Second Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO REREVISED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted in the Second House LLS NO. 24-0285.01 Yelana Love x2295 HOUSE BILL 24-1262 House Committees Senate Committees Health & Human Services Health & Human Services Appropriations Appropriations A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING MATERNAL HEALTH, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH,101 MAKING AN APPROPRIATION .102 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) Current law requires "direct-entry midwives" to register with the division of professions and occupations in the department of regulatory agencies before practicing. Sections 2 through 12 of the bill make changes within the direct-entry midwives practice act to update the title of these professionals to "certified professional midwives" and change the regulation from registration to licensure. Sections 21 through 31 make SENATE 3rd Reading Unamended May 4, 2024 SENATE Amended 2nd Reading May 3, 2024 HOUSE 3rd Reading Unamended April 17, 2024 HOUSE Amended 2nd Reading April 16, 2024 HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Garcia and Jodeh, Bacon, Boesenecker, Brown, Duran, Epps, Froelich, Hamrick, Herod, Kipp, Lieder, Lindstedt, Mabrey, Marvin, McCormick, McLachlan, Ortiz, Parenti, Rutinel, Sirota, Story, Titone, Velasco, Willford, Young SENATE SPONSORSHIP Buckner and Michaelson Jenet, Bridges, Coleman, Danielson, Exum, Ginal, Gonzales, Hansen, Hinrichsen, Jaquez Lewis, Kolker, Marchman, Priola, Roberts, Sullivan, Zenzinger Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. the same updates to current law in other statutes outside of the practice act. Current law allows the state board for community colleges and occupational education to use unexpended resources from the in-demand short-term health-care credentials program (program) to expand the eligible programs that may receive support through the program. Section 13 allows the board to expand the eligible programs to include certified professional midwives. Section 14 requires the civil rights commission to establish certain parameters when receiving reports for maternity care. Section 15 adds pregnancy as a protected class for purposes of discrimination in places of public accommodation. The bill adds a midwife to the environmental justice advisory board (section 16) and the governor's expert emergency epidemic response committee (section 20). Section 17 requires a health facility that provides maternal health services to notify certain individuals before eliminating or reducing the services. Section 18 adds midwifery as a preferred area of expertise for members of the health equity commission. Section 19 requires the maternal mortality review committee to: ! Study closures related to perinatal health-care practices and facilities and perinatal health-care deserts and assets related to perinatal health and health-care services across the state, not limited to obstetric providers; ! Identify major outcome categories that the department of public health and environment should track over time and identify risks and opportunities; ! Explore the effects of practice and facility closures (closures) on maternal and infant health outcomes and experiences; ! Identify recommendations during closures and resultant transfers of care; ! Identify best practice guidelines during closures and resultant transfers of care; and ! Create a maternal health desert and asset map. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly2 finds and declares that:3 (a) With the increased demand for reproductive health-care4 1262-2- services in the state, it is important to support the full infrastructure of1 reproductive health-care providers. This includes:2 (I) Integrating the services and expertise of direct-entry midwives;3 (II) Assessing and maintaining the level of reproductive4 health-care services needed in a community in a way that is accessible to5 the community;6 (III) Understanding the assets and the gaps in services at the7 county level; and8 (IV) Understanding and implementing best practices for when9 services are discontinued in a community, including providing notice10 and a transition plan to the state in