens, Lynch,
5-Mauro, Parenti, Ricks, Snyder, Soper, Story, Titone, Valdez, Vigil, Young,
6-McCluskie, Armagost, English, Herod, Joseph, Lieder, Marshall, Marvin,
7-Ortiz, Weinberg, Willford;
8-also SENATOR(S) Ginal and Pelton B., Pelton R., Simpson, Bridges,
9-Danielson, Hansen, Jaquez Lewis, Kirkmeyer, Kolker, Marchman, Roberts,
10-Van Winkle, Will.
9+House Committees Senate Committees
10+Agriculture, Water & Natural Resources Agriculture & Natural Resources
11+A BILL FOR AN ACT
1112 C
12-ONCERNING THE PROVISION OF VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH
13-TELEHEALTH
14-.
15-
16-Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:
17-SECTION 1. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 12-315-104, amend
18-(19) as follows:
19-12-315-104. Definitions. As used in this article 315, unless the
20-context otherwise requires:
13+ONCERNING THE PROVISION OF VETERI NARY SERVICES THROUGH101
14+TELEHEALTH.102
15+Bill Summary
16+(Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does
17+not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill
18+passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that
19+applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at
20+http://leg.colorado.gov/
21+.)
22+Water Resources and Agriculture Review Committee. The bill
23+concerns the use of telehealth to provide veterinary services. The bill
24+defines different types of telehealth tools that can be used in a veterinary
25+practice.
26+In current law, one criterion for the establishment of a
27+veterinarian-client-patient relationship is that the veterinarian has
28+SENATE
29+3rd Reading Unamended
30+February 26, 2024
31+SENATE
32+Amended 2nd Reading
33+February 23, 2024
34+HOUSE
35+3rd Reading Unamended
36+February 12, 2024
37+HOUSE
38+Amended 2nd Reading
39+February 9, 2024
40+HOUSE SPONSORSHIP
41+McCormick and Martinez, McLachlan, Amabile, Bacon, Bird, Boesenecker, Brown,
42+Catlin, Clifford, Epps, Froelich, Garcia, Hamrick, Jodeh, Kipp, Lindsay, Lindstedt, Lukens,
43+Lynch, Mauro, McCluskie, Parenti, Ricks, Snyder, Soper, Story, Titone, Valdez, Vigil, Young
44+SENATE SPONSORSHIP
45+Ginal and Pelton B., Pelton R., Simpson, Bridges, Danielson, Hansen, Jaquez Lewis,
46+Kirkmeyer, Kolker, Marchman, Roberts, Van Winkle, Will
47+Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment.
48+Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law.
49+Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. conducted an examination of the animal that is the patient. The bill
50+clarifies that the examination must be an in-person, physical examination.
51+The bill also extends the veterinarian-client-patient relationship to other
52+licensed veterinarians who share the same physical premises as the
53+veterinarian who established the relationship if the other veterinarians
54+have access to and have reviewed the patient's medical records.
55+The bill allows a licensed veterinarian who has established a
56+veterinarian-client-patient relationship to use telehealth to provide
57+veterinary services to clients and patients in Colorado with the consent of
58+the client. A licensed veterinarian may also refer a patient to a veterinary
59+specialist, who may provide veterinary services via telemedicine under
60+the referring veterinarian's veterinarian-client-patient relationship.
61+The bill authorizes the state board of veterinary medicine to
62+establish rules for the use of telehealth to provide veterinary services.
63+The bill clarifies that only a licensed veterinarian with an
64+established veterinarian-client-patient relationship may prescribe
65+medication using telemedicine.
66+The bill allows a licensed veterinarian who has established a
67+veterinarian-client-patient relationship to supervise veterinary personnel
68+who are not located on the same premises using telesupervision if the
69+veterinarian and the personnel are employees of the same veterinary
70+practice and the veterinary premises, the veterinary professionals or other
71+veterinary personnel, and the patient are all located in Colorado.
72+The bill establishes record-keeping, confidentiality, and privacy
73+requirements related to the use of telehealth.
74+Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1
75+SECTION 1. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 12-315-104, amend2
76+(19) as follows:3
77+12-315-104. Definitions. As used in this article 315, unless the4
78+context otherwise requires:5
2179 (19) (a) "Veterinarian-client-patient relationship" means that
22- THE
23-NOTE: This bill has been prepared for the signatures of the appropriate legislative
24-officers and the Governor. To determine whether the Governor has signed the bill
25-or taken other action on it, please consult the legislative status sheet, the legislative
26-history, or the Session Laws.
