LCO \\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757-R01- HB.docx 1 of 12 General Assembly Substitute Bill No. 6757 January Session, 2023 AN ACT CONCERNING TEACHER PERFORMANCE EVALUATIONS. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Assembly convened: Section 1. Section 10-151b of the general statutes is repealed and the 1 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2024): 2 (a) The superintendent of each local or regional board of education 3 shall annually evaluate or cause to be evaluated each teacher, and for 4 the school year commencing July 1, 2013, and each school year 5 thereafter, such annual evaluations shall be the teacher evaluation and 6 support program adopted pursuant to subsection (b) of this section. 7 The superintendent may conduct additional formative evaluations 8 toward producing an annual summative evaluation. An evaluation 9 pursuant to this subsection shall include, but need not be limited to, 10 strengths, areas needing improvement, strategies for improvement and 11 multiple indicators of student academic growth. Claims of failure to 12 follow the established procedures of such teacher evaluation and 13 support program shall be subject to the grievance procedure in 14 collective bargaining agreements negotiated subsequent to July 1, 2004. 15 In the event that a teacher does not receive a summative evaluation 16 during the school year, such teacher shall [receive a "not rated" 17 designation for such school year] be recorded as not evaluated. The 18 superintendent shall report (1) the status of teacher evaluations to the 19 local or regional board of education on or before June first of each year, 20 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 2 of 12 and (2) the status of the implementation of the teacher evaluation and 21 support program, including the frequency of evaluations, [aggregate 22 evaluation ratings,] the number of teachers who have not been 23 evaluated and other requirements as determined by the Department of 24 Education, to the Commissioner of Education on or before September 25 fifteenth of each year. For purposes of this section, the term "teacher" 26 shall include each professional employee of a board of education, 27 below the rank of superintendent, who holds a certificate or permit 28 issued by the State Board of Education. 29 (b) [Except as provided in subsection (d) of this section, not] Not 30 later than September 1, [2013] 2024, each local and regional board of 31 education shall adopt and implement a teacher evaluation and support 32 program that is consistent with the guidelines for a [model] teacher 33 evaluation and support program adopted by the State Board of 34 Education, pursuant to subsection (c) of this section. Such teacher 35 evaluation and support program shall be developed through mutual 36 agreement between the local or regional board of education and the 37 professional development and evaluation committee for the school 38 district, established pursuant to subsection (b) of section 10-220a. If a 39 local or regional board of education is unable to develop a teacher 40 evaluation and support program through mutual agreement with such 41 professional development and evaluation committee, then such board 42 of education and such professional development and evaluation 43 committee shall consider the model teacher evaluation and support 44 program adopted by the State Board of Education, pursuant to 45 subsection (c) of this section, and such board of education may adopt, 46 through mutual agreement with such professional development and 47 evaluation committee, such model teacher evaluation and support 48 program. If a local or regional board of education and the professional 49 development and evaluation committee are unable to mutually agree 50 on the adoption of such model teacher evaluation and support 51 program, then such board of education shall adopt and implement a 52 teacher evaluation and support program developed by such board of 53 education, provided such teacher evaluation and support program is 54 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 3 of 12 consistent with the guidelines adopted by the State Board of 55 Education, pursuant to subsection (c) of this section. [Each local and 56 regional board of education may commence implementation of the 57 teacher evaluation and support program adopted pursuant to this 58 subsection in accordance with a teacher evaluation and support 59 program implementation plan adopted pursuant to subsection (d) of 60 this section.] 61 (c) (1) On or before July 1, [2012] 2025, the State Board of Education 62 shall adopt, in consultation with the Performance Evaluation Advisory 63 Council established pursuant to section 10-151d, as amended by this 64 act, guidelines for a [model] teacher evaluation and support program. 