order to recognize and monitor the11 ongoing impact to the community.12 (b) Demand for community birth options jumped 30% from 201913 to 2020, with the majority of demand coming from Black and Latinx14 birthing people;15 (c) People are choosing community birth care because they find16 it supportive of not just their health needs but their social, spiritual, and17 community values and needs; however, community birth facilities and18 providers face barriers to providing care; 19 20 (d) Patients should have the ability to choose the provider that is21 right for them, regardless of the setting. Especially for underserved Black,22 Indigenous, Asian, rural, refugee, or immigrant communities or someone23 dealing with a substance use or mental health condition, the ability to24 choose a provider that can meet their needs isn't just important, it could25 be lifesaving.26 (e) Facility and practice closures leave communities scrambling27 1262 -3- when they close suddenly and without guidance to patients. When1 closures occur, the state must ensure that vulnerable communities are2 protected.3 (f) The preventable maternal mortality crisis is only growing4 worse in our state, disproportionately harming Black and Indigenous5 people; and6 (g) The maternal mortality review committee has made several7 recommendations to combat this crisis, including:8 (I) Increased access to a variety of health-care professionals, such9 as direct-entry midwives;10 (II) Addressing critical maternal health workforce shortages, such11 as ensuring that direct-entry midwives can provide care at their full scope12 and preventing perinatal facility and practice closures as much as13 possible;14 (III) Examining unintended consequences of policies and15 procedures, such as exploring the impact of facility and practice closures16 on Black, Indigenous, Latinx, Asian, rural, and immigrant and refugee17 communities; and18 (IV) The Colorado department of public health and environment19 recommends that health-care providers be trained and prepared to provide20 a type of care that direct-entry midwives already specialize in. The21 midwifery model of care exemplifies certain recommendations such as22 dyad care, trauma-informed care, shared decision-making, and expertise23 in safe transitions, care navigation, and wraparound services.24 25 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, amend 12-225-11426 as follows:27 1262 -4- 12-225-114. Repeal of article - subject to review. This article1 225 is repealed, effective September 1, 2028. Before the repeal, the2 registering of direct-entry midwives by the division is scheduled for3 review in accordance with section 24-34-104.4 5 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-34-305, amend6 (1)(k) as follows:7 24-34-305. Powers and duties of commission. (1) The8 commission has the following powers and duties:9 (k) (I) To receive reports from people alleging MISTREATMENT IN10 THE CONTEXT OF maternity care, INCLUDING CARE that is not organized11 for, and provided to, a person who is pregnant or in the postpartum period12 AS DEFINED IN SECTION 12-225-103, in a manner that is culturally13 congruent; maintains THAT FAILS TO MAINTAIN the person's dignity,14 privacy, and confidentiality; ensures THAT FAILS TO ENSURE freedom from15 harm and mistreatment; and enables THAT FAILS TO ENABLE informed16 choices and continuous support.17 (II) R EPORTS SHALL BE COLLECTED IN A WAY TO ENSURE THAT :18 (A) C ONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION CAN BE DE -IDENTIFIED;19 (B) I NDIVIDUALS CAN IDENTIFY MISTREATMENT THEY20 EXPERIENCED BASED ON THE FOLLOWING MISTREATMENT INDEX21 CATEGORIES: PHYSICAL ABUSE, SEXUAL ABUSE, VERBAL ABUSE, STIGMA22 AND DISCRIMINATION, FAILURE TO MEET PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS OF23 CARE, OR POOR RAPPORT BETWEEN PATIENTS OR CLIENTS AND PROVIDERS ;24 POOR CONDITIONS AND CONSTRAINTS PRESENTED BY THE HEALTH -CARE25 SYSTEM; AND OBSTETRIC RACISM;26 (C) N UMBERS OF REPORTS BASED ON TYPOLOGY CAN BE27 1262 -5- GENERATED AND SHARED WITH THE PUBLIC AND OTHER AGENCIES ;1 (D) A N INDIVIDUAL MAY IDENTIFY ANY PROTECTED CLASS THE2 INDIVIDUAL MAY BE PART OF AND THAT MAY HAVE FACTORED INTO THE3 INDIVIDUAL'S MISTREATMENT;4 (E) A N INDIVIDUAL MAY INDICATE WHAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN DONE5 DIFFERENTLY TO IMPROVE THE INDIVIDUAL 'S SITUATION;6 (F) A N INDIVIDUAL MAY ENTER NARRATIVE INFORMATION IN THE7 INDIVIDUAL'S OWN WORDS; AND8 (G) A N INDIVIDUAL MAY VOLUNTARILY SHARE THE INDIVIDUAL 'S9 CONTACT INFORMATION AND INDICATE WHETHER THE INDIVIDUAL10 CONSENTS TO BEING CONTACTED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF REGULATORY11 AGENCIES OR THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT . 12 (III) T HE COMMISSION SHALL GENERATE DE -IDENTIFIED13 COMPOSITE INFORMATION BASED ON REPORTS SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO14 THIS SUBSECTION (1)(k). NOTWITHSTANDING SECTION 24-1-136 (11)(a)(I),15 NO LATER THAN JULY 1, 2025, AND NO LATER THAN JULY 1 EVERY THREE16 YEARS THEREAFTER, THE COMMISSION SHALL SHARE THE GENERATED17 DE-IDENTIFIED COMPOSITE INFORMATION WITH :18 (A) T HE COLORADO MATERNAL MORTALITY REVIEW COMMITTEE19 CREATED IN SECTION 25-52-104 (1);20 (B) T HE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES HEALTH AND HUMAN21 SERVICES COMMITTEE AND THE SENATE HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES22 COMMITTEE, OR THEIR SUCCESSOR COMMITTEES ; AND23 (C) T HE MATERNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE DEFINED IN SECTION24 25.5-4-506 (1)(b).25 (IV) R EPORTS MAY BE SHARED INTERNALLY WITH STAFF FOR26 STUDY, INVESTIGATION, REPORTS, PUBLICATIONS, OR HEARINGS.27 1262 -6- 1 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 25-1-134, amend2 (2)(c)(IV) as follows:3 25-1-134. Environmental justice - ombudsperson - advisory4 board - grant program - definitions - repeal. (2) Environmental5 justice advisory board. (c) The advisory board consists of the following6 twelve members who, to the extent practicable, must reside in different7 geographic areas of the state, reflect the racial and ethnic diversity of the8 state, and have experience with a range of environmental issues, including9 air pollution, water contamination, and public health impacts:10 (IV) Four voting members appointed by the executive director of11 the department, AT LEAST ONE OF WHOM MUST BE A MIDWIFE WHO IS12 PRACTICING IN A FREESTANDING BIRTH CENTER , IN A RURAL AREA, OR AS13 A HOME BIRTH PROVIDER.14 SECTION 5. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 25-3-131 as15 follows:16 25-3-131. Maternal health-care services - discontinuation17 - required notifications - definition - repeal. (1) EXCEPT AS PROVIDED18 IN SUBSECTION (3) OF THIS SECTION, AT LEAST NINETY DAYS BEFORE A19 HOSPITAL PROVIDING MATERNAL HEALTH-CARE SERVICES OR A BIRTH20 CENTER MAY DISCONTINUE SUCH SERVICES, THE FACILITY SHALL PROVIDE21 NOTICE TO:22 (a) T HE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT23 RESPONSIBLE FOR LICENSING HEALTH FACILITIES PURSUANT TO SECTION24 25-3-101;25 (b) THE PRIMARY CARE OFFICE, CREATED IN SECTION 25-1.5-403;26 (c) T HE GOVERNOR;27 1262 -7- (d) ALL PATIENTS RECEIVING MATERNAL HEALTH -CARE SERVICES1 AT THE FACILITY AS OF THE DATE OF THE NOTICE;2 (e) A LL HEALTH-CARE PROVIDERS THAT PROVIDE MATERNAL3 HEALTH-CARE SERVICES FOR THE FACILITY AS OF THE DATE OF THE4 NOTICE; AND5 (f) T HE GENERAL PUBLIC.6 (2) T HE NOTICE REQUIRED IN SUBSECTION (1) OF THIS SECTION7 MUST INCLUDE:8 (a) A DESCRIPTION OF THE MATERNAL HEALTH -CARE SERVICES9 BEING DISCONTINUED;10 (b) T HE RATE THE MATERNAL HEALTH -CARE SERVICES HAD BEEN11 PROVIDED AT IN THE PREVIOUS YEAR;12 (c) T HE NUMBER AND TYPE OF HEALTH -CARE PROVIDERS13 IMPACTED;14 (d) T HE PROPOSED PLAN FOR TRANSITIONING PATIENTS TO NEW15 HEALTH-CARE PROVIDERS; AND16 (e) T HE PROPOSED PLAN FOR TRANSITIONING THE HEALTH -CARE17 PROVIDERS TO NEW POSITIONS.18 (3) (a) I N THE EVENT OF AN EMERGENCY , A FACILITY SHALL 19 PROVIDE THE NOTICE REQUIRED IN SUBSECTION (1) OF THIS SECTION ON20 THE DAY A DEFINITIVE PLAN FOR ALTERNATIVE PATIENT CARE HAS BEEN21 ARRANGED OR WITHIN SEVEN DAYS AFTER THE EMERGENCY HAS BEEN22 IDENTIFIED, WHICHEVER IS EARLIER.23 (b) T HIS SUBSECTION (3) DOES NOT APPLY IN THE EVENT OF AN 24 EMERGENCY COVERED BY RULES PROMULGATED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF25 PUBLIC HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT IF SUCH EMERGENCY AFFECTS THE26 PHYSICAL SPACE OF THE FACILITY AND NECESSITATES THE REMOVAL OF27 1262 -8- CLIENTS, EMPLOYEES, OR CONTRACTORS FROM THE FACILITY .1 (4) AS USED IN THIS SECTION:2 (a) "E MERGENCY" MEANS A SUDDEN AND UNFORESEEN 3 CIRCUMSTANCE OR FINANCIAL IMPEDIMENT THAT WOULD INHIBIT A4 HOSPITAL'S ABILITY TO SAFELY AND EFFECTIVELY OPERATE A MATERNAL5 HEALTH-CARE SERVICE.6 (b) "M ATERNAL HEALTH-CARE SERVICES" MEANS HEALTH-CARE7 SERVICES PROVIDED TO AN INDIVIDUAL REGARDING CARE RELATED TO THE8 INDIVIDUAL'S PREGNANCY, CHILDBIRTH, AND POSTPARTUM PERIOD.9 (5) T HIS SECTION IS REPEALED, EFFECTIVE JULY 1, 2027. 