27-________
28-Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material added to existing law; dashes
29-through words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law and such material is not part of
30-the act. relationship established when:
31-(a) (I) The veterinarian has assumed the responsibility for making
32-medical judgments regarding the health of an animal and the need for
33-medical treatment, and the owner,
34-OWNER'S AGENT, or other AUTHORIZED
35-caretaker has agreed to follow the instruction of the veterinarian;
36-(b) (II) There is sufficient knowledge of an animal by the
37-veterinarian to initiate at least a general or preliminary diagnosis of the
38-medical condition of the animal, which means that the veterinarian has
39-recently seen and is personally acquainted with the keeping and care of the
40-animal by virtue of an
41-IN-PERSON, PHYSICAL examination of the animal or
42-by medically appropriate and timely visits to the premises where the animal
43-is kept; and
80+ THE6
81+relationship established when:7
82+(a) (I) The veterinarian has assumed the responsibility for making8
83+medical judgments regarding the health of an animal and the need for9
84+medical treatment, and the owner, OWNER'S AGENT, or other AUTHORIZED10
85+caretaker has agreed to follow the instruction of the veterinarian;11
86+1048-2- (b) (II) There is sufficient knowledge of an animal by the1
87+veterinarian to initiate at least a general or preliminary diagnosis of the2
88+medical condition of the animal, which means that the veterinarian has3
89+recently seen and is personally acquainted with the keeping and care of4
90+the animal by virtue of an
91+IN-PERSON, PHYSICAL examination of the5
92+animal or by medically appropriate and timely visits to the premises6
93+where the animal is kept; and7
4494 (c)
45- (III) The practicing veterinarian is readily available, or has
46-arranged for emergency coverage, for follow-up evaluation in the event of
47-adverse reactions or failure of the treatment regimen.
95+ (III) The practicing veterinarian is readily available, or has8
96+arranged for emergency coverage, for follow-up evaluation in the event9
97+of adverse reactions or failure of the treatment regimen.10
4898 (b) A
49- VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP ESTABLISHED
50-ACCORDING TO SUBSECTION
51- (19)(a) OF THIS SECTION MAY EXTEND TO OTHER
52-LICENSED VETERINARIANS WORKING OUT OF THE SAME PHYSICAL PRACTICE
53-LOCATION AS THE VETERINARIAN WHO ESTABLISHED THE
54-VETERINARIAN
55--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IF THE OTHER LICENSED
56-VETERINARIANS HAVE ACCESS TO AND HAVE REVIEWED THE PATIENT
57-'S
58-MEDICAL RECORDS
59-.
60-SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 12-315-106, add (9) as
61-follows:
62-12-315-106. Board of veterinary medicine - creation - powers -
63-rules. (9) (a) T
64-HE BOARD MAY PROMULGATE RULES REGARDING THE USE OF
65-TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES IN
66-COLORADO PURSUANT
67-TO PART
68-3 OF THIS ARTICLE 315.
69-(b) I
70-N DEVELOPING RULES PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (9)(a) OF THIS
71-SECTION
72-, THE BOARD SHALL CONSULT WITH LICENSED VETERINARIANS ,
73-REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS , CLIENTS, AND OTHER RELEVANT
74-STAKEHOLDERS AS DETERMINED BY THE BOARD
75-.
76-PAGE 2-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add part 3 to article
77-315 of title 12 as follows:
78-PART 3
79-USE OF TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE
80-VETERINARY SERVICES
99+ VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP ESTABLISHED11
100+ACCORDING TO SUBSECTION (19)(a) OF THIS SECTION MAY EXTEND TO12
101+OTHER LICENSED VETERINARIANS
102+WORKING OUT OF THE SAME PHYSICAL13
103+PRACTICE LOCATION AS THE VETERINARIAN WHO ESTABLISHED THE14
104+VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IF THE OTHER LICENSED15
105+VETERINARIANS HAVE ACCESS TO AND HAVE REVIEWED THE PATIENT 'S16
106+MEDICAL RECORDS.17
107+SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 12-315-106, add (9)18
108+as follows:19
109+12-315-106. Board of veterinary medicine - creation - powers20
110+- rules. (9) (a) THE BOARD MAY PROMULGATE RULES REGARDING THE USE21
111+OF TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES IN COLORADO22
112+PURSUANT TO PART 3 OF THIS ARTICLE 315.23
113+(b) IN DEVELOPING RULES PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (9)(a) OF24
114+THIS SECTION, THE BOARD SHALL CONSULT WITH LICENSED25
115+VETERINARIANS, REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS, CLIENTS, AND26
116+OTHER RELEVANT STAKE HOLDERS AS DETERMINED BY THE BOARD .27
117+1048
118+-3- SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add part 3 to article1
119+315 of title 12 as follows:2
120+PART 33
121+USE OF TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE4
122+VETERINARY SERVICES5
81123 12-315-301. Definitions - rules. A
82-S USED IN THIS PART 3, UNLESS
83-THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES
84-:
124+S USED IN THIS PART 3, UNLESS6
125+THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES :7
85126 (1) "T
86-ELE-ADVICE" MEANS THE PROVISION OF ANY HEALTH
87-INFORMATION
88-, OPINION, OR GUIDANCE BY A VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL
89-THAT IS NOT INTENDED TO DIAGNOSE
90-, TREAT, OR ISSUE PROGNOSES OF AN
91-ANIMAL
92-'S, OR GROUP OF ANIMALS', PHYSICAL OR BEHAVIORAL ILLNESS OR
93-INJURY
94-. A VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IS NOT REQUIRED
95-TO PROVIDE TELE
96--ADVICE.
127+ELE-ADVICE" MEANS THE PROVISION OF ANY HEALTH8
128+INFORMATION, OPINION, OR GUIDANCE BY A VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL9
129+THAT IS NOT INTENDED TO DIAGNOSE,
130+ TREAT, OR ISSUE PROGNOSES OF AN10
131+ANIMAL'S, OR GROUP OF ANIMALS', PHYSICAL OR BEHAVIORAL ILLNESS OR11
132+INJURY. A VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IS NOT12
133+REQUIRED TO PROVIDE TELE-ADVICE.13
97134 (2) "T
98-ELECONSULTING" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WHO
99-COMMUNICATES WITH A VETERINARY SPECIALIST OR OTHER QUALIFIED
100-EXPERT USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY TO GAIN INSIGHT OR
101-ADVICE REGARDING THE CARE OF A PATIENT
102-.