65 Such guidelines shall include, but not be limited to, (A) [the use of four 66 performance evaluations designators: Exemplary, proficient, 67 developing and below standard; (B)] the use of multiple indicators of 68 student [academic] learning, growth and [development] achievement 69 in teacher evaluations; [(C)] (B) methods for assessing student 70 [academic] learning, growth and [development; (D)] achievement; (C) 71 a consideration of control factors tracked by the state-wide public 72 school information system, pursuant to subsection (c) of section 10-10a, 73 that may influence teacher performance, [ratings,] including, but not 74 limited to, student characteristics, student attendance and student 75 mobility; [(E)] (D) minimum requirements for teacher evaluation 76 instruments and procedures, including [scoring systems to determine 77 exemplary, proficient, developing and below standard ratings; (F)] an 78 annual summary of teacher growth provided by the evaluator; (E) the 79 development and implementation of periodic training programs 80 regarding the teacher evaluation and support program to be offered by 81 the local or regional board of education or regional educational service 82 center for the school district to teachers who are employed by such 83 local or regional board of education and whose performance is being 84 evaluated and to administrators who are employed by such local or 85 regional board of education and who are conducting performance 86 evaluations; [(G)] (F) the provision of professional development 87 services based on the individual or group of individuals' needs that are 88 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 4 of 12 identified through the evaluation process; [(H)] (G) the creation of 89 individual teacher improvement and remediation plans for teachers 90 [whose performance is developing or below standard] who require 91 additional support, designed in consultation with such teacher and his 92 or her exclusive bargaining representative for certified teachers chosen 93 pursuant to section 10-153b, and that (i) identify resources, support 94 and other strategies to be provided by the local or regional board of 95 education to address documented deficiencies, (ii) indicate a timeline 96 for implementing such resources, support, and other strategies, in the 97 course of the same school year as the plan is issued, and (iii) include 98 indicators of success [including a summative rating of proficient or 99 better] immediately at the conclusion of the improvement and 100 remediation plan; [(I)] (H) opportunities for career development and 101 professional growth; and [(J)] (I) a validation procedure to audit 102 [evaluation ratings of exemplary or below standard] remediation plans 103 by the department or a third-party entity approved by the department. 104 (2) (A) The State Board of Education [shall, following the 105 completion of the teacher evaluation and support pilot program, 106 pursuant to section 10-151f, and the submission of the study of such 107 pilot program, pursuant to section 10-151g, review and] may revise, as 108 necessary, the guidelines for a [model] teacher evaluation and support 109 program and the model teacher evaluation and support program 110 adopted under [this subsection] subparagraph (B) of this subdivision. 111 (B) The State Board of Education shall adopt a model teacher 112 evaluation and support program that may be used by local and 113 regional boards of education. Such model teacher evaluation and 114 support program shall be consistent with the guidelines described in 115 subdivision (1) of this subsection. 116 (d) [A local or regional board of education may phase in full 117 implementation of the teacher evaluation and support program 118 adopted pursuant to subsection (b) of this section during the school 119 years commencing July 1, 2013, and July 1, 2014, pursuant to a teacher 120 evaluation and support program implementation plan adopted by the 121 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 5 of 12 State Board of Education, in consultation with the Performance 122 Evaluation Advisory Council, not later than July 1, 2013.] The 123 Commissioner of Education may waive the provisions of subsection 124 (b) of this section [and the implementation plan provisions of this 125 subsection] for any local or regional board of education that has 126 expressed an intent, not later than July 1, [2013] 2024, to adopt a 127 teacher evaluation program for which such board requests a waiver in 128 accordance with this subsection. 129 Sec. 2. Section 10-151d of the general statutes is repealed and the 130 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2023): 131 (a) There is established a Performance Evaluation Advisory Council 132 within the Department of Education. Membership of the council shall 133 consist of: (1) The Commissioner of Education and the president of the 134 Connecticut State Colleges and Universities, or their designees, (2) one 135 representative from each of the following associations, designated by 136 the association, the Connecticut Association of Boards of Education, 137 the Connecticut Association of Public School Superintendents, the 138 Connecticut Federation of School Administrators, the Connecticut 139 Education Association, the American Federation of Teachers -140 Connecticut, the Connecticut Association of School Administrators and 141 the Connecticut Association of Schools, (3) a representative from the 142 Task Force to Diversify the Educator Workforce, established pursuant 143 to section 10-156aa, designated by the chairpersons of said task force, 144 and (4) persons selected by the Commissioner of Education who shall 145 include, but need not be limited to, teachers, persons with expertise in 146 performance evaluation processes and systems, and any other person 147 the commissioner deems appropriate. 