10 SECTION 6. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 25-4-2206, amend11 (2)(a)(III) introductory portion and (2)(a)(III)(J); and add (2)(a)(III)(J.5)12 as follows:13 25-4-2206. Health equity commission - creation - repeal.14 (2) (a) The commission consists of the following twenty-three members,15 who are as follows:16 (III) The executive director of the department shall appoint ten17 members who represent, to the extent practical, Colorado's diverse ethnic,18 racial, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, disability,19 aging population, socioeconomic, and geographic backgrounds. Each20 person INDIVIDUAL appointed to the commission must have demonstrated21 expertise in at least one, and preferably two, of the following areas: 22 (J) Behavioral health; or23 (J.5) M IDWIFERY; OR24 SECTION 7. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 25-52-104, amend25 (2)(b)(II); and add (5.5) as follows:26 25-52-104. Colorado maternal mortality review committee -27 1262 -9- creation - members - duties - report to the general assembly - repeal.1 (2) (b) In appointing members to the committee, the executive director2 shall:3 (II) Ensure that committee members represent diverse4 communities and a variety of clinical, forensic, and psychosocial5 specializations and community perspectives, INCLUDING6 COMMUNITY-BASED MIDWIFERY; and7 (5.5) THE DEPARTMENT MAY CONTRACT WITH AN INDEPENDENT8 THIRD-PARTY EVALUATOR TO:9 (a) STUDY CLOSURES, CONSOLIDATIONS, AND ACQUISITIONS10 RELATED TO PERINATAL HEALTH -CARE PRACTICES AND FACILITIES AND11 PERINATAL STATE-DESIGNATED HEALTH PROFESSIONAL SHORTAGE AREAS ,12 AS DEFINED IN SECTION 25-1.5-402 (11), AND ASSETS AND DEFICITS13 RELATED TO PERINATAL HEALTH AND HEALTH -CARE SERVICES ACROSS THE14 STATE, NOT LIMITED TO OBSTETRIC PROVIDERS;15 (b) IDENTIFY MAJOR OUTCOME CATEGORIES AT THE CLINICAL ,16 FAMILY, COMMUNITY, AND PROVIDER LEVELS THAT THE DEPARTMENT17 SHOULD TRACK OVER TIME AND IDENTIFY RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES18 RELATED TO CLOSURES, CONSOLIDATIONS, AND ACQUISITIONS OF19 PERINATAL HEALTH-CARE PRACTICES AND FACILITIES;20 (c) EXPLORE THE EFFECTS OF PRACTICE AND FACILITY CLOSURES21 ON MATERNAL AND INFANT HEALTH OUTCOMES AND EXPERIENCES , TO22 ILLUSTRATE STRUCTURAL NEEDS AROUND CLOSURES, WHEN APPLICABLE;23 (d) IDENTIFY RECOMMENDATIONS DURING PRACTICE AND FACILITY24 CLOSURES AND RESULTANT TRANSFERS OF CARE . THE DEPARTMENT OR25 THIRD PARTY EVALUATOR MAY USE BOTH PRIMARY AND SECONDARY DATA26 IN MAKING THE RECOMMENDATIONS . THE DEPARTMENT OR THIRD PARTY27 1262 -10- EVALUATOR SHALL USE THE MAP CREATED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION1 (5.5)(f) OF THIS SECTION IN DEVELOPING THE RECOMMENDATIONS . THE2 RECOMMENDATIONS MUST :3 (I) INCLUDE SOLUTIONS AT THE FACILITY LEVEL , THE PRACTICE4 LEVEL, THE WORKFORCE LEVEL , THE COMMUNITY LEVEL , AND THE5 PATIENT LEVEL;6 (II) INCLUDE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR REPORTING ON7 CLOSURES, INCLUDING METRICS ON TIMELINES AND GEOGRAPHIC AREA,8 INCLUDING WHETHER THE TIMELINE CREATED IN SECTION 25-3-131 IS9 APPROPRIATE;10 (III) DEVELOP RECOMMENDATIONS ON PRIMARY AND SECONDARY11 DATA COLLECTION RELATED TO CLOSURES AND RESULTANT TRANSFERS OF12 CARE.13 (e) IDENTIFY BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES DURING PRACTICE AND14 FACILITY CLOSURES AND RESULTANT TRANSFERS OF CARE . THE THIRD15 PARTY EVALUATOR MAY USE BOTH PRIMARY AND SECONDARY DATA IN16 IDENTIFYING THE BEST PRACTICE GUIDELINES . THE THIRD PARTY17 EVALUATOR SHALL USE THE MAP CREATED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION18 (5.5)(f) OF THIS SECTION IN DEVELOPING THE GUIDELINES. THE GUIDELINES19 MUST CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING AREAS : RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES;20 TRANSFERS OF CARE; COMMUNITY NOTICE NEEDS AND OPPORTUNITIES ;21 NOTIFICATION TO THE DEPARTMENT; CLOSURE TIMELINE; AND RESOURCES22 NEEDED BY FACILITIES, PROVIDERS, AND FAMILIES.23 (f) CREATE A HEALTH PROFESSIONAL SHORTAGE AREA AND24 PERINATAL HEALTH SERVICES ASSETS AND DEFICITS ASSET MAP THAT25 IDENTIFIES BY PERINATAL SERVICE AREA:26 (I) PRIMARY HEALTH-CARE PROVIDERS, INCLUDING PHYSICIANS27 1262 -11- AND MIDWIVES OF ALL CREDENTIAL TYPES WHO PROVIDE OR COULD BE1 PROVIDING PERINATAL HEALTH CARE ;2 (II) THE TYPE AND LOCATION OF PERINATAL HEALTH CARE3 OFFERED BY THE PROVIDERS LISTED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (5.5)(f)(I)4 OF THIS SECTION;5 (III) COMMUNITY-BASED PERINATAL HEALTH -CARE WORKERS,6 SUCH AS DOULAS, CHILDBIRTH EDUCATORS, AND LACTATION SUPPORT7 CONSULTANTS; AND8 (IV) RESOURCES SUCH AS COMMUNITY ADVOCATES , GATHERING9 PLACES, AND EDUCATIONAL HUBS;10 (g) BY JULY 1, 2026, DELIVER THE BEST PRACTICES AND11 RECOMMENDATIONS CREATED PURSUANT TO THIS SUBSECTION (5.5) TO12 THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES13 COMMITTEE AND THE SENATE HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMI TTEE ,14 OR THEIR SUCCESSOR COMMITTEES .15 SECTION 8. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-33.5-704.5,16 amend (1)(b)(II)(G) and (1)(b)(II)(H); and add (1)(b)(II)(I) as follows:17 24-33.5-704.5. Governor's expert emergency epidemic18 response committee - creation. (1) (b) (II) In addition to the state19 members of the committee, the governor shall appoint to the committee20 an individual from each of the following categories:21 (G) A wildlife disease specialist with the division of wildlife; and22 (H) A pharmacist member of the state board of pharmacy; AND23 (I) A MIDWIFE WITH EXPERIENCE IN OUT-OF-HOSPITAL BIRTHS.24 25 SECTION 9. Appropriation. (1) For the 2024-25 state fiscal26 year, $328,946 is appropriated to the department of public health and27 1262 -12- environment for use by the prevention services division. This1 appropriation is from the general fund. To implement this act, the division2 may use this appropriation for maternal and child health related to3 community health, which amount is based on an assumption that the4 division will require an additional 0.8 FTE.5 (2) For the 2024-25 state fiscal year, $111,072 is appropriated to6 the department of regulatory agencies. This appropriation is from the7 general fund. To implement this act, the department may use this8 appropriation as follows:9 (a) $54,717 from general fund for use by the civil rights division10 for personal services, which amount is based on an assumption that the11 division will require an additional 1.0 FTE;12 (b) $7,950 from general fund for use by the civil rights division13 for operating expenses; 14 15 (c) $32,005 from general fund for the purchase of legal services;16 and17 (d) $16,400 from general fund for the purchase of information18 technology services. 19 (3) For the 2024-25 state fiscal year, $32,005 is appropriated to20 the department of law. This appropriation is from reappropriated funds21 received from the department of regulatory agencies under subsection22 (2)(c) of this section and is based on an assumption that the department23 of law will require an additional 0.1 FTE. To implement this act, the24 department of law may use this appropriation to provide legal services for25 the department of regulatory agencies.26 (4) For the 2024-25 state fiscal year, $16,400 is appropriated to27 1262 -13- the office of the governor for use by the office of information technology.1 This appropriation is from reappropriated funds received from the2 department of regulatory agencies under subsection (2)(d) of this section.3 To implement this act, the office may use this appropriation to provide4 information technology services for the department of regulatory5 agencies.6 SECTION 10. Safety clause. The general assembly finds,7 determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate8 preservation of the public peace, health, or safety or for appropriations for9 the support and maintenance of the departments of the state and state10 institutions.11 1262 -14-