135+ELECONSULTING" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WHO14
136+COMMUNICATES WITH A VETERINARY SPECIALIST OR OTHER QUALIFIED15
137+EXPERT USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY TO GAIN INSIGHT OR16
138+ADVICE REGARDING THE CARE OF A PATIENT .17
103139 (3) "T
104-ELE-EDUCATION" MEANS THE USE OF INFORMATION AND
105-TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY FOR DISTANCE LEARNING
106-.
140+ELE-EDUCATION" MEANS THE USE OF INFORMATION AND18
141+TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY FOR DISTANCE LEARNING .19
107142 (4) (a) "T
108-ELEHEALTH" MEANS THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS
109-TECHNOLOGY TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES OR TO COLLECT AND
110-DELIVER VETERINARY HEALTH INFORMATION OR EDUCATION VIRTUALLY
111-AND CAN ENCOMPASS GENERAL V ETERINARY SERVICES OR PATIENT
112--SPECIFIC
113-VETERINARY SERVICES
114-.
143+ELEHEALTH" MEANS THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS20
144+TECHNOLOGY TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES OR TO COLLECT AND21
145+DELIVER VETERINARY HEALTH INFORMATION OR EDUCATION VIRTUALLY22
146+AND CAN ENCOMPASS GENERAL VETERINARY SERVICES OR23
147+PATIENT-SPECIFIC VETERINARY SERVICES.24
115148 (b) "T
116-ELEHEALTH" MAY INCLUDE TELE-ADVICE, TELECONSULTING,
117-TELE-EDUCATION, TELEMEDICINE, TELEMONITORING, TELEREFERRAL,
118-TELESUPERVISION, TELETRIAGE, AND OTHER TOOLS THAT HELP VETERINARY
119-PROFESSIONALS DELIVER VETERINARY EDUCATION AND SERVICES
120-VIRTUALLY
121-.
149+ELEHEALTH" MAY INCLUDE TELE-ADVICE, TELECONSULTING,25
150+TELE-EDUCATION, TELEMEDICINE, TELEMONITORING, TELEREFERRAL,26
151+TELESUPERVISION, TELETRIAGE, AND OTHER TOOLS THAT HELP27
152+1048
153+-4- VETERINARY PROFESSIONALS DELIVER VETERINARY EDUCATION AND1
154+SERVICES VIRTUALLY.2
122155 (5) "T
123-ELEMEDICINE" MEANS THE REMOTE PRACTICE OF VETERINARY
124-MEDICINE THROUGH THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY THAT
125-ALLOWS A LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH AN ESTABLISHED
126-PAGE 3-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP TO EVALUATE , DIAGNOSE,
127-AND TREAT A PATIENT VIRTUALLY.
156+ELEMEDICINE" MEANS THE REMOTE PRACTICE OF3
157+VETERINARY MEDICINE THROUGH THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS4
158+TECHNOLOGY THAT ALLOWS A LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH AN5
159+ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN -CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP TO6
160+EVALUATE, DIAGNOSE, AND TREAT A PATIENT VIRTUALLY.7
128161 (6) "T
129-ELEMONITORING" MEANS THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS
130-TECHNOLOGY TO AUGMENT VETERINARY SERVICES BY COLLECTING AND
131-DELIVERING HEALTH INFORMATION FROM A PATIENT
132-.
162+ELEMONITORING" MEANS THE USE OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS8
163+TECHNOLOGY TO AUGMENT VETERINARY SERVICES BY COLLECTING AND9
164+DELIVERING HEALTH INFORMATION FROM A PATIENT .10
133165 (7) "T
134-ELEREFERRAL" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WITH AN ESTABLISHED
135-VETERINARIAN
136--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP WHO REFERS THE CLIENT TO
137-A VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES USING
138-TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY UNDER THE ESTABLISHED
139-VETERINARIAN
140--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP.
166+ELEREFERRAL" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WITH AN11
167+ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP WHO REFERS12
168+THE CLIENT TO A VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO PROVIDE VETERINARY13
169+SERVICES USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY UNDER THE14
170+ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP.15
141171 (8) "T
142-ELESUPERVISION" MEANS THE SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUALS
143-PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES USING MEDIA SUCH AS AUDIO
144-,
145-AUDIO-VISUAL CONFERENCING , TEXT MESSAGING, E-MAIL, OR OTHER
146-VIRTUAL OR DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES
147-.
172+ELESUPERVISION" MEANS THE SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUALS16
173+PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES USING MEDIA SUCH AS AUDIO ,17
174+AUDIO-VISUAL CONFERENCING, TEXT MESSAGING, E-MAIL, OR OTHER18
175+VIRTUAL OR DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES .19
148176 (9) "T
149-ELETRIAGE" MEANS THE SAFE, APPROPRIATE, AND TIMELY
150-ASSESSMENT OF AN ANIMAL
151-, OR A GROUP OF ANIMALS, UNDER CONDITIONS
152-OF UNCERTAINTY AND URGENCY
153-, AND THE POSSIBLE REFERRAL TO A
154-LICENSED VETERINARIAN
155-, AFTER DISCUSSION WITH THE INDIVIDUAL
156-RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ANIMAL OR GROUP OF ANIMALS
157-, USING
158-TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY
159-. A VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT
160-RELATIONSHIP IS NOT REQUIRED FOR SUCH AN ASSESSMENT OR REFERRAL
161-.