148 (b) The council shall be responsible for (1) assisting the State Board 149 of Education in the development of [(A)] guidelines for a [model] 150 teacher evaluation and support program, and [(B) a model teacher 151 evaluation and support program, pursuant to subsection (c) of section 152 10-151b,] (2) the data collection and evaluation support system, 153 pursuant to subsection (c) of section 10-10a. [, and (3) assisting the 154 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 6 of 12 State Board of Education in the development of a teacher evaluation 155 and support program implementation plan, pursuant to subsection (e) 156 of section 10-151b.] The council shall meet at least quarterly. The 157 council shall collaborate with the Task Force to Diversify the Educator 158 Workforce, established pursuant to section 10-156aa, to focus on issues 159 concerning equity and closing the achievement gap, as defined in 160 section 10-14u. 161 (c) On and after July 1, 2018, the council shall, in collaboration with 162 the [minority teacher recruitment task force] Task Force to Diversify 163 the Educator Workforce, incorporate into the work of the council 164 strategies and a framework for educators to be effective in closing the 165 achievement gap and in increasing educational opportunities. 166 Sec. 3. Section 10-151h of the general statutes is repealed and the 167 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2023): 168 (a) Upon the implementation of the teacher evaluation and support 169 program adopted pursuant to subsection (b) of section 10-151b, as 170 amended by this act, each local and regional board of education shall 171 conduct training programs for all evaluators and orientation for all 172 teachers employed by such board relating to the provisions of such 173 teacher evaluation and support program adopted by such board of 174 education. Such training shall provide instruction to evaluators in how 175 to conduct proper performance evaluations prior to conducting an 176 evaluation under the teacher evaluation and support program. Such 177 orientation shall be completed by each teacher before a teacher 178 receives an evaluation under the teacher evaluation and support 179 program. For purposes of this section, "teacher" includes each 180 professional employee of a board of education, below the rank of 181 superintendent, who holds a certificate or permit issued by the State 182 Board of Education. 183 (b) For the school year commencing July 1, [2014] 2023, and each 184 school year thereafter, each local and regional board of education shall 185 (1) conduct the training programs and orientation described in 186 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 7 of 12 subsection (a) of this section at least [biennially] annually to all 187 evaluators and teachers employed by such board, (2) conduct such 188 training programs for all new evaluators prior to any evaluations 189 conducted by such evaluators, and (3) provide such orientation to all 190 new teachers hired by such board before such teachers receive an 191 evaluation. 192 Sec. 4. Subsection (i) of section 10-145a of the general statutes is 193 repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 194 1, 2023): 195 (i) On and after July 1, 2016, any program of teacher preparation 196 leading to professional certification shall require, as part of the 197 curriculum, clinical experience, field experience or student teaching 198 experience in a classroom during four semesters of such program of 199 teacher preparation. Such clinical experience, field experience or 200 student teaching experience shall occur: (1) In a school district that has 201 been categorized by the Department of Education as District Reference 202 Group A, B, C, D or E, and (2) in a school district that has been 203 categorized by the department as District Reference Group F, G, H or I. 204 Such clinical experience, field experience or student teaching 205 experience may include a cooperating teacher serving as a mentor to 206 student teachers. [, provided such cooperating teacher has received a 207 performance evaluation designation of exemplary or proficient, 208 pursuant to section 10-151b, for the prior school year.] 209 Sec. 5. Subsection (c) of section 10-223h of the general statutes is 210 repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 211 1, 2023): 212 (c) Following the establishment of a turnaround committee, the 213 Department of Education shall conduct, in consultation with the local 214 or regional board of education for a school selected to participate in the 215 commissioner's network of schools, the school governance council for 216 such school and such turnaround committee, an operations and 217 instructional audit, as described in subparagraph (A) of subdivision (2) 218 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 8 of 12 of subsection (e) of section 10-223e, for such school. Such operations 219 and instructional audit shall be conducted pursuant to guidelines 220 issued by the department and shall determine the extent to which the 221 school (1) has established a strong family and community connection 222 to the school; (2) has a positive school environment, as evidenced by a 223 culture of high expectations, a safe and orderly workplace, and that 224 address other nonacademic factors that impact student achievement, 225 such as students' social, emotional, arts, cultural, recreational and 226 health needs; (3) has effective leadership, as evidenced by the school 227 principal's performance appraisals, track record in improving student 228 achievement, ability to lead turnaround efforts, and managerial skills 229 and authority in the areas of scheduling, staff management, 230 curriculum implementation and budgeting; (4) has effective teachers 231 and support staff as evidenced by performance evaluations, policies to 232 retain staff determined to be effective and who have the ability to be 233 successful in the turnaround effort, policies to prevent ineffective 234 teachers from transferring to the schools, and job-embedded, ongoing 235 professional development informed by the teacher evaluation and 236 support programs that are tied to teacher and student needs; (5) uses 237 time effectively as evidenced by the redesign of the school day, week, 238 or year to include additional time for student learning and teacher 239 collaboration; (6) has a curriculum and instructional program that is 240 based on student needs, is research-based, rigorous and aligned with 241 state academic content standards, and serves all children, including 242 students at every achievement level; and (7) uses evidence to inform 243 decision-making and for continuous improvement, including by 244 providing time for collaboration on the use of data. Such operations 245 and instructional audit shall be informed by an inventory of the 246 following: (A) Before and after school programs, (B) any school-based 247 health centers, family resource centers or other community services 248 offered at the school, including, but not limited to, social services, 249 mental health services and parenting support programs, (C) whether 250 scientific research-based interventions are being fully implemented at 251 the school, (D) resources for scientific research-based interventions 252 during the school year and summer school programs, (E) resources for 253 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 9 of 12 gifted and talented students, (F) the length of the school day and the 254 school year, (G) summer school programs, (H) alternative education, 255 as defined in section 10-74j, if any, offered to students at the school, (I) 256 the number of teachers employed at the school and the number of 257 teachers who have left the school in each of the previous three school 258 years, (J) student mobility, including the number of students who have 259 been enrolled in and left the school, (K) the number of students whose 260 primary language is not English, (L) the number of students receiving 261 special education services, (M) the number of truants, (N) the number 262 of students who are eligible for free or reduced price lunches, (O) the 263 number of students who are eligible for HUSKY A, (P) the curricula 264 used at the school, (Q) the reading curricula and programs for 265 kindergarten to grade three, inclusive, if any, at the school, (R) arts and 266 music programs offered at the school, (S) physical education programs 267 offered and periods for recess or physical activity, (T) the number of 268 school psychologists at the school and the ratio of school psychologists 269 to students at the school, (U) the number of social workers at the 270 school and the ratio of social workers to students at the school, (V) the 271 teacher and administrator performance evaluation program, including 272 the frequency of performance evaluations, how such evaluations are 273 conducted and by whom, the standards for performance ratings and 274 follow-up and remediation plans and the [aggregate] results of teacher 275 performance evaluation ratings conducted pursuant to section 10-151b, 276 as amended by this act, and any other available measures of teacher 277 effectiveness, (W) professional development activities and programs, 278 (X) teacher and student access to technology inside and outside of the 279 classroom, (Y) student access to and enrollment in mastery test 280 preparation programs, (Z) the availability of textbooks, learning 281 materials and other supplies, (AA) student demographics, including 282 race, gender and ethnicity, (BB) chronic absenteeism, and (CC) 283 preexisting school improvement plans, for the purpose of (i) 284 determining why such school improvement plans have not improved 285 student academic performance, and (ii) identifying governance, legal, 286 operational, staffing or resource constraints that contributed to the lack 287 of student academic performance at such school and should be 288 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 10 of 12 addressed, modified or removed for such school to improve student 289 academic performance. 