177+ELETRIAGE" MEANS THE SAFE, APPROPRIATE, AND TIMELY20
178+ASSESSMENT OF AN ANIMAL, OR A GROUP OF ANIMALS, UNDER CONDITIONS21
179+OF UNCERTAINTY AND URGENCY , AND THE POSSIBLE REFERRAL TO A22
180+LICENSED VETERINARIAN, AFTER DISCUSSION WITH THE INDIVIDUAL23
181+RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ANIMAL OR GROUP OF ANIMALS , USING24
182+TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY . A VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT25
183+RELATIONSHIP IS NOT REQUIRED FOR SUCH AN ASSESSMENT OR REFERRAL .26
162184 "T
163-ELETRIAGE" DOES NOT INCLUDE THE RENDERING OF A DIAGNOSIS BUT MAY
164-INCLUDE THE PROVISION OF TELE
165--ADVICE.
185+ELETRIAGE" DOES NOT INCLUDE THE RENDERING OF A DIAGNOSIS BUT
186+27
187+1048
188+-5- MAY INCLUDE THE PROVISION OF TELE-ADVICE.1
166189 (10) "V
167-ETERINARY SPECIALIST" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WHO IS
168-FORMALLY RECOGNIZED AS A SPECIALIST FROM A SPECIALTY ORGANIZATION
169-THAT IS RECOGNIZED BY THE
170-AMERICAN VETERINARY MEDICAL
171-ASSOCIATION'S AMERICAN BOARD OF VETERINARY SPECIALTIES, OR ITS
172-SUCCESSOR ORGANIZATION
173-, OR ANOTHER ASSOCIATION THAT REC OGNIZES
174-VETERINARY SPECIALISTS THAT THE STATE BOARD OF V ETERINARY MEDICINE
175-HAS APPROVED BY RULE
176-.
177-12-315-302. Veterinarian-client-patient relationship -
190+ETERINARY SPECIALIST" MEANS A VETERINARIAN WHO IS2
191+FORMALLY RECOGNIZED AS A SPECIALIST FROM A SPECIALTY3
192+ORGANIZATION THAT IS RECOGNIZED BY THE AMERICAN VETERINARY4
193+M
194+EDICAL ASSOCIATION'S AMERICAN BOARD OF VETERINARY5
195+S
196+PECIALTIES, OR ITS SUCCESSOR ORGANIZATION , OR ANOTHER6
197+ASSOCIATION THAT RECOGNIZES V ETERINARY SPECIALISTS THAT THE7
198+STATE BOARD OF VETERINARY MEDICINE HAS APPROVED BY RULE .8
199+12-315-302. Veterinarian-client-patient relationship -9
178200 telemedicine. (1) O
179-NLY A LICENSED VETERINARIAN MAY ESTABLISH A
180-VETERINARIAN
181--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IN THIS STATE.
182-PAGE 4-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 (2) (a) A VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MUST BE
183-ESTABLISHED BY AN IN
184--PERSON, PHYSICAL EXAMINATION OF THE ANIMAL OR
185-TIMELY VISITS TO THE PREMISES WHERE THE ANIMAL IS KEPT
186-.
201+NLY A LICENSED VETERINARIAN MAY ESTABLISH A10
202+VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IN THIS STATE.11
203+(2) (a) A
204+ VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MUST BE12
205+ESTABLISHED BY AN IN-PERSON, PHYSICAL EXAMINATION OF THE ANIMAL13
206+OR TIMELY VISITS TO THE PREMISES WHERE THE ANIMAL IS KEPT .14
187207 (b) A
188- VETERINARY SPECIALIST MAY USE TELECOMMUNICATIONS
189-TECHNOLOGY TO SEE A PATIENT UNDER ANOTHER VETERINARIAN
190-'S
191-PREVIOUSLY ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN
192--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP
193-PURSUANT TO SECTION
194-12-315-306.
208+ VETERINARY SPECIALIST MAY USE TELECOMMUNICATIONS15
209+TECHNOLOGY TO SEE A PATIENT UNDER ANOTHER VETERINARIAN 'S16
210+PREVIOUSLY ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN -CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP17
211+PURSUANT TO SECTION 12-315-306.18
195212 (3) A
196-N ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP
197-MAY BE MAINTAINED THROUGH EXAMINATIONS THAT OCCUR USING
198-TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY IN BETWEEN APPROPRIATE IN
199--PERSON,
200-PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS OR VISITS TO THE PREMISES WHERE THE PATIENT
201-IS KEPT
202-.
203-12-315-303. Treatment of patients using telehealth - telemedicine
204-- licensure - technology - consent. (1) (a) A
205- PERSON MUST BE LICENSED TO
206-PRACTICE VETERINARY MEDICINE IN
207-COLORADO IN ORDER TO PRACTICE
208-TELEMEDICINE IN
209-COLORADO.
213+N ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN -CLIENT-PATIENT19
214+RELATIONSHIP MAY BE MAINTAINED THROUGH EXAMINATIONS THAT20
215+OCCUR USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY IN BETWEEN21
216+APPROPRIATE IN-PERSON, PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS OR VISITS TO THE22
217+PREMISES WHERE THE PATIENT IS KEPT.23
218+12-315-303. Treatment of patients using telehealth -24
219+telemedicine - licensure - technology - consent. (1) (a) A
220+ PERSON MUST25
221+BE LICENSED TO PRACTICE VETERINARY MEDICINE IN COLORADO IN ORDER26
222+TO PRACTICE TELEMEDICINE IN COLORADO.27
223+1048
224+-6- (b) A PERSON WHO IS NOT A LICENSED VETERINARIAN IN1
225+C
226+OLORADO AND WHO USES TELEMEDICINE TO PROVIDE VETERINARY2
227+SERVICES TO ANIMALS AND INDIVIDUALS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ANIMALS3
228+ENGAGES IN THE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE .4
229+S
230+UCH PERSON IS SUBJECT TO PENALTIES FOR THE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE5
231+OF VETERINARY MEDICINE PURSUANT TO SECTION 12-315-114.6
232+(2) A
233+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL EMPLOY SOUND ,7
234+PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT WHEN DETERMINING WHETHER TO PROVIDE8
235+VETERINARY SERVICES TO A PATIENT THROUGH TELEMEDICINE AND SHALL9
236+USE TELEMEDICINE ONLY WHEN SUCH USE IS MEDICALLY APPROPRIATE10
237+BASED ON THE PATIENT'S CONDITION.11
238+(3) A
239+ VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL SHALL ENSURE THAT THE12
240+TECHNOLOGY USED WHEN PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH13
241+TELEHEALTH IS OF APPROPRIATE QUALITY TO ENSURE :14
242+(a) A
243+CCURACY OF THE REMOTE ASSESSMENT OF THE PATIENT 'S15
244+CONDITION OR BEHAVIOR;16
245+(b) C
246+LEAR COMMUNICATION WITH CLIENTS ; AND17
247+(c) C
248+OMPLIANCE WITH ALL RELEVANT PRIVACY AND18
249+CONFIDENTIALITY REQUIREMENTS .19
250+(4) (a) A
251+ VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL SHALL OBTAIN CONSENT20
252+FROM THE CLIENT BEFORE PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH21
253+TELEHEALTH AND SHALL RECORD THE CLIENT 'S CONSENT IN THE PATIENT'S22
254+MEDICAL RECORD.23
210255 (b) A
211- PERSON WHO IS NOT A LICENSED VETERINARIAN IN COLORADO
212-AND WHO USES TELEMEDICINE TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES TO
213-ANIMALS AND INDIVIDUALS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ANIMALS ENGAGES IN THE
214-UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE
215-. SUCH PERSON IS
216-SUBJECT TO PENALTIES FOR THE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF VETERINARY
217-MEDICINE PURSUANT TO SECTION
218-12-315-114.
256+ VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL USING TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE24
257+VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL INFORM THE CLIENT , OR THE CLIENT'S25
258+AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE , OF:26
259+(I) T
260+HE VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL 'S NAME, LOCATION, AND, IF27
261+1048
262+-7- APPLICABLE, LICENSE NUMBER AND LICENSURE STATUS ;1
263+(II) W
264+HETHER, IN THE VETERINARIAN'S PROFESSIONAL OPINION,2
265+THE PATIENT'S CONDITION CAN BE ACCURATELY DIAGNOSED OR TREATED3
266+USING TELEMEDICINE; AND4
267+(III) T
268+HE DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSIS, AND TREATMENT OPTIONS FOR5
269+THE PATIENT.6
270+12-315-304. Standard of care. (1) A
271+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN7
272+USING TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL CONDUCT8
273+ALL NECESSARY PATIENT EVALUATIONS AND TREATMENT USING THE9
274+APPLICABLE STANDARD OF CARE FOR THOSE EVALUATIONS AND10
275+TREATMENTS.11
219276 (2) A
220- LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL EMPLOY SOUND ,
221-PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT WHEN DETERMINING WHETHER TO PROVIDE
222-VETERINARY SERVICES TO A PATIENT THROUGH TELEMEDICINE AND SHALL
223-USE TELEMEDICINE ONLY WHEN SUCH USE IS MEDICALLY APPROPRIATE
224-BASED ON THE PATIENT
225-'S CONDITION.
226-(3) A
227- VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL SHALL ENSURE THAT THE
228-TECHNOLOGY USED WHEN PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH
229-TELEHEALTH IS OF APPROPRIATE QUALITY TO ENSURE
230-:
231-(a) A
232-CCURACY OF THE REMOTE ASSESSMENT OF THE PATIENT 'S
233-CONDITION OR BEHAVIOR
234-;
235-PAGE 5-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 (b) CLEAR COMMUNICATION WITH CLIENTS ; AND
236-(c) COMPLIANCE WITH ALL RELEVANT PRIVACY AND
237-CONFIDENTIALITY REQUIREMENTS
238-.
239-(4) (a) A
240- VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL SHALL OBTAIN CONSENT FROM
241-THE CLIENT BEFORE PROVIDING VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH
242-TELEHEALTH AND SHALL RECORD THE CLIENT
243-'S CONSENT IN THE PATIENT'S
244-MEDICAL RECORD
245-.