290 Sec. 6. Subsection (d) of section 10-262u of the general statutes is 291 repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 292 1, 2023): 293 (d) The local or regional board of education for a town designated 294 as an alliance district may apply to the Commissioner of Education, at 295 such time and in such manner as the commissioner prescribes, to 296 receive any increase in funds received over the amount the town 297 received for the prior fiscal year pursuant to subsection (a) of section 298 10-262i. Applications pursuant to this subsection shall include 299 objectives and performance targets and a plan that are developed, in 300 part, on the strategic use of student academic performance data. Such 301 plan may include, but not be limited to, the following: (1) A tiered 302 system of interventions for the schools under the jurisdiction of such 303 board based on the needs of such schools, (2) ways to strengthen the 304 foundational programs in reading, through the intensive reading 305 instruction program pursuant to section 10-14u, to ensure reading 306 mastery in kindergarten to grade three, inclusive, with a focus on 307 standards and instruction, proper use of data, intervention strategies, 308 current information for teachers, parental engagement, and teacher 309 professional development, (3) additional learning time, including 310 extended school day or school year programming administered by 311 school personnel or external partners, (4) a talent strategy that 312 includes, but is not limited to, teacher and school leader recruitment 313 and assignment, career ladder policies that draw upon guidelines for a 314 [model] teacher evaluation program adopted by the State Board of 315 Education, pursuant to section 10-151b, as amended by this act, and 316 adopted by each local or regional board of education. Such talent 317 strategy may include provisions that demonstrate increased ability to 318 attract, retain, promote and bolster the performance of staff in 319 accordance with performance evaluation findings and, in the case of 320 new personnel, other indicators of effectiveness, (5) training for school 321 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 11 of 12 leaders and other staff on new teacher evaluation models, (6) 322 provisions for the cooperation and coordination with early childhood 323 education providers to ensure alignment with district expectations for 324 student entry into kindergarten, including funding for an existing local 325 Head Start program, (7) provisions for the cooperation and 326 coordination with other governmental and community programs to 327 ensure that students receive adequate support and wraparound 328 services, including community school models, (8) provisions for 329 implementing and furthering state-wide education standards adopted 330 by the State Board of Education and all activities and initiatives 331 associated with such standards, (9) strategies for attracting and 332 recruiting minority teachers and administrators, (10) provisions for the 333 enhancement of bilingual education programs, pursuant to section 10-334 17f, or other language acquisition services to English language 335 learners, including, but not limited to, participation in the English 336 language learner pilot program, established pursuant to section 10-17n, 337 (11) entering into the model school district responsibilities agreement, 338 described in section 10-223l, (12) leadership succession plans that 339 provide training and learning opportunities for administrators and are 340 designed to assist in the seamless transition of school and district 341 personnel in and out of leadership positions in the school district and 342 the continuous implementation of plans developed under this 343 subsection, (13) implementing the policy adopted pursuant to section 344 10-223m to improve completion rates of the Free Application for 345 Federal Student Aid by students enrolled in grade twelve in a high 346 school under the jurisdiction of such board or students enrolled in an 347 adult education program maintained by such board pursuant to 348 section 10-69, and, as applicable, the parent and guardians of such 349 students, and (14) any additional categories or goals as determined by 350 the commissioner. Such plan shall demonstrate collaboration with key 351 stakeholders, as identified by the commissioner, with the goal of 352 achieving efficiencies and the alignment of intent and practice of 353 current programs with conditional programs identified in this 354 subsection. The commissioner may (A) require changes in any plan 355 submitted by a local or regional board of education before the 356 Substitute Bill No. 6757 LCO {\\PRDFS1\HCOUSERS\BARRYJN\WS\2023HB-06757- R01-HB.docx } 12 of 12 commissioner approves an application under this subsection, and (B) 357 permit a local or regional board of education, as part of such plan, to 358 use a portion of any funds received under this section for the purposes 359 of paying tuition charged to such board pursuant to subdivision (1) of 360 subsection (k) of section 10-264l or subsection (b) of section 10-264o. 361 Sec. 7. Sections 10-151f and 10-151g of the general statutes are 362 repealed. (Effective July 1, 2023) 363 This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following sections: Section 1 July 1, 2024 10-151b Sec. 2 July 1, 2023 10-151d Sec. 3 July 1, 2023 10-151h Sec. 4 July 1, 2023 10-145a(i) Sec. 5 July 1, 2023 10-223h(c) Sec. 6 July 1, 2023 10-262u(d) Sec. 7 July 1, 2023 Repealer section Statement of Legislative Commissioners: In Section 1(c)(2)(A), "guidelines for a model teacher evaluation and support program" was changed to "guidelines for a [model] teacher evaluation and support program" for consistency, and "this subsection" was changed to "[this subsection] subparagraph (B) of this subdivision" for accuracy. ED Joint Favorable Subst.