277+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL NOT RECOMMEND12
278+TREATMENT OR CARE FOR AN ANIMAL BASED SOLELY ON A CLIENT 'S13
279+RESPONSES TO AN ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE .14
280+12-315-305. Prescribing medication through telemedicine.15
281+(1) (a) E
282+XCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (3) OF THIS SECTION, ONLY
283+16
284+A LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH AN ESTABLISHED17
285+VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY PRESCRIBE18
286+MEDICATION THROUGH TELEMEDICINE .19
246287 (b) A
247- VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL USING TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE
248-VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL INFORM THE CLIENT
249-, OR THE CLIENT'S
250-AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE
251-, OF:
252-(I) T
253-HE VETERINARY PROFESSIONAL 'S NAME, LOCATION, AND, IF
254-APPLICABLE
255-, LICENSE NUMBER AND LICENSURE STATUS ;
256-(II) W
257-HETHER, IN THE VETERINARIAN'S PROFESSIONAL OPINION, THE
258-PATIENT
259-'S CONDITION CAN BE ACCURATELY DIAGNOSED OR TREATED USING
260-TELEMEDICINE
261-; AND
262-(III) THE DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSIS, AND TREATMENT OPTIONS FOR THE
263-PATIENT
264-.
265-12-315-304. Standard of care. (1) A
266- LICENSED VETERINARIAN
267-USING TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL C ONDUCT ALL
268-NECESSARY PATIENT EVALUATIONS AND TREATMENT USING THE APPLICABLE
269-STANDARD OF CARE FOR THOSE EVALUATIONS AND TREATMENTS
270-.
288+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL USE PROFESSI ONAL20
289+JUDGMENT WHEN DETERMINING IF IT IS APPROPRIATE TO PRESCRIBE21
290+MEDICATION THROUGH TELEMEDICINE .22
271291 (2) A
272- LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL NOT RECOMMEND TREATMENT
273-OR CARE FOR AN ANIMAL BASED SOLELY ON A CLIENT
274-'S RESPONSES TO AN
275-ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE
276-.
277-12-315-305. Prescribing medication through telemedicine.
278-(1) (a) E
279-XCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (3) OF THIS SECTION, ONLY A
280-LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH AN ESTABLISHED
281-VETERINARIAN
282--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY PRESCRIBE MEDICATION
283-THROUGH TELEMEDICINE
284-.
285-(b) A
286- LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL USE PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT
287-PAGE 6-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 WHEN DETERMINING IF IT IS APPROPRIATE TO PRESCRIBE MEDICATION
288-THROUGH TELEMEDICINE
289-.
290-(2) A
291- LICENSED VETERINARIAN WHO PRESCRIBES MEDICATION
292-THROUGH TELEMEDICINE IS SUBJECT TO THE LIMITATIONS ON PRESCRIPTIONS
293-SPECIFIED IN SECTION
294-12-30-109.
292+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN WHO PRESCRIBES MEDICATION23
293+THROUGH TELEMEDICINE IS SUBJECT TO THE LIMITATIONS ON24
294+PRESCRIPTIONS SPECIFIED IN SECTION 12-30-109.25
295295 (3) I
296296 N ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 12-315-105 (2)(b), A LICENSED
297-VETERINARIAN WHO DOES NOT HAVE AN ESTABLISHED
298-VETERINARIAN
299--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP WITH AN ANIMAL AND ITS
300-OWNER MAY USE TELEMEDICINE TO ADMINISTER
301-, DISTRIBUTE, OR DISPENSE
302-A PRESCRIPTION DRUG THAT HAS BEEN PRESCRIBED BY ANOTHER LICENSED
303-VETERINARIAN WHO HAS AN ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN
304--CLIENT-PATIENT
305-RELATIONSHIP
306-.
297+26
298+VETERINARIAN WHO DOES NOT HAVE AN ESTABLISHED27
299+1048
300+-8- VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP WITH AN ANIMAL AND ITS1
301+OWNER MAY USE TELEMEDICINE TO ADMINISTER , DISTRIBUTE, OR DISPENSE2
302+A PRESCRIPTION DRUG THAT HAS BEEN PRESCRIBED BY ANOTHER LICENSED3
303+VETERINARIAN WHO HAS AN ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN -CLIENT-PATIENT4
304+RELATIONSHIP.5
307305 12-315-306. Telereferral. (1) A
308- VETERINARIAN WITH AN
309-ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN
310--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY REFER A
311-PATIENT TO A VETERINARY SPECIALIST
312-.
306+ VETERINARIAN WITH AN6
307+ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY REFER7
308+A PATIENT TO A VETERINARY SPECIALIST.8
313309 (2) A
314- VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS REFERRED
315-MAY PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS
316-TECHNOLOGY FOR THE PATIENT AND CLIENT UNDER THE REFERRING
317-VETERINARIAN
318-'S VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP.
310+ VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS REFERRED9
311+MAY PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES USING TELECOMMUNICATIONS10
312+TECHNOLOGY FOR THE PATIENT AND CLIENT UNDER THE REFERRING11
313+VETERINARIAN'S VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP.12
319314 (3) A
320- VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS REFERRED
321-SHALL PROVIDE THE REFERRING VETERINARIAN WITH INFORMATION RELATED
322-TO THE DIAGNOSIS
323-, TREATMENT, AND PROGRESS OF THE PATIENT.
315+ VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS REFERRED13
316+SHALL PROVIDE THE REFERRING VETERINARIAN WITH INFORMATION14
317+RELATED TO THE DIAGNOSIS, TREATMENT, AND PROGRESS OF THE PATIENT.15
324318 (4) (a) A
325- VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS REFERRED
326-SHALL NOT PRESCRIBE MEDICATIONS TO THE PATIENT UNLESS THE
327-VETERINARY SPECIALIST ESTABLISHES A VETERINARIAN
328--CLIENT-PATIENT
329-RELATIONSHIP THROUGH AN IN
330--PERSON, PHYSICAL EXAMINATION OF THE
331-PATIENT
332-.
319+ VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM A PATIENT IS16
320+REFERRED SHALL NOT PRESCRIBE MEDICATIONS TO THE PATIENT UNLESS17
321+THE VETERINARY SPECIALIST ESTABLISHES A18
322+VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP THROUGH AN IN -PERSON,19
323+PHYSICAL EXAMINATION OF THE PATIENT .20
333324 (b) T
334-HE LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH THE ESTABLISHED
335-VETERINARIAN
336--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY PRESCRIBE
337-MEDICATIONS TO THE PATIENT AFTER CONSULTATION WITH THE VETERINARY
338-SPECIALIST TO WHOM THE PATIENT WAS REFERRED
339-.
325+HE LICENSED VETERINARIAN WITH THE ESTABLISHED21
326+VETERINARIAN-CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY PRESCRIBE22
327+MEDICATIONS TO THE PATIENT AFTER CONSULTATION WITH THE23
328+VETERINARY SPECIALIST TO WHOM THE PATIENT WAS REFERRED .24
340329 12-315-307. Telesupervision. (1) A
341- LICENSED VETERINARIAN MAY
342-PAGE 7-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 PROVIDE, AT THE VETERINARIAN 'S DISCRETION, TELESUPERVISION OF
343-REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS FOR TASKS THAT DO NOT REQUIRE
344-DIRECT OR IMMEDIATE SUPERVISION
345-, PURSUANT TO BOARD RULES.
330+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN25
331+MAY PROVIDE, AT THE VETERINARIAN'S DISCRETION, TELESUPERVISION
332+OF26
333+REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS FOR TASKS THAT DO NOT REQUIRE27
334+1048
335+-9- DIRECT OR IMMEDIATE SUPERVISION, PURSUANT TO BOARD RULES.1
346336 (2) A
347- SUPERVISING LICENSED VETERINARIAN WHO HAS AN
348-ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN
349--CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY USE
350-TELESUPERVISION TO SUPERVISE REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS
351-WHO ARE NOT LOCATED ON THE SAME PREMISES AS THE SUPERVISING
352-VETERINARIAN IF
353-:
337+ SUPERVISING LICENSED VETERINARIAN WHO HAS AN2
338+ESTABLISHED VETERINARIAN -CLIENT-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP MAY USE3
339+TELESUPERVISION TO SUPERVISE
340+REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS4
341+WHO ARE NOT LOCATED ON THE SAME PREMISES AS THE SUPERVISING5
342+VETERINARIAN IF:6
354343 (a) T
355-HE SUPERVISING LICENSED VETERINARIAN AND THE REGISTERED
356-VETERINARY TECHNICIANS ARE EMPLOYEES OF THE SAME VETERINARY
357-PRACTICE LOCATION
358-; AND
359-(b) THE VETERINARY PROFESSIONALS ARE REGISTERED OR LICENSED
360-IN
361-COLORADO AND THE PATIENT IS LOCATED IN COLORADO.
362-12-315-308. Emergency care - continuity of care. (1) A
363- LICENSED
364-VETERINARIAN WHO PRACTICES VETERINARY MEDICINE THROUGH
365-TELEMEDICINE SHALL BE AVAILABLE IN PERSON AT A VETERINARY PREMISES
366-THAT IS ACCESSIBLE TO THE CLIENT AND PATIENT OR SHALL ARRANGE FOR
367-ANOTHER LICENSED VETERINARIAN IN
368-COLORADO TO BE AT A VETERINARY
369-PREMISES THAT IS ACCESSIBLE TO THE CLIENT AND PATIENT IN CASE OF AN
370-EMERGENCY OR FOR NECESSARY FOLLOW
371--UP EVALUATIONS.
344+HE SUPERVISING LICENSED VETERINARIAN AND THE7 REGISTERED VETERINARY TECHNICIANS ARE EMPLOYEES OF THE SAME8
345+VETERINARY PRACTICE LOCATION; AND9
346+(b) THE VETERINARY PROFESSIONALS ARE REGISTERED OR10
347+LICENSED IN COLORADO AND THE PATIENT IS LOCATED IN COLORADO.11
348+12-315-308. Emergency care - continuity of care. (1) A12
349+LICENSED VETERINARIAN WHO PRACTICES VETERINARY MEDICINE13
350+THROUGH TELEMEDICINE SHALL BE AVAILABLE IN PERSON AT A14
351+VETERINARY PREMISES THAT IS ACCE SSIBLE TO THE CLIENT AND PATIENT15
352+OR SHALL ARRANGE FOR ANOTHER LICENSED VETERINARIAN IN COLORADO16
353+TO BE AT A VETERINARY PREMISES THAT IS ACCESSIBLE TO THE CLIENT17
354+AND PATIENT IN CASE OF AN EMERGENCY OR FOR NECESSARY FOLLOW -UP18
355+EVALUATIONS.19
372356 (2) A
373- LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL PROVIDE THE CLIENT WITH A
374-PLAN FOR EMERGENCY OR FOLLOW
375--UP CARE WHEN PROVIDING VETERINARY
376-SERVICES THROUGH TELEMEDICINE
377-.
357+ LICENSED VETERINARIAN SHALL PROVIDE THE CLIENT WITH20
358+A PLAN FOR EMERGENCY OR FOLLOW -UP CARE WHEN PROVIDING21
359+VETERINARY SERVICES THROUGH TELEMEDICINE .22
378360 12-315-309. Medical records - definition. (1) A
379-S USED IN THIS
380-SECTION
381-, UNLESS THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES , "ANIMAL CARE
382-PROVIDER
383-" HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH IN SECTION 12-315-119 (1).
361+S USED IN THIS23
362+SECTION, UNLESS THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES , "ANIMAL CARE24
363+PROVIDER" HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH IN SECTION 12-315-119 (1).25
384364 (2) A
385-N ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER THAT USES TELEHEALTH TO PROVIDE
386-VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL MAINTAIN MEDICAL RECORDS PURSUANT TO
387-SECTION
388-12-315-119.
365+N ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER THAT USES TELEHEALTH TO26
366+PROVIDE VETERINARY SERVICES SHALL MAINTAIN MEDICAL RECORDS27
367+1048
368+-10- PURSUANT TO SECTION 12-315-119.1
389369 (3) A
390-N ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER THAT CREATES MEDICAL RECORDS
391-DURING THE PROVISION OF VETERINARY SERVICES
392-, INCLUDING THE CLIENT'S
393-CONSENT TO TELEHEALTH SERVICES
394-, SHALL INCLUDE THE RECORDS IN THE
395-PAGE 8-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 PATIENT'S MEDICAL RECORD AND MAKE THE RECORDS ACCESSIBLE TO BOTH
396-THE CLIENT AND THE ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER
397-.
370+N ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER THAT CREATES MEDICAL RECORDS2
371+DURING THE PROVISION OF VETERINARY SERVICES , INCLUDING THE3
372+CLIENT'S CONSENT TO TELEHEALTH SERVICES , SHALL INCLUDE THE4
373+RECORDS IN THE PATIENT'S MEDICAL RECORD AND MAKE THE RECORDS5
374+ACCESSIBLE TO BOTH THE CLIENT AND THE ANIMAL CARE PROVIDER .6
398375 12-315-310. Confidentiality and privacy. A
399- LICENSED
400-VETERINARIAN SHALL ENSURE THAT A CLIENT
401-'S PRIVACY AND
402-CONFIDENTIALITY ARE PROTECTED WHEN THE VETERINARIAN IS PROVIDING
403-VETERINARY SERVICES USING TELEHEALTH PURSUANT TO THE
404-VETERINARIAN
405-'S PROFESSIONAL AND LEGAL OBLIGATIONS .
406-SECTION 4. Act subject to petition - effective date. This act
407-takes effect at 12:01 a.m. on the day following the expiration of the
408-ninety-day period after final adjournment of the general assembly; except
409-that, if a referendum petition is filed pursuant to section 1 (3) of article V
410-of the state constitution against this act or an item, section, or part of this act
411-within such period, then the act, item, section, or part will not take effect
412-unless approved by the people at the general election to be held in
413-PAGE 9-HOUSE BILL 24-1048 November 2024 and, in such case, will take effect on the date of the official
414-declaration of the vote thereon by the governor.
415-____________________________ ____________________________
416-Julie McCluskie Steve Fenberg
417-SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE PRESIDENT OF
418-OF REPRESENTATIVES THE SENATE
419-____________________________ ____________________________
420-Robin Jones Cindi L. Markwell
421-CHIEF CLERK OF THE HOUSE SECRETARY OF
422-OF REPRESENTATIVES THE SENATE
423- APPROVED________________________________________
424- (Date and Time)
425- _________________________________________
426- Jared S. Polis
427- GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF COLORADO
428-PAGE 10-HOUSE BILL 24-1048
376+ LICENSED7
377+VETERINARIAN SHALL ENSURE THAT A CLIENT 'S PRIVACY AND8
378+CONFIDENTIALITY ARE PROTECTED WHEN THE VETERINARIAN IS PROVIDING9
379+VETERINARY SERVICES USING TELEHEALTH PURSUANT TO THE10
380+VETERINARIAN'S PROFESSIONAL AND LEGAL OBLIGATIONS .11
381+SECTION 4. Act subject to petition - effective date. This act12
382+takes effect at 12:01 a.m. on the day following the expiration of the13
383+ninety-day period after final adjournment of the general assembly; except14
384+that, if a referendum petition is filed pursuant to section 1 (3) of article V15
385+of the state constitution against this act or an item, section, or part of this16
386+act within such period, then the act, item, section, or part will not take17
387+effect unless approved by the people at the general election to be held in18
388+November 2024 and, in such case, will take effect on the date of the19
389+official declaration of the vote thereon by the governor.20
390+1048